A discourse of conscience wherein is set down the nature, properties, and differences thereofA discourse of conscience wherein is set downe the nature, properties, and differences thereof
A discourse of conscience wherein is set down the nature, properties, and differences thereof: as also the way to get and keep good conscience.A discourse of conscience wherein is set downe the nature, properties, and differences thereof: as also the way to get and keepe good conscience.
William Perkins 1558–1602Cambridge: printed by John Legate, 1596Cambridge: printed by Iohn Legate, 1596
[8], 174, [2] p. · 41k words · STC 19696 · ESTC S110415
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Touching humane laws, the special point to be considered is, In what manner they 1bind. That this may in part be cleared, I will stand a while to examine and confute the opinion that the very pillars of the popish Church at this day maintain; namely, that Civill and Ecclesiastical Jurisdiction have a coactive power in the conscience, and that the […] made thereby do as truly and properly bind (as they speak) to mortal and venial sin, as Gods law it self. The arguments which they commonly use, are these.
Touching humane lawes, the speciall point to be considered is, In what manner they 1binde. That this may in part be cleared, I will stande a while to examine and confute the opinion that the very pillers of the popish Church at this day maintaine; namely, that Civill and Ecclesi•sticall Iuris••ction haue a coactive povver in the conscience, and that the 〈…〉 made thereby doe as truly and properly binde (as they speake) to mortall and venial sinne, as Gods law it selfe. The arguments which they commonly vse, are these.
Argum. 1. Deut. 17. That man that vvill […] presumptuously, and not obey the bau• horitie of the priest, or Judge, shall […] and th•• shalt take away evil from Israel. Here (say they) the precepts of the high priest are
Imperia, not admonitions or exhortations, and they bind in conscience; otherwise the transgressors thereof
⟨p. 39⟩
should not have bin punished so severely. Answ. The intent of this law (as a very child may perceive) is to establish the authority and right of the highest appeals for all matters of controversy in the Synedrium o• great court at Jerusalem. Therefore the words alleged do not give unto the priest a sovereign power of making laws, but a power of giving judgement of controversies, and that according to laws already made by God himself: from which judgement there might be no appeal. Now this power of determining doth not constrain conscience, but the outward man to maintain order and peace. For what reason is there that that sentence which might be either a gainsaying of Gods law, or a mistaking of it, should bind the conscience to a sin. Again, not every one that refused to subject themselves to the sentence of this court, were straightway guilty of sin (for this did Jeremiah the Prophet,
and Christ our Saviour, when they were condemned for wicked persons) but he that presumptuously despised the sentence, and by consequent the authority it self, which was the ordinance of God, was guilty. Lastly, the severity of the punishment, which is temporal death, doth not argue any power in the judge of binding conscience: this they might have
that they that bind any man to mortal sin, m•st be able to punish him with answer rabble punishment, which is eternal death.
Argum. 1. Deut. 17. That man that vvill 〈…〉 presumptuous•y, and not ob•y the bau• horitie of the priest, or I•dge, shall 〈…〉 and th•• shalt take away euill from Israel. Here (say they) the precepts of the high priest are *Imperia, not •dmonitions or exhortations, and they binde in conscience; otherwise the transgressours thereof ⟨p. 39⟩should not haue bin punished so seuerely. Answ. The intent of this law (as a very child may perceiu•) is to establish the authoriue and right of the highest appeales for all matters of controversie in the Synedrium o• great court at Ierusa lem. Therefore the words alleadged doe not giue vnto the priest a soveraigne power of making lawes, but a power of giuing iudgement of controuersies, and that according to lawes alreadie made by God himselfe: from which iudgement there might be no appeale. Nowe this power of determining doth not constraine conscience, but the outward man to maintaine order and peace. For what reason is there that that sentence which might be either a gainsaying of Gods law, or a mistaking of it, should binde the conscience to a sinne. Againe, not euery one that refused to subiect themselues to the sentence of this court, were straightway guiltie of sinne (for this did Ieremie the Prophet, 3and Christ our Sauiour, when they were condemned for wicked persons) but he that presumptuously despised the sentence, and by consequent the authoritie it selfe, which was the ordinence of God, was guiltie. Lastly, the seueritie of the punishment, which is temporall death, doth not argue any power in the iudge of binding conscience: this they might haue ⟨p. 40⟩learned of their owne D•ct••〈…〉, who holdeth 4that they that binde any man to mortall sinne, m•st be able to punish him with answe• rable punishment, which is eternall death.
