A04920:498
An Answer to a Great Number of Blasphemous Cavillations
An answer to a great number of blasphemous cavillations written by an Anabaptist, and adversary to Gods eternal predestination. And confuted by John Knox, minister of Gods word in Scotland. Wherein the author so discovereth the craft and falsehood of that sect, that the godly knowing that error, may be confirmed in the trueth by the evident Word of GodAn answer to a great nomber of blasphemous cauillations written by an Anabaptist, and aduersarie to Gods eternal predestination. And confuted by Iohn Knox, minister of Gods worde in Scotland. Wherein the author so discouereth the craft and falshode of that sect, that the godly knowing that error, may be confirmed in the trueth by the euident Worde of God
Geneva: printed by John Crespin, 1560Geneva: printed by Iohn Crespin, 1560
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Ye be never able to prove that Cain was elected to life everlasting in Christ Jesus:1 for God looked not to Cain, nor yet to his sacrifice, as that he did to Abel. And why?2 because, as the Apostle affirmeth, the one offered in faith and the other without faith. Remember, I pray you, your former reason: there is none (say you) elected without faith, but Cain was without faith even before he did kill or hate his brother, therefore by your own reason, he was not in the election, no not even before he hated. I do not approve this argument: but yet your former reason standing true, it is invincible. Moses sayeth not that God promised dominion to ⟨p. 269⟩Cain over his lusts,3 but sayeth, unto thee shall his appetites or lusts be, & thou shall bear dominion over him: which is not spoken of sin, but of Abel, who as he was the younger, so was he appointed to be subject to Cain,4 and to serve him, and therefore most unjustly did he hate him. It is the same phrase that before was spoken of the woman concerning her subjection to man. Such as have but mean knowledge in the hebrew text, know well that both these articles be of the masculine gender, & the substantive which signifieth sin in that place, is of the feminine gender & therefore will not yt propriety of the tongue suffer, that dominion promised, be referred to sin. where blasphemously ye ask if god gave Cain no power to subdue his lust, who was then the author of his sin? I answer Cain him self: for he was not like to a dead and unsensible sword, as ye adduce the similitude, but he was a reasonable instrument infected by the venom of Satan, from the which he not being purged could do nothing but serve the devil and his own lusts, against gods expressed will and commandment. I have before, proved that God is the cause of no mans damnation but sin in which they are fallen, is the very cause which all reprobates do find in them selves.
Ye be neuer able to proue that Cain was elected to life euerlasting in Christ Iesus:1 for God loked not to Cain, nor yet to his sacrifice, as that he did to Abel. And why?2 because, as the Apostle affirmeth, the one offered in faith and the other without faith. Remembre, I pray you, your former reason: there is none (say you) elected without faith, but Cain was without faith euen before he did kil or hate his brother, therefor by your owne reason, he was not in ye election, no not euen before he hated. I do not approue this argument: but yet your former reason standing true, it is inuincible. Moises saieth not that God promised dominion to ⟨p. 269⟩Cain ouer his lustes,3 but saieth, vnto thee shal his appetites or lustes be, & thow shall beare dominion ouer him: which is not spoken of sinne, but of Abel, who as he was the yōger, so was he appoīted to be subiect to Cain,4 and to serue him, and therefor most vniustly did he hate him. It is the same phrase that before was spoken of the woman concerning her subiection to man. Such as haue but mean knowledge in the hebrew text, know well that bothe these articles be of the masculin gendre, & the substātiue which signifieth sinne in that place, is of ye feminin gēdre & therefor wil not yt proprietie of the tongue suffer, yt dominion promised, be referred to sinne. where blasphemously ye aske if god gaue Cain no power to subdue his lust, who was thē ye author of his sinne? I answer Cain him self: for he was not lyke to a dead and vnsensible sworde, as ye adduce the similitude, but he was a reasonable instrumēt infected by the venom of Satā, from the whiche he not being purged could do nothing but serue the deuil and his owne lustes, against gods expressed will and commandement. I haue before, proued taht God is the cause of no mās damnation but sinne in which they are fallen, is the very cause which all reprobates do find in them selues.
- 1To the 5. & 6
- 2The adversary is convicted by his own reasons.The aduersarie is conuicted by his own reaso•s.
- 3The place of Moses concerningThe place of Moises cōcerning
- 4Cain.
Touching the fidelity of God who suffereth none of his to be tempted above their strength,1 it is only true of Gods elect,2 to whom it is plain that Paul there speaketh. for albeit that amongst the Corinthians there were many reprobates, yet doth Paul address his style as it were to the elect Church of God, calling them his beloved, willing them to fly from idolatry, and speaking to them, as unto men endued with wisdom &c. And therefore must ye first prove, that Cain had as great testimony of God that he was his elect, as the Corinthians had of Paul that they were beloved and elected in Christ, before that ye can make this place to serve for him. for albeit he did advertise him what was his duty to do, yet doth it not thereof follow, that he gave ⟨p. 270⟩him power to obey his will revealed, nether yet power to resist all tentation. To Pharaoh he did no less make manifest his will then that he did to Cain, and yet of him he did before pronounce that he should not hear nor obey the voice of Moses, I do not deny but that he stubbornly forsook the counsel of God, which mercifully called him. But why did he, and do all reprobate forsake it, we have oft before declared, to wit: because the seed of God abideth not in them.
