A06490:18
A book made by a certain great clerk, against the new idol, and old…A boke made by a certayne great clerke, agaynst the newe idole, and olde…
A book made by a certain great clerk, against the new idol, and old devil which of late time, in Misnia should have ben canonised for a saint.A boke made by a certayne great clerke, agaynst the newe idole, and olde deuyll whiche of late tyme, in Misnia shulde haue ben canonysed for a saynt.
London : Imprinted by me Robert Wyer dwelling in saint Martins parish, besides charring Cross, 1534London : Imprynted by me Robert Wyer dwellynge in saynt Martyns parysshe, besydes charynge Crosse, 1534
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
But O good lord, how uncircumspectelye & unwisely do we all things? Howe rashly & unadvisedly do we run on forth as it were certain blind men? Howe piteously did the devil ⟨image 18⟩deceive saint Gregory in his dialogues? 1For there is in every place so much plenty of such manner juggling castes and deceits, which he hath exercised, & yet doth exercise, that I could of them make ten other such saints, as Benno is / who again can sufficiently prove, that the holy fountain was brought forth by Benno: saving only that the common opinion goeth so about of it? For a man may find many like things / the nature and original cause whereof is strange and unknown / of which sort there are many things at Rome. Briefly, who soever will describe and imagine yt good life of an holy bishop: He ought of necessity to bring forth the words and doctrine, 2wherein he was excellent. And also ⟨image 19⟩faith, charity and the cross of persecution which was laid upon his back for his doctrines sake. These things only are the true tokens of an holy man / But now this bull saith in deed, that Benno did preach: but what he did preach, or what he did utterly believe, it maketh no mention at all / neither is there so much as any mention at all made of charity, and of the cross / only it speaketh of his ceremonies, & how that in great anger he ran away & afflicted and vexed certain men for the goods of the church. Besides this there is carried about tales of certain spirits and fantasies or imaginations of uncertain and feigned miracles, which should need much more probation, whether they did chance ⟨image 19⟩accordingly and verily or not, than this, whether Benno be a saint or not. But this thing might easily be persuaded unto me, that Benno in deed was a good man, but yet was in many things seduced and deceived of the Pope: 3and yet nevertheless at the last through the unmeasurable mercy of god was saved in like manner as it hath chanced to Bernard, & to very many other elect & chosen persons. But that he did such miracles, or wrought such foolish wonders as the bull doth assign & ascribe unto him: I suppose no man shall prove / or at the least wise if he can prove it: than they do make Benno the child of damnation, and heir of hell / for as much as his life is clean repugnant and contrary to the