A friendly trial of the grounds tending to separation in a plain and modest…A friendly triall of the grounds tending to separation in a plain and modest…
A friendly trial of the grounds tending to separation in a plain and modest dispute touching the lawfulness of a stinted liturgy and set form of prayer, Communion in mixed assemblies, and the primitive subject and first receptacle of the power of the Keys: tending to satisfy the doubtful, recall the wandering, and to strengthen the weak: by John Ball.A friendly triall of the grounds tending to separation in a plain and modest dispute touching the lawfulnesse of a stinted liturgie and set form of prayer, Communion in mixed assemblies, and the primitive subject and first receptacle of the power of the Keyes: tending to satisfie the doubtfull, recall the wandering, and to strengthen the weak: by John Ball.
John Ball 1585–1640Cambridge: printed by Roger Daniel printer to the University of Cambridge for Edward Brewster, 1640Cambridge: printed by Roger Daniel printer to the Universitie of Cambridge for Edward Brewster, 1640
[16], 314, [4] p. · 84k words · STC 1313 · ESTC S122227
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
And so the whole controversy turneth upon this one hinge, Whether one or two or some few private Christians have power to cast out and excommunicate whole societies & churches for some remissness or abuse in bearing with or admitting scandalous offenders in ⟨p. 211⟩the societies, so long as the doctrine of grace is purely taught, the sacraments rightly administered for substance, Christ is pleased to tolerate and bear with their manners, continueth the visible signs of his presence among them, and is present by special grace to bless his ordinances to the worthy receiver. A few words one would think might suffice in this matter: but seeing the strength of the cause lieth therein, in the chapters following it shall be handled more at large.
And so the whole controversie turneth upon this one hinge, Whether one or two or some few private Christians have power to cast out and excommunicate whole societies & churches for some remissenesse or abuse in bearing with or admitting scandalous offenders in ⟨p. 211⟩the societies, so long as the doctrine of grace is purely taught, the sacraments rightly administred for substance, Christ is pleased to tolerate and bear with their manners, continueth the visible signes of his presence among them, and is present by speciall grace to blesse his ordinances to the worthy receiver. A few words one would think might suffice in this matter: but seeing the strength of the cause lieth therein, in the chapters following it shall be handled more at large.
in that some came to it drunken; there was fornication and such like sins not repented of; things indifferent were used with manifest offence, and idolatry committed in eating at the tables of idols meats sacrificed to devils: Notwithstanding all which abuses that society is called and was the church of God,
and the faithful did and might communicate with others without pollution. The Galatians had so far adulterated the Gospel of Christ that the Apostle telleth them they were removed to another Gospel, pronounceth that they were bewitched,
but was dead; her works were not perfect before God; there were but a few there who had not defiled their garments: Of Laodicea it is recorded that she was neither hot nor cold, and then it is not hard to conceive how she was overgrown with disorders; and yet Christ was present with her by his grace, and the faithful are exhorted to repent, or beware of her sin, and not to forsake her society.
Of the abuses in the church of Rome something hath been noted before: Of corruptions and disorders in other churches the scriptures give plentiful testimony:
and labour the reformation of others by all means lawful.
In the church of Corinth there were divisions,1 fects,2 emulations, contentions, and quarrels, and going to law one with another for every trifle,3 and that under the infidels; Pauls name and credit was despitefully called in question there,4 whom they should have honoured as a father;5 the resurrection of the dead (which is the life of Christianity) was denied;6 that wickednesse was winked at there which is execrable to the very heathen;7 the Lords supper was horribly profaned,8 in that some came to it drunken; there was fornication and such like sins not repented of; things indifferent were used with manifest offense, and idolatry committed in eating at the tables of idoles meats sacrificed to devils: Notwithstanding all which abuses that societie is called and was the church of God, 9and the faithfull did and might communicate with others without pollution. The Galatians had so farre adulterated the Gospel of Christ that the Apostle telleth them they were removed to another Gospel, pronounceth that they were bewitched,10 and if they still persisted to joyn circumcision and the works ⟨p. 212⟩of the law with Christ, they were fallen from grace,11 and Christ could not profit them: and yet they are called churches of Galatia. Ephesus was extremely decayed in her first love;12 she was not onely cooled a little,13 but had left it: In Pergamus there were some that held the doctrine of Balaam, and of the Nicolaitanes:14 In Thyatira the woman Jezebel was suffered to teach and seduce the servants of Christ:15 Of Sardis the holy Ghost saith, she had a name to live, 16but was dead; her works were not perfect before God; there were but a few there who had not defiled their garments: Of Laodicea it is recorded that she was neither hot nor cold, and then it is not hard to conceive how she was overgrown with disorders; and yet Christ was present with her by his grace, and the faithfull are exhorted to repent, or beware of her sinne, and not to forsake her society.17 Of the abuses in the church of Rome something hath been noted before: Of corruptions and disorders in other churches the scriptures give plentifull testimony:18 But you shall never find that the faithfull are warned to separate from the worship of God in these assemblies,19 but to keep themselves pure and undefiled,20 and labour the reformation of others by all means lawfull.