Touching the fidelitie of God who suffereth none of his to be tempted aboue their strength,1 it is onely true of Gods elect,2 to whom it is plaine that Paul there speaketh. for albeit that amonges the Corinthians there were many reprobates, yet doth Paul addresse his style as it were to the elect Church of God, calling them his beloued, willing them to flie from idolatrie, and speaking to them, as vnto men indued with wisdome &c. And therefore must ye first proue, that Cain had as great testimonie of God that he was his elect, as the Corinthians had of Paule yt they were beloued and elected in Christ, before that ye can make this place to serue for him. for albeit he did aduertise him what was his duetie to do, yet doth it not thereof follow, that he gaue ⟨p. 270⟩him power to obey his will reueled, nether yet power to resist all tentation. To Pharao he did no les make manifest his will then that he did to Cain, and yet of him he did before pronounce that he should not heare nor obey the voice of Moises, I do not denie but that he stubbornly foresooke the counsell of God, whiche mercifully called him. But why did he, and do all reprobate forsaik it, we haue oft before declared, to witt: because the sede of God abideth not in them.
- 1To the 7
- 21. Cor. 10
What was the benediction given after the flood unto Noah and to his sons,1 the holy Ghost doth not conceal, to wit multiplication, preservation, and the restitution of all things, as touching the order of nature, like as they were before that vastation, (by reason of the waters which had so long continued). In that place is no mention made of election to life everlasting in Christ Jesus, and therefore your connection, that Ham was not reprobate, when he was blessed of God, is foolish. for albeit that none can be both blessed and cursed, loved and hated all at once, in that degree of love or of hatred which God freely beareth in Christ to his elect, and most justly hateth the reprobate, for the causes known to his visdom, yet in an other sort, it is no repugnancy to say that God both blesseth, and loveth in bestowing temporal benedictions, upon such as in his eternal counsel he hath rejected, and therefore hateth. As it is no repugnancy to say that God both blesseth and loveth his elect children, even when most severely he doth chasten and punish them.
What was the benediction giuen after the floode vnto Noah and to his sonnes,1 the holie Gost doth not conceale, to witt multiplication, preseruation, and the restitutiō of all thinges, as touching the order of nature, like as they were before that vastation, (by reason of the waters which had so long continued). In that place is no mention made of election to life euerlasting in Christ Iesus, and therefor your connexion, that Ham was not reprobat, when he was blessed of God, is foolishe. for albeit that none can be both blessed and cursed, loued and hated all at once, in that degre of loue or of hatered wc God frely beareth in Christ to his elect, and most iustlie hateth the reprobate, for the causes knowen to his visdom, yet in an other sort, it is no repugnancie to say that God both blesseth, and loueth in bestowing tempoall benedictions, vpon such as in his eternall counsell he hath reiected, and therefor hateth. As it is no repugnancie to say that God bothe blesseth and loueth his elect children, euen when most seruerely he doth chasten and punishe them.
- 1To the 8 Genese 9
To all that which ye adduce of the Israelites,1 my former answers may suffice, for you be never able to prove, that any of them, which was chosen to lief everlasting did fall into death eternal. It nothing hurt y• salvation of Moses albeit his body fell in the wilderness.2 That place of Paul proveth not that all the Israelites, which was called from Egypt, were within gods holy election to lief everlasting in Christ Jesus, but doth prove that they ⟨p. 271⟩were all externally called and that they did all communicate with those external signs and sacraments, which did signify, & represent spiritual things, but he doth not affirm that all did receive the spiritual and inward graces of the holy Ghost. The mind of the Apostle is plain enough in that place to such as willingly list not blind them selves. For he exhorteth the Corinthians not to think it sufficient that they did communicate with the sacraments of Christ Jesus, except that a godly lief & unfeigned obedience to gods will revealed should be joined with the same: for otherwise the same should happen unto them, that happened to the Israelites. And therefore he sayeth let him that standeth take heed, lest he fall, which is nothing contrary to our doctrine nether yet is our doctrine in any jot repugnant to the holy Ghost. for we did never deny but that many who before men had a fair glister of holiness, yea which thought them selves sure in their own fantasy hath taken horrible falls, both of one sort & of the other. And unto all men we cry no less then you do, that they tempt them selves, & that they take heed lest by slothfulness they fall. but that any that standeth in Christ Jesus, and in the eternal counsel of God can so fall that finally he perish, that we constantly deny. Behold how smoothly God conducteth our tossed boat through the raging waves of your furious arguments.3
To all yt which ye adduce of the Israelites,1 my former answers may suffice, for you be neuer able to proue, that any of thē, which was chosen to lief euerlasting did fall into death eternall. It nothing hurt y• saluation of Moises albeit his bodie fell in the wildernes.2 That place of Paule proueth not that all the Israelites, which was called from Egypt, were within gods holie election to lief euerlasting in Christ Iesus, but doth proue yt they ⟨p. 271⟩were all externally called and yt they did all cōmunicat with those externall signes and sacremēts, wc did signifie, & represent spirituall thinges, but he doth not affirm yt all did receaue ye spiritual and inward graces of the holie Gost. The mynd of the Apostle is plaine ynough in yt place to such as willingly list not blynd them selues. For he exhorteth the Corinthians not to think it sufficient that they did commuicat with the sacramentes of Christ Iesus, except that a godlie lief & vnfeined obediē ce to gods will reueled should be ioyned with the same: for otherwise the same should happen vnto them, that happened to the Israelites. And therefor he saieth let him that standeth take hede, lest he fall, which is nothīg contrarie to our doctryne nether yet is our doctrine in any iote repugnant to ye holie Gost. for we did neuer denie but yt many who before mē had a faire glister of holynes, yea which thoght thē selues sure in their own fantasie hath taken horrible falles, bothe of one sort & of ye other. And vnto all mē we cry no les then you do, that they tēpt them selues, & yt they take hede lest by slothfulnes they fall. but yt any yt standeth in Christ Iesus, and in the eternall counsale of God can so fall that finally he perishe, that we cōstantly denie. Behold how smothly God conducteth our tossed bote through the raiging waues of your furious argumentes.3
- 1To the 9 10 11. 12 & 13.
