A01273:164
A disputacio[n] of purgatory madeA disputacio[n] of purgatorye made
A disputacio[n] of purgatory made by Joh[a]n Frith which is divided in to three books. The first book is an answer unto Rastell, which goeth about to prove purgatory by natural philosophy. The second book answereth unto Sir Thomas More, which laboureth to prove purgatory by scripture. The third book maketh answer unto my lord of Rochester which most leaneth unto the doctorsA disputacio[n] of purgatorye made by Ioh[a]n Frith which is deuided in to thre bokes. The first boke is an answere vnto Rastell, which goeth aboute to proue purgatorye by naturall phylosophye. The seconde boke answereth vnto Sir Thomas More, which laboureth to proue purgatorye by scripture. The thirde boke maketh answere vnto my lorde of Rochestre which most leaneth vnto the doctoures
Antwerp : S. Cock, 1531?
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
His second reason that he hath to prove1 purgatory is this: The very miscreants and idolaters / Turks / Saracens and paynims ha ue ever for the most part thought and believed that after the bodies are deceased: the souls of such as were neither deadly damned wretches ⟨image 40⟩for ever / nor on the tother side / so good […] that their offences done in this world have deserved more punishment then they had suffered and sustained there / were purged and punished by pain aster the death / ere ever they were admitted unto their wealth & rest. And so must there needs be a purgatory.
His second reason that he hath to proue1 purgatorye is this: The verye miscreauntes ād idolatres / Turkes / Saracenes and paynims ha ue ever for the most parte thought and beleued that after the bodyes are deceased: the soules of such as were neyther deedlye dampned wretches ⟨image 40⟩for euer / nor on the tother syde / so good 〈…〉 that their offences done in this worlde haue deserved more punishment then they had suffered and sustayned there / were purged and punished by payne aster the deeth / ere ever they were admit•ed vnto their welth & rest. And so must there nedes be a purgatorye.
- 1M. more
I answer / if it were lawful to require wy1 sodom in a man so wise as Master More is counted / here would I wish him a little more wit. for I think there is no wise man that will grant this to be a good argument / the Turks / Saracens / paynims & Jews believe it to be true / ergo we must believe that it is true: for I will show you a like argument. The Turks / Saracens / paynims and Jews believe that we have not the right Christ / but that we are all damned which believe in Christ. Is it therefore true? shall we turn our faith because they believe that we be deceived? I think there is no man so foolish as to grant him this. But if Master More will have his reason hold / he must argue on this manr: The […] and infidels before named believe that there is a purgatory & their believe is true / therefore we must believe that there is a purgatory. Now followeth this argu meant sum what more formally. Here might I put him to the proof of his minor / which is / that their belief (in believing purgatory) is true: which thing he shall never be able to prove. But I have such confidence of the truth on my side […] I will take upon me to prove the negative / Even that their belief is not true as […] purgatory. for these miscreants which […] purgatory (believe not that there is a purgatory for us that be Christen: for they believe