Rainoldes. S. Austin, and the Fathers, are beholding to you: whose words (though not answering well to your fancies) are handled so gently. If you were as favourable to Sadeel and Mornay: that, which they write of Peter, would have a true meaning. Though, if they (with greater zeal unto his doctrine then unto his person, that is, to Christ then to Peter) had given a little less to him then is due: the fault were not so much to be •aide on their restraint, as on your excess, who say a great deal more of him then you ought. For example, Father cRobert, the Prince of the Jesuits (in his Divinity lectures read publicly at Rome about seven years ago) handling this same point of the foundation of the Church, did ground him self on a sentence of the Prophet Isaiah to prove it to be Peter, and Peters see, the see of Rome. Whereof to make his proof strong by the words which God doth speak of Christ, dBehold, I lay in Zion ⟨p. 62⟩a tried precious corner stone, a sure foundation: he affirmed that Isaiah did therein prophesy not of Christ, but of Peter, a stumbling stone to heretics, & a rock of offence, but to Catholics a tried, a precious, a corner stone. S. ePeter the Apostle expoundeth those words not of himself, but of Christ. Father Robert the Jesuit saith that they agree not to Christ, but to him. So to advance the Popes dignity by Peter: he maketh Peter himself, nay, the holy Ghost a liar. Such blasphemous outrages of your chief professors giving more to Peter then standeth with the truth and honour of the Son of God, might provoke the godly spirits of his servants to bend to the contrary: as husbandmen, when they would straighten a young plant that groweth crooked one way, do bow it to the other. But in the discourse of Sadeel and Mornay ▪ that the Church is built upon the confession of Peter not his person, there is no straining of ought beyond the truth (for the meaning of it) by your own judgement. For they approve and follow the exposition of S. Austin: and *that (you affirm) hath a true meaning. As for the manner of S. Austins speech, I grant it seemeth somewhat tough to expound those words of Christ as if he said, Thou art Peter and upon me, not, Thou art Peter and upon thee will I build my Church. But, if the circumstances of his speech be weighed: you shall find, not only the meaning of it, true; but the manner, good.
Rainoldes. S. Austin, and the Fathers, are beholding to you: whose wordes (though not answering well to your fansies) are handled so gentlie. If you were as fauourable to Sadeel and Mornay: that, which they write of Peter, would haue a true meaning. Though, if they (with greater zeale vnto his doctrine then vnto his person, that is, to Christ then to Peter) had giuen a litle lesse to him then is due: the faulte were not so much to bée •aide on their restraint, as on your excesse, who say a great deale more of him then you ought. For example, Father cRobert, the Prince of the Iesuites (in his Diuinitie lectures read publikelie at Rome about seuen yeares agoe) handling this same point of the foundation of the Church, did ground him selfe on a sentence of the Prophet Esay to proue it to be Peter, and Peters see, the see of Rome. Whereof to make his proofe strong by the wordes which God doth speake of Christ, dBehold, I lay in Sion ⟨p. 62⟩a tried pretious corner stone, a sure foundation: he affirmed that Esay did therein prophecie not of Christ, but of Peter, a stumbling stone to heretikes, & a rock of offense, but to Catholikes a tried, a pretious, a corner stone. S. ePeter the Apostle expoundeth those wordes not of himselfe, but of Christ. Father Robert the Iesuit sayth that they agrée not to Christ, but to him. So to aduaunce the Popes dignitie by Peter: he maketh Peter himselfe, nay, the holy Ghost a lier. Such blasphemous outrages of your chéefe professors giuing more to Peter then stādeth with the truth and honor of the Sonne of God, might prouoke the godly spirites of his seruantes to bend to the contrarie: as husbandmen, when they would straighten a young plant that groweth crooked one way, do bow it to the other. But in the discourse of Sadeel and Mornay ▪ that the Church is built vpon the confession of Peter not his person, there is no straining of ought beyond the truth (for the meaning of it) by your owne iudgement. For they approue and folow the exposition of S. Austin: and *that (you affirme) hath a true meaning. As for the maner of S. Austins spéech, I graunt it séemeth somewhat tough to expound those wordes of Christ as if he sayd, Thou art Peter and vpon me, not, Thou art Peter and vpon thee will I build my Church. But, if the circumstances of his spéeche bée weighed: you shal find, not only the meaning of it, true; but the maner, good.
- cReverendi patris Roberti Bellarmini praelectiones Romae, an. Dom. 1577. In praefat. Controvers. de summo Pontisice.Reuerendi patris Roberti Bellarmini praelectiones Romae, ann. Dom. 1577. In praefat. Controuers. de summo Pontisice.
- dIsaiah. 28.•• ▪Esai. 28.•• ▪
- e1. Pet. 2. ver. 6. & 8.
- *Expositio Augustini habet •ententiam veram. Staplet. •. 6. c. 3.