- 21 Cor. 10
- 3To the 14. 15 & 16.
The fall of the reprobate we remit to gods judgement Albeit that Balaam had been endued with greater graces, then in scriptures, we read that he had, yet doth it not thereof follow, that he had received the spirit of sanctification by true faith, which is given to the elect only. for we find the power given to some to expel devils, whom Christ affirmeth, that he never knew. And therefore willeth he his disciples, not to rejoice in that that spirits were subject unto them, but that their names were written in the book of lief. But yet I wonder where ye have found that Balaam was so filled with the spirit of God, the spirit of trueth, the spirit ⟨p. 272⟩of power and the spirit of grace (as ye write) that whom) soever he blessed, was blessed, and whom he cursed, he was cursed. I find no such thing witnessed of him by y• holy Ghost. True it is that Balack gave unto him that praise and commendation that he was assured, that whom he blessed should be happy, & whom he cursed should be cursed But whether that it was the purpose of the holy Ghost to teach and assure us thereby that in very deed such graces were in him,1 I greatly doubt. yea I doubt nothing to affirm the contrary, to wit that he nether had power spirit, nor grace of God to bless those whom God hath cursed, neither yet to curse those whom God hath blessed. for so doth he him self confess. And for that end is the history written. If ye understand that the benediction remained upon Jacob because that Balaam did so pronounce and speak, you are more blind then Balaam was. for he assigneth an nother cause, saying, how shall I curse where God hath not cursed, or how shall I detest where the Lord hath not detested. God is not as man that he should lie, nether as the son of man, that he should repent: hath he said, and shall he not do it? and hath he spoken, and shall he not accomplish it? Behold, I have received commandment to bless: for he hath blessed, and I can not alter it. He seeth none iniquity in Jacob, nor seeth no transgression in Israel: the Lord his God, is with him, and the joyful shout of a king is amongest them.
The fall of the reprobate we remit to gods iudgement Albeit that Balaam had bene indued with greater graces, then in scriptures, we read that he had, yet doth it not thereof follow, that he had receaued ye spirit of sanctification by true faith, which is giuen to ye elect onely. for we fynd the power giuen to some to expell deuilles, whom Christ affirmeth, that he neuer knew. And therefor willeth he his disciples, not to reioyse in that that spirites were subiect vnto them, but that their names were written in the booke of lief. But yet I wonder where ye haue found that Balaam was so filled with the spirit of God, the spirit of trueth, the spirit ⟨p. 272⟩of power and the spirit of grace (as ye write) that whom) soeuer he blessed, was blessed, and whom he cursed, he was cursed. I fynd no such thing witnessed of him by y• holie Gost. Trew it is that Balack gaue vnto him that praise and cōmendation that he was assured, that whō he blessed should be happie, & whō he cursed should be cursed But whether that it was the purpose of ye holie Gost to teach and assure vs therby that in very dede such graces were in him,1 I greatly doubt. yea I doubt nothīg to affirm the contrarie, to witt that he nether had power spirit, nor grace of God to blesse those whom God hath curssed, nerher yet to curse those whom God hath blessed. for so doth he him self confes. And for that end is the historie written. If ye vnderstand that the benediction remained vpon Iacob becaus that Balaam did so pronounce and speak, you are more blynd then Balaam was. for he assigneth an nother cause, saying, how shall I cursse where God hath not cursed, or how shall I detest where the Lord hath not detested. God is not as man that he shoulde lie, nether as the sonne of man, that he should repent: hath he said, and shall he not do it? and hathe he spoken, and shall he not accōplish it? Behold, I haue receaued commandement to blesse: for hehath blessed, and I can not alter it. He seeth none iniquitie in Iacob, nor seeth no transgression in Israel: the Lord his God, is with him, and the ioyfull showte of a king is amongest them.
- 1Nom. 23
In these words,1 I say, Balaam assigneth the cause why he was compelled to bless Israel, because, saith he, God hath blessed them. And why also he could not change his blessing, because in God there is no mutability, nor change, like as there is in man. And therefore as he had once blessed that people, by his plain word and promise spoken, and revealed to Abraham, so should he most constantly perform it. If malice did not blind you, you should clearly see, that the holy Ghost meaneth nothing less then to teach that Balaam was blessed of God, and ⟨p. 273⟩therefore was not at that time a reprobate: But that Israel was so elected, so sanctified, and blessed of God, that their very enemies, and such as were hired to curse them, were compelled to give testimony against them selves, that gods people was blessed. But this doeth no more make Balaam to be gods elect, then did that confession, which the wicked spirits gave to Christ, (confessing him to be the Son of the living God) change their nature.