In the primitive church after the apostles, the discipline of the church was in some cases very severe, partly to prevent the abuse of Gods ordinances, partly to maintain the dignity and authority of the censures: nevertheless the godly were compelled to tolerate many disorders, which they could not redress, not in doctrine and worship, but in manners ⟨p. 213⟩and conversation.1 For as soon as Christians began a little to breathe from the fear of bloody persecution, they fell into dissolute idleness, and began to nourish debate,2 strife, hatred, emulation, pride, &c. to heap sin upon sin, as might be proved at large by the complaints of the Fathers made of the sins of the times, in all sorts, ministers and people, men and women. But it was and ever hath been the judgement of them who did so grievously complain of the sins of their times, that the godly did not communicate with others in their sins although they did continue with them in the communion of the sacraments.3
In the primitive church after the apostles, the discipline of the church was in some cases very severe, partly to prevent the abuse of Gods ordinances, partly to maintein the dignitie and authority of the censures: neverthelesse the godly were compelled to tolerate many disorders, which they could not redresse, not in doctrine and worship, but in manners ⟨p. 213⟩and conversation.1 For as soon as Christians began a little to breathe from the fear of bloudy persecution, they fell into dissolute idlenesse, and began to nourish debate,2 strife, hatred, emulation, pride, &c. to heap sinne upon sinne, as might be proved at large by the complaints of the Fathers made of the sinnes of the times, in all sorts, ministers and people, men and women. But it was and ever hath been the judgement of them who did so grievously complain of the sinnes of their times, that the godly did not communicate with others in their sinnes although they did continue with them in the communion of the sacraments.3
2Quia traditam nobis Divinitus disciplinam pa• longa corruperat, jacentem fidem & penè dixe••m dormientem censura coelestis erexit.
3Cypr. De laps. studebant augendo patrimonio singuli, &c. Cypr. Epist. 51. ad Maxim. Etsi videntur in Ecclesia esse zizania, non tamen impediri dedet aut fides aut charitas nostra, ut quoniam zizania esse in Ecclesia cerni••••, ipsi de Ecclesia recedamus. And Epist. 52. Nobis autem secundùm fidem nostram & Divinae praedicationis datam formam competit ratio versicatis, unumquemque in peccato suo ipsum teneri, nec posse alterum pro altero reum fieri, cùm Dominus praemoneae. & dicat, Justitia justi super eum erit, et scelus scelerati super eum erit. Aug. lib. 2. Contr. Crescon. Gram. cap. 32. Non est Ecclesia deserenda, tanquam frumenta propter paleam vel zizania, sicut nec domus magna propter va•• in honorata. & cap. •7. August. Contr. Donatist. cap. 20. Toleramus quae nolumus, ut perveniamus quò volumus, •tentes cautelâ praecepti Dominici, &c. August. lib. De fide & oper. Perniciosa est audacia, stultáque praesumtio, se ab Ecclesia separate ob exempla quorundam malè moratorum, &c. And lib. 3. Contr. Par. cap. 2. Si contagio peccandi multitudinem invaserit, non est illa excommunicanda, sed Dei correctio exspectati debet. Nam separationis consilia sunt inania, perniciosa, sacrilega, impia, superba, plùs pertûrbant infirmos bonos quàm corrigunt animosos mal•s. See whit•k. De Eccl. qu. 1. cap. 10, 11. See August. Brevicul. Collat. And Aug. lib. 3. Cont. lit. Parmen. cap. 1. AUFERTE, inquit, MALUM EX VOBIS; ut si fortè non possent auferre malos à congregation sua auferendo, malum ex seipsis, id est, non cum ipsis peccando, nec iis ad peccandum consentiendo aut favendo, integerrimi inter eos & incorruptissimi versarentur.Cypr. De laps. studebant augendo patrimonio singuli, &c. Cypr. Epist. 51. ad Maxim. Etsi videntur in Ecclesia esse zizania, non tamen impediri dedet aut fides aut charitas nostra, ut quoniam zizania esse in Ecclesia cerni••••, ipsi de Ecclesia recedamus. And Epist. 52. Nobis autem secundùm fidem nostram & Divinae praedicationis datam formam competit ratio versicatis, unumquemque in peccato suo ipsum teneri, nec posse alterum pro altero reum fieri, cùm Dominus praemoneae. & dicat, Justitia justi super eum erit, et scelus scelerati super eum erit. Aug. lib. 2. Contr. Crescon. Gram. cap. 32. Non est Ecclesia deserenda, tanquam frumenta propter paleam vel zizania, sicut nec domus magna propter va in honorata. & cap. 7. August. Contr. Donatist. cap. 20. Toleramus quae nolumus, ut perveniamus quò volumus, tentes cautelâ praecepti Dominici, &c. August. lib. De fide & oper. Perniciosa est audacia, stultáque praesumtio, se ab Ecclesia separate ob exempla quorundam malè moratorum, &c. And lib. 3. Contr. Par. cap. 2. Si contagio peccandi multitudinem invaserit, non est illa excommunicanda, sed Dei correctio exspectati debet. Nam separationis consilia sunt inania, perniciosa, sacrilega, impia, superba, plùs pertûrbant infirmos bonos quàm corrigunt animosos mals. See whitk. De Eccl. qu. 1. cap. 10, 11. See August. Brevicul. Collat. And Aug. lib. 3. Cont. lit. Parmen. cap. 1. AUFERTE, inquit, MALUM EX VOBIS; ut si fortè non possent auferre malos à congregatione sua auferendo, malum ex seipsis, id est, non cum ipsis peccando, nec iis ad peccandum consentiendo aut favendo, integerrimi inter eos & incorruptissimi versarentur.
If a church depart from the Lord by any transgression,1 and therein remain irrepentant after due conviction, and will not be reclaimed, it manifesteth ⟨p. 214⟩unto us, that God also hath left it, and that as the church by her sin hath separated from and broken covenant with God, so God by leaving her in hardness of heart without repentance, hath on his part broken and dissolved the covenant also. The Lord Jesus threateneth the churches for leaving their first love and for their lukewarmness,2 that he will come against them speedily, and remove their candlestick, that is, dischurch them, except they repent, and spue them as loathsome out of his mouth.
If a church depart from the Lord by any transgression,1 and therein remain irrepentant after due conviction, and will not be reclaimed, it manifesteth ⟨p. 214⟩unto us, that God also hath left it, and that as the church by her sinne hath separated from and broken covenant with God, so God by leaving her in hardnesse of heart without repentance, hath on his part broken and dissolved the covenant also. The Lord Jesus threatneth the churches for leaving their first love and for their lukewarmnesse,2 that he will come against them speedily, and remove their candlestick, that is, dischurch them, except they repent, and spue them as lothsome out of his mouth.
