2. Take one Instance more.q Matthew andr Mark say, that the thieves which were crucified with him, reviled him: the number was but two, and both of them are accused. Yet Luke says, that one of thems rebuked his fellow for that contumely cast upon Christ; prayed, and was saved. This is a difficulty; how shall we understand it? Some answer, that at first both the thieves railed on Christ: but one of them, observing the patience of the sufferer in his extremity, the wonderful miracles, and the compassion of nature it self: the Suns darkening, the earths shaking, the stones rending; was converted; and did salve his former exprobration of Christ, with an humble confession of him.4 But against this may be objected. First, These miracles were the effects of Christs death, and begun when he ended: but the thief was then in articulo mortis, and could not be sensible of them. Secondly, When he reproved his fellow for reproaching of Christ, why did he not reply; Thou hast also reviled him. Thirdly, It is the custom of the sacred story, when it hath disgraced a man for sin, not to conceal the honour of his repentance, if ever he had remorse. St. Matthew therefore had done the malefactor some wrong, to set down his offence, and not his penitence. The most and best expositors fly to this, with Augustine; that it was Enallage numeri: as,a The Disciples are charged to say, Why is this waste? When Saint John chargeth onlyb Judas with it. So,c The Kings of the earth set themselves against Christ: yet literally, no king but Herod: so Peter quotes it, and so expounds it;d Herod and Pilate against Jesus; now Pilate was but a Judge, no king. So,e They were stoned, sawen asunder, wandered about in skins: and before, they stopped the mouths of Lions: In the plural, They: yet none stopped the Lions mouths but Daniel; none sawen but Isaiah, and that but by tradition: none wandered in skins but Elijah. So Beza observes upon that of John, fIt is written in the Prophets: yet none expressly saith so butg Isaiah: albeit indeedh Jeremiah hath something to the same sense. When a gentleman lights among clowns, and receives some injury by one of them; he is ready to say, look how these clowns abuse me; when one only did it. A father that is displeased with one of his children, will say, See how unruly these children are; when as but one only offended him. Indeed St.
2. Take one Instance more.q Matthew andr Marke say, that the theeves which were crucified with him, reviled him: the number was but two, and both of them are accused. Yet Luke sayes, that one of thems rebuked his fellow for that contumelie cast upon Christ; prayed, and was saved. This is a difficultie; how shall we understand it? Some answere, that at first both the theeves railed on Christ: but one of them, observing the patience of the sufferer in his extremitie, the wonderfull miracles, and the compassion of nature it selfe: the Sunnes darkening, the earths shaking, the stones rending; was converted; and did salve his former exprobration of Christ, with an humble confession of him.4 But against this may bee objected. First, These miracles were the effects of Christs death, and begun when he ended: but the theefe was then in articulo mortis, and could not be sensible of them. Secondly, When he reproved his fellow for reproching of Christ, why did he not reply; Thou hast also reviled him. Thirdly, It is the custome of the sacred story, when it hath disgraced a man for sinne, not to conceale the honour of his repentance, if ever he had remorse. St. Matthew therefore had done the malefactor some wrong, to set downe his offence, and not his penitence. The most and best expositors flie to this, with Augustine; that it was Enallage numeri: as,a The Disciples are charged to say, Why is this waste? When Saint Iohn chargeth onelyb Iudas with it. So,c The Kings of the earth set themselves against Christ: yet literally, no king but Herod: so Peter quotes it, and so expounds it;d Herod and Pilate against Iesus; now Pilate was but a Iudge, no king. So,e They were stoned, sawen asunder, wandred about in skinnes: and before, they stop't the mouthes of Lions: In the plurall, They: yet none stop't the Lions mouths but Daniel; none sawen but Esay, and that but by tradition: none wandred in skinnes but Elias. So Beza observes upon that of Iohn,
- qMatth. 17.44
- rMark. 15.32.
- sLuk. 23.40.
- 4Hieron. Chrys.
- aMat. 26.8.
- bJob. 12.4.Iob. 12.4.
- cPsal. 2.1.
- dAct. 4.26.27.
- eHebr. 11.33.37.
- fJoh. 6.•5.Ioh. 6.•5.
- gEsa. 54.13.
- hJer. 31.34.Ier. 31.34.