In these wordes,1 I say, Balaam assigneth the cause why he was compelled to blesse Israel, because, saith he, God hath blessed them. And why also he could not change his blessing, because in God there is no mutabilitie, nor chāge, like as there is in mā. And therefor as hehad once blessed that people, by his plaine word and promes spoken, and reueled to Abrahā, so shoulde he most constantly perfourme it. If malice did not blynd you, you should clerely se, that the holie Gost meaneth nothing les then to teach that Balam was blessed of God, and ⟨p. 273⟩therefor was not at that tyme a reprobate: But that Israel was so elected, sosanctified, and blessed of God, that their very ennemis, and suche as were hyred to curse them, were compelled to giue testimonie against them selues, that gods people was blessed. But this doeth no more make Balaam to be gods elect, then did that confession, which the wicked spirites gaue to Christ, (confessing him to be the Sonne of the liuing God) change their nature.
- 1why Balaam blessed Israel & could not curs them.
If you be able to prove that hole Israel so fell from gods favour, that to none of Abraham's posterity did he perform the promise made to him, and to his seed, then have ye proved somewhat of your purpose, to wit, that God may make a promise, & that with an oath, & yet perform no part of it. But if it be manifest that notwithstanding their grudging, their rebellion, their carnal lusts, their idolatry, and abominations, gods promise remained so sure, that the same was performed (after many temptations) in full perfection: Consider what may be concluded against you, in applying examples by similitude, & equality. I would wish in you greater wisdom, then to compare Balaam one particular person, a false prophet accursed of God, and so perishing amongest the ungodly, and hole israel gods elect and chosen people, so blessed of God, that not only they were preserved in all storms,1 but also of them, according to the flesh, came that blessed seed, the messias promised.
If you be able to proue that hole Israel so fell frō gods fauor, that to none of Abrahams posteritie did he perfourm the promes made to him, and to his sede, then haue ye proued somwhat of your purpose, to witt, that God may make a promes, & that with an oth, & yet perfourm no part of it. But if it be manifest that notwithstanding their grudging, their rebellion, their carnall lustes, their idolatrie, and abominations, gods promes remained so sure, that the same was perfourmed (after many tēptations) in full perfection: Consider what may be cōcluded against you, in applying examples by similitude, & equalitie. I wold wish in you greater wisdom, then to compare Balaam one particulare person, a fals prophete accursed of God, and so perishing amongest the vngodlie, and hole israell gods elect and chosen people, so blessed of God, yt not onely they were preserued in all stormes,1 but also of them, according to the flesh, came that blessed sede, the messias promised.
- 1To the 17 & 18.
To Saul and to his kingdom I have before answered, to wit, that one thing it is to be appointed to a temporal office, and an other to be elected in Christ Jesus to lief everlasting. But yet I will add somewhat more, which is this Proposition directly fighting against yours:1 Saul nor his house was never chosen in gods eternal counsel to be kings and Rulers over Israel for ever. If ye cry, then did the holy Ghost, speaking in Samuel, lie. for he affirmed, that God had prepared the reign and kingdom of Saul upon Israel for ever, ⟨p. 274⟩I answer Samuel speaketh not in that place, what God had determined in his eternal counsel,2 but what he him self thought that God had determined and appointed. And therefore ye may not conclude that the holy Ghost doth lie, except the kingdom of Saul was once appointed to have remained over Israel for ever. Nay, so can ye not conclude. But ye may say, that except that so it was, the prophet was deceived. And so no doubt he was for a season, and did speak those words according to the apprehension & judgement which he had conceived by reason of his unction and lawful election to his office. If it appear hard to you, that the prophets be deceived in any thing, consider I pray you what chanced unto him after. did he not at the sight of Eliab pronounce with an affirmation, that before the eternal,3 he was his anointed? did the holy Ghost lie because that Eliab was refused, and David chosen, or was not rather Samuel ignorant and in an error? the same might I prove by Nathan, & others, who being gods true prophets were yet for a season left in error & did both speak and give counsel otherwise than God had determined in his eternal counsel. But now shortly to prove my proposition, I say, that gods eternal purpose and counsel concerning the chief ruler and governor over Israel was long before pronounced, by Jacob in his last testament,4 who did appoint the crown, and Sceptre royal to an other tribe then to Benjamin. for thus he sayeth, Thou Judah thy brethren shall praise thee: thine hand shall be in the the neck of thine enemies: thy fathers sons shall bow down unto thee, &c. The Sceptre shall not depart from Judah, nether the law giver from betwixt his feet until Shiloh come and the people shall be gathered to him, &c.
