A01268:210
A book made by John Frith prisoner in the tower of London answering unto M mores letter which he wrote against the first little treatise that John Frith made concerning the sacrament of the body and blood of, christ unto which book are added in the end the articles of his examination before the bishops ... for which John Frith was condemned a[n]d after bur[n]et ... the fourth day of Juli. Anno. 1533.A boke made by Iohn Frith prisoner in the tower of London answeringe vnto M mores lettur which he wrote agenst the first litle treatyse that Iohn̄ Frith made concerninge the sacramente of the body and bloude of, christ vnto which boke are added in the ende the articles of his examinacion before the bishoppes ... for which Iohn Frith was condempned a[n]d after bur[n]et ... the fourth daye of Iuli. Anno. 1533.
Imprinted at Monster i.e. Antwerp : Anno 1533 by me Conrad Willems i.e. H. Peetersen van Middelburch?, 1533Imprinted at Monster i.e. Antwerp : Anno 1533 by me Conrade Willems i.e. H. Peetersen van Middelburch?, 1533
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Now to be short / in thes .iij. points frith dissenteth from our prelates & from master ⟨image 77⟩More which taketh upon him to be their proctor. §1Our prelates believe that in the sacrament remaineth no bred / but that it is turned in to the natural body of Christ both flesh blood & bones. Frith saith that it is none article of our Creed: and therefore let them believe it that will. And he thinketh that there remaineth bred still. And that he proveth, iij. manner of ways.1 First by the scripture of Paul / which calleth it bred saying the breed which we break / is it not the fellowship of the body of christ? For we though we be many / are yet one body and one bred / as many as are partakers of one bred.2 And again he sa•eth / as often as ye eat of this bred or drink of this cup / you shall show the lords death until he come. Also luke calleth it bred saying in the Acts3 they continued in the fellowship of the apostles / & in the breaking of the breed and prayer.4 56Also Christ called the cup the fruit of a vine / saying I shall not from hence forward drink of the fruit of the vine until I drink that new in the ki• dom of my father.
NOw to be short / in thes .iij. poyntes frith dissenteth from oure prelates & from master ⟨image 77⟩More wc taketh vppon him to be their proctoure. §1Oure prelates beleue that in the sacrament remayneth no bred / but that yt ys torned in to the naturall bodye of Christ both fleshe bloude & bones. Frith sayth that yt is none article of oure Crede: and therfore let them beleue yt that will. And he thinketh that there remayneth bred styll. And that he proueth, iij. maner of wayes.1 Fyrste by the scripture of Paule / wc calleth yt bred sayinge the brede wc we breake / ys yt not the fellowship of the bodie of christe? For we though we be manye / are yet one bodye and one bred / as mannye as are partakers of one bred.2 And agayne he sa•eth / as oftē as ye eate of this bred or drīke of this cuppe / you shall shewe the lordes deth vn•yll he come. Also luke callethe yt bred saying in the Actes3 they continued in the fellowship of the aposteles / & in the breakinge of the brede and prayer.4 56Also Christe called the cuppe the frute of a vyne / saying I shall not from hence forward drinke of the frute of the vine vntill I drinke that newe in the ki• dom of my father.
Furthermore nature doth teach you that both the bred and wine continue in their nature. For the bred mouldeth if it be kept long / yea & worms bred in it. And the poor mouse will run away with it and eat it / which are evidence enough that there remaineth bred. Also the wine if it were reserved / would wax sower / as they confess them selvest And therefore they housel the lay people / but with one kind only: because the wine can not continue nor be reserved to have ready ⟨image 78⟩at hand / when need were. And surely as y• there remained no bred / it could not mould nor wax full of worms / even so if there remained no wine / it could n•t wax sower. And therefore it is but false doctrine tha• our prelates so long have taught & published.
Furthermore nature doth teache you that both the bred and wine contin•e in their nature. For the bred muldeth yf yt be kept longe / ye & wormis bred in yt. And ye poore mouse will runne awaye wt yt and eate yt / wc are euidence ynough that there remaynith bred. Also the wine yf yt were reserued / wold wax sower / as they confesse them selues• And therfore they howsell the laye people / but wt one kinde onlye: because the wine can not cōtinue nor be re••rued to haue readye ⟨image 78⟩at hande / when nede were. And surelye as y• there remayned no bred / yt could not mould nor wax full of wormes / euyn so yf there remayned no wine / yt could n•t wax sower. And therfore yt is but faulse doctrine tha• our p̄lates so long haue taught & published.
