The sum of the conference between John Rainoldes and John Hart touching the head…The summe of the conference betwene Iohn Rainoldes and Iohn Hart touching the head…
The sum of the conference between John Rainoldes and John Hart touching the head and the faith of the Church. Wherein by the way are handled sundry points, of the sufficiency and right expounding of the Scriptures, the ministry of the Church, the function of priesthood, the sacrifice of the mass, with other controversies of religion: but chiefly and purposely the point of Church-government ... Penned by John Rainoldes, according to the notes set down in writing by them both: perused by John Hart, and (after things supplied, & altered, as he thought good) allowed for the faithful report of that which past in conference between them. Whereunto is annexed a treatise entitled, Six conclusions touching the Holy Scripture and the Church, written by John Rainoldes. With a defence of such things as Thomas Stapleton and Gregory Martin have carped at therein.The summe of the conference betwene Iohn Rainoldes and Iohn Hart touching the head and the faith of the Church. Wherein by the way are handled sundrie points, of the sufficiencie and right expounding of the Scriptures, the ministerie of the Church, the function of priesthood, the sacrifice of the masse, with other controuerises of religion: but chiefly and purposely the point of Church-gouernment ... Penned by Iohn Rainoldes, according to the notes set downe in writing by them both: perused by Iohn Hart, and (after things supplied, & altered, as he thought good) allowed for the faithfull report of that which past in conference betwene them. Whereunto is annexed a treatise intitled, Six conclusions touching the Holie Scripture and the Church, writen by Iohn Rainoldes. With a defence of such thinges as Thomas Stapleton and Gregorie Martin haue carped at therein.
John Rainolds 1549–1607Londini: printed by John Wolfe, 1584Londini: printed by Iohn Wolfe, 1584
475, [1], 479-674, 659-750 p. · 304k words · STC 20626 · ESTC S115546
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Hart. The other were abolished justly, as unfit. But this is •ot so. For why should you mislike a prayer to the cross, of which S. mPaul saith, God forbid that I should rejoice but in the cross of our Lord Jesus Christ?
Hart. The other were a•olished iustly, as vnfit. But this is •ot so. For why should you mislike a prayer to the crosse, of which S. mPaule saith, God forbid that I should reioyce but in the crosse of our Lord Iesus Christ?
Rainoldes. That is, in Christ crucified, as S. Paul doth mean it: not in the 1wood, the 2gallows, the 3tree, 4to which you make your prayer. For God forbid that we should rejoice in any thing, saving nin the Lord: whose redeeming of us by suffering death upon the cross, because it was a stumbling block to the Jews; S. Paul saith
persecution for the cross: and against them who rejoiced in circumcision and the law, he saith that he rejoiceth not but in the cross of our Lord Jesus Christ. But, to the purpose of my question, if they of your Church, who reformed your Service-books, thought, that of the prayers which we do mislike they might abolish some and retain others: what if amongst the feasts which others do mislike, they, who reformed our ceremonies, retained the annunciation and purification of the virgin, though they abolished the conception, nativity, and assumption? Chiefly seeing that in those, which they retained, they regarded the honour of Christ conceived and presented, as your selves acknowledge: in those, which they abolished, they removed the superstitious worship of a creature, as the thing witnesseth. For both they were supposed to be feasts instituted to a Saints honour, as they were indeed: neither is there any thing of them in the scriptures, that men might be edified by that whereof the memory was celebrated in them: and they maintain corrupt opinions, touching the virgin, with derogation to Christs honour. For
you mean by the feasts of her nativity, and conception, that she was neither borne nor conceived in sin. Which if it were so▪ then neither she needed Christ to be