To Saul and to his kingdom I haue before answered, to witt, that one thing it is to be appointed to a temporall office, and an other to be elected in Christ Iesus to lief euerlasting. But yet I will adde somwhat more, which is this Propo•ition directlie fighting against yours:1 Saul nor his house was neuer chosen in gods eternall counsel to be kings and Reulars ouer Israel for euer. If ye cry, then did the holie Gost, speaking in Samuel, lie. for he affirmed, that God had prepared the reigne and kingdom of Saul vpon Israel for euer, ⟨p. 274⟩I answer Samuel speaketh not in that place, what God had determined in his eternall counsel,2 but what he him self thoght that God had determined and appointed. And therefore ye may not conclude that the holie Gost doth lie, except the kingdom of Saul was once appointed to haue remained ouer Israel for euer. Nay, so can ye not conclude. But ye may say, yt except that so it was, ye prophet was deceaued. And so no doubt he was for a ceason, and did speake those wordes according to the apprehension & iudgement which he had conceaued by reason of his vnction and lawfull election to his office. If it appere hard to you, that ye prophetes be deceaued in any thing, consider I praie you what chanced vnto him after. did he not at the sight of Eliab pronounce with an affirmation, that before the eternall,3 he was his anointed? did the holie Gost lie because that Eliab was refused, and Dauid chosen, or was not rather Samuel ignorant and in an error? the same might I proue by Nathan, & others, who being gods true prophetes were yet for a ceason left in error & did both speak and giue counsel otherwies than God had determined in his eternal counsel. But now shortlie to proue my proposition, I say, that gods eternall purpose and counsel concerning the chief rewler and gouernor ouer Israel was long before pronounced, by Iacob in his last testament,4 who did appoint the crown, and Sceptre royall to an other tribe then to Beniamin. for thus he saieth, Thou Iudah thy bretheren shall praise thee: thine hand shalbe in the the necke of thine ennemies: thy fathers sonnes shall bowe downe vnto thee, &c. The Sceptre shall not depart frō Iudah, nether the law giuer from betwext his fete vntil Shiloh come and the people shalbe gathered to him, &c.
here I say it is plain that many years before the election of Saul was the Kingly dignity appointed to Judah, which sentence was never after retracted. And therefore my proposition ⟨p. 275⟩affirming that Saul was never elected in the eternal counsel of God to reign for ever over Israel, standeth sure and sufficiently proved. If any ask to what purpose was Saul then elected king? I answer, because so it pleased gods wisdom to tempt his people,1 to tempt the tribe of Judah, yea and all the faithful, that then were a live, to tempt them I say, whether they would still depend upon gods promise, & look for their felicity, even by the same means, that God had forespoken: how so ever things appeared to the contrary for a season. The hole people no doubt, yea and Samuel him self, were partly criminal in that point, that they looked for salvation, and for deliverance from all their enemies by the ham des of any other, then by one of the tribe of Judah: considering that the former prophecy was so plain. But that error he did first correct in his prophet, showing unto him just causes why Saul was unworthy of that great honour, and after he did correct the same in the people moving their hearts to elect David, whom the prophet had before anointed. And so did God retain y• firmitie of his counsel, and did perform the same, when all things appeared, Plainly to repugn to his promise, yea when men had received an other to be their king, then God by his former promise had appointed.2 We nether deny the supernatural wisdom and manifold graces given to Solomon, nether yet his most horrible fall, to be a document, and a memorial for ever, of his abominable idolatries, and most unthankful defection from God. which only one example we affirm ought to admonish every man most carefully to examine him self, with what simplicity he walketh before gods Majesty. But whether that Solomon so became the son of the devil, that after he did never return to God but that finally he did perish, we dare not be bold to pronounce sentence. And that because to us it appeareth, that God did make unto him a promise of mercy, his grievous ⟨p. 276⟩offence not withstanding.3 for this did God speak by Nathan of him:
here I say it is plaine that many yeres before the election of Saul was the Kinglie dignitie appointed to Iuda, which sentence was neuer after retracted. And therefor my proposition ⟨p. 275⟩affirming yt Saul was neuer elected in ye eternall counsel of God to reign for euer ouer Israel, stādeth sure and sufficientlie proued. If any ask to what purpose was Saul then elected king? I answer, because so it pleased gods wisdom to tempt his people,1 to tempt the tribe of Iudah, yea and all the faithfull, that then were a liue, to tempt them I say, whether they wolde still depend vpon gods promes, & look for their felicitie, euen by the same meanes, that God had foresopken: how so euer thinges appered to the contrarie for a ceason. The hole people no doubt, yea and Samuel him self, were partlie criminall in that point, that they looked for saluation, and for delyuerance from all their ennemies by the hā des of any other, then by one of the tribe of Iuda: considering that the former prophecie was so plaine. But yt error he did first correct in his prophet, shewing vnto him iust causes why Saul was vnworthie of that great honor, and after he did correct the same in the people mouing their hartes to elect Dauid, whom the prophet had before anointed. And so did God retein y• firmitie of his counsel, and did perfourme the same, when all things appered, Plainelie to repugne to his promes, yea when men had receaued an other to be their king, then God by his former promes had appointed.2 We nether denie the supernaturall wisdom and manifold graces giuen to Salomon, nether yet his most horrible fall, to be a document, and a memoriall for euer, of his abominable idolatries, and most vnthankfull defection from God. which onelie one example we affirme oght to admonish euery man most carefully to examin him felf, with what simplicitie he walketh before gods Maiestie. But whether that Salomon so became the sonne of ye deuil, that after he did neuer returne to God but yt finally he did perish, we dare not be bolde to pronoūce sentēce. And yt because to vs it appereth, yt God did make vnto him a promes of mercie, his greuous ⟨p. 276⟩offence not withstanding.3 for this did God speak by Nathan of him:
- 1why Saul was elected•• the king dō which was appointed to an •ther tribs.why Saul was elected•• the king dō which was appointed to an •ther tribs.
- 2To the 18. 19. & 20.
