1Origen was the Scholar of Clemens Alexandrinus; these do as evidently explain it, as any of our Divines, though not so distinctly, because the controversy was not then moved: and therefore you must not expect so full and so clear and distinct expressions, as you have in these times, when we have more occasion to do it. ⟨p. 67⟩I will not trouble you with Citation, lest I spend time too much: but you shall find it so in them. After their time, Augustine expresseth it so fully, as that Calvin, or Beza, hath not done it more clearly, as I showed by some Allegations out of him the last day. From his time I do not find, that this opinion of theirs had any footing in the Church, till the time of Damascens, that lived in the year, seven hundred thirty. He was the first that began in the Eastern Churches: this opinion of transubstantiation, Chrysostom hath sore hard speeches, but such as may well be interpreted; if you look on him in the tract of his writings, you shall see evidently, that he never dreamed of any such real presence as the Papists affirm. But I say,2 Damascene was the first that set this false opinion abroach in the Eastern Churches, in the Greek Churches about a hundred years after. In the Western Churches, in Italy, and those parts, it began a little to be set on foot, in the time of Carolus Calvus Emperor; who being troubled with that controversy set Bertram a work, a Presbyter, a learned man, one of the most learned of those times; and desired him to express his opinion in that point: He writ a learned book of it, and so the controversy continued in good state and condition, till two hundred years after, or less, between one, and two hundred. And the first man that began to infuse this poison into the Church, was one Lanfranc, Arch-Bishop ⟨p. 68⟩of Canterbury in England: a man learned, but very pernicious to the Church. After his time,3 the opinion began to be somewhat hot: and then Beringarius writ against it; who upon his condemnation retracted it, but before his death repented the retraction; and upon writing his retractation, it began to be put upon men by necessity, by the Pope: which was done in the time of Bernard, 4four hundred years since. I have done this, that those may be satisfied, that are not satisfied with the Scriptures, and with the reasons that were brought, but would know the opinion of the Fathers.
1Origen was the Scholer of Clemens Alexandrinus; these do as evidently explaine it, as any of our Divines, though not so distinctly, because the controversie was not then moved: and therfore you must not expect so full and so cleare and distinct expressions, as you have in these times, when wee have more occasion to doe it. ⟨p. 67⟩I will not trouble you with Citation, lest I spend time too much: but you shall finde it so in them. After their time, Augustine expresseth it so fully, as that Calvin, or Beza, hath not done it more clearely, as I shewed by some Allegations out of him the last day. From his time I doe not finde, that this opinion of theirs had any footing in the Church, till the time of Damascens, that lived in the yeare, seven hundred thirty. He was the first that began in the Easterne Churches: this opinion of transubstantiation, Chrysostome hath sore hard speeches, but such as may well be interpreted; if you looke on him in the tract of his writings, you shall see evidently, that hee never dreamed of any such reall presence as the Papists affirme. But I say,2 Damascene was the first that set this false opinion abroach in the Easterne Churches, in the Greeke Churches about a hundred years after. In the Western Churches, in Italy, and those parts, it began a little to bee set on foot, in the time of Carolus Calvus Emperour; who being troubled with that controversie set Bertram a work, a Presbyter, a learned man, one of the most learned of those times; and desired him to expresse his opinion in that point: Hee writ a learned booke of it, and so the controversie continued in good state and condition, till two hundred yeares after, or lesse, betweene one, and two hundred. And the first man that began to infuse this poyson into the Church, was one Lanfranke, Arch-Bishop ⟨p. 68⟩of Canterbury in England: a man learned, but very pernitious to the Church. After his time,3 the opinion began to bee somewhat hot: and then Beringarius writ against it; who upon his condemnation retracted it, but before his death repented the retraction; and upon writing his retractation, it beganne to bee put upon men by necessity, by the Pope: which was done in the time of Bernard, 4foure hundred yeares since. I have done this, that those may bee satisfied, that are not satisfied with the Scriptures, and with the reasons that were brought, but would know the opinion of the Fathers.
- 1Why the Fathers are not so distinct in the doctrine of Transubst.
- 2Damascene set transubstantiation a broach in Grecia, 730. years after Christ.Damascene set transubstantiation a broach in Grecia, 730. yeares after Christ.
- 3Lanfranc Bishop of Canterbury, 1030 years after Christ brought transubstantiation into England.Lan•ranke Bishop of Canturbury, 1030 yeares after Christ brought transubstantiation into England.
- 4B•ringerius lived four hundred years since.B•ringerius lived foure hundred yeares since.