Rainoldes. That is, in Christ crucified, as S. Paule doth meane it: not in the 1wood, the 2galowes, the 3tree, 4to which you make your prayer. For God forbidde that wee should reioyce in any thing, sauing nin the Lord: whose redéeming of vs by suffering death vpon the crosse, because it was a stumbling blocke to the Iewes; S. Paule saith othe crosse was a stumbling blocke, by a *figuratiue spéech, meaning (as him selfe doth open it) pChrist crucified. And so he calleth Christes blood, qthe blood of the crosse; and the preaching of his gospell, rthe preaching of the crosse; and persecution rising of it, spersecution for the crosse: and against them who reioyced in circumcision and the law, he saith that he reioyceth not but in the crosse of our Lord Iesus Christ. But, to the purpose of my question, if they of your Church, who reformed your Seruice-bookes, thought, that of the prayers which we doo mislike they might abolish some and retaine others: what if amongst the feastes which others doo mislike, they, who reformed our ceremonies, retained the annuntiation and purification of the virgin, though they abolished the conception, natiuitie, and assumption? Chiefly séeing that in those, which they reteined, they regarded the honour of Christ conceiued and presented, as your selues acknowledge: in those, which they abolished, they remoued the superstitious worship of a creature, as the thing witnesseth. For both they were supposed to be feastes instituted to a Saintes honour, as they were indéede: neither is there any thing of them in the scriptures, that men might be edified by that wherof the memorie was celebrated in them: and they maintaine corrupt opinions, touching the virgin, with derogation to Christes honour. For tyou meane by the feastes of her natiuity, and conception, that she was neither borne nor conceiued in sinne. Which if it were so▪ then neither she néeded Christ to be uher Sauiour, who came to saue sinners: & the prerogatiue of Christ, yto be seuered from sinners, were common vnto her with him.x A thing so absurd and contrarie to the scriptures, (which shew that zall haue sinned, and aare the children of wrath by nature,) that not bthe Fathers onely, but your chiefe cSchoole-men, and dCanons also, doo gainesay it. Yea the ⟨p. 483⟩feast of her conception, when it was créeping in, was therefore ereproued:
1Regnavit a ligno De•s.Regnauit a ligno De•s.
2Suspensus est paribulo.
3Arbour decora & fulgid•, Or na•• aegis purpura. Electa digno •••pite […] sancta membra tangere:Arbor decora & fulgid•, Or na•••egis purpura. Electa digno •••pite 〈…〉 sancta membra tangere:
4Be•ta cuius brachiis Secli pependit pretium, Statêra sacta corporis, Praedam•ue tulit Tartari, O crux, •ue spes unica, & quae sequuntur.Be•ta cuius brachiis Secli pependit pretium, Statêra sacta corporis, Praedam•ue tulit Tartari, O crux, •ue spes vnica, & quae sequūtur.
bAmbros. l. 2. comment. in Luc c. 2. & in Psal•. 1.11•. Serm. 6. August. in Psal. 34. concion. 2. & contr. Julian. l. 5. c. 15. & De perfect. justit. c. 21. Leo de nativit. •om. Serm. 1. & 2. Fulgent. de side ad Petr. c. 26. Damascen. de orthod. fid. l. 3. cap. 2. Bede l. 1 ••Luc. c. 1. Anselm. Cur Deus homo. l. 2. c. •• 6. Bernard. ad Canon. Lugdun. epist. 174.Ambros. l. 2. comment. in Luc c. 2. & in Psal•. 1.11•. Serm. 6. August. in Psal. 34. concion. 2. & contr. Iu•ian. l. 5. c. 15. & De perfect. iustit. c. 21. Leo de natiuit. •om. Serm. 1. & 2. Fulgent. de side ad Petr. c. 26. Damascen. de orthod. fid. l. 3. cap. 2. Beda l. 1 ••Luc. c. 1. Anselm. Cur Deus homo. l. 2. c. •• 6. Bernard. ad Canon. Lugdun. epist. 174.
eBernard. ad Canon. Lugdun. epist. 174. Belleth. in explicat. divin. offic. c. 146. Durand. in Rationali l. 7. cap. 7.Bernard. ad Canon. Lugdun. epist. 174. Beleth. in explicat. diuin. offic. c. 146. Durand. in Rationali l. 7. cap. 7.
and the very gloss of your fCanon-law condemned sundry countries, and England namely, for keeping it. But the conception and nativity of the blessed virgin make her scarce equal unto Christ: the feast of the assumption doth lift her somewhat higher. For when Christ was taken up into heaven: gthe Apostles were lead forth a little way on foot, to see it and witness it. But to her assumption they were brought by miracle, in clouds, as in chariots, from all the coasts of the world, through which they were dispersed. And this is it which I called, and call again, a fable, or if you will, a lye, as hBede doth: though your Divines of Rhemes do vouch it as a true story.
