I answer they must of necessity then admit the trope or figure Synecdoche, and that therefore the institution of Christ, or the words of the institution, can not be understood without a trope or figure.1 And what man that is in his right wits shall they persuade, that the word body can at one & the self same time be spoken of the bread & of the body without an other Synedoche also. And this you see what they have gained, who think it, and publish it in others to be a horrible heresy by a trope or figure to understand the words ⟨p. 104⟩of the supper, whereas they themselves are enforced and found out, to make a double trope or figure. Now let us come to the word Est, 2that is to say, Is. Seeing that whatsoever is, is not after one sort (for to be, hath place in all the predicaments) when these men from hence gather thus, or do after this sort expound these words. §1This bread is Christs body, therefore it is essentially Christs body, do they not I beseech you speak as if they should say: §2This is a living creature: therefore it is a man? And again, do they reason less fondly, when they gather thus: This bread is Christs body, therefore this bread is Christs body, not absent but present? Now, whereas they say, that the word body, because it is a substance, cannot be otherwise spoken or uttered, than substantially, I say they should have left this to the papists, who are therefore enforced to bring in their transubstantiation of the bread, because they say, that things sundered or separated one of them from another, could not be spoken one of another (& that therefore also this proposition was false, the bread is the body) except they granted either that the bread it self became nothing, ⟨p. 105⟩or by changing were turned into a substance of another sort, to wit,3 the substance of his body. Therefore these men alone do keep or urge, & that most fondly, the bare word or letter. But these men of whom I now speak, though in outward show and speech, they refuse all tropes and figures, in the exposition of these words of the institution, do yet notwithstanding over and besides the two tropes above mentioned, that is to say,4 the figure Synecdoche diversly used in deed bring in an other, and that same very strange and wonderful: when they will have this speech: this bread is my body, to signify and mean as much, as if Christ should have said:
I answer they must of necessitie then admit the trope or figure Synecdoche, and that therefore the institution of Christ, or the words of the institution, can not be vnderstood without a trope or figure.1 And what man that is in his right wits shall they persuade, that the word bodie can at one & the selfe same time be spoken of the bread & of the bodie without an other Synedoche also. And this you see what they haue gained, who thinke it, and publish it in others to be a horrible heresie by a trope or figure to vnderstand ye words ⟨p. 104⟩of the supper, wheras they themselues are inforced and found out, to make a double trope or figure. Now let vs come to the word Est, 2that is to say, Is. Seeing that whatsoeuer is, is not after one sort (for to be, hath place in all the predicaments) when these men from hense gather thus, or doo after this sort expound these words. §1This bread is Christs bodie, therfore it is essentiallie Christes bodie, doo they not I beseech you speake as if they should say: §2This is a liuing creature: therfore it is a man? And againe, doo they reason lesse fondlie, when they gather thus: This bread is Christs bodie, therfore this bread is Christs bodie, not absent but present? Now, whereas they say, that the word bodie, because it is a substance, cannot be otherwise spoken or vttered, than substantiallie, I say they should haue left this to the papists, who are therefore inforced to bring in their transubstantiation of the bread, because they say, that things sundered or separated one of them from another, could not be spoken one of another (& that therfore also this propositiō was false, the bread is the bodie) except they granted either that ye bread it selfe became nothing, ⟨p. 105⟩or by changing were tourned into a substance of another sort, to wit,3 the substance of his body. Therfore these men alone do keep or vrge, & that most fondlie, the bare worde or letter. But these men of whom I now speake, though in outward shewe and speech, they refuse all tropes and figures, in the exposition of these words of the institution, doo yet notwithstanding ouer and besides the two tropes aboue mentioned, that is to say,4
- 1He proveth the adversaries to fall into that which they dislike in others.He proueth the aduersaries to fall into that which they dislike in others.
- 2The word Est, is expounded.
- 3Ubiquitaries, in urging the ba•e letter, as absurd as Papists at the least.Vbiquitaries, in vrging the ba•e letter, as absurd as Papists at the least.
- 4The adversaries by power of trueth constrained to fall into three tropes in the exposition of a few words though otherwise the name be odious to them.The aduersaries by power of trueth constrained to fall into three tropes in the exposition of a fewe words though otherwise the name be odious to them.