I come now to the third fine reason of Lombard which is alleged touching the loathing and horror.1 For thus he speaketh. And for this cause also, that the stomach should not abhor that which the eye did see, because we do not accustom our selves to devour raw flesh and blood. Go to, and what followeth then? therefore because it is not lawful too devour Christ with teeth, for this cause his pleasure was too deliver unto us flesh and blood in a mystery, &c. I do perceive what you speak, Lombard, and allow thereof: but how will you now agree with your self? for you deny it too be lawful too devour Christ with the teethe: And how then is he not devoured with teethe, if ye establish an essential nature of his body really in the sacrament? you say that he delivered ⟨image 92⟩us his fl•sh and blood in a mystery. This is truly spoken in deed, but how shall these Jermaines lips hang together: that the body of Christ is given in a mystery,2 and with all in very deed, to be devoured and not to be devoured, with teeth and not with teeth? For if in the Greek tongue a Mystery is all one in effect as in our language, a sacrament: And if the sacrament be a sign of an holy thing: now he that giveth his body in a mystery, what doth he give else, then a sign of his body? notwithstanding, I am not ignorant of all these your juggling and cavilling which you frequent about sacramental signs, under the which you maintain sturdily that the true and undoubted body of Christ, though not apparent to the eyes, yet is contained and eaten really and substantially by an invisible mean. I beseech you Lombard, what reason hath this your divinity, or rather drowsy slumber, to call us to a supper, to prepa•• feast, to set down in a dish the very real substantial and whole fleshly body of Christ, whereof the guest that is invited can not perceive nor see either form or substance? But you will say, that the mystery of the whole sacrament consisteth in the same, to wit, that we should not doubt that the substance of the body is mo•t truly present and eaten also bodily and really, though we see not the thing it self that we do eat: but you fall here into the elench logical called Petitio principii • For how shall this appear that the Lords pleasure was that we should eat the same which we do see?
I come nowe to the thirde fine reason of Lombard which is alleadged touching the loathing and horrour.1 For thus he speaketh. And for this cause also, that the stomacke should not abhorre that which the eye did see, bycause wee doe not accustome our selues to deuoure rawe fleshe and blood. Goe to, and what followeth then? therefore bicause it is not lawefull too deuoure Christe with teeth, for this cause his pleasure was too deliuer vnto vs fleshe and blood in a mysterie, &c. I doe perceiue what you speake, Lombard, and allowe thereof: but howe will you nowe agree with your selfe? for you deny it too bee lawefull too deuoure Christe with the teethe: And howe then is hee not deuoured with teethe, if ye establishe an essentiall nature of his body really in the sacrament? you saye that hee deliuered ⟨image 92⟩vs his fl•sh and blood in a mysterie. This is truely spoken in deede, but howe shall these Iermaines lippes hange together: that the body of Christe is giuen in a mysterie,2 and with all in very deede, to be deuoured and not to be deuoured, with teeth and not with teeth? For if in the Greeke tongue a Mystery is all one in effect as in our language, a sacrament: And if the sacrament bee a signe of an holy thing: nowe he that giueth his body in a mystery, what doth he giue els, then a signe of his body? notwithstanding, I am not ignorant of al these your iuggling and caffling which you frequent about sacramentall signes, vnder the which you mainteine sturdely that the true and vndouted body of Christe, though not apparant to the eyes, yet is conteined and eaten really and substantially by an inuisible meane. I beseeche you Lombard, what reason hath this your diuinitie, or rather drowsy slumber, to call vs to a supper, to prepa•• feast, to set downe in a dishe the very reall substantiall and whole fleshly body of Christe, whereof the gueste that is inuited can not perceiue nor see either forme or substāce? But you will saye, that the mysterie of the whole sacrament consisteth in the same, to wit, that we should not dout that the substance of the body is mo•t truely present and eaten also bodily and really, though wee see not the thing it selfe that we doe eate: but you fall here into the elenche logicall called Petitio principii • For howe shall this appeare that the Lordes pleasure was that wee should eate the same which we do see?
- 1The third reason of Lomb. li. 4 dist. 11. cap. 5.
- 2Lombard doth not agree with him self.Lombard doth not agree with him selfe.