and the very glose of your fCanon-law condemned sundry countries, and England namely, for kéeping it. But the conception and natiuitie of the blessed virgin make her scarse equall vnto Christ: the feast of the assumption doth lift her somwhat higher. For when Christ was taken vp into heauen: gthe Apostles were lead forth a litleway on foote, to sée it and witnes it. But to her assumption they were brought by miracle, in cloudes, as in chariots, from all the coastes of the world, through which they were dispersed. And this is it which I called, and cal againe, a fable, or if you will, a lye, as hBede doth: though your Diuines of Rhemes doo vouch it as a true storie.
Hart. It is a true story, as our Divines of Rhemes do •ouch it: though, as he reported it whom venerable Bede doth touch, it was a lye. For ihe reported it to have been done the second year after Christs ascension▪ which Bede doth prove it could not be. But our Divines refer it to the fifteenth year after. For they take the common opinion that she lived three score and three years in all. Now, kshe brought forth Christ when she was fifteen year old. So that her assumption was eight and forty years after Christs nativity. And this agreeth with lEusebius, who saith that some do write it was revealed to them that she was assumed the eight and forteeth year of Christ: which was fifteen years after his ascension.
Hart. It is a true storie, as our Diuines of Rhemes doo •ouch it: though, as he reported it whom venerable Bede doth touch, it was a lye. For ihe reported it to haue béene doon the second yeare after Christes ascension▪ which Bede doth proue it could not be. But our Diuines referre it to the fifteenth yeare after. For they take the common opinion that she liued three score and three yeares in all. Now, kshee brought forth Christ when she was fifteene yeare olde. So that her assumption was eight and fortie yeares after Christs natiuitie. And this agréeth with lEusebius, who saith yt some do write it was reueled to them that she was assumpted the eight and forteeth yeare of Christ: which was fifteene yeares after his ascension.
Hart. What if some were deceived in circumstance of time. Yet the story notwithstanding of her assumption is true, as our Divines of Rhemes report it. For *at the time of her death, (as S. oDenis first, and after him S. pDamascene writeth,) all the Apostles, then dispersed into divers nations to preach the gospel, were miraculously brought together, (saving S. Thomas who came the third day after,) to Jerusalem, to honour her divine departure and funeral, as the said S. Denis writeth. Who saith, that him self, S. Timothy, and S. Hierotheus were present: testifying ⟨p. 484⟩also of his own hearing, that, both before her death and after for three days, not only the Apostles and other holy men present, but the Angels also and powers of heaven did sing most melodious hymns. They buried her sacred body in Gethsemani. But for S. Thomas sake, who desired to see and to reverence it, they opened the sepulchre the third day: and finding it void of the holy body, but exceedingly fragrant, they returned, assuredly deeming that her body was assumed into heaven. As the Church of God holdeth, being most agreeable to the singular privilege of the mother of God: and therefore celebrateth most solemnly the day of her assumption. And it is consonant not only to the said S. Denis, & S. Damascene, but to S. qAthanasius also, who avoucheth the same. Of which assumption of her body S. Bernard also wrote five notable sermons, extant in his works.
Hart. What if some were deceiued in circumstance of time. Yet the storie notwithstanding of her assumption is true, as our Diuines of Rhemes report it. For *at the time of her death, (as S. oDenys first, and after him S. pDamascene writeth,) al the Apostles, then dispersed into diuers nations to preach the gospell, were miraculously brought togither, (sauing S. Thomas who came the third day after,) to Ierusalem, to honour her diuine departure and funerall, as the said S. Denys writeth. Who saith, that him self, S. Timothee, and S. Hierotheus were present: testifying ⟨p. 484⟩also of his owne hearing, that, both before her death and after for three daies, not onely the Apostles and other holy men present, but the Angels also and powers of heauen did sing most melodious hymnes. They buried her sacred body in Gethsemani. But for S. Thomas sake, who desired to sée and to reuerence it, they opened the sepucher the third day: and finding it voide of the holy body, but excéedingly fragrant, they returned, assuredly déeming that her body was assumpted into heauen. As the Church of God holdeth, being most agréeable to the singular priuilege of the mother of God: and therefore celebrateth most solemnely the day of her assumption. And it is consonant not onelie to the said S. Denys, & S. Damascene, but to S. qAthanasius also, who auoucheth the same. Of which assumption of her bodie S. Bernard also wrote fiue notable sermons, extant in his workes.