Argum•Math. 16. What soever ye shall bind upon […] shall be […] in heaven. Here to bind, is to make laws inning conscience according to Matth. 23. 4. They bind […] bur••ns, and lay the•• […] mens […]. Answer. The […] power of binding and soo•, is not belonging to any creature; but is p•op•• to Christ, who hath the keys of heaven and hell, he openeth and no man sh• h• […] ••d no man openeth, R• 3. 7. As for the power of the Church it is nothing but […] ministry of service whereby men publish and pro• that Christ bindeth or Idoleth. Again, this binding stands not in the power of making laws, but in remitting and retaining of m•n's sins, as the words going before declare, v. 18. If thy brother sin against thee, &•. and Christ ••eweth h•▪ own meaning, when he ••ith, Whose sins ye remit they are remitted, and ••hose sins […] retain they are retained, Joh. 20. 23. […] before in the person of Peter promised them this honour, in this form of words, Math. 16. I will give unto thee the keys of the ⟨p. 41⟩king dome of •e […], what soever th•• shalt bind upon earth, sh•• be bo• in •e […]. This which I say, is approved by consent of ancient Divines, August. Psal. 101. ser. 2. Remission of s• (saith he) is loosing: therefore by the law of contraries, binding is to hold sin unpardoned. Hilar. upon Math. cap. 18. Whom they bind on earth, that is (saith he) leave untied of the knots of their s••nes. Lombard the popish master 1of sentences, The Lord, saith he, hath given to priests power of binding and loosing, that is, of making manifest that men are bound or loosed Again both Origen, bAugustine, and Theophilact attribute the power of binding to all 3Christians, and therefore they for their parts never dreamed that the power of binding should be an authority to make laws. Lastly, the place Matt. 23. 4. overturns the argument, for there the Scribes and Pharisees are condemned, because they laid upon mens shoulders the burdens of their traditions as means of God• worship and things binding conscience.
Argum•Math. 16. What soeuer ye shall bind vpon 〈…〉 shall be 〈…〉 in heauen. Here to binde, is to make lawes •ning conscience according to Matth. 23. 4. They binde 〈…〉 bur••ns, and lay the••〈…〉 mens 〈…〉. Ansvver. The 〈…〉 power of binding and soo•, is not belonging to any creature; but is p•op•• to Christ, who hath the keyes of heauen and hell, he openeth and no man sh• h•〈…〉••d no man openeth, R• 3. 7. As for the power of the Church it is nothing but 〈…〉 ministerie of seruice whereby men publish and pro• that Christ bindeth or Ido•eth. Againe, this binding stands not in the power of making lawes, but in remitting and retaining of m•n's sinnes, as the words going before declate, v. 18. If thy brother sinne against thee, &•. and Christ ••eweth h•▪ owne meaning, when he ••ith, Whose sinnes ye remit they are remitted, and ••hose sinnes 〈…〉 retaine they are retained, Ioh. 20. 23. 〈…〉 before in the person of Peter promised them this honour, in this forme of words,
Arg. 3. Act. 15. It seems good unto us & the Holy Ghost, to lay no more burden on you the• these necessary things, that ye abstain from things offered to idols, and blood, and that which is strangled, and fornication. Here, say they, the Apostles by the instinct of the holy ghost make ⟨p. 42⟩a new law not for this or that respect, but simply to bind consciences of the Gentiles that they might be exercised in obedience. And this is proved because the Apostles call this law a burden, and call the things prescribed necessary, and S. Luke terms them, the commandments of the Apostles: and Chrysostom calls the Epistle sent to the Church, Imperium, that is, a lordly charge. To this they add, the testimonies of Tertullian, Origen, Augustine. Answ. Though all be granted that the law is a burden imposed, a precept of the Apostles, a charge, again that things required therein are necessary: yet will it not follow by good consequent, that the law simply binds conscience: because it was given with a reservation of Christian liberty, so as out of the case of scandal, that is, if no offence were given to the weak Jews, it might freely be omitted. And that will appear by these reasons. First of all Peter saith, that it is a tempting of God, to impose upon the Gentiles the yoke of Jewish ceremonies: he therefore must needs be contrary to himself if he intend to bind mens consciences to abstinence from strangled, blood, and things offered to idols. A reply is made, that this abstinence is prescribed not by the ancient law of Moses, but by a new Ecclesiastical or Apostolical authority. I answer ⟨p. 43⟩again, that a Mosaical ceremony is still the same thing though it be stablished by a new authority. And whereas Christ by his death put an end to the ceremonial law, it is absurd to think that the Apostles by their authority revived some part of it again, and bound mens consciences thereto. Secondly the Church of god in all places suffered this commandment to cease, which the faithful servants of God would never have done, if they had bin persuaded that this law had bound conscience simply. It is answered, that this law ceased not because the giving of offence unto the Jews ceased, but because it ceased universally:
Arg. 3. Act. 15. It seemes good vnto vs & the Holy Ghost, to lay no more burden on you the• these necessary things, that yee abstaine from things offered to i•ols, and blood, and that which is strangled, and fo•nication. Here, say they, the Apostles by the instinct of the holy ghost make ⟨p. 42⟩a new lawe not for this or that respect, but simply to binde consciences of the Gentils that they might be exercised in obedience. And this is prooued because the Apostles call this lawe a burden, and call the things prescribed necessary, and S. Luke tearmes them, the commandements of the Apostles: and Chrysostome calls the Epistle sent to the Church, Imperium, that is, a lordly charge. To this they adde, the testimonies of Tertullian, Origen, Augustine. Answ. Though all be granted that the law is a burden imposed, a precept of the Apostles, a charge, againe that things required therein are necessary: yet will it not follow by good consequent, that the lawe simply bindes conscience: because it was giuen with a reseruation of Christian libertie, so as out of the case of scandall, that is, if no offence were giuen to the weake Iewes, it might freely be omitted. And that will appeare by these reasons. First of all Peter saith, that it is a tempting of God, to impose upon the Gentiles the yoke of Iewish ceremonies: hee therefore must needs be contrary to himselfe if he intend to binde mens consciences to abstinence from strangled, blood, and things offered to idols. A reply is made, that this abstinence is prescribed not by the ancient law of Moses, but by a new Ecclesiasticall or Apostolicall authority. I answer ⟨p. 43⟩againe, that a Mosaicall ceremony is still the same thing though it be stablished by a new authority. And wheras Christ by his death put an end to the ceremoniall lawe, it is absurde to thinke that the Apostles by their authority revived some part of it againe, and bound mens consciences therto. Secondly the Church of god in all places suffered this cōmandement to cease, which the faithful seruants of God would neuer haue done, if they had bin perswaded that this law had bound conscience simply. It is answered, that this law ceased not because the giuing of offence unto the Iewes ceased, but because it ceased vniuersally:
yea but it could not have ceased universally, if it had bound conscience simply, specially considering it was propounded to the Church without any mention or limitation of time. Thirdly Paul was present in this counsel and knew the intent of this law very well, & therefore no doubt he did not in any of his Epistles gainsay the same. This being granted, it can not be, that this law should bind conscience out of the case of offence. For he teacheth the Corinthians that things offered to idols 1may be eaten so be it the weake• brother be not offended. Here it is answered that when Paul writ his first Epistle to the Corinthians, this commandment of the Apostles touching things ⟨p. 44⟩strangled & blood was not come unto them. Well, to grant all this which can not be proved, let it be answered, why Paul did not now deliver it, & why he delivereth doctrine contrary to that which he had […] […] Jerusalem, which was that the Gentiles should absolutely abstain from things o•d to Idols. As for the testimonies of the fathers they • bused. Indeed T•li•• […] plainly, that christians 2in his days abstained […] of blood, and he persuades men to […] […] so doing, because he is of opinion (being indeed far deceived) that this very law of the Apostles must l•st to the end of the world which conceit if the Papists hold not, what mean they to build upon him. Origen saith, that this law was very 3necessary in his days: and no […]. For by Idolithy••s he understands not things that have been offered to idols, & are afterward brought 4to private houses or to the market as other common meats, but he understands things that remain 5consecrated to idols, & are no where else used but in their temples, which we grant with him must for ever be avoided a• means and instruments of Idolatry whereas the law of the Apostles speaks only of the first kind. As for things strangled and blood, he takes them to be the devils food: and for this cause he approves ⟨p. 45⟩abstinence from them. And whereas Augustine 6saith, that it is a good thing to abstain from things offered to idols, though he be in necessity, […] must be understood of the first kind of Idolithy••• which •re yet remaining in the idol temples still consecrated unto them, and not of the second, of which the Apostles law (as I have said) must be understood.
