A01273:103
A disputacio[n] of purgatory madeA disputacio[n] of purgatorye made
A disputacio[n] of purgatory made by Joh[a]n Frith which is divided in to three books. The first book is an answer unto Rastell, which goeth about to prove purgatory by natural philosophy. The second book answereth unto Sir Thomas More, which laboureth to prove purgatory by scripture. The third book maketh answer unto my lord of Rochester which most leaneth unto the doctorsA disputacio[n] of purgatorye made by Ioh[a]n Frith which is deuided in to thre bokes. The first boke is an answere vnto Rastell, which goeth aboute to proue purgatorye by naturall phylosophye. The seconde boke answereth vnto Sir Thomas More, which laboureth to proue purgatorye by scripture. The thirde boke maketh answere vnto my lorde of Rochestre which most leaneth vnto the doctoures
Antwerp : S. Cock, 1531?
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
This reason hath no great pith. Notwithstanding1 if it were well prosecuted / it would be to hard for Rastell to avoid it. For this is no formal argument / it is mete that the body which offendeth with the soul should be purged with the soul / ergo purgatory must be upon the earth. For god may join the body and soul together again after they be departed and so punish them together although purgatory were not in earth / even where so ever it be. And therefore thus me thinketh it should well follow.
This reason hath no greate pith. Notwithstondinge1 if it were well prosequuted / it wold be to harde for Rastell to avoyde it. For this is no formall argument / it is mete that the bodye which offendeth with the soule shuld be purged with the soule / ergo purgatorye must be vppon the erth. For god maye ioyne the bodye and sou le to gether agayne after they be departed and so punish them to gether although purgatorye were not in erth / even where so ever it be. And therfore thus me thinketh it shulde well folow.
- 1Frith.
The body was follow and partner with the soul in committing the crime and sin / §23and shall also be partaker of the glory which ⟨image 23⟩is prepared for them that love god. wherefore it is reason if the soul should be purged and punished in purgatory: that y• body should also suffer with him in purgatory: feign that place of purgatory where you will / in heaven / in earth or in hell But wot ye what Rastell would here say unto me? for south even as he did in the first chapter of the third dialogue. that is to say: he would stoutly affirm that the body suffereth neither well nor woo / joy nor pain / good nor evil / and therefore it needeth not go to purgatory. And by that reason it is folly that the body should go either to heaven or hell. for it neigh there feeleth pleasure nor pain. this is new learning in deed. But I think there is no christen man so foolish as to believe him.