Rainoldes. But in all those five sermons of S. Bernard, there is not one word of your miraculous fable. As little, in S. Athanasius: beside that, the sermon, which you allege as his, is in ryour own edition rejected for a bastard. In Damascene there is more: yet not so much neither, as here syour Portesse hath. But he is *too late & too weak a witness, to prove a doubtful matter pretended to be done almost five hundred years before him. The best, or rather all your proof, is S. Denis: whom you belie notably. For where saith he that which you do father on him?
Rainoldes. But in all those fiue sermons of S. Bernard, there is not one worde of your miraculous fable. As litle, in S. Athanasius: beside that, the sermon, which you alleage as his, is in ryour own edition reiected for a bastard. In Damascene there is more: yet not so much neither, as here syour Portesse hath. But he is *too late & too weake a witnes, to proue a doubtful matter pretended to be doon almost fiue hundred yeares before him. The best, or rather all your proofe, is S. Denys: whom you belye notablie. For where saith he that which you doo father on him?
rIn edit. Petri Nannij Lovan. prae•at. ad Episcopum Atrebat.In edit. Petri Nannij Louan. prae•at. ad Episcopum Atrebat.
sBreviar. Romanum in Festis August. quarto di• infra octavam assump•. Beat. Mariae.Breuiar. Romanum in Festis August. quarto di• infra octauam assump•. Beat. Mariae.
*About the year of Christ 740.About the yeare of Christ 740.
Rainoldes. He wrote no such epistle. Your Rhemists did mistake their Portesse, whence this stuff is borrowed. For reading there, that Denis wrote hereof to Timothy, they thought it had been in an epistle to Timothy. The place, which they meant, is in a tbook entitled of the names of God: pretended to be written to Timothy by Denis.
Rainoldes. He wrote no such epistle. Your Rhemistes did mistake their Portesse, whence this stuffe is borowed. For reading there, that Denys wrote hereof to Timothee, they thought it had béene in an epistle to Timothee. The place, which they meant, is in a tbooke entitled of the names of God: pretended to be writen to Timothee by Denys.
tDionys. ad Timotheum de divin. nomin. cap. 3.Dionys. ad Timotheum de diuin. nomin. cap. 3.
Rainoldes. I do not therefore charge them with it. Neither would I mention this, but to point you the place in which they lye. For they say that S. Denis writeth these & these things: where neither the author who writeth is S. Denis, neither writeth he the things which they allege. Touching the things, first, he saith no more thereof but that amongst the Bishops inspired of the holy Ghost Hierothe•s excelled all the rest (save ⟨p. 485⟩the Apostles) in praising Christs goodness, when him self, and Timothy, and many of their holy brethren, *came together to behold the body which received God, and which the Prince of life was in. As for the miracle of the Apostles brought together, S. Thomas coming the third day after, the Angels singing hymns three days, the burial of the virgins body, the desire of Thomas to see it, the sepulchre opened for his sake, and the body assumed into heaven: he saith not one word of these conceits, not one word. Nay he rather saith against them. For he noteth namely that James was also present the brother of the Lord, and Peter the chief and ancientest top of the Apostles. Which it is not likely he would so note of two Apostles, if they had all been present. Much less is it likely that he would say nothing of so great a miracle, if any such had happened.
Rainoldes. I doo not therefore charge them with it. Neither would I mention this, but to point you the place in which they lye. For they say that S. Denys writeth these & these things: where neither the autour who writeth is S. Denys, neither writeth he the thinges which they alleage. Touching the thinges, first, he saith no more thereof but that amongst the Bishops inspired of the holy Ghost Hierothe•s excelled all the rest (saue ⟨p. 485⟩the Apostles) in praysing Christes goodnesse, when him selfe, and Timothee, and many of their holy brethren, *came together to behold the