4 He offers up hisq own daughters to the rage of the Sodomites, that he might deliver his guests: choosing rather to be a bad father, than a bad host. This fact ha•• found diverse excuses. 1. It was a less sinne, Coire secundum naturam, than advers•• naturam: 2and of two evils the less is to be chosen. Answ. This is true in pe••• evils, not in criminals: in corporal things, not in spiritual. There is no necessity that should compel a man to sin: he ought rather to die.r Blessed is he that c•• demneth not himself in the thing that he alloweth: then he is not blessed that allowe• the thing in act,4 which he condemns in Judgement. 2. Lot did not mean to p•• off one sin with another, but useth a seeming submission to qualify their rage: he knew his daughters espoused to some great men of the City, and that they durst […] attempt their constupration. Answ. But this had been to tempt God by a fo••• presumption, to make such an unruly rabble this offer, in hope it would not be taken. 3. Though a man in himself must not do a less evil for avoidance of a greater:5 yet to stop another's precipice into some monstrous mischief, and to mo•••• his mind by insinuation to a less; this they hold tolerable. As if men by custom must swear, the oath is better by their head, than by God. He that is shut up i• […] walled fort,6 let him escape where the wall is lowest. Answ. This is true, where we are persuaders from evil, not actors of evil our selves. So if Lot had perswade• them to the young maids of the town, and to forbear the men, it had been more sufferable. But no man is to sin himself, with the hazard of his own soul, for the prevention of another's wickedness. 4. His intent was good to preserve his gods. Answ. sWe must not do evil, that good may come thereof.
4 He offers up hisq owne daughters to the rage of the Sodomites, that he might deliver his guests: chusing rather to be a bad father, than a bad hoste. This fact ha•• found diverse excuses. 1. It was a lesse sinne, Coire secundum naturam, than advers•• naturam: 2and of two evills the lesse is to be chosen. Answ. This is true in pe••• evills, not in criminalls: in corporall things, not in spirituall. There is no necessitie that should compell a man to sinne: he ought rather to die.r Blessed is he that c•• demneth not himselfe in the thing that he alloweth: then he is not blessed that allowe• the thing in act,4 which he condemnes in Iudgement. 2. Lot did not meane to p•• off one sinne with another, but useth a seeming submission to qualifie their rage: he knew his daughters espoused to some great men of the Citie, and that they durst 〈…〉 attempt their constupration. Answ. But this had beene to tempt God by a fo••• presumption, to make such an unruly rabble this offer, in hope it would not be taken. 3. Though a man in himselfe must not doe a lesse evill for avoidance of a greater:5 yet to stop anothers precipice into some monstrous mischiefe, and to mo•••• his mind by insinuation to a lesse; this they hold tolerable. As if men by custome must sweare, the oath is better by their head, than by God. He that is shut up i• 〈…〉 walled fort,6 let him escape where the wall is lowest. Answ. This is true, where we are perswaders from evill, not actors of evill our selves. So if Lot had perswade• them to the young maides of the towne, and to forbeare the men, it had beene more sufferable. But no man is to sin himselfe, with the hazard of his owne soule, for the prevention of anothers wickednesse. 4. His intent was good to preserve his gods. Answ.
- qGen. 16.8.
- 2Ambr.
- rRom. 14.22.
- 4Cajetan.
- 5Chrys.
- 6Greg.
- sRom. 3.8.