- 32. Sam. 7
when thy days shall be fulfilled, thou shalt sleep with thy fathers, and I will set up thy seed after the which shall proceed out of thy body, and will stablish his kingdom, he shall build an house for my name, & I will stablish the throne of his kingdom for ever: I will be his father and he shall be my son: and if he sin, I will chasten him with the rod of men, and with the plagues of the children of men. But my mercy shall not depart away from him, as I toke it from Saul, whom I have put away before thee, &c. howsoever ye list to understand this free mercy promised to abide after in iniquity committed, you cannot deny, but that a plain difference is made betwixt Solomon, & Saul. And if ye think, that nothing spoken in that place, did appertain to Solomon, who was born before that David had finished his days & did sleep with his fathers, but that all is performed in Christ, who many years after did spring of him ye do not rightly mark the words of God nether yet the mind of the holy Ghost, he saith not, that the child who should build a house to the name of God, and whose kingdom he would establish, should be borne after his death, but that God should raise one who should spring of his own loins, whom he would so honour after his death, that he would become his father, whom he would so entreat: that albeit he should offend, yet should he not be rejected from regiment in Israel, as Saul was, and so was the kingdom established not only to David, but also to his posterity after him. The perfection no doubt was reserved to Christ Jesus, but so was the verity in him, that the figure passed before in Solomon. Moreover somewhat is spoken in this promise, which in no wise can be referred to Christ Jesus. for how shall any be able to prove that the just seed of David in whose mouth was no deceit found, did in any sort wickedly in his own person, so that he had need of mercy, & to be corrected with the rod of the children. This I note, to give you ⟨p. 277⟩occasion to take heed what sentence ye pronounce in things so far removed from the reach of your understanding.1 In the history of Jeroboam, ye do not observe that whatsoever is promised unto him, except the first […] of the ten tribes, is conditional. for thus saith the Prophet unto him.2
when thy daies shalbe fulfilled, thou shalt slepe with thy fathers, and I will sett vp thy sede after the which shal procede out of thy body, and wil stablish his kingdome, he shall buyld an house for my name, & I wil stablish the throne of his kingdome for euer: I will be his father and he shalbe my sonne: and if he sinne, I wil chasten him with the rodde of men, and with the plagues of the children of men. But my mercy shal not departe away from him, as I toke it frō Saul, whome I haue put away before thee, &c. howsoeuer ye list to vnderstand this fre mercy promised to abide after in iquitie committed, you cānot denie, but that a plaine difference is made betwext Salomō, & Saul. And if ye think, that nothing spoken in that place, did appertein to Salomō, who was born before that Dauid had finished his daies & did slepe with his fathers, but that all is performed in Christ, who many yeares after did spring of him ye do not rightly mark the wordes of God nether yet ye mynd of the holie Gost, he saith not, that the childe who shoulde builde a house to the name of God, and whose kingdome he wolde establish, shoulde be borne after his death, but that God shoulde raise one who shoulde sprīg of his own loynes, whom he wolde so honor after his death, that he wolde become his father, whom he wolde so intreate: that albeit he shoulde offend, yet shoulde he not be reiected frō regiment in Israel, as Saul was, and so was the kingdome established not onelie to Dauid, but also to his posteritie after him. The perfection no doubt was reserued to Christ Iesus, but so was the veritie in him, that the figure passed before in Salomō. Moreouer somwhat is spokē in this promes, which in no wise can be referred to Christ Iesus. for how shal any be able to proue that ye iust sede of Dauid in whose mouth was no deceat founde, did in any sort wickedly in his owne person, so that he had nede of mercy, & to be corrected with the rodde of the children. This I note, to giue you ⟨p. 277⟩occasion to take hede what sentence ye pronounce in things so farre remoued frō the reache of your vnderstanding.1 In the historie of Ieroboam, ye do not obserue that whatsoeuer is promised vnto him, except the first 〈…〉 of the tenne tribes, is cōdicionall. for thus saith the Prophet vnto him.2
- 1To the 21
- 23 K•g, 11
And if thou hearken unto all that I command thee, and wilt walk in my ways, & do right in my sight as did David my servant, then will I be, with thee, and build thee assure house, as I built unto David & will give Israel unto thee, &c. I pray you what can ye hereof conclude? That Jeroboam say you not withstanding gods election and free ordinance did fall from the favour of God. But how be you able to prove, that he was elected and before ordained to stand in gods favour for ever? These sayings, if thou walk before me in righteousness, if thou keep my precepts, and such others, will not prove it. I can evidently prove that Jeroboam, and all the kings in Israel after him were given to the people in gods anger, and were taken away in his hot displeasure, for so doth the Prophet Oseas witness. Now if you can prove, that such rulers, as be given in gods wrath, and taken away in his just fury, were elected and before ordained to stand in his favour for ever, advise with your counsellors, and produce your witness against the next time.1 That Judas was never elected to life everlasting, I have before declared and therefore at this present I only say, that no more did Christ mean of Judas that he should be the salt of the earth, the light of the world, nether that he should sit upon any seat to judge any tribe in Israel, then that he meant of Peter, that he was the devil, that he should betray him, or that better it it had been for him never to have been borne. for as Christ in pronouncing the words, you twelve have I chosen but one of you is the devil, one of you shall betray me in express words he did nether appoint the person of Judas to that fact, nether yet did exempt and make free any of the rest, from suspicion of that crime, in express words ⟨p. 278⟩(I say) So like wise in saying, ye are the salt of the earth and you shall sit upon twelve seats, &c. he nether meant of the hole number of the twelve, nether yet of them only. for as for Judas, I doubt not to affirm, but that according, as it was written in the book of Psalms, That his habitation should be desolate, & that an other should receive the honour of his bishopric: that so even in the time, when he stood in the ministry most sure to mans judgement, that yet in gods eternal counsel, he was appointed to that treason, and most fearful end.
