But again they say, that they dispute not of particular Churches, which they grant may fall away, but of that Catholic or universal Church,1 which is the pillar & foundation of truth. But how I pray you do they define this catholic Church. First by a certain place, as §1those that will have catholic and Roman to be all one: Secondly, by the multitude, §22as they which upbraid us with fewness. Let us see, therefore what manner of arguments these be. They be (if they be kept within the just rules of reasoning) unless I be deceived, these and such like. The church of Rome teacheth so: very many, in respect of a very few so believe, and so it was from hand delivered unto us. Therefore this is the catholic truth. But who is so far void of all reason, that he seeth not here again, Petitio principij, and the thing in controversy to be taken as granted? ⟨image 11⟩Show us therefore, ye Sophisters, or at least wise teach us probably, first how a part should be the whole (that we may grant unto you your Romish church, to be a principal member of the catholic church). And then from whence, I pray you, have ye learned, this Romish Church, to be ordained for a perpetual rule of truth? and from whence have ye drawn that to be true, which is approved of the greatest number? Verily ye shall never prove this, out of the books of the old or new Testament. For those corrupt arguments: Upon this rock I have builded my Church: 3I bave prayed for thee Peter that thy faith fail not: and that saying of Christ thrice repeated, feed my sheep, 4with men not altogether ignorant of these things, need not any further confutation. But haply, ye will prove it out of the writings of ancient fathers. As though for sooth it were the same thing, to commend the faith and religion of the church of Rome (as long as it was worthy praise) and to establish her for the catholic church, or a perpetual rule to the catholic ⟨image 11⟩church. And seeing that by the name of the church of Rome (if these flatterers will speak that they think) they do understand no other thing, than the bishop of Rome him self, what madness is this, I beseech you, to have the deciding of so great a controversy, to depend upon that seat, in which their own writers being witness, not so much the monsters of men, as Satan himself, doth seem to have sit so many ages together.
But againe they say, that they dispute not of particular Churches, which they graunt may fall away, but of that Catholique or vniuersall Church,1 which is the piller & foundation of truth. But how I pray you do they define this catholike Churche. Firste by a certayne place, as §1those that will haue catholicke and Roman to be al one: Secondly, by the multitude, §22as they which vpbraide vs with fewnes. Let vs see, therfore what manner of arguments these be. They be (if they be kept within the iust rules of reasoning) vnlesse I be deceaued, these and such like. The church of Rome teacheth so: very many, in respect of a very few so beleeue, and so it was from hand deliuered vnto vs. Therefore this is the catholique truth. But who is so far void of all reason, that he seeth not here againe, Petitio principij, and the thing in controuersie to be taken as graunted? ⟨image 11⟩Shew vs therefore, ye Sophisters, or at least wise teach vs probablie, firste how a part should be ye whol (yt we may graunt vnto you your Romish church, to be a principall member of the catholicke church). And then from whence, I pray you, haue ye learned, this Romish Church, to be ordayned for a perpetuall rule of truth? and from whence haue ye drawen that to be true, which is approued of the greatest number? Verely ye shall neuer proue this, out of the bookes of the old or new Testament. For those corrupt argumentes: Vpon this rocke I haue builded my Church: 3I baue prayed for thee Peter that thy fayth faile not: and that saying of Christe thrise repeated, feed my sheepe, 4with men not altogether ignorant of these thinges, need not any further confutation. But happely, ye will prooue it out of the writinges of auncient fathers. As though for sooth it were the same thing, to commende the faith and religion of the church of Rome (as long as it was worthy praise) and to establish hir for the catholicke church, or a perpetuall rule to the catholicke ⟨image 11⟩church. And seeing that by the name of the church of Rome (if these flatterers will speake that they thinke) they doe vnderstand no other thing, than the byshop of Rome him selfe, what madnesse is this, I beseech you, to haue the deciding of so great a controuersie, to depēd vpon yt seat, in which their own writers being witnes, not so much the monsters of men, as Sathan himselfe, doth seeme to haue sit so many ages together.
- 11. Tim. 3.15.
- 2Catholic and Roman are not all one.Catholique and Roman are not all one.
- 3Mat. 16.18. Luk. 22.23.
- 4Joh. 21.15.16Ioh. 21.15.16