Finally that there remaineth bred / might be proved by the authority of many doctors with call it bred & wine / even as Christ & his apostles dead And though some sophisters would wrest their saying / and expound them after their own •hantas•e / yet shall I allege them one doctor which was pope / that maketh so plain with us that they shall never be able to avoid him.
Finallie that ther remaineth bred / might be ꝓuyd by the auctorite of manie doctoures wt calle yt bred & wine / euyn as Christe & his appostelis ded And though some sophisters wolde wreste their sayinge / and expoūd thē after their owyn •hantas•e / yet shall I allege thē one doctoure wc was pope / that maketh so plaine wt vs that they shall neuer be able to auoyde hym.
1For pope Gelasius writeth on this manner. Certe sacramenta q sumimus corporis & sanguinis Christi• divinae res sunt, propter qd & per eadē divinae efficimur consortes naturae. Et tamē nō de•init esse substantia uel natura panis et uini, sed permanet in suae proprietate naturae. Et certe imago et similitudo corporis & sanguinis Christi in actione misteriorū celebrantur. That is to say / surely the sacrament of the body & blood of Christ with we receive / are a godly thing / & therefore thorough them are we made partakers of the godly nature. And yet doth it not cease to be the substance or nature of bred and wine / but they continue in the property of their own nature. And surely the image and similitude of the body and blood are celebrated in the act of the mysteries This I am sure / that no man can avoid it / nor so wrest it / but that all men shall soon espy his folly / and therefore I may conclude that there remaineth the ⟨image 78⟩substance and nature of breed & wine.
1For pope Gelasius writeth on this maner. Certe sacramēta q sumimus corporis & sanguinis Christi• diuinae res sunt, propter qd & per eadē diuinae efficimur cōsortes naturae. Et tamē nō de•init esse substātia uel natura panis et uini, sed ꝑmanet in suae ꝓprietate naturae. Et certe imago et similitudo corporis & sanguinis Christi in actiōe misteriorū celebrantur. That is to saie / surelye the sacramēt of the bdye & bloude of Christe wt we receyue / are a godlye thynge / & therfore thorough th•m are we made ꝑtakers of the godly nature. And yet doth yt not cease to be the substāce or nature of bred and wine / but they continue in the propertie of their owyn nature. And surely the image and similitude of the bodye and bloude are celebrated in the acte of the misterys This I am sure / that no mā can auoyd yt / nor so wrest yt / but that all men shall sone espye hys folye / and therfore I maye conclude that there remayneth the ⟨image 78⟩
The prelates believe that his very flesh is present to the teeth of them that eat the sacrament / and that the wicked eat his very body Frith saith that it is none article of our Creed and therefore he reckoneth that he is in no Jeopardy though he believe it not. And he thinketh that his flesh is not present unto the teeth of them that receive the sacrament. For his flesh is only in one place at once. And that he proveth both by the authority of Sainct Austen ad Dardanum / and also by the authority of Fulgentius ad Thrasuvandum libro 20. as before appeareth in the book. And Frith saith that the wicked eat not his very flesh although they receive the sacrament. And that he proveth by the scripture / doctors and good reason grounded upon the scriptures.
THe prelates beleue that his verie fleshe is p̄sent to the teth of thē that eate the sacrament / and that the wicked eate his verye bodye Frith sayth that yt is none article of our Crede and therfore he rekenith that he is in no Ieoperdye though he beleue yt not. And he thinketh that his fleshe is not p̄sent vnto the teth of thē that receyue the sacrament. For hys fleshe ys onlye in one place at once. And that he proue•h both by the auctorite of Sainct Austen ad Dardanum / and also by the auctorite of Fulgentius ad Thrasuuādum libro 20. as before apereth in the boke. And Fryth sayth that the wicked eate not hys verye fleshe allthough they receue the sacrament. And that he proueth by the scripture / doctoures and good reason grounded vppon the scryptures.
The scripture is this / he that eateth christs1 body hath everlasting life / but the wicked hath not everlasting life / ergo then the wicked eat not his body. Again the scripture sayeth he that eateth christs flesh & drinketh his blood abideth in christ & christ in him but the wicked abide not in christ nor christ in him / ergo the wicked eat not his flesh nor drink his blood.
The scripture is this / he that eateth christes1 bodie hath euerlastīge liffe / but the wicked hath not euerlastinge liffe / ergo then the wicked eate not his bodye. Agayne the scrypture sayeth he that eateth christes fleshe & drinketh his bloude abydeth in christe & christe in hī but the wicked abyde not in christe nor christe ī hī / ergo the wicked eate not his fleshe nor drinke his bloude.