It is true,1 the Apostles mention corruptions in the churches with utter dislike,2 severe reproof, and strait charge of reformation:3 and the Lord Jesus threateneth the churches for lukewarmness and leaving their first love:4 But neither Christ nor his Apostles did ever blame the faithful for holding communion in those churches in the ordinances of worship,5 or give them charge to depart if disorders and abuses were not forthwith corrected and amended.6 Not to enquire what is due conviction,7 Not to enquire what is due conviction, or when a church is to be deemed obstinately impenitent, it is most untrue, that the toleration of disorders or maintenance of corruptions of some kind by some, yea by many in the church, is to us a manifest token that God hath left it. The history of the church from the very first plantation thereof unto this very day doth evidence, that many and foul abuses, disorders and corruptions have continued in the churches of God; when yet the Lord did not utterly take from them all tokens of his visible presence. This is confessed of the church ⟨p. 215⟩of the Jews: And if they continued the church of God when they had broken covenant for their part, so long as the Lord continued the signs of his visible presence among them; how dare any man think or say that God hath utterly left or forsaken that people amongst whom he dwelleth plentifully by the means of grace, and unto whom he imparteth the graces of his Spirit, though for their sins they deserve to be cast off? The Lord is God and not man, therefore the sons of Jacob are not confounded. The Jews at first were chosen to be the people of God, not for their righteousness, but of the rich grace and mercy of God: They continue to be his church, not for their righteousness, but according to his free and gracious promise: And so long as Christ doth of his mere grace and love bear with the manners of his church, and giveth her not a bill of divorce, it is not for men to say or judge that he hath utterly left and forsaken her. And seeing the faithful must follow Christ, dwell with Christ and abide with him, so long as Christ doth dwell in the assembly by his presence and plentiful means of grace it is not lawful for them voluntarily to depart and break off communion.
It is true,1 the Apostles mention corruptions in the churches with utter dislike,2 severe reproof, and strait charge of reformation:3 and the Lord Jesus threatneth the churches for lukewarmnesse and leaving their first love:4 But neither Christ nor his Apostles did ever blame the faithfull for holding communion in those churches in the ordinances of worship,5 or give them charge to depart if disorders and abuses were not forthwith corrected and amended.6 Not to enquire what is due conviction,7 Not to enquire what is due conviction, or when a church is to be deemed obstinately impenitent, it is most untrue, that the toleration of disorders or maintenance of corruptions of some kind by some, yea by many in the church, is to us a manifest token that God hath left it. The history of the church from the very first plantation thereof unto this very day doth evidence, that many and foul abuses, disorders and corruptions have continued in the churches of God; when yet the Lord did not utterly take from them all tokens of his visible presence. This is confessed of the church ⟨p. 215⟩of the Jews: And if they continued the church of God when they had broken covenant for their part, so long as the Lord continued the signes of his visible presence among them; how dare any man think or say that God hath utterly left or forsaken that people amongst whom he dwelleth plentifully by the means of grace, and unto whom he imparteth the graces of his Spirit, though for their sinnes they deserve to be cast off? The Lord is God and not man, therefore the sonnes of Jacob are not confounded. The Jews at first were chosen to be the people of God, not for their righteousnesse, but of the rich grace and mercy of God: They continue to be his church, not for their righteousnesse, but according to his free and gracious promise: And so long as Christ doth of his mere grace and love bear with the manners of his church, and giveth her not a bill of divorce, it is not for men to say or judge that he hath utterly left and forsaken her. And seeing the faithfull must follow Christ, dwell with Christ and abide with him, so long as Christ doth dwell in the assembly by his presence and plentifull means of grace it is not lawfull for them voluntarily to depart and break off communion.
Whosoever neglecteth Christs rule in proceeding with his minister or others of the church,1 both partaketh in their sin, and sinneth against Christs command, Matth. 18. If he be ignorant of Christs rule and order, yet he sinneth: but if he know it, and do it not, then his sin remaineth. Now the rule prescribed by Christ is, That one brother offended should warn any member of the same church whereof he is a member, if he offend him, yea though it be his minister: And if he reform not, he must proceed to warn him more solemnly, taking two or three with him, doing it in the name of Christ: If this admonition take not effect for reformation, he must tell the church: If the church then will not do their duty, he must clear himself, protesting against their neglect therein, Hos. 2. 12.
VVHosoever neglecteth Christs rule in proceeding with his minister or others of the church,1 both partaketh in their sin, and sinneth against Christs command, Matth. 18. If he be ignorant of Christs rule and order, yet he sinneth: but if he know it, and do it not, then his sin remaineth. Now the rule prescribed by Christ is, That one brother offended should warn any member of the same church whereof he is a member, if he offend him, yea though it be his minister: And if he reform not, he must proceed to warn him more solemnly, taking two or three with him, doing it in the name of Christ: If this admonition take not effect for reformation, he must tell the church: If the church then will not do their duty, he must clear himself, protesting against their neglect therein, Hos. 2. 12.
