1. Observe that Saint John lays this fault on Judas 1only: but Saint Matthew and Mark charge the Disciples with it, and find them guilty of this repining: and that (in both, [Greek or Hebrew]) not without Indignation. This knot is easily untied; Judas was the ring-leader, and his voice was the voice of Jacob, all charitable; but his hands were the hands of Esau, rough and injurious: Judas pleads, for the poor, the whole Synod, likes the motion well; they second it with their verdicts: their words agree; but their spirits differ: Judas hath a further reach; to distil this ointment through the Limbeck of hypocrisy into his own purse; the Apostles mean plainly: Judas was malicious against his master; they simply thought the poor had more need. So sensible and ample a difference do circumstances put into one and the same action: presumption ⟨p. 4⟩or weakness, knowledge or ignorance, simplicity or craft do much aggravate or mitigate an offence. The Apostles consent to the circumstance, not to the substance, setting as it were) their hands to a blank paper: it was in them pity, rather then piety, in Judas neither pity nor piety, but plain perfidy, an exorbitant and transcendent sin, that would have brought innocence it self into the same condemnation: thus the aggregation of circumstances, is the aggravation of offences. Consider his covetise, fraud, malice, hypocrisy, and you will say, his sin was monstrous; sine modo, like a Mathematical line, (divisibilis in semper divisibilia) infinitely divisible. The other Apostles receive the infection, but not into so corrupted stomachs, therefore it may make them sick, not kill them: sin they do, but not unto death. It is a true rule even in good works: finibus non officijs, discernendae sunt virtutes a vitijs: virtues are discerned from vices not by their offices, but by their ends or intents: neither the outward form, no nor (often) the event, is a sure rule to measure the action by: the eleven Tribes went twice by Gods special word and warrant against the Beniamites, yet in both assaults received the overthrow. Cùm Pater 2filium, Christus corpus, Judas Dominum, res eadem, non causa, non intentio operantis: when God gave his Son, Christ gave himself, Judas gave his Master; here was the same work, not the same cause nor intention in the workers:
1. Obserue that Saint Iohn laies this fault on Iudas 1only: but Saint Mathew and Marke charge the Disciples with it, and finde them guilty of this repining: and that (in both, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉) not without Indignation. This knot is easily vntied; Iudas was the ring-leader, and his voice was the voice of Iacob, all charitable; but his hands were the hands of Esau, rough and iniurious: Iudas pleades, for the poore, the whole Synode, likes the motion well; they second it with their verdits: their words agree; but their spirits differ: Iudas hath a further reach; to distill this ointment thorow the Limbecke of hypocrisie into his owne purse; the Apostles meane plainly: Iudas was malicious against his master; they simply thought the poore had more neede. So sensible and ample a difference doe circumstances put into one and the same action: presumption ⟨p. 4⟩or weaknesse, knowledge or ignorance, simplicity or craft doe much aggrauate or mitigate an offence. The Apostles consent to the circumstance, not to the substance, setting as it were) their hands to a blancke paper: it was in them pitty, rather then piety, in Iudas neither pitty nor piety, but plaine perfidie, an exorbitant and transcendent sinne, that would haue brought innocence it selfe into the same condemnation: thus the aggregation of circumstances, is the aggrauation of offences. Consider his couetise, fraud, malice, hypocrisie, and you will say, his sinne was monstrous; sine modo, like a Mathematicall line, (diuisibilis in semper diuisibilia) infinitely diuisible. The other Apostles receiue the infection, but not into so corrupted stomackes, therefore it may make them sicke, not kill them: sinne they doe, but not vnto death. It is a true rule euen in good workes: finibus non officijs, discernendae sunt virtutes a vitijs: vertues are discerned from vices not by their offices, but by their ends or intents: neither the outward forme, no nor (often) the euent, is a sure rule to measure the action by: the eleuen Tribes went twice by Gods speciall word and warrant against the Beniamites, yet in both assaults receaued the ouerthrow. Cùm Pater 2filium, Christus corpus, Iudas Dominum, res eadem, non causa, non intentio operantis: when God gaue his sonne, Christ gaue himselfe, Iudas gaue his Master; here was the same worke, not the same cause nor intention in the workers:
- 1Generally. Matt. 26. 8. Mark. 14. 4.
- 2Aug.