A02990:88
A friendly trial of the grounds tending to separation in a plain and modest…A friendly triall of the grounds tending to separation in a plain and modest…
A friendly trial of the grounds tending to separation in a plain and modest dispute touching the lawfulness of a stinted liturgy and set form of prayer, Communion in mixed assemblies, and the primitive subject and first receptacle of the power of the Keys: tending to satisfy the doubtful, recall the wandering, and to strengthen the weak: by John Ball.A friendly triall of the grounds tending to separation in a plain and modest dispute touching the lawfulnesse of a stinted liturgie and set form of prayer, Communion in mixed assemblies, and the primitive subject and first receptacle of the power of the Keyes: tending to satisfie the doubtfull, recall the wandering, and to strengthen the weak: by John Ball.
Cambridge: printed by Roger Daniel printer to the University of Cambridge for Edward Brewster, 1640Cambridge: printed by Roger Daniel printer to the Universitie of Cambridge for Edward Brewster, 1640
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
For it is a rule in Divinity, That against a general negative precept no particular affirmative can be lawful, unless that particular be warranted in scripture: For the scripture should not be perfect, to furnish the man of God completely to every good work,1 if a particular affirmative not warranted in special might be lawful against a general negative; seeing in that case a man can have no sure ground to rest on. But against this supposed general negative precept, forbidding all humane inventions in Gods worship, all devised helps and furtherances, all strange worship, there is no particular warrant allowing it in singing psalms. When all devised worship is condemned, how shall the conscience be assured that this particular devised worship shall be accepted? No necessity excuseth in the doing, of a thing otherwise unlawful, but that which exempteth from ⟨p. 64⟩the commandment in that case. Now whether that pretended necessity of a set form should exempt from the general negative precept forbidding all devised forms as will-worship (as they expound it) or from the affirmative precept of singing of psalms, let them judge who put the exception. Necessity which hath no law, in some particular case, presupposeth some free time wherein that pressing necessity hath no place; & then what necessity hath found out for remedy, that must cease, the necessity ceasing: But that any necessity which lieth continually upon all churches, as doth the singing in a prescript form, if they sing at all, should warrant them to do that which is contrary to a general negative precept, is a tradition in Divinity never heard of before. The reason therefore standeth still in force; If it be lawful to praise God in a form of words devised by man, it is lawful also to pray to God in a stinted form; and an arbitrary form is altogether as lawful as a devised form. And if Christians shall not withdraw themselves from the stinted prayers of the congregation before a material difference be showed in these particulars, and that distinction of Arbitrary and Necessary devised forms be proved by scripture or solid reason, the world shall end (I am confident) before they separate. And thus some other objections made against a stinted Liturgy are answered.
For it is a rule in Divinity, That against a generall negative precept no particular affirmative can be lawfull, unlesse that particular be warranted in scripture: For the scripture should not be perfect, to furnish the man of God completely to every good work,