A03618:61
An answer unto my lord of Winchester's [sic] book entitled a detection of the…An answer vnto my lord of wynthesters [sic] booke intytlyd a detection of the…
An answer unto my lord of Winchester's [sic] book entitled a detection of the devils sophistry wherewith he robbeth the unlearned people of the true belief in the most blessed sacrament of the altar made by Johann Hopper.An answer vnto my lord of wynthesters [sic] booke intytlyd a detection of the deuyls sophistrye wherwith he robith the vnlernyd people of the trew byleef in the moost blessyd sacrament of the aulter made by Johann Hoper.
printed by Augustine Fries, 1547printed by Augustyne Fries, 1547
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
When the rod was turned into A serpent yet was the serpent called still arod. This simile proveth nothing, for when the text sayth, sed devoravit uirga Aharon uirgas illorum Exo• 7• there remained nor form not figure of Arod, but of à very horrible an fearful serpent. If this place serve to prove the alteration of bread into the natural body of Christ let them show me the form of bread changed, into as natural a man, as the rod was changed into à natural serpent and then jam content. I will not dispute, of the name so greatly though they called flesh and blood, bread but they must make demonstration of Christs body unto the external senses, as Moses made of the serpent unto the Egyptians. When god called our first father, Adam, because he was created of the earth. And Adam said by his wife be hold a bone of mine bones Gen. 1• ⟨image 40⟩there was nether Adam that had the form of earth, nor Eve the form of Abone. The one was a man and the other a woman. How be it they Kept still the name of the thing they were created of. Change the form of bread in the sacrament and make thereof the form of Aman. Then th•se places will suffer the manner of speech right well that a man may be called bread if he be made of bread, as well as A serpent called Arod because he was see made of arod. But for as much as there is no form of the bread changed in the sacrament, believe with the Evangelists and Apostoles that it is in matter and substance very bread, how it appointed to an holy use, to be ministered unto the church of god in the remembrance of Christs death. With these words. Christ took bread and gave it to his disciples Mat. 26. Luce 22. 1. Cor. 10. 11. These men agree with them selves, in the spirit of god, and teacheth ascertain doctrine, those that defend these ma• ses and transubstantiation agreeth not with them selves. And hath nothing certain the one saith the thing that corrupted is nothing but accidens, the other saith that it is the very substance of bread. Read the book of innocentius tercius de officio missoe, where as be these words, quod sicut miraculose substancia panis, uertitur in corpus Christi remanentibus accidentibus panis: ita miraculose redire substancia prioris panis possit, de qua generetur uel uermis uel quid aliud tale. Into what substance the water mingled in the chalice with the win is turned see the mind of Clement in the 3.