yea but it could not haue ceased universally, if it had bound conscience simply, specially considering it was propounded to the Church without any mention or limitation of time. Thirdly Paul was present in this counsell and knewe the intent of this lawe very well, & therefore no doubt he did not in any of his Epistles gainsay the same. This being graunted, it can not be, that this law should bind conscience out of the case of offence. For he teacheth the Corinthians that things offered to idols 1may be eaten so be it the weake• brother be not offended. Here it is answered that when Paul writ his first Epistle to the Corinthians, this cō mandement of the Apostles touching things ⟨p. 44⟩strangled & bloode was not come unto them. Well, to grant all this which can not be prooued, let it be answered, why Paul did not now deliuer it, & why he deliuereth• doctrine contrary to that which he had 〈…〉〈…〉 Hierusalem, which was that the Gentiles should absolutely abstaine from things o•d to Idols. As for the testimonies of the fathers they • bused. Indeed T•li••〈…〉 plainly, that christians 2in his daies abstained 〈…〉 of blood, and he persvvades men to 〈…〉〈…〉 so doing, because he is of opinion (being indeed farre deceiued) that this very law of the Apostles must l•st to the end of the worlde •which conceit if the Papists hold not, what meane they to build vpon him. Origen saith, that this law was very 3necessary in his daies: and no 〈…〉. For by Idolithy••s he understands not things that haue bene offered to idols, & are afterward brought 4
Arg. 4. Joh. 21. Christ saith to Peter, [[Greek or Hebrew]] […] my […]: that is, (as the word importeth) […] and rule my sheep. Answ. This feeding and ruling stands not in making new laws, but in teaching and governing the Church of God according to the doctrine which they had received from Christ. And this action of feeding is ascribed to all Christians Revelat. 3. 27. who can not thereupon challenge a power of making laws to the conscience.
Arg. 4. Ioh. 21. Christ saith to Peter, [〈non-Latin alphabet〉] 〈…〉 my 〈…〉: that is, (as the word importeth) 〈…〉 and rule my sheepe. Answ. This feeding and ruling stands not in making new lawes, but in teaching and gouerning the Church of God according to the doctrine which they had receiued from Christ. And this action of feeding is ascribed to all Christians Revelat. 3. 27. who can not therupon chalenge a power of making lawes to the conscience.
Argum. 5. Joh. 20. As my father sent me, so I send you: but Christ was sent of his father not only with power of preaching and ministering the sacraments, but also with authority of commanding and giving judgement. Answ. Is this kind of reasoning may stand, all the Apostles shall be made redeemers; for they were all sent as Christ was: and he was sent not only to preach the redemption of mankind, but also to effect and work the same. It this be absurd, ⟨p. 46⟩then it is a flat abusing of scripture to gather from this saying of Christ, that the Apostles had power of binding conscience because he had so. It is true indeed that there is a similitude or analogy between the calling of Christ and his Apostles; but it wholly stands in these points. Christ was ordained to his office before all worlds, & so were the Apostles: Christ was called of his father immediately, and so were they of Christ: Christ was sent to the whole world, & so were they: Christ received all power in heaven and earth as being necessary for a mediator; and they received an extraordinary authority from him with such a plentiful measure of the spirit as was necessary for the Apostolical function. Lastly Christ was sent even as he was man to be a teacher of the Jews: & therefore be is called the minister of circumcision, Rom. 15. 8. & so the Apostles are sent by him to teach the Gentiles. Thus far is the comparison to be enlarged, & no further. And that no man might imagine that some part of this resemblance stands in a power of binding conscience, Christ hath put a special exception when he saith, Go teach all nations, teaching them to observe all things that I have commanded you.
Argum. 5. Ioh. 20. As my father sent me, so I send you: but Christ was sent of his father not only with power of preaching and ministring the sacraments, but also with authority of commanding and giuing iudgement. Answ. Is this kind of reasoning may stand, all the Apostles shall be made redeemers; for they were all sent as Christ was: and hee was sent not onely to preach the redemption of mankind, but also to effect and worke the same. It this be absurde, ⟨p. 46⟩then it is a flat abusing of scripture to gather frō this saying of Christ, that the Apostles had power of binding conscience because he had so. It is true indeed that there is a similitude or analogie betwene the calling of Christ and his Apostles; but it wholly stands in these points. Christ was ordained to his office before all worldes, & so were the Apostles: Christ was called of his father immediatly, and so were they of Christ: Christ was sent to the whol worlde, & so were they: Christ receiued all power in heaven and earth as beeing necessary for a mediatour; and they receiued an extraordinary authority from him with such a plentifull measure of the spirit as was necessary for the Apostolicall function. Lastly Christ was sent euen as he was man to be a teacher of the Iewes: & therfore be is called the minister of circumcision, Rom. 15. 8. & so the Apostles are sent by him to teach the Gentiles. Thus far is the comparison to be enlarged, & no further. And that no man might imagine that some parte of this resemblance stands in a power of binding conscience, Christ hath put a speciall exception when he saith, Goe teach all nations, teaching them to obserue al things that I have commanded you.
