A01272:60
An other book against Rastel named the subsidy or bulwark to his first book,…An other boke against Rastel named the subsedye or bulwark to his fyrst boke,…
An other book against Rastel named the subsidy or bulwark to his first book, made by John Frith preso[n]ner in the TowerAn other boke against Rastel named the subsedye or bulwark to his fyrst boke, made by Ihon Frithe preso[n]ner in the Tower
London? : S.n., 1537?
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
I trow sayeth Rastell all wise men would think that this were a fond exposition and yet this exposition would please children fools and mad men / as well as the exposicy on of Saint Austayne or Saint Hierom or any other doctor of the church / because it would make them to laugh, so (sayeth Rastell) Frith maketh such expositions with jesting and railing to make the people laugh / not regarding to edify the people / nor to provoke them to virtue meekness or charity nor to leave their sin / but rather giveth them boldness and to believe that their is no purgatory nor hell / but mocketh and jesteth at those reasons that be made for prove of purgatory.
I trowe sayeth Rastell all wyse men wolde thinke that this were a fonde exposiciō and yet this exposicoyn wolde please chylderne foles and mad men / as well as the exposicy on of Saynt Austayne or Saynte Hierom or any other doctour of the churche / because it wolde make them to laugh, so (sayeth Rastell) Frith maketh suche exposicions wyth yestynge and raylinge to make the people laugh / not regardinge to edifye the people / nor to prouoke them to vertue mekenes or charyte nor to leue theyr syn̄e / but rather geueth thē bouldenes and to beleue that their is no purgatory nor hell / but mocketh and yestethe at those reasons that be made for proue of purgatorye.
Now as touching the first part / where1 he sayeth that my expositions be an occasion to bring the people to boldness of sin / I axe him why? his answer is because I give them boldness that there is no purgatory / nor yet hell / thereto Rastel by his ⟨image 15⟩leave (maketh a fitten) I dare not say he maketh a lye for that he would call• railing for I never denied hell / but affirm in many places of my book and even in the first side of mine answer against him I affirm hell / and perpetual damnation / but when ye come to the proof of his words / then you shall see how wisely the man concludeth / for he thinketh that ab inferiori ad suum superius confuse distribue / men shall think it a good consequent as if I should say that we lack fire in prison / then would he conclude that there lacked fire in all Middlesex Or if I would say their were no wit in Rastels heed / then would he conclude that their were no wit in no mans heed / he hath so long studied philosophy / that he hath clean forgotten his principals of sophistry / notwithstanding we will forgive him this fault for the man is somewhat aged and therefore I think it is long sins he read them / and that they are now out of his memory: nevertheless he will say that his argument is not solved for although I deny not hell / yet I deny purgatory / and so I give the people an occasion to sin / because they fear not purgatory / where unto I have so sufficiently answered in Rastels seventh argument that I wonder that he is not a shamed to bring the same again but he trusteth that my books shall never be read / and his may goo surely abroad / and