IX. Secret sins known only to thee, or to a few, must be reproved secretly, betwixt thee and the party alone: they §20must not be divulged, but concealed in love, which covereth a multitude of sins. For if thou hast offended, or if thy brother hath ought against thee, go thy way, and be reconciled to thy brother. Matth. 5. 23, 24. If he have trespassed against thee, or thou hast ought against him, go and tell him his fault between §25him and thee alone. Matth. 18. 15. And albeit Solomon say, That open rebuke is better then secret love, Prou. 27. 5. yet it makes nothing against this rule: for he understandeth not that reproof which is uttered before witnesses, but that private reproof which is given to his face, and not behind his back, betwixt §30them two alone. But open sins are to be reproved openly. 1. Tim. 5. 20. Them that sin, rebuke openly, that the rest also may fear. Which text of Scripture must rightly be conceived: for it is not a general commandment given to all, (as some have thought, in alleging it to prove that they may lawfully §35reprove open swearers, and offenders, and that openly:) but it is a special commandment given to the Pastors, or governors of the Church, that they should reprove those elders, and so consequently all such as were convicted of any crime, by witnesses, and that before all men, that is, before the whole ⟨p. 486⟩Church, and not before all men, in every place, and assembly, where they offend. For we have no warrant in Scripture so to do. Secondly, this open disgraceful rebuking of men will rather harden them in their sins, then any way reclaim them from sin. Augustine saith well, Prae pudore incipiet defendere peccatum suum, & quem vis correctiorem, facis peiorem. §51Thirdly, they might as well say, a man is to be reproved for every sin, and that openly before all men, as for open sins, because Paul saith not, Them that sin openly, rebuke before all men, but them that sin, rebuke openly. Fourthly, the words depend upon the former verse, where it is said, Receive not an §10accusation against an Elder, under two or three witnesses: and then it follows, Those that sin, rebuke openly: that is, those elders that sin, and have been first privately admonished, and after that before witnesses, if they be accused by two or three witnesses; then reprove them openly, before all men:
IX. Secret sinnes knowne onely to thee, or to a few, must be reprooued secretly, betwixt thee and the partie alone: they §20must not be divulged, but concealed in loue, which couereth a multitude of sinnes. For if thou hast offended, or if thy brother hath ought against thee, goe thy way, and be reconciled to thy brother. Matth. 5. 23, 24. If he haue trespassed against thee, or thou hast ought against him, goe and tell him his fault betweene §25him and thee alone. Matth. 18. 15. And albeit Salomon say, That open rebuke is better then secret loue, Prou. 27. 5. yet it makes nothing against this rule: for he vnderstandeth not that reproofe which is vttered before witnesses, but that priuate reproofe which is giuen to his face, and not behind his backe, betwixt §30thē two alone. But open sins are to be reprooued openly. 1. Tim. 5. 20. Them that sinne, rebuke openly, that the rest also may feare. Which text of Scripture must rightly be conceiued: for it is not a generall commandement giuen to all, (as some haue thought, in alleadging it to prooue that they may lawfully §35reprooue open swearers, and offenders, and that openly:) but it is a special cōmandement giuen to the Pastors, or gouernours of the Church, that they should reprooue those elders, and so consequently all such as were conuicted of any crime, by witnesses, and that before all men, that is, before the whole ⟨p. 486⟩Church, and not before all men, in euery place, and assemblie, where they offend. For we haue no warrant in Scripture so to doe. Secondly, this open disgracefull rebuking of men will rather harden them in their sinnes, then any way reclaime them from sinne. Augustine saith well, Prae pudore incipiet defendere peccatum suum, & quem vis correctiorem, facis peiorem. §51Thirdly, they might as well say, a man is to be reprooued for euery sinne, and that openly before all men, as for open sinnes, because Paul saith not, Them that sinne openly, rebuke before all men, but them that sinne, rebuke openly. Fourthly, the wordes depend vpon the former verse, where it is said, Receiue not an
- 1De verb. Dom. see[…]. 16.De verb. Dom. se〈…〉. 16.