And if thou harken vnto al that I command thee, and wilt walk in my waies, & do right in my sight as did Dauid my seruant, then wil I be, with thee, and build thee asure house, as I buylt vnto Dauid & wil giue Israel vnto thee, &c. I pray you what can ye hereof conclude? That Ieroboam say you not withstanding gods election and fre ordinance did fall from the fauor of God. But how be you able to proue, that he was elected and before ordeined to stand in gods fauor for euer? These saings, if thou walke before me in righteousnes, if thou kepe my preceptes, and such others, will not proue it. I can euidently proue that Ieroboam, and all the kings in Israel after him were giuen to the people in gods anger, and were taken away in his hote displeasure, for so doth the Prophet Oseas witnes. Now if you can proue, that such reulers, as be giuen in gods wrath, and taken awaie in his iust furie, were elected and before ordeined to stand in his fauor for euer, aduise wt your counsellers, and produce your witnes against the next time.1 That Iudas was neuer elected to life euerlasting, I haue before declared and therfore at this present I onely say, that no more did Christ mean of Iudas that he shoulde be the salt of the earth, the light of the worlde, nether that he shoulde sit vpō any seat to iudge any tribe in Israel, then that he ment of Peter, yt he was the deuil, that he shoulde betraie him, or that better it it had bene for him neuer to haue bene borne. for as Christ in pronoūcing ye wordes, you twelue haue I chosē but one of you is the deuil, one of you shal betraie me in expresse wordes he did nether appoint ye person of Iudas to that fact, nether yet did exempt and make fre any of the rest, from suspition of that cryme, in expres wordes ⟨p. 278⟩(I say) So like wise in saing, ye are the salt of ye earth and you shall sitt vpon twelue seates, &c. he nether ment of the hole nomber of the twelue, nether yet of thē onely. for as for Iudas, I doubte not to affirme, but yt according, as it was written in the book of Psalmes, That his habitacion shoulde be desolate, & that an other should receaue ye honor of his bushoprike: yt so euē in ye tyme, whē he stood in the ministerie most sure to mānes iudgemēt, that yet in gods eternall coūsel, he was appointed to that treason, and most feareful end.
- 1To the 22. 23.
and I suppose that none will be so perverse of judgement, as to deny, that none other was appointed to be the salt of the earth, and the light of the world, except those twelve. I verily believe that Paul is nothing inferior to any of the chiefest Apostles in that case. And so yet I affirm, that nether were those words spoken of all the twelve, nether yet of them only. If this can not satisfy your curiosity, labour you to prove that Judas was elected to life everlasting in Christ Jesus before the foundations of the world were laid. I have before proved that the elect can not finally refuse nor deny Christ Jesus their head, and therefore I will not trouble the reader with the repetition.
and I suppose that none wil be so peruerse of iudgement, as to denie, that none other was appointed to be the salt of ye earth, and the light of the worlde, except those twelue. I verilie beleue that Paule is nothing inferior to any of the chiefest Apostles in that case. And so yet I affirme, that nether were those wordes spokē of all the twelue, nether yet of thē onely. If this can not satisfie your curiositie, labor you to proue that Iudas was elected to life euerlasting in Christ Iesus before the fundacions of the world were laid. I haue before proued that the elect can not finally refuse nor deny Christ Iesus their head, and therefor I will not trouble the reader with the repetition.
The place of Ezekiel1 serveth nothing your purpose. for there doth he only entreat of such righteous men, as in the beginning of the same chapter used this proverb: The fathers have eaten sour grapes and the children's teeth are set on edge, signifying thereby (as before we have declared) that they were just and innocent and that yet they did suffer punishment, for the offences of their fathers. Against whom the Prophet speaketh most sharply affirming that the soul which did sin should die: in this praising gods justice, that he would suffer sin unpunished in none of his creatures, supposing that some for a time, had a show of righteousness. The prophet doeth further accuse, and convict their consciences, for they knew them selves criminal in all crimes, which the prophet there recited. And therefore ⟨p. 279⟩to provoke them to repentance with this exhortation: Cast away from you (sayeth he) all your transgressions whereby ye have transgressed, and make you a new heart, and a new spirit, for why will you die ô house of Israel, for I desire not the death of him that dieth (saith the Lord God) Cause therefore one another to return, and live ye.
The place of Ezechiell1 serueth nothing your purpose. for there doth he onely intreat of such righteous men, as in the beginning of the same chapter vsed this prouerbe: The fathers haue eaten soure grapes and the childrens teeth are set on edge, signifying thereby (as before we haue declared) that they were iust and innocēt and that yet they did suffer punishement, for the offenses of their fathers. Against whom ye Prophet speaketh most sharpely affirming that the soule which did sinne shoulde die: in this praising gods iustice, that he wolde suffer sinne vnpunished in none of his creatures, supposing that some for a time, had a shew of righteousnes. The prophet doeth further accuse, and conuict their consciences, for they knew them selues criminall in all crimes, which the prophet there recited. And therefore ⟨p. 279⟩to prouoke them to repentāce wt this exhortacion: Cast away from you (saieth he) all your transgressiōs whereby ye haue transgressed, and make you a new heart, and a new spirit, for why wil you die ô house of Israel, for I desire not the death of him yt dieth (saith the Lord God) Cause therefore one another to returne, and liue ye.
