A01540:425
A just defence of certain passages in a former treatise concerning the nature and…A iust defence of certaine passages in a former treatise concerning the nature and…
A just defence of certain passages in a former treatise concerning the nature and use of lots, against such exceptions and oppositions as have been made thereunto to Mr. I.B. Wherein the insufficiency of his answers given to the arguments brought in defence of a lusorious lot is manifested; the imbecility of his arguments produced against the same further discovered; and the point it self in controversy more fully cleared; by Thomas Gataker B. of D. and author of the former treatise.A iust defence of certaine passages in a former treatise concerning the nature and vse of lots, against such exceptions and oppositions as have beene made thereunto to Mr. I.B. Wherein the insufficiencie of his answers giuen to the arguments brought in defence of a lusorious lot is manifested; the imbecillitie of his arguments produced against the same further discouered; and the point it selfe in controuersie more fully cleared; by Thomas Gataker B. of D. and author of the former treatise.
London: printed by John Haviland for Robert Bird, 1623London: printed by Iohn Haviland for Robert Bird, 1623
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Only I add ⟨p. 188⟩thereunto, upon further view of the place, that it is evidently apparent by the whole sequel of the Sermon, (the main scope whereof is to persuade men to rest satisfied with Gods will and pleasure in all accidents and occurrents, as loss of friends by decease, and the like) that Bernards *meaning is, that when ought falleth out, whether by casualty (which he mentioneth, because that might most be stuck at) or otherwise, Gods will was thereby manifested that so it should be, and therefore that we were to submit to Gods will in it. But no more will it hence follow, that there is an immediate providence of God in all casual things, more than in any other sort of events. Gods decreeing will in every event is revealed by his work. And every event, be it casual, or not casual, is a word of God revealing his pleasure unto us, and acquainting us with his will. For the latter allegation Mr. B. most shamefully abuseth me, or himself, and his Reader rather, clipping off just so much of the sentence spoken by me; as to make it speak directly contrary to that that it doth. He bringeth me in affirming, that In casual events there is nothing guiding them but Gods providence. Whereas my words are these, mIf in casual events we consider ought beside the creature and the uncertain motion thereof, (uncertain, I say, to us, because not determinable by us, though determined ordinarily by some natural cause or other) there is nothing guiding them but Gods providence. I remember one that in the Schools gave this Position to be disputed of, Virtus est vitium; and being required to show some Author for it, produced Horace, where he saith, ⟨p. 189⟩nVirtus est vitium fugere. And I could relate the like trick that a Popish Priest sometime showed me in some things that passed in writing between him and me. And such shifting may well be seem such as they are. But I would wish Mr. B. to be better advised than to deal thus, if he regard his own credit. Which I wonder he would thus hazard the calling in question, unless he thought that no body would take the pains to search the places quoted by him: where how that that I say, fitteth his turn, may soon be seen, or rather how directly it contradicteth it.