A10322:59
A defence of the judgment of the Reformed churches. That a man may lawfully…A defence of the iudgment of the Reformed churches. That a man may lawfullie…
A defence of the judgment of the Reformed churches. That a man may lawfully not only put away his wife for her adultery, but also marry another. / Wherein both Robert Bellarmin the Jesuits Latin treatise, and an English pamphlet of a nameless author maintaining the contrary are co[n]futed by John Raynolds. A taste of Bellarmins dealing in controversies of religion: how he depraveth Scriptures, misalleagthe [sic] fathers, and abuseth reasons to the perverting of the truth of God, and poisoning of his Church with error..A defence of the iudgment of the Reformed churches. That a man may lawfullie not onelie put awaie his wife for her adulterie, but also marrie another. / Wherin both Robert Bellarmin the Iesuites Latin treatise, and an English pamphlet of a namelesse author mainteyning the contrarie are co[n]futed by Iohn Raynolds. A taste of Bellarmins dealing in controversies of religion: how he depraveth Scriptures, misalleagthe [sic] fathers, and abuseth reasons to the perverting of the truth of God, and poisoning of his Churche with errour..
Dordrecht: printed by George Walters, 1609
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Wherefore when Bellarmin draweth out of that sentence such a conclusion as if S. James in saying there is sin to him, had simply meant, he sinneth; Bellarmin mistaketh the meaning of the sentence; which if the text it self cannot inform him,g his doctors well considered may. But take the right meaning & the conclusion will be sound. Whosoever doth not good and honest things, except it he of ignorance, he sinneth desperately & mainly. Therefore whoso of ignorance omitteth to do them, he sinneth not desperately. And thus our conclusion drawn from Christs sentence is rather confirmed than prejudiced by this example. Yea let even. S. hAustin, whose authority Bellarmin doth ground on herein, be diligently marked: And himself in matching these sentences together bewrayeth an oversight, which being corrected will help the truth with light & strength. For to make the one of them like the other, he is fain to fashion Christs speech in this fort: To him who putteth away his wife without the cause of whoredom & marrieth another, ⟨p. 17⟩1to him there is the crime of committing adultery. Now Christ hath not2 these words of emphatical property, and strong signification, whereby he might teach, as S. Angustin gathereth, that whosoever putteth away his wife for any cause, save for whoredom, and marrieth another, committeth adultery in an high degree: and soe imply by consequence, that who soe marrieth another, though having put away his former wife for whoredom, yet committeth adultery too, a less adultery.
Wherefore when Bellarmin draweth out of that sentence such a conclusiō as if S. Iames in saying there is sinne to him, had simply meant, hee sinneth; Bellarmin mistaketh the meaning of the sentence; which if the text it self cannot informe him,g his doctors well considered may. But take the right meaning & the conclusion wilbe sound. Whosoever doth not good and honest things, except it he of ignoraunce, he sinneth desperatelie & mainely. Therefore whoso of ignorance omitteth to doe them, he sinneth not desperately. And thus our conclusion drawen frō Christs sentence is rather confirmed thē preiudiced by this example. Yea let even. S.