The brief and plain meaning of this objection is,1 That every Christian is bound to perform all those offices mentioned to every delinquent brother in society or communion; and that it is not lawful to abide in society or communion where a man cannot perform all those duties without defiling or undoing himself. And therein is implied, that seeing the Jews had no such order for excommunication ⟨p. 217⟩established amongst them, therefore they might hold communion not withstanding the corruptions that were found amongst them. To try the strength of this argument, let it be granted, that our Saviour speaketh not of private managing of civil affairs and private injuries, whereby we might recover what we lost by the injury of our brother, (for that is an indulgence or benefit, no commandment of rule and duty; yea sometimes it is a fault not to suffer wrong) but of church-admonitions and censures,2 and that order which he hath set for the winning or punishment of offenders. But then by a delinquent brother we must not understand only one of the same particular society or fellowship, but any one, of what country or condition soever, with whom we have religious fellowship:3 If thy brother, If any man that is called a brother; thy brother, that is, a Christian. For our Lord hath appointed no such course to be taken with them that are out of the church.4 Suppose Christians of distinct societies living remote one from another do trespass one against the other, is not the innocent party bound to hold the course here prescribed with the delinquent brother? The rule of our Saviour is not, That one brother offended should admonish any member of the same church whereof he is a member (that is an addition which the text will not acknowledge) but, If thy brother trespass against thee. 5Christ speaketh here unto his Apostles, but not unto them simply as Apostles, but as disciples, ⟨p. 218⟩Christians, and followers of Christ; because the things here commanded are common to all Christians, and not peculiar to the Apostolical function. It is further to be enquired, in what cases we are to hold the course prescribed. If thy brother sin against thee. This cannot be meant of secret offences known unto one only: For wisdom and piety both forbid us to bring into light the private sins and offences of brethren, whereof they cannot be convinced:
The brief and plain meaning of this objection is,1 That every Christian is bound to perform all those offices mentioned to every delinquent brother in society or communion; and that it is not lawfull to abide in society or communion where a man cannot perform all those duties without defiling or undoing himself. And therein is implyed, that seeing the Jews had no such order for excommunication ⟨p. 217⟩established amongst them, therefore they might hold communion not withstanding the corruptions that were found amongst them. To trie the strength of this argument, let it be granted, that our Saviour speaketh not of private managing of civil affairs and private injuries, whereby we might recover what we lost by the injurie of our brother, (for that is an indulgence or benefit, no commandment of rule and duty; yea sometimes it is a fault not to suffer wrong) but of church-admonitions and censures,2 and that order which he hath set for the winning or punishment of offenders. But then by a delinquent brother we must not understand onely one of the same particular society or fellowship, but any one, of what countrey or condition soever, with whom we have religious fellowship:3 If thy brother, If any man that is called a brother; thy brother, that is, a Christian. For our Lord hath appointed no such course to be taken with them that are out of the church.4 Suppose Christians of distinct societies living remote one from another do trespasse one against the other, is not the innocent party bound to hold the course here prescribed with the delinquent brother? The rule of our Saviour is not, That one brother offended should admonish any member of the same church whereof he is a member (that is an addition which the text will not acknowledge) but, If thy brother trespasse against thee. 5Christ speaketh here unto his Apostles, but not unto them simply as Apostles, but as disciples, ⟨p. 218⟩Christians, and followers of Christ; because the things here commanded are common to all Christians, and not peculiar to the Apostolicall function. It is further to be enquired, in what cases we are to hold the course prescribed. If thy brother sin against thee. This cannot be meant of secret offenses known unto one onely: For wisdome and piety both forbid us to bring into light the private sinnes and offenses of brethren, whereof they cannot be convinced:
for this is to be a revealer rather then a healer of our brothers infirmities. If I know an offence committed by another whereof I can make no proof,1 in love I must admonish him privately, mourn and pray for him, and so leave him to the Lord, to whom the judgement of secret things doth belong. This is acknowledged by them who interpret this text of sins secretly committed against God.2 In those sins which are so hid and secret that he who should deny them can be convinced with no witnesses, there is none or very little place left to this saying of Christ.3 Some would have it, that Christ speaketh of secret offences against God; because the word is most properly used for sin, and another for wrong and injury: but this will bear no weight. For the word is general, but the phrase, To sin against thee, is spoken of wrongs and injuries against men.4 As, Let not the King sin against David his servant: that is; Do not evil unto him; Plot not evil or death against him: because he hath not sinned against thee: that is, He hath hurt thee in nothing; He hath offended thee in no matter. ⟨p. 219⟩Did I not say unto you, 5Sin not against the lad? that is, Hurt him not; or, Kill him not: for so Reuben spake unto his brethren when they thought of killing Joseph. When any one hath sinned against his neighbour; 6that is, hath hurt or offended him by any means. What have I sinned against thee or against thy servants? 7that is, Wherein have I done wrong or injury to thee? And so in this passage, If thy brother sin against thee: that is, If he hurt or wrong thee;8 not, If thou be privy to his sin. This is plain, if it be compared with that of Luke, If thy brother sin against thee seven times a day: 9and the question of Peter, If my brother sin against me, how oft must I forgive him? till seven times? and our Saviours answer,10 I say not unto thee, Till seven times; but, Until seventy times seven times. Neither is our brother to be accused for every light fault or trespass against us, but for that which is scelus or affine sceleri, or for that which is an argument (unless the rest of his life be known and approved) of a profane man, a contemner of God and his neighbour.11 There are some faults of men as it were natural, and of no great moment: there it is not always necessary that complaints should be doubled.12
for this is to be a revealer rather then a healer of our brothers infirmities. If I know an offense committed by another whereof I can make no proof,1 in love I must admonish him privately, mourn and pray for him, and so leave him to the Lord, to whom the judgement of secret things doth belong. This is acknowledged by them who interpret this text of sinnes secretly committed against God.2 In those sinnes which are so hid and secret that he who should deny them can be convinced with no witnesses, there is none or very little place left to this saying of Christ.3 Some would have it, that Christ speaketh of secret offenses against God; because the word is most properly used for sinne, and another for wrong and injury: but this will bear no weight. For the word is generall, but the phrase, To sinne against thee, is spoken of wrongs and injuries against men.4 As, Let not the King sinne against David his servant: that is; Do not evil unto him; Plot not evil or death against him: because he hath not sinned against thee: that is, He hath hurt thee in nothing; He hath offended thee in no matter. ⟨p. 219⟩Did I not say unto you, 5Sinne not against the lad? that is, Hurt him not; or, Kill him not: for so Reuben spake unto his brethren when they thought of killing Joseph. When any one hath sinned against his neighbour; 6that is, hath hurt or offended him by any means. What have I sinned against thee or against thy servants? 7that is, Wherein have I done wrong or injurie to thee? And so in this passage, If thy brother sin against thee: that is, If he hurt or wrong thee;8 not, If thou be privie to his sin. This is plain, if it be compared with that of Luke, If thy brother sinne against thee seven times a day: 9and the question of Peter, If my brother sin against me, how oft must I forgive him? till seven times? and our Saviours answer,
1Gratian. Decret. part. 2. c. 2. qu. 1. c. 1, 2, 3, 4, 19.
