A03618:45
An answer unto my lord of Winchester's [sic] book entitled a detection of the…An answer vnto my lord of wynthesters [sic] booke intytlyd a detection of the…
An answer unto my lord of Winchester's [sic] book entitled a detection of the devils sophistry wherewith he robbeth the unlearned people of the true belief in the most blessed sacrament of the altar made by Johann Hopper.An answer vnto my lord of wynthesters [sic] booke intytlyd a detection of the deuyls sophistrye wherwith he robith the vnlernyd people of the trew byleef in the moost blessyd sacrament of the aulter made by Johann Hoper.
printed by Augustine Fries, 1547printed by Augustyne Fries, 1547
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Now that these words, can make no alteration, of the bread an win, nor, make the natural, corporal, nor physical presence of Christs body. The first reason is, that the words, Hoc est corpus meum, proveth that the bread is already the body, before the words be spoken, or else they mi•name the thing and call bread flesh. The second reason. If the words and the thing meant by the words be one, th•n is the cup and not the win in •he cup, the testament in Christs blood Luce 22. 1. Co. 11. Thirdly if it were the very body of Christ corporally present, Christs words were not true, for he bid them do it in the Remembrance of him. Now the Remembrance of a•hing is not the same self thing, that is remembered, as many men use to remem hre a weighty matter, by a little ring upon there finger. If Christs most honourable body were present corporally in the sacrament it were no need remembrance at all, for the thing present, presenteth it self without the help of memory. Turn they which ways the list, these words, Hoc est corpus meum, will not serve for there purpose, except they add there interpretation, the best gloss they have, is this, that these words, Hoc est corpus meū, bringeth with them the body of Christ but this is there interpretation ⟨image 29⟩of the text, and not the meaning of the text. Ponder every word and first this pronoun hoc. Which de montrative they refer unto the bread and win only. How be it we may with saint Paule referr hoc unto •hole action an ceremony of the supper, as well as unto the bread an win. Paul saith not, Hic panis est communio corporis Christi, as though we should think, that he spake of the bread only. But with plain words saith, Panis quem frangimus, to declare that the bread is not the sacrament of Christs body, till it be broken unto the church, according to the institution of Christ à spiritual meat. As Paul calleth it, so that the bread lift up over the priests head, nor kept in the box is not the sacrament, but the bread rightly distributed. And in the same place he calleth the bread broken, the table of the lord by the which is understand the whole institution of Christs supper. And where men contend so much of this word corpus repeting thole hoc corpus meum. Saint Paul the true interpreter of Christs words, resolveth them thus. Nonne panis quē frangimus communio corporis Christi est.