Arg. 6. Rom. 13. Whosoever resisteth the power resisteth the ordinance of God: and, they that resist ⟨p. 47⟩••all receive to them selves judgement: and, ye must be subject not only for wrath, but also for conscience s••e. Answ. Magistracy indeed is an ordinance of God to which we owe subjection, but how far subjection is due there is the question. For body & goods & outward conversation I grant all: but a subjection of conscience to mans laws, I deny. And between these two there is a great difference to be subject to authority in conscience, & to be subject to it for conscience, as will be manifest if we do but consider the phrase of the Apostle, the meaning whereof is, that we must perform obedience not only for anger, that is, for the avoiding of punishment, but also for the avoiding of sin, & so by consequent for avoiding a breach in conscience. Now this breach is not properly made because mans law is neglected, but because Gods law is broken which ordaineth magistracy, & withal binds mens consciences to obey their lawful commandments. And the damnation that is due unto men for resisting the ordinance of God comes not by the single breach of magistrates commandment, but by a transgression of the law of God which appointeth magistrates & their authority. To this answer papists reply nothing that is of moment. Therefore I proceed.
Arg. 6. Rom. 13. Whosoever resisteth the power resisteth the ordinance of God: and, they that resist ⟨p. 47⟩••all receive to them selues iudgement: and, ye must be subiect not onely for wrath, but also for conscience s••e. Answ. Magistracie indeed is an ordinance of God to which we owe subiectiō, but how farre subiection is due there is the questiō. For body & goods & outward cōversation I grant all: but a subiection of cōscience to mans lawes, I deny. And betweene these two there is a great difference to be subiect to authority in conscience, & to be subiect to it for conscience, as wil be manifest if we do but consider the phrase of the Apostle, the meaning whereof is, that we must performe obedience not onely for anger, that is, for the auoiding of punishment, but also for the auoiding of sinne, & so by cōsequent for auoiding a breach in cōsciēce. Now this breach is not properly made because mans law is neglected, but because Gods law is broken which ordaineth magistracie, & withall binds mens consciences to obey their lawfull commandements. And the dānation that is due unto men for resisting the ordinance of God comes not by the single breach of magistrates commandemet, but by a transgression of the law of God which appointeth magistrates & their authority. To this answer papists reply nothing that is of moment. Therfore I proceed.
Arg. 7. 1. Cor. 4. What will you that I come unto ⟨p. 48⟩you with a rod, or in the spirit of meekness? Now this rod is a judicial power of punishing sinners. Answ. For the regiment & protection of Gods Church. There be 2. rods m•oned in scripture: the rod of Christ, & the Apostolical rod. The rod of Christ is termed a rod of iron or the rod of his mouth, & it signifies that absolute & sovereign power which Christ hath over his creatures whereby he is able to convert & save them, or to forsake and destroy them. And it is a peculiar privilege of this rod to smite and wound the conscience. The Apostolical rod was a certain extraordinary power whereby God enabled them to plague and punish rebellious offenders with grievous judgements not in their souls but in their bodies alone. With this rod Paul smote Elimas blind, & Peter smote Ananias and Sapphira with bodily death. And it may be that Paul by this power did give up the incestuous man when he was excommunicate, to be vexed in his body and tormented by the devil: but that by this rod the Apostles could smite conscience, it can not be proved.