Some faults are to be wrapped up in silence, and covered with the cloak of charity.1 Not all sins are meant, but such as are stumbling-blocks to mens consciences, and such as are manifest to be sins, and to be committed, 2in case they should be denied. But though sins against God be not expressly intended in this place,3 by analogy they must be understood; because ⟨p. 220⟩the principal end why our brother offending is to be admonished, and complained of if he do not repent,4 is the salvation of his soul, which hath place in sins against God no less then in offences against our selves. But herein Christian moderation requireth, that many ignorances, errors, infirmities, and weaknesses of quotidian incursion, which overtake the godly, be covered in love, and not made the matter of complaint and censure. Some errors and frailties be of that nature, that if by admonition of love I cannot cure them, I must cover them in love, yea though the party, out of a false persuasion that he is in the truth when he doth err, should be obstinate. It must also be remembered, that this duty first by one, then by more, and lastly by the church upon complaint made, is affirmative, and bindeth only when occasion, season and opportunity is offered, or a Christian in special is called thereunto. An oath is one branch of Gods worship; but he dishonoureth not God who never sweareth, if he be never lawfully called thereunto: and the like may be said of the duty of admonition by way of censure. It is the office of a chirurgeon to launch and cut when need requireth: but it is no impeachment to his skill or office, if he was never enforced to that service. If the occasion of admonition be just, a Christian must further wait for the season, when it may be fit to administer it best, and in what manner. For admonition must be used as physic, which is not like to work kindly unless the patient be in right temper to receive it. And for complaint to the ⟨p. 221⟩church, if private admonition first by one then by more prevail not, a Christian is not ordinarily bound unto it when he cannot perform it or do it with good success.5 If the Jews had not the distinct ordinance of ecclesiastical excommunication, yet the Lord took order then as well as now that no sin should be suffered unreformed, no obstinate sinner uncut off.
Some faults are to be wrapped up in silence, and covered with the cloke of charity.1 Not all sinnes are meant, but such as are stumbling-blocks to mens consciences, and such as are manifest to be sinnes, and to be committed, 2in case they should be denied. But though sins against God be not expressely intended in this place,3 by analogie they must be understood; because ⟨p. 220⟩the principall end why our brother offending is to be admonished, and complained of if he do not repent,4 is the salvation of his soul, which hath place in sinnes against God no lesse then in offenses against our selves. But herein Christian moderation requireth, that many ignorances, errors, infirmities, and weaknesses of quotidian incursion, which overtake the godly, be covered in love, and not made the matter of complaint and censure. Some errours and frailties be of that nature, that if by admonition of love I cannot cure them, I must cover them in love, yea though the party, out of a false perswasion that he is in the truth when he doth erre, should be obstinate. It must also be remembred, that this duty first by one, then by more, and lastly by the church upon complaint made, is affirmative, and bindeth onely when occasion, season and opportunity is offered, or a Christian in speciall is called thereunto. An oath is one branch of Gods worship; but he dishonoureth not God who never sweareth, if he be never lawfully called thereunto: and the like may be said of the duty of admonition by way of censure. It is the office of a chirurgian to launch and cut when need requireth: but it is no impeachment to his skill or office, if he was never enforced to that service. If the occasion of admonition be just, a Christian must further wait for the season, when it may be fit to administer it best, and in what manner. For admonition must be used as physick, which is not like to work kindly unlesse the patient be in right temper to receive it. And for complaint to the ⟨p. 221⟩church, if private admonition first by one then by more prevail not, a Christian is not ordinarily bound unto it when he cannot perform it or do it with good successe.5 If the Jews had not the distinct ordinance of ecclesiasticall excommunication, yet the Lord took order then as well as now that no sinne should be suffered unreformed, no obstinate sinner uncut off.
