T. G. Mr. B. having in stead of proving it overthrown his own Proposition: now cometh to try, if he can yet make good Mr. Easties.
A thing may be warranted, say I, though neither by precept or practise, yet by permission.
Against this Mr. B. objecteth, that for a thing permitted some precept may be. I answer.
1. Unless he say, must be, he saith nothing; because he saith nothing to the purpose.
2. If there be a precept for ought, so far forth it is not barely permitted: for where permission is, athe thing is left free.
Yea but Mr. G. saith, that recreation is warrantable both by permission and by precept. True by precept in some cases, by permission in other: or by precept in general, by permission in particular, for balls or bowls, and the like.
Yea but again Mr. G. saith, (to let the rest pass of Mr. Bs. bBesoms here without bands) that every ⟨p. 259⟩thing indifferent, is lawful, if by rule, and consequently, if you give Mr. B. leave to expound it as he list, by precept. Let me mind Mr. B. what before he told us, it is ca cursed gloss that corrupteth the Text. Doth every Rule necessarily imply a precept? Then belike of things Indifferent, that is, (not, of things neither good nor bad; in which sense my former words cited by Mr. B. jumbling things here together, nothing to the purpose, are to be understood; but) of things neither enjoined nor inhibited, no Rules can be given. But let us try (though it be too palpable) the truth hereof. When the Apostle saith, dA woman is free to marry again if her husband be deceased. Is it not a Rule? Or is it therefore a precept? when he saith, eIf an infidel inviteth you, you may go if you will: for fthat is also implied: and, when you are there, you may eat of all that is set before you without scruple of conscience. Are not these Rules, and yet no precepts? If they be, by Mr. Bs. own grant, Mr. Gs. exception against Mr. Easties proposition standeth good, and the proposition consequently is unsound.
T. G. Mr. B. hauing in stead of prouing it ouerthrowne his owne Proposition: now commeth to try, if he can yet make good Mr. Easties.
A thing may be warranted, say I, though neither by precept or practise, yet by permission.
Against this Mr. B. obiecteth, that for a thing permitted some precept may be. I answer.
1. Vnlesse he say, must be, he saith nothing; because he saith nothing to the purpose.
2. If there be a precept for ought, so farre forth it is not barely permitted: for where permission is, athe thing is left free.
Yea but Mr. G. saith, that recreation is warrantable both by permission and by precept. True by precept in some cases, by permission in other: or by precept in generall, by permission in particular, for balls or bowles, and the like.
Yea but againe Mr. G. saith, (to let the rest passe of Mr. Bs. bBesomes here without bands) that euery ⟨p. 259⟩thing indifferent, is lawfull, if by rule, and consequently, if you giue Mr. B. leaue to expound it as he list, by precept. Let me minde Mr. B. what before he told vs, it is ca cursed glosse that corrupteth the Text. Doth euery Rule necessarily imply a precept? Then belike of things Indifferent, that is, (not, of things neither good nor bad; in which sense my former words cited by Mr. B. iumbling things heere together, nothing to the purpose, are to be vnderstood; but) of things neither inioyned nor inhibited, no Rules can be giuen. But let vs try (though it be too palpable) the truth hereof. When the Apostle saith, dA woman is free to marry againe if her husband be deceased. Is it not a Rule? Or is it therefore a precept? when he saith, eIf an infidell inuiteth you, you may goe if you will: for fthat is also implied: and, when you are there, you may eat of all that is set before you without scruple of conscience. Are not these Rules, and yet no precepts? If they bee, by Mr. Bs. owne grant, Mr. Gs. exception against Mr. Easties proposition standeth good, and the proposition consequently is vnsound.
- aLibera res relinquitur. Calvin. in 1 Cor. 7. Huc illud in Jure Canonico, Quod licet, non praecipitur. Zachar. Ferrer. addit. ad Abbat. de Cohab. Cler. & mull.Libera res relinquitur. Calvin. in 1 Cor. 7. Huc illud in Iure Canonico, Quod licet, non praecipitur. Zachar. Ferrer. addit. ad Abbat. de Cohab. Cler. & mul.
- bScopae dissolutae. Cic. de orat. perfect.
- cMaledicta glossa quae corrumpit textum.
- d1 Cor. 7. 39.
- e1 Cor. 10. 27.
- fIre vel non ireliberum vobis relinquo. Morton.