Arg. 7. 1. Cor. 4. What will you that I come unto ⟨p. 48⟩you with a rod, or in the spirit of meeknes? Now this rod is a iudicial power of punishing sinners. Answ. For the regiment & protection of Gods Church. There be 2. rods m•oned in scripture: the rod of Christ, & the Apostolicall rodd. The rod of Christ is termed a rod of iron or the rod of his mouth, & it signifies that absolute & soueraigne power which Christ hath ouer his creatures wherby he is able to cōuert & saue them, or to forsake and destroy them. And it is a peculiar priuiledge of this rodde to smite and wound the conscience. The Apostolicall rodde was a certaine extraordinary power whereby God inabled them to plague and punish rebellious offenders with grieuous iudgements not in their soules but in their bodies alone. With this rod Paul smote Elimas blind, & Peter smote Ananias and Saphira with bodily death. And it may be that Paul by this power did giue up the incestuous man when he was excommunicate, to be vexed in his body and tormented by the deuill: but that by this rodde the Apostles could smite conscience, it can not be prooued.
Arg. 8. 1. Tim. 3. Paul made a law that none having two wives should be ordained a Bishop: now this law is positive and Ecclesiastical and binds conscience. Answ. Paul is not the maker of this law, but God himself, who ordained ⟨p. 49⟩that in marriage not three but two alone should be one flesh: and that they which serve at the altar of the Lord, should be holy. And to grant that this law were a new law beside the written word of God, yet doeth it not follow that Paul was the maker of it: because he used not to deliver any doctrine to the Churches but that which he received of the Lord.
Arg. 8. 1. Tim. 3. Paul made a law that none hauing two wiues should be ordained a Bishop: now this law is positiue and Ecclesiasticall and bindes conscience. Answ. Paul is not the maker of this law, but God himselfe, who ordained ⟨p. 49⟩that in mariage not three but two alone should be one flesh: and that they which serue at the altar of the Lord, should be holy. And to graunt that this law were a new law beside the written word of God, yet doeth it not follow that Paul was the maker of it: because he used not to deliuer any doctrine to the Churches but that which he receiued of the Lord.
Argum. 9. Luc. 10. He which heareth you, heareth me. Answ. These words properly concern the Apostles, and do not in like manner belong to pastors & teachers of the Church. And the end of these words is not to confirm any Apostolical authority in making laws to the conscience; but to signify the privilege which he had vouchsafed them above all others, that he would so far forth assist them with his spirit, that they should not err or be deceived in teaching & publishing the doctrine of salvation, though otherwise they were sinful men: according to Matth. 10. It is not you that speak, but the spirit of my father which speaketh in you. And the promise to be led into all truth was directed unto them.
Argum. 9. Luc. 10. He which heareth you, heareth me. Answ. These wordes properly concerne the Apostles, and doe not in like maner belong to pastors & teachers of the Church. And the end of these wordes is not to confirme any Apostolicall authority in making lawes to the conscience; but to signifie the priviledge which hee had vouchsafed them aboue all others, that he would so farre forth assist them with his spirite, that they should not erre or be deceiued in teaching & publishing the doctrine of saluation, though otherwise they were sinfull men: according to Matth. 10. It is not you that speake, but the spirite of my father which speaketh in you. And the promise to be led into all truth was directed vnto them.
Arg. 10. 1. Cor. 11. I praise you that ye keep my commandments. Answ. Paul delivered nothing of his own concerning the substance of the doctrine of salvation & the worship of God, ⟨p. 50⟩but that which he received from Christ; the precepts here meant are nothing else but rules of decency & comely order in the congregation: and though they were to be obeyed, yet Pauls meaning was not to bind any mans conscience therewith. For of greater matters he saith, This I speak for your commodity, and not to entangle you in a snare, 1. Cor. 7. 35.
Arg. 10. 1. Cor. 11. I praise you that yee keepe my commandements. Answ. Paul deliuered nothing of his owne concerning the substance of the doctrine of saluation & the worship of God, ⟨p. 50⟩but that which he receiued from Christ; the precepts here ment are nothing else but rules of decencie & comely order in the congregation: and though they were to be obeyed, yet Pauls meaning was not to binde any mans conscience therewith. For of greater matters he saith, This I speake for your commoditie, and not to intangle you in a snare, 1. Cor. 7. 35.
Arg. 11. Councils of ancient fathers when they command or forbid any thing, do it with threatening of a curse to the offenders. Ans. The church in former time used to annex unto her Canons the curse anathema, because things decreed by them were indeed, or at the least thought to be the will and word of God: and they had respect to the saying of Paul, If any teach otherwise though he be an angel from heaven, let him be accursed. Therefore councils in this action were no more but instruments of God to accurse those, whom he first of all had accursed.