And therefore if a man committed a sin, whether of ignorance or otherwise, for which he was not to die without pardon, he was to be told and admonished of his offence,1 and to manifest his repentance:2 But the obstinate and presumptuous were to be cut off.3 So that the godly amongst the Jews were first to admonish the transgressor, and if he did not repent, then to proceed further, according to the Lords ordinance. But now suppose the guides temporal or ecclesiastical, to whom the matter must be brought, be so corrupt that they would countenance the offender, punish the complainant, establish the disorder rather then redress or amend it, in this case what should the innocent do? must he complain to his undoing, or leave his standing in the church as unlawful, because he cannot do the duties which God calleth for at his hands?4 The shepherds of the church of the Jews were many times blind,5 wicked,6 vain persons,7 such as Christ calleth thieves, robbers, hirelings. The scribes and Pharisees, what were they but blind guides,8 corrupt teachers, who caused the people to err: If the disciples or faithful had sought to them for reformation of abuses, or redress of offences, what could have ⟨p. 222⟩been expected? If by the church we understand either the guides and governors, or the whole society and faithful: we know the guides of the church are many times remiss, idle, partial, corrupt. 9The Corinthian Pastors built hay and stubble upon the foundation which Paul had laid: amongst them were false Apostles, deceitful workers,10 who did transform themselves into the Apostles of Christ.11 In Galatia the Pastors troubled the church with corrupt doctrine. The Angels of Thyatira,12 Laodicea, Pergamus and Sardis are all reprehended. What then must the faithful do? leave their standings, and depart from the ordinances of grace, whilst God is pleased to dwell amongst them? or neglect the duty which God calleth them unto, and so partake in other mens sin? The community or congregation it self is oft divided, remiss; the greatest part many times the worst, so that the best cannot be heard amongst them,13 truth cannot take place. In Corinth there were so many sects and divisions that the house of Chloe was constrained to complain of them to the Apostle:14
And therefore if a man committed a sinne, whether of ignorance or otherwise, for which he was not to die without pardon, he was to be told and admonished of his offense,1 and to manifest his repentance:2 But the obstinate and presumptuous were to be cut off.3 So that the godly amongst the Jews were first to admonish the transgressour, and if he did not repent, then to proceed further, according to the Lords ordinance. But now suppose the guides temporall or ecclesiasticall, to whom the matter must be brought, be so corrupt that they would countenance the offender, punish the complainant, establish the disorder rather then redresse or amend it, in this case what should the innocent do? must he complain to his undoing, or leave his standing in the church as unlawfull, because he cannot do the duties which God calleth for at his hands?4 The shepherds of the church of the Jews were many times blind,5 wicked,6 vain persons,7 such as Christ calleth thieves, robbers, hirelings. The scribes and Pharisees, what were they but blind guides,8 corrupt teachers, who caused the people to erre: If the disciples or faithfull had sought to them for reformation of abuses, or redresse of offenses, what could have ⟨p. 222⟩been expected? If by the church we understand either the guides and governours, or the whole society and faithfull: we know the guides of the church are many times remisse, idle, partiall, corrupt. 9The Corinthian Pastours built hay and stubble upon the foundation which Paul had laid: amongst them were false Apostles, deceitfull workers,10 who did transform themselves into the Apostles of Christ.11
most of them were puffed up in the case of the incestuous man, that it had been in vain for the better sort to seek his casting out if the Apostle had not sharply admonished them of their duty: And their disorder in coming to the Lords supper was general, so that the better sort might bewail but could not redress it. In the primitive church there was such contention oftentimes about the choice and election of ministers, the Pastors divided from the ⟨p. 223⟩people, and the people one from another, to the committing of many outrages, that if the godly must not hold any place in the church but where they could perform all offices enjoined in the text of scripture before alleged, they must wellnigh go out of the world. In this and such cases then what should the faithful do? Tell the church they cannot; for that is divided, and it may be the greatest part holdeth the worst cause: Depart they must not, for the Lord doth not go before them; and if they depart without him, they depart from the Lord himself. What remaineth then, but that with merciful affection they dislike, reprove, and correct as much as in them lieth what they find to be amiss; what they cannot amend, that they should patiently endure and suffer, and in loving sort bewail and lament, till God do either correct and amend it, or make way for their enlargement, as they may see the Lord to go before them. But in the mean space it will be said they do not their duty in telling the church: Nay rather, the Lord requireth not that particular duty at that time, because they have no opportunity or means to do it. The rule prescribed concerneth visible and particular churches, as a solemn ordinance of Christ, for the humbling and saving of an obstinate sinner: but a Christian may be a true member of a visible church when he is hindered and cannot do the thing that is there prescribed. For our Saviour speaketh of a brother that doth justly, truly, and according to equity reprehend, admonish, or complain; and of them who being ⟨p. 224⟩set in office do rightly and lawfully perform the office whereunto they are appointed of God; of the church who doeth what becometh her, keepeth herself within the bounds prescribed of God, and rightly executeth what is committed to her trust. But in the true church of God, which Christ is pleased to grace with the visible tokens of his presence, all things may fall out clean contrary;
most of them were puffed up in the case of the incestuous man, that it had been in vain for the better sort to seek his casting out if the Apostle had not sharply admonished them of their duty: And their disorder in coming to the Lords supper was generall, so that the better sort might bewail but could not redresse it. In the primitive church there was such contention oftentimes about the choise and election of ministers, the Pastours divided from the ⟨p. 223⟩people, and the people one from another, to the committing of many outrages, that if the godly must not hold any place in the church but where they could perform all offices injoyned in the text of scripture before alledged, they must welnigh go out of the world. In this and such cases then what should the faithfull do? Tell the church they cannot; for that is divided, and it may be the greatest part holdeth the worst cause: Depart they must not, for the Lord doth not go before them; and if they depart without him, they depart from the Lord himself. What remaineth then, but that with mercifull affection they dislike, reprove, and correct as much as in them lieth what they find to be amisse; what they cannot amend, that they should patiently endure and suffer, and in loving sort bewail and lament, till God do either correct and amend it, or make way for their enlargement, as they may see the Lord to go before them. But in the mean space it will be said they do not their duty in telling the church: Nay rather, the Lord requireth not that particular duty at that time, because they have no opportunity or means to do it. The rule prescribed concerneth visible and particular churches, as a solemn ordinance of Christ, for the humbling and saving of an obstinate sinner: but a Christian may be a true member of a visible church when he is hindred and cannot do the thing that is there prescribed. For our Saviour speaketh of a brother that doth justly, truly, and according to equity reprehend, admonish, or complain; and of them who being ⟨p. 224⟩set in office do rightly and lawfully perform the office whereunto they are appointed of God; of the church who doeth what becometh her, keepeth herself within the bounds prescribed of God, and rightly executeth what is committed to her trust. But in the true church of God, which Christ is pleased to grace with the visible tokens of his presence, all things may fall out clean contrary;
