A01273:134
A disputacio[n] of purgatory madeA disputacio[n] of purgatorye made
A disputacio[n] of purgatory made by Joh[a]n Frith which is divided in to three books. The first book is an answer unto Rastell, which goeth about to prove purgatory by natural philosophy. The second book answereth unto Sir Thomas More, which laboureth to prove purgatory by scripture. The third book maketh answer unto my lord of Rochester which most leaneth unto the doctorsA disputacio[n] of purgatorye made by Ioh[a]n Frith which is deuided in to thre bokes. The first boke is an answere vnto Rastell, which goeth aboute to proue purgatorye by naturall phylosophye. The seconde boke answereth vnto Sir Thomas More, which laboureth to proue purgatorye by scripture. The thirde boke maketh answere vnto my lorde of Rochestre which most leaneth vnto the doctoures
Antwerp : S. Cock, 1531?
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Upon this text would I fain dispute a point of sophistry / which I would gladly have dissolved of them that think them selves learned in philosophy. My sophism is / y• two contradictories may stand together and be1 both true. which I am sure no sophister dare grant / for it hath in times past ben condemned in oxford foran•eresie. The contradictories are these. Every man shall receive according to the works of his body. And some man shall not receive according to the works of his bo dye / that these two contradictories be both true I will prove. The first proposition is pauls ⟨image 31⟩2. Cor. 5. which no man will deny to be true. And the second may caselye be proved true / which is / that some man shall not receive according to the works of his body. For be y• in case y• there depart a man out of thys worl de which is not clean purged by faith and y• wor de of god neither hath his rebellious members subdued through death (as they imagine) but y• the spots and remnants of sin remain in him for the which he is worthy to lye in y• pains of purgatory for the space of six year This granted / which I am sure they will not deny / then also put I the case that this man lying in purgatory by the space of a month / have a friend which offereth for him a penny unto. S. dominikes box (which hath such power that as soon as the tinging is hard in the box so soon the soul is free in heaven) or that a friend of his bye a pardon for him which may absolve him a pena & a culpa for all cometh to one effect. This man delivered on that manner doth not receive according to the works of his bo dye for by the works of his body he should yet lye in purgatory more then. v. year? And that doth he not / but is by and by delivered from purgatory. Ergo I may conclude that some man receiveth not according to the works of his body / and so are two contradictories true or else there can be no such deliverance out of purgatory / which destroyeth all pardons / mass pence and suffrages for the deed. This would I have solved. How be it I will not adnumbre it for an argument because the unlearned people (unto whom I write this book) can not well perceive it. But this sophism have I written to stop the chattering mouths of the