Arg. 11. Councels of ancient fathers when they commād or forbid any thing, do it with threatning of a curse to the offenders. Ans. The church in former time used to annexe vnto hir Canons the curse anathema, because things decreed by them were indeed, or at the least thought to be the will and word of God: and they had respect to the saying of Paul, If any teach otherwise though he be an angell from heauen, let him be accursed. Therfore councels in this action were no more but instruments of God to accurse those, whome he first of all had accursed.
Arg. 12. An act indifferent if it be commanded is made necessary: & the keeping of it is the practise of virtue, therefore every law binds conscience to a sin. Ans. An act in it self indifferent being commanded by mans law is not made simply necessary, for that is as much as gods law doth or can do, but only in some part, that is, so far forth as the said act or action tends to maintain ⟨p. 51⟩and preserve the good end for which the law is made. And though the action be in this regard necessary, yet doth it still remain indifferent as it is considered in it self out of the end of the law: so as if peace, the common good & comely order may be maintained & all offence avoided by any other means, the act may be done or not done without sin before God. For whereas God himself hath given liberty & freedom in the use of things indifferent, the law of man doeth not take away the same but only moderate and order it for the common good.
Arg. 12. An act indifferent if it be commanded is made necessary: & the keeping of it is the practise of vertue, therefore euery law bindes conscience to a sinne. Ans. An act in it selfe indifferent being commāded by mans law is not made simply necessary, for that is as much as gods law doth or can doe, but only in some part, that is, so far forth as the said act or action tends to maintaine ⟨p. 51⟩and preserue the good end for which the law is made. And though the action be in this regard necessary, yet doth it still remaine indifferent as it is considered in it selfe out of the ende of the law: so as if peace, the common good & comely order may be maintained & all offence auoided by any other meanes, the act may be done or not done without sinne before God. For whereas God himselfe hath giuen liberty & freedome in the use of things indifferent, the law of man doeth not take away the same but onely moderate and order it for the common good.
Arg. 13. The fast of Lent stands by a law and commandment of men: and this law binds conscience simply: for the ancient fathers have called it a Tradition Apostolical, and make the keeping of it to be necessary, and the not keeping of it a sin, and punish the offenders with excommunication. Answer. It is plain to him that will not be obstinate, that Lent fast was not commanded in the Primitive Church, but was freely kept at mens pleasures, & in several Churches diversly both in regard of space of time, as also in respect of diversity of meats. Ireneus in his epistle to Victor •ed by Eusebius 1saith, Some have thought that they must fast o• day, some two days, some more, some 40. hours ⟨p. 52⟩day and night, which diversity of fasting commendeth the unity of faith. Spiridion a good 2man did eat flesh in Lent, and caused his guest to do the same, and this he did upon judgement because he was persuaded out of Gods word, that to the clean all things were clean. And Eusebius records that Montanus the heretic was 3the first that prescribed solemn and set laws of fasting. And whereas this fast is called an Apostolical tradition it is no great matter, for it was the manner of the ancient Church in former times to term rites and orders Ecclesiastical not set down in scriptures Apostolical orders, that by this means they might commend 4them to the people: as Jerome testifieth, Every province (saith he) may think the constitutions of the ancestors to be Apostolical laws. And whereas it is said to be a sin not to fast in Lent (as Augustine speaketh) it is not by reason 5of any commandment binding conscience, for Augustine saith plainly, that neither Christ nor 6his Apostles appointed any set time of fasting: & Chrysostom, that Christ never commanded 7us to follow his fast: but the true reason hereof is borrowed from the end. For the Primitive Church used not the popish fast, which is to eat white meat alone, but an abstinence from all meats used specially to mortify the flesh and ⟨p. 53⟩to prepare men before-hand to a worthy receiving of the Eucharist. And in regard of this good end was the offence. And whereas it is said, that ancient fathers taught a necessity of keeping this fast, even Hierome whom they allege to this purpose saith the contrary.