that such as be in office do not truly discharge their office, that the church doth not keep herself to the rule, nor fulfil the trust committed unto her.1 In the Law they that were thought unclean were to be restrained from the sacrifices,2 the eating of the passover, entrance into the temple. And not only legal pollutions,3 but sins of all kinds,4 whether by error or ignorance of the law or fact,5 or voluntarily committed, were to be expiated according to the prescript of the law, which doth necessarily presuppose uncleanness, and that accompanied separation from the altar, and the participation of the holy things. The legal ceremonies, which were outward and carnal, did represent spiritual and internal to the minds of the faithful, as the uncleanness of the body did the inward filth of the soul.6 The wicked are oftentimes upbraided,7 that they durst come into the presence of God. The scriptures testify, that the Lord accepteth the sacrifices of righteousness, 8of a broken and contrite heart;9 that he is not pleased with the sacrifices of wicked men,10 whose hands are full of blood:11 And the Lord often giveth commandment,12 that he which shall ⟨p. 225⟩do so or so, or shall not do this or that, shall be cut off from his people. All which, whether they conclude the use of excommunication amongst the Jews, let the learned judge. But howsoever, this is most certain; Many things were required which the wicked altogether neglected, the godly could not redress, nor complain of to them that should; or if they did, no regard was had thereunto, no reformation followed: and yet the godly left not their standings, as unlawful; nor the society, as left and forsaken of God because they had broken covenant with him; nor the ordinances of God, as if external communion with the wicked as one body had polluted and defiled them. Put case a brother offended make a complaint to the church of some private injury or wrong received by one of the same or another society, and the church to whom the complaint is brought deal remissly, either through ignorance, partiality, carelessness, or the like; must the innocent party stand to the decision of the church, although they do not see right exactly restored, and the delinquent brought to repentance?
that such as be in office do not truly discharge their office, that the church doth not keep herself to the rule, nor fulfill the trust committed unto her.1 In the Law they that were thought unclean were to be restrained from the sacrifices,2 the eating of the passeover, entrance into the temple. And not onely legall pollutions,3 but sinnes of all kinds,4 whether by errour or ignorance of the law or fact,5 or voluntarily committed, were to be expiated according to the prescript of the law, which doth necessarily presuppose uncleannesse, and that accompanied separation from the altar, and the participation of the holy things. The legall ceremonies, which were outward and carnall, did represent spirituall and internall to the minds of the faithfull, as the uncleannesse of the body did the inward filth of the soul.6 The wicked are oftentimes upbraided,7 that they durst come into the presence of God. The scriptures testifie, that the Lord acceteth the sacrifices of righteousnesse, 8of a broken and contrite heart;9 that he is not pleased with the sacrifices of wicked men,10 whose hands are full of bloud:11 And the Lord often giveth commandment,12 that he which shall ⟨p. 225⟩do so or so, or shall not do this or that, shall be cut off from his people. All which, whether they conclude the use of excommunication amongst the Jews, let the learned judge. But howsoever, this is most certain; Many things were required which the wicked altogether neglected, the godly could not redresse, nor complain of to them that should; or if they did, no regard was had thereunto, no reformation followed: and yet the godly left not their standings, as unlawfull; nor the society, as left and forsaken of God because they had broken covenant with him; nor the ordinances of God, as if externall communion with the wicked as one body had polluted and defiled them. Put case a brother offended make a complaint to the church of some private injury or wrong received by one of the same or another socity, and the church to whom the complaint is brought deal remissely, either through ignorance, partiality, carelessenesse, or the like; must the innocent party stand to the decision of the church, although they do not see right exactly restored, and the delinquent brought to repentance?
or must he protest against their neglect, and depart from the society as not to be communicated with, because they tolerate a wicked and ungodly person among them? If the first, then simply to be present at the worship of God where wicked men are tolerated is not to partake in their sin: If the latter, then the accuser may be judge in his own cause, and not only hold him an heathen whom the church esteemeth holy and honest, but hold the church it self heathen, ⟨p. 226⟩then, because they account him not so blameworthy whom he accuseth: then which what is more contrary to the rule of our Saviour? And so if true examination be made, they that leave our societies because they cannot observe the rule prescribed by Christ, do of all others most neglect it in their separation; because they challenge that authority which Christ never gave them, and wait not upon him to go before them.
or must he protest against their neglect, and depart from the society as not to be communicated with, because they tolerate a wicked and ungodly person among them? If the first, then simply to be present at the worship of God where wicked men are tolerated is not to partake in their sin: If the latter, then the accuser may be judge in his own cause, and not onely hold him an heathen whom the church esteemeth holy and honest, but hold the church it self heathen, ⟨p. 226⟩then, because they account him not so blameworthy whom he accuseth: then which what is more contrary to the rule of our Saviour? And so if true examination be made, they that leave our societies because they cannot observe the rule prescribed by Christ, do of all others most neglect it in their separation; because they challenge that authority which Christ never gave them, and wait not upon him to go before them.
If iniquity be committed in the church,1 and complaint and proof accordingly made, and the church will not reform or reject the party offending, but will on the contrary maintain presumptuously and abet such impiety, then by abetting the party and his sin she maketh it her own by imputation, and enwrappeth her self in the same guilt with the sinner; and remaining irreformable, either by such members of the same church as are faithful (if there be any) or by other sister-church, wipeth herself out of the Lords church-roll, and now ceaseth to be any longer the true church of Christ.2 And whatsoever truths or ordinances of Christ this rebellious rout still retaineth, it but usurpeth the same, without right unto them or promise of blessing upon them; both the persons and sacrifices are abominable.
