A03618:124
An answer unto my lord of Winchester's [sic] book entitled a detection of the…An answer vnto my lord of wynthesters [sic] booke intytlyd a detection of the…
An answer unto my lord of Winchester's [sic] book entitled a detection of the devils sophistry wherewith he robbeth the unlearned people of the true belief in the most blessed sacrament of the altar made by Johann Hopper.An answer vnto my lord of wynthesters [sic] booke intytlyd a detection of the deuyls sophistrye wherwith he robith the vnlernyd people of the trew byleef in the moost blessyd sacrament of the aulter made by Johann Hoper.
printed by Augustine Fries, 1547printed by Augustyne Fries, 1547
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
And likewise to confess that his grace and favour maketh rich, and his displeasure pour and not to attribute the gifts they received unto the second causes as the Stoics doth that say god is bound to do as the second cause ⟨image 82⟩is disposed, it is not so for he can make scarcity and need of corn where as is good fertile ground, and abundance, in the barren fields, and Now if, an oaten or barley sheaf that was offered for the purpose that I have showed figured the mass let the Christian reader judge, I marvel my lord is so full of Allegories and speaketh nothing of the text when an allegory proveth nothing. But is used to declare the thing that we would prove. Let him first prove his proposition by, the scripture. And then I will admit the figurative locution as truth shall force me my lord in the end of his book speaketh of them that study to impung this stablyshyd verity as he calleth it of the church the ministration of the sacrament under one kind and then saith they are not only in that high matter of the sacrament. But also in ceremonies and namely such as garnish Christs religion wherein he saith the devil useth A marvellous point of Sophistry by division, and examining parts alone which parts so considered sever ally be nothing, and yet joined to gather be some what &c. My lord will open this point of Sophistry he saith, which consisteth in division between the hole and the part. And putteth this example if one were asked whether à farthing would make à rush man? A simple man would say: nay &c. Then maketh he his simile: like wise in the discussion of ceremonies, seemliness, and others, the devil frameth his questions by division and asketh of each thing alone. as for example whether à shaven crown maketh à priest: then answer is made nay. doth a long gown make à priest nay and so forth as my lord telleth ⟨image 82⟩his tale. My lord hath well opened a point of Sophistry doubtless as he that meant nothing else but to set à which candle before the Eyes of the simple that they should not see the truth. And would carry them by sophistry whether he listeth. He that will argue of à similitude must put all ways too things alike that the one may open the other. Now my lord maketh à comparison of too things unlike as the qualities of gall should, in sweetness be compared unto the qualities of honey.
And likewyce to confesse that his grace and ffauor makithe ryche, and his displeasure poure and not to attribut the gifftes they receauid unto the second causes as the Stoykes doothe that say god is bound to do as the second cause