Again, hence it follows, that works of the regenerate, are mixed works, that is, good works indeed, yet not perfectly good, but partly evil: for such as the cause is, such is the effect: now the mind and will of man, are the cause of his §10works, and the mind is partly carnal, and partly spiritual: so also is the will: and therefore the works that proceed from them, are partly spiritual, & in part carnal. Upon this ground it follows, that all the works of regenerate men, are sinful, and in the rigour of justice deserve damnation. Object. Sin §15is the transgression of the law: good works are no transgression of the law: therefore good works are no sins. I answer to the minor. The transgression of the law is twofold: One, which is directly against the law, both for matter, and manner: the second is, when that is done which the law requires, but §20not in that manner it should be done. And thus good works become sinful. The duty which the law requires, is done, but it is not done perfectly as it ought to be done, by reason of the flesh. Secondly, it is alleged that good works are from the spirit of God: and that nothing proceeding from the spirit of §25God is sin. Ans. Things proceeding from the spirit of God alone, or from the spirit immediately, are no sins: now good works proceed not only from the spirit, but also from the mind and will of man, as instruments of the spirit. And when §30an effect proceeds from sundry causes that are subordinate, it takes unto it the nature of the second cause: hereupon works are ••rtly spiritual, and partly carnal, as the mind and will of the doer is. Thirdly, it is alleged, that good works please God: and that things pleasing God, are no sins. Ans. They please God; because the doer is in Christ, and so pleaseth God. Again, §35they please not God before, or without pardon: for they are accepted, because God approves his own work in us, & pardons the defect thereof. Lastly, some object on this manner. No sins are to be done: good works are sins: therefore ⟨p. 420⟩not to be done. Ans. They are not simply sins, but only by accident. For as God commands them they are good: and as godly men do them, they are good in part. Now the reason holds only thus: That which is sin, so far forth as it is a sin, or if it be simply a sin, is not to be done.
Againe, hence it followes, that workes of the regenerate, are mixed workes, that is, good workes indeed, yet not perfectly good, but partly euill: for such as the cause is, such is the effect: now the minde and will of man, are the cause of his §10workes, and the mind is partly carnall, and partly spirituall: so also is the will: and therefore the workes that proceede from them, are partly spirituall, & in part carnall. Vpon this ground it followes, that all the workes of regenerate men, are sinfull, and in the rigour of iustice deserue damnation. Obiect. Sinne §15is the transgression of the law: good workes are no transgression of the law: therefore good workes are no sinnes. I answer to the minor. The transgression of the law is twofold: One, which is directly against the law, both for matter, and manner: the second is, when that is done which the law requires, but §20not in that manner it should be done. And thus good workes become sinfull. The dutie which the law requires, is done, but it is not done perfectly as it ough to be done, by reason of the flesh. Secondly, it is alleaged that good workes are from the spirit of God: and that nothing proceeding from the spirit of §25God is sinne. Ans. Things proceeding from the spirit of God alone, or from the spirit immediatly, are no sinnes: now good workes proceed not only from the spirit, but also from the mind and will of man, as instruments of the spirit. And when §30an effect proceedes from sundrie causes that are subordinate, it takes vnto it the nature of the second cause: hereupon workes are ••rtly spirituall, and partly carnall, as the minde and will of the doer is. Thirdly, it is alleged, that good works please God: and that things pleasing God, are no sinnes. Ans. They please God; because the doer is in Christ, and so pleaseth God. Againe, §35they please not God before, or without pardon: for they are accepted, because God approoues his owne worke in vs, & pardons the defect thereof. Lastly, some obiect on this manner. No sinnes are to be done: good workes are sinnes: theretherefore ⟨p. 420⟩not to be done. Ans. They are not simply sinnes, but onely by accident. For as God commands them they are good: and as godly men doe them, they are good in part. Now the reason holds onely thus: That which is sinne, so farre forth as it is a sinne, or if it be simplie a sinne, is not to be done.