If iniquity be committed in the church,1 and complaint and proof accordingly made, and the church will not reform or reject the party offending, but will on the contrary maintein presumptuously and abett such impiety, then by abetting the party and his sin she maketh it her own by imputation, and enwrappeth her self in the same guilt with the sinner; and remaining irreformable, either by such members of the same church as are faithfull (if there be any) or by other sister-churche, wipeth herself out of the Lords church-rolle, and now ceaseth to be any longer the true church of Christ.2 And whatsoever truths or ordinances of Christ this rebellious rout still reteineth, it but usurpeth the same, without right unto them or promise of blessing upon them; both the persons and sacrifices are abominable.
This peremptory censure is as directly cross to that which followeth immediately in the same author as any thing that can be spoken.1 For if the ⟨p. 227⟩toleration or maintenance of one sinner against reproof and conviction do necessarily dischurch a society, how then did the church of the Jews continue the true church of God, wherein sin was generally, impudently, impenitently committed, and that by such as should have censured it in others; where the offenders were countenanced, and the reprovers persecuted, imprisoned, put to death? If no church in the world now hath that absolute promise of the Lords visible presence which that church then had till the coming of Christ, if the Messiah must be born in the true church, and the Lord did ever afford the Jews some or other visible signs of his presence in the greatest apostasy; this is nothing to the purpose. For if the maintenance of one wicked ungodly wretch wipeth a church out of the Lords church roll, then the Jews, who did both countenance offenders, and commit wickedness themselves and that with greediness, had blotted themselves out of that book. And if the Jews continued the church of God notwithstanding their great impiety and obdurateness, because the Lord continued the visible tokens of his presence among them, then if a church or some in the church shall tolerate or countenance iniquity in others, or practice it themselves, so long as God shall be pleased to bear with their manners, and vouchsafe unto them ⟨p. 228⟩the signs of his gracious presence and holy ordinances, it is to be reputed the true church of God, wherewith the faithful may hold communion in the branches of worship. If therefore the author had well pondered his own words, or consulted the rule of our Saviour, this labour might well have been spared. But more fully to open the weakness of this objection; Errors; as in doctrine so in practice, are of two sorts: some fundamental or bordering thereupon, which concern the very heart and life of religion, and cannot stand with faith and holiness; others not fundamental, which strike not directly at the soul of religion, though they hinder the working somewhat, or stain the work. In matters fundamental, as the profession of faith must be entire in all points of simple belief, so must the doctrine of the church in all things concerning practice:
This peremptory censure is as directly crosse to that which followeth immediately in the same authour as any thing that can be spoken.1 For if the ⟨p. 227⟩toleration or maintenance of one sinner against reproof and conviction do necessarily dischurch a society, how then did the church of the Jews continue the true church of God, wherein sinne was generally, impudently, impenitently committed, and that by such as should have censured it in others; where the offenders were countenanced, and the reprovers persecuted, imprisoned, put to death? If no church in the world now hath that absolute promise of the Lords visible presence which that church then had till the coming of Christ, if the Messiah must be born in the true church, and the Lord did ever afford the Jews some or other visible signes of his presence in the greatest apostasie; this is nothing to the purpose. For if the maintenance of one wicked ungodly wretch wipeth a church out of the Lords churchroll, then the Jews, who did both countenance offenders, and commit wickednesse themselves and that with greedinesse, had blotted themselves out of that book. And if the Jews continued the church of God notwithstanding their great impiety and obduratenesse, because the Lord continued the visible tokens of his presence among them, then if a church or some in the church shall tolerate or countenance iniquity in others, or practice it themselves, so long as God shall be pleased to bear with their manners, and vouchsafe unto them ⟨p. 228⟩the signes of his gracious presence and holy ordinances, it is to be reputed the true church of God, wherewith the faithfull may hold communion in the branches of worship. If therefore the authour had well pondered his own words, or consulted the rule of our Saviour, this labour might well have been spared. But more fully to open the weaknesse of this objection; Errours; as in doctrine so in practice, are of two sorts: some fundamentall or bordering thereupon, which concern the very heart and life of religion, and cannot stand with faith and holinesse; others not fundamentall, which strike not directly at the soul of religion, though they hinder the working somewhat, or stain the work. In matters fundamentall, as the profession of faith must be intire in all points of simple belief, so must the doctrine of the church in all things concerning practice:
1Answ. If my brother sin a scandalous sin, and I by just order make complaint thereof to the church, I have done my duty. It appertaineth to the church to excommunicate him if he repent not, but not to me, except (Pope-like) I would make my self the church. I am guilty of the evil in the common-wealth and family for the redressing whereof I do not my duty in my place, which if I do in the church as I can, I am free from the sins done and suffered thee: which sins and evils I can no more be said to suffer (wanting power to reform them) they to suffer it to blow or rain because I hinder it not, Robins. Treat. pag. 18.Answ. If my brother sin a scandalous sin, and I by just order make complaint thereof to the church, I have done my duty. It apperteineth to the church to excommunicate him if he repent not, but not to me, except (Pope-like) I would make my self the church. I am guilty of the evil in the common-wealth and family for the redressing whereof I do not my duty in my place, which if I do in the church as I can, I am free from the sinnes done and suffered thee: which sinnes and evils I can no more be said to suffer (wanting power to reform them) they to suffer it to blow or rain because I hinder it not, Robins. Treat. pag. 18.
I say not unto thee, Till seven times; but, Vntill seventy times seven times. Neither is our brother to be accused for every light fault or trespasse against us, but for that which is scelus or affine sceleri, or for that which is an argument (unlesse the rest of his life be known and approved) of a prophane man, a contemner of God and his neighbour.
Laodicea, Pergamus and Sardis are all reprehended. What then must the faithfull do? leave their standings, and depart from the ordinances of grace, whilest God is pleased to dwell amongst them? or neglect the duty which God calleth them unto, and so partake in other mens sin? The community or congregation it self is oft divided, remisse; the greatest part many times the worst, so that the best cannot be heard amongst them,