Arg. 13. The fast of Lent stands by a lawe and commandement of men: and this lawe bindes conscience simply: for the ancient fathers haue called it a Tradition Apostolicall, and make the keeping of it to be necassary, and the not keeping of it a sinne, and punish the offenders with excommunication. Answer. It is plaine to him that will not be obstinate, that Lent fast was not commaunded in the Primitiue Church, but was freely kept at mens pleasures, & in seuerall Churches diuersly both in regard of space of time, as also in respect of diversity of meats. Ireneus in his epistle to Victor •ed by Eusebius 1saith, Some have thought that they must fast o• day, some two daies, some more, some 40. houres ⟨p. 52⟩day and night, which diversitie of fasting commendeth the vnitie of faith. Spiridion a good 2man did eate flesh in Lent, and caused his guest to doe the same, and this he did upon iudgemēt because he was perswaded out of Gods worde, that to the clean all things were cleane. And Eusebius recordes that Montanus the hereuke was 3the first that prescribed solemne and set lawes of fasting. And whereas this fast is called an Apostolicall tradition it is no great matter, for it was the manner of the ancient Church in former times to tearme rites and orders Ecclesiasticall not set downe in scriptures Apostolicall orders, that by this meanes they might commend 4them to the people: as Ierome testifieth, Every province (saith he) may thinke the constitutions of the ancestours to be Apostolicall lawes. And whereas it is said to be a sinne not to fast in Lent (as Augustine speaketh) it is not by reason 5of any commandement binding conscience, for Augustine saith plainly, that neither Christ nor 6his Apostles appointed any set time of fasting: & Chrysostome, that Christ neuer commanded 7vs to follow his fast: but the true reason hereof is borrowed from the ende. For the Primitiue Church vsed not the popish fast, which is to eat whitmeate alone, but an abstinence from all meates vsed specially to morufie the flesh and
For confuting the error of Montanus who had his set times of fast to be kept of necessity, he 1saith, We fast in Lent according to the Apostles tradition as in a time meet for us: and we do it not as though it were not lawful for us to fast in the rest of the year except Pentecost: but it is one thing to do a thing of necessity, and another thing to offer a gift of free-vvill. Lastly, excommunication was for the open contempt of this order taken up in the Church, which was, that men should fast before Faster for their further humiliation & preparation to the sacrament. So the 29. canon of the council of […] must be 2understood. As for the Canons of the Apostles (so falsely called) and the 8. council of Toledo, I much respect not what they say in this case.
For confuting the errour of Montanus who had his set times of fast to be kept of necessity, hee 1saith, We fast in Lent according to the Apostles tradition as in a time meete for vs: and wee doe it not as though it were not lawfull for vs to fast in the rest of the yeere except Penticost: but it is one thing to doe a thing of necessitie, and anothing to offer a gift of free-vvill. Lastly, excommunication was for the open contempt of this order taken vp in the Church, which was, that men should fast before Faster for their further humiliation & preparation to the sacrament. So the 29. canō of the councill of 〈…〉 must be 2understood. As for the Canons of the Apostles (so falsely called) and the 8. councill of Toledo, I much respect not what they say in this case.
1[…] ed Marcel. de error. […].〈…〉 ed Marcel. de error. 〈…〉.
king dome of •e 〈…〉, what soeuer th•• shalt binde vpon earth, sh•• be bo• in •e 〈…〉. This which I say, is approoued by consent of auncient Divines, August. Psal. 101. ser. 2. Remission of s• (saith he) is loosing: therefore by the law of contraries, binding is to hold sinne vnpardoned. Hilar. vpon Math. cap. 18. Whome they binde on earth, that is (saith he) leaue vntied of the knots of their s••nes. Lumberd the popish master
of sentences, The Lord, saith he, hath given to priests power of binding and loosing, that is, of making manifest that men are bound or loosed Againe both Origen,
Christians, and therefore they for their partes neuer dreamed that the power of binding should be an authority to make lawes. Lastly, the place Matt. 23. 4. overturnes the argument, for there the Scribes and Phanses are condemned, because they laid upon mens shoulders the burdens of their traditions as meanes of God• worship and things binding conscience.
to priuat houses or to the market as other common meates, but he understands things that remaine
consecrated to idols, & are no where els used but in their temples, which we grant with him must for euer be avoided a• meanes and instruments of Idolatry wheras the law of the Apostlesspeaks only of the first kind. As for things strangled and blood, hee takes them to be the deuils foode: and for this cause hee approoues
saith, that it is a good thing to abstain frō things offered to idols, though he be in necessity, 〈…〉 must be understoode of the first kind of Idolithy••• which •re yet remaining in the idoltemples still consecrated unto them, and not of the second, of which the Apostles law (as I haue said) must be understood.
⟨p. 53⟩
to prepare men before-hand to a worthy receiuing of the Eucharist. And in regarde of this good ende was the offence. And whereas it is said, that auncient fathers taught a necessitie of keeping this fast, euen Hierome whome they alledge to this purpose saith the contrary.