Question is made what the words are which are to be supplied in this article, the holy Catholic Church, whether, I believe, or, I believe in: and ancient expositors have sufficiently determined the matter. One csayeth, In these words in which is set forth our faith of the godhead, it is said, In God the father, in the son, and in the holy ghost: but in the rest where the speech is not of the godhead but of creatures and mysteries, the preposition In is not added that it should be, in the holy Church, but, that we should believe there is an ⟨p. 421⟩an holy Church not as God, but as a company gathered to God. And men should believe that there is remission of sins, not, in the remission of sins: and they should believe the resurrection of the body, not, in the resurrection of the body: therefore by this preposition the Creator is distinguished from the creatures, and things pertaining to God from things pertaining to men. Another upon these words,2 This is the work of God that ye believe in him, saith, If ye believe in him, ye believe him; not if ye believe him, ye believe in him, for the devils believed God, but did not believe in him. Again of the Apostles, we may say, we believe Paul, but we do not believe in Paul: we believe Peter, but we believe not in Peter. For his faith that believeth in him which justifieth the ungodly, is imputed to him for righteousness. What is it therefore to believe in him? by believing to love and like, and as it were to pass into him, and to be incorporated into his members. Now the reasons which some Papists bring to the contrary to prove that we may believe in the creatures, and in the Church, are of no moment. First they allege the phrase of scripture, Exod. 14.31. They believed in God, and in Moses. 1. Sam. 27.12. And Achis believed in David. 2. Chron. 20.20. Believe in the Prophets and prosper. Answer. The Hebrew phrase in which the servile letter Beth is used, must not be translated with a preposition that ruleth an accuseth or ablative case, but with a dative case on this manner, Believe Moses, David, the Prophets: and it doeth not import any affiance in the creature, but only a giving of credence by one man to another. Secondly they allege, that ancient fathers read the article on this manner, I believe in the holy Catholic Church. Answer. 3Indeed some have done so:
Question is made what the wordes are which are to be supplied in this article, the holy Catholike Church, whether, I beleeve, or, I beleeve in: and ancient expositours haue sufficiently determined the matter. One csaieth, In these vvordes in which is set forth our faith of the godhead, it is said, In God the father, in the sonne, and in the holy ghost: but in the rest where the speech is not of the godhead but of creatures and mysteries, the preposition In is not added that it should be, in the holy Church, but, that we should beleeve there is an ⟨p. 421⟩an holy Church not as God, but as a companie gathered to God. And men should beleeve that there is remission of sinnes, not, in the remission of sinnes: and they shoulde beleeve the resurrection of the body, not, in the resurrection of the body: therefore by this preposition the Creatour is distinguished from the creatures, and thinges pertaining to God from things pertaining to men. Another upon these wordes,2 This is the worke of God that yee beleeue in him, saith, If yee beleeve in him, ye beleeve him; not if yee beleeve him, yee beleeve in him, for the devils beleeved God, but did not beleeue in him. Againe of the Apostles, we may say, we beleeve Paul, but vvee doe not beleeve in Paul: wee beleeve Peter, but wee beleeve not in Peter. For his faith that beleeveth in him which iustifieth the ungodly, is imputed to him for righteousnesse. What is it therefore to beleeve in him? by beleeving to love and like, and as it vvere to passe into him, and to be incorporated into his members. Novv the reasons which some Papistes bring to the contrarie to prooue that wee may beleeue in the creatures, and in the Church, are of no moment. First they alledge the phrase of scripture, Exod. 14.31. They beleeved in God, and in Moses. 1. Sam. 27.12. And Achis beleeved in David. 2. Chron. 20.20. Beleeve in the Prophets and prosper. Answer. The Hebrewe phrase in which the servile letter Beth is used, must not be translated with a preposition that ruleth an accuseth or ablatiue case, but with a datiue case on this manner, Beleeve Moses, David, the Prophets: and it doeth not import any affiance in the creature, but onely a giuing of credence by one man to another. Secondly they alleadge, that ancient fathers reade the article on this manner, I beleeve in the holy Catholike Church. Ansvver.
- cRuffin. in symb.
- 2Aug. tract. 29. in Joh.Aug. tract. 29. in Ioh.
- 3Epiphan. in Anchor.