A03618:22
An answer unto my lord of Winchester's [sic] book entitled a detection of the…An answer vnto my lord of wynthesters [sic] booke intytlyd a detection of the…
An answer unto my lord of Winchester's [sic] book entitled a detection of the devils sophistry wherewith he robbeth the unlearned people of the true belief in the most blessed sacrament of the altar made by Johann Hopper.An answer vnto my lord of wynthesters [sic] booke intytlyd a detection of the deuyls sophistrye wherwith he robith the vnlernyd people of the trew byleef in the moost blessyd sacrament of the aulter made by Johann Hoper.
printed by Augustine Fries, 1547printed by Augustyne Fries, 1547
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
That these masters of the later days fight so sore to defend, an accidens with out à subject. And hath taken from the supper, the thing that we see we touch, we taste, we eat we drink and we swallow through the throat, to say bread and wine, As the Apostles did and yet say it is no bread nor wine. If it be altered some were best that best can maintain ally to show how and by what words it is changed. By these words hoc est, it is not done. For no man can do more by the virtue of those words then Christ him self. Now Christ by these words declared that it was his body. And not made his body. Then must ye show the other words that wrought this marvellous transubstantiation. Or else we should make Christ a liar who is the fountain of all verity and truth. But such as defend this alteration of bread rather then they would say that by the ⟨image 13⟩words of Christ, Hoc est corpus meum, were not made the very body of Christ. They will expound thys uerb (est) per fit. And say thus, that by the pour of god and virtue of his words spoken by the minister, the substance of the bread is altered into the substance of Christ body. So is Christs body made present by this word est. But this interpretation the letter without a trope will not admit. Nether that est schuld be expounded by fit. Nether that the bread should be made the body of Christ, but that it is already the body of Christ before these words be spoken, Hoc est corpus meum. If it be not before he call it the body, why doth he lye then. And call it other wise then it is. If it be the body as he saith it is by what words of the scripture hath he made the bread the body and the wine the blood. By these words, hoc est corpus meum, there is nether bread nether wine altered. But the text sayeth that the bread is the body, and the wine the blood. Which this new doctrine will not admit that bread should be booth bread and also the it glorious body of Christ. For then duo corpora essent simul in eodem loco. Which indeed reason will not grant. No more then it is possible that à true body may be, and yet occupy no place. Such as would defend a wicked and most damnable purpose good reader Clean contrary to the nature of thys uerbe (est) expound it per fit.
That these masters of the later dayes fyghtso sore to defend, an accidens with out à subiect. And hath taken from the supper, the thing that wese we touche, we taste, we eat we drynke and we swalow throwghe the throte, to say bread and wyne, As the Apostelles dyd and yeat say it is no bread nor wyne. If it be alteryd some were best that best can mayntayne alye to shew how and by what wordes it is changyd. By these wordes hoc est, it is not done. For noman can do more by the uertewe of those wordes then Christ him selfe. Now Christ by these wordes declaryd that it was his body. And not made his body. Then must ye shewe theother wordes that wrowght this meruelous transubstancion. Or else we shuld make Christ alyer who is the fontayne of all ueryte and truyth. But souch as defend thys alteracion of breade rather then they would say that by the