- 1Ez•• 18.
Of this conclusion (I say) it easily may appear of what sort of righteous men the Prophet speaketh: not of such as being ingrafted in Christs body, by the true sanctification of his spirit, do daily study to mortify their affections: but of such as having an outward appearance or show of holiness, did notwithstanding loose the bridle to all impiety. In very deed God can not remember the justice of any such (which is not) but their sins must crave just vengeance, & that the rather because by them the name of God is blasphemed. Now to the rest of that which followeth in your book.
Of this co•clusiō (I say) it easely may appere of what sort of righteous men ye Prophet speaketh: not of such as being ingrafted in Christes bodie, by the true sanctification of his spirit, do daylie studie to mortifie their affections: but of such as hauing an outward appearance or shew of holines, did notwithstāding lowse ye bridle to all impietie. In very dede God can not remēbre ye iustice of any such (wc is not) but their sinnes must craue iust vengeance, & yt the rather because by thē ye name of God is blasphemed. Now to ye rest of yt wc foloweth in yor book.
THE ADVERSARY.
THE ADVERSARIE.
This say you,1 with many other manifest testimonies of the Scriptures, ye •osse, and turn upside doun• seeking shifts to maintain your errors, where by you declare your self to be of the number of them, of whom it is written in the same place, which do say tush the way of the Lord is not indifferent §1ye will not that the Lord judge according to this way set. forth in his word but of necessity by an immutable […] save a certain, & of necessity to con den all the rest, ye must not so read gods word studying rather to teach the holy Ghost, then to learn your duty of him, seeking means rather to con firm your preconceived error, then to avoid it. what true•• can he learn §2at the word of God, which worshippeth the idol of his own fantasy, and hath already forsaken the mind of the trueth. Remember that the first less• ̄ of wisdom, is to be willing to learn wisdom▪ Cast away therefore the •doles of your hearts, which made you stumble in your ways, submit your selves to the word, as humble and meek lambs. for the lamb only was §3found worthy to open the seals of the book. Trust not your error to be the better because it hath many favourers specially of them, which have the name of learning for such have been always in all ages, enemies to the trueth §4inventers of sects & errors, such like as Jannes and •ambres resisted Moses so do they the trueth, as the learned scribes & Pharisees blasphemed the word of God and persecuted Christ the trueth it self, so do they yet in hu members. And even as the pharisees said, do any of the rulers or of the pharisees believe in him, this common people which know not the law is cursed,§5 so say they now do any of our learned doctors teach so these unlearned fellows are cursed, for they can not understand gods word they understand only the english tongue, & yet will they meddle with […], as though the gift […] ⟨p. 280⟩& the gifts of prophesying were so bound together, that God could not minister the one without the other. but this is no new• thing, for this was laid to Christ, & his Apostles charge▪ that they were unlearned▪ But the holy Ghost wille• us not to judge so.
This say you,1 with many other manifest testimonies of the Scriptures, ye •osse, and turne vpside doun• seking shiftes to maintein your errors, where by you declare your self to be of the nombre of them, of whom it is written in the same place, which do say tush the way of the Lord is not indifferent §1ye will not that the Lord iudge according to this way set. furth in his word but of necessitie by an immutable 〈…〉 saue a certē, & of necess•tie to cō dēne all the rest, ye must not so read gods word studying rather to teache the holy Gost, then to learne your duetie of him, seking meanes rather to cō firme your preconceaued error, then to auoid it. what true•• can he learne §2at the word of God, which worshippeth the idoll of his own phantasie, and hath alredie forsaken the mynd of the trueth. Remēbre that the first less• ̄ of wisdom, is to be willing to learne wisdom▪ Cast away therefor the •doles of your heartes, which made you st•mble in your wayes, submit your selues to the word, as humble and meke lābes. for the lambe onelie was §3found worthie to open the seales of the book. Trust not your error to be thebetter because it hath many fauorers specially of thē, which haue the name of learning for such haue bene alwaies in all ages, ennemies to the trueth §4inuenters of sectes & errors, such like as Iannes and •ambres resisted Moises so do they the trueth, as the learned scribes & Pharise•s blasphem•d the word of God and persecuted Christ the trueth it selfe, so do they yet in hu membres. And euen as the pharesies said, do any of the reulers or of the phareseis beleue in him, this comō people which know not the law is cursed,§5 so say they nowdo any of our learned doctors teach so these vnlearned felowes are cursed, for they cā not vnderstād gods word they vnderstād onely the english tōgue, & yet wil they medle with 〈…〉, as thogh the gifte 〈…〉 ⟨p. 280⟩& the giftes of prophecying were so boūd together, that God coulde not minister the one without the other. but this is no new• thing, for this was laid to Christ, & his Apostles charge▪ that they were vnlearned▪ But the holie Gost wille• vs not to iudge so.
- 1The 33 sectio