By the which you see (holy father of Rome) unless you have lost your eyes & see nothing, what the doctrine and opinion touching the substance and faith of this sacrament was then in that old ancient age amongest those Catholic and godly ancient fathers: and how far this your new upstart changeling of transubstantiation doth differ not only from all ancient antiquity, but also from the trueth of the scripture it self, which many of your own frate•ny, Imps of this later age did not only very wisely foresee, but very frankly confess as your self do know well enough. For I suppose the name ⟨p. 104⟩of the Author or the words of the Author at the least be not unknown unto you, who albeit never durst deny transubstantiation himself: yet feared nothing •o v•ter his judgement thereof freely:1 The Church (sayeth he) did but very lately set down the determination touching transubstantiation: 2for before that, it was thought sufficient that the true body of Christ was contained really either under consecrated bread, or by any means else, but afterwards when the church began to look more narrowly into the substance of the matter, and to enter into more exact consideration thereof, it gave forth a more resolute determination of the same, &c. To the same effect almost writeth also John Fisher bishop of Rochester not the least Apostle of the Romish church, who in his book entitled A Defence for the King of England, discoursing upon transubstantiation and the use of the sacrament, cometh at the last to this conclusion, to wit, that Transubstantiation is grounded more upon the authority and determination of the church, then can be justifiable by the scriptures of God & the Gospel. Wherein he did not amiss. For who doth not know that in that first nursery of the Primitive Church, yea, and many hundred years after:3 whenas Bede, Bertram, and Rabanus Maurus were living in the world, even unto that unlucky hatching of Hildebrand and Innocent the third, not so much as this name Transubstantiation was ever heard of, until at the length in a Council holden at Lateran in Rome the solemn edict was established of banishing the substance of bread quyt• out of the sacrament.4 For if at any time before that council the church had defined any certain and grounded doctrine touching the same:
By the which you see (holy father of Rome) vnlesse you haue lost your eyes & see nothing, what the doctrine and opinion touching the substaunce and fayth of this sacrament was then in that olde auncient age amongest those Catholike and godly auncient fathers: and howe farre this your newe vpstart chaungeling of •rāsubstantiation doth differre not only from al auncient antiquity, but also from the trueth of the scripture it selfe, which many of your own frate•ny, Impes of this later age did not onely very wisely forsee, but very frankely confesse as your selfe do know wel ynough. For I suppose the name ⟨p. 104⟩of the Author or the wordes of the Author at the least bee not vnknowen vnto you, who albeit neuer durst deny transubstantiation himselfe: yet feared nothing •o v•ter his iudgement thereof freely:1 The Churche (saieth hee) did but very lately set down the determination touching transubstantiation: 2for before that, it was thought sufficient that the true body of Christ was conteined really either vnder consecrated bread, or by any meanes els, but afterwardes when the churche began to looke more narrowly into the substaunce of the matter, and to enter into more exact consideration therof, it gaue foorth a more resolute determinatiō of the same, &c. To the same effect almost writeth also Iohn Fisher bishop of Rochester not the least Apostle of the Romish church, who in his booke entituled A Defe•ce for the King of England, discoursing vppon transubstantiation and the vse of the sacrament, commeth at the last to this conclusion, to wit, that Trāsubstantiation is groūded more vpō the authoritie aud determination of the church, then can be iustifiable by the scriptures of God & the Gospel. Wherein he did not amisse. For who doth not know that in that first nourcery of the Primitiue Churche, yea, and many hundred yeeres after:3 whenas Bede, Bertram, and Rabanus Maurus were liuing in the world, euen vnto that vnlucky hatching of Hildebrande and Innocent the thi•de, not so much as this name Transubstantiation was euer hearde of, vntill at the length in a Councell hold•n at Laterane in Rome the solemne edicte was established of banishing the substaunce of bread quyt out of the sacrament.
- 1Eras•in Ann. in 1. Cor. 7.
- 2The Church did lately determine of transubstantiation.The Churche did lately determine of transubstantiation.
- 3When transubstantiation began first.
- 4The Lateran councel under Pope Innocent the third. Anno 1216.The •aterane councel vnder Pope Innocent the thi•d. Anno 1216.