This may also be confirmed by good authority.1 For saint Austen sayeth he that ab•deth not in christ & in whom christ abideth not / with ou•e doubt he eateth not his flesh nor drinketh his ⟨image 79⟩blood / although he eat & drink the sacrament of so great a thing unto his damnation.
This maye also be confyrmed by good auctorite.1 For sainct Austen sayeth he that ab•deth not in christe & in whō christe abydeth not / wt ou•e doubte he eateth not his fleshe nor drīketh his ⟨image 79⟩bloude / allthough he eate & drinke the sacramēt of so great a thinge vnto his •ampnacion.
1Again. s. Austen sayeth / he that abideth not in me & in whom I abide not / let him not say nor think / that he eateth my body or drinketh my blood. And even the same words hath Bede upon the sixth chapter of the first epistle to the Corinthians. And even the same sentence hath Ambrose / and Prosper / and Bede upon the .xi chapter of the first pistle to the Corinthians.
1Agayne. s. Austene sayeth / he that abideth not in me & in whom I abyde not / let him not saye nor thinke / that he eateth my bodye or drinketh my bloude. And euen the same wordes hath Beda vppon the sixt chapter of the firste epistle to the Corinthiās. And euen the same sentēce hath Ambrose / and Prosper / ād Beda vppon the .xi chapter of the firste pistle to the Corinthians.
Finally this may be proved by good reason grounded upon the scripture. Christ would not suffer Mary (though she loved him well) to touch him / because she lacked one point of faith / and did not believe that he was equal with his father. And therefore be reason it must follow / that he will not suffer the wicked (which nether have good faith nor love towards him) both to touch him and eat him in to their unclean bodies
Finallye this maye be proued by good reason grounded vppon the scripture. Christ wold not suffer marye (though she loued him well) to touche him / because she lacked one poynt of faythe / and did not beleue that he was equale wt his father. And therfore be reason yt muste followe / that he wil not suffer the wicked (wc nether haue good faith nor loue towardes hī) both to touche him and eate him in to their vnclene bodies
Now sith this is proved true that the wicked eat not his body / it must also thereof needs follow / that the sacrament is not his natural body For they do eat the sacrament as all men know
Now sith this is proued true that the wicked eate not his bodie / yt must also therof nedes followe / that the sacramēt is not his naturall bodie For they do eate the sacramēt as all men knowe
Besides that the faithful do not eat christs body with their teeth. And therefore it must follow that the wicked do not eat it with there teeth. The antecedent or first pert of the reason is proved by the words of christ which saith that the flesh profiteth nothing at all / meaning that it doth not profit as they understood him:1 that is to say / it ⟨image 79⟩profiteth nothing to be eaten carnally with their teeth & belly / as they understood him. For else it profiteth much to be eaten spiritually / that is to say / to believe that thorough his body breaking and blood shedding our sins are purged. And thus doth Origene / s. Austen / Bede / Chrysostom / and Athanasius expound it / as appeareth in the book before. And therefore Frith saith that only faithful men eat his body: not with there teeth and mouth / but with their faith and heart / y• digest it in to the bowels of their soulless thorough believing that it was broken on the cross / to wash away their since. And the wicked eat not his body but on•ye the bred and there damnation / because they eat him not spiritually: that is / because they believe not in his body breaking and blood shedding.
Besides that the faithfull do not eate christes bodye wt their teth. And therfore yt muste followe that the wicked do not eate yt wt ther teth. The antecedēt or first ꝑte of the reason is ꝓued by the wordes of christe wc saith that the fleshe ꝓfiteth nothinge at all / meaning that yt doth not ꝓfite as they vnderstode him:1 that is to saie / yt ⟨image 79⟩profiteth nothinge to be eaten carnallie wt their teth & bellye / as they vnderstode him. For els yt profyteth moche to be eatē spūallye / that ys to saye / to beleue that thorough his bodye breakinge and bloud shedinge oure sinnes are purged. And thus doth Origene / s. Aus•en / Beda / Chrisostome / and Athanasius expoūd yt / as apereth in the boke before. And therfore Frith saith that onlie faithfull mē eate his bodie: not wt ther teth and mouth / but wt their faieth ād harte / y digest yt in to the bowelles of their soulles thorough beleuing that yt was brokē on the crosse / to washe awaye their synnes. And the wicked eate not his bodye but onye the bred and there dāpnacyon / because they eate him not spūallie: that is / because they beleue not in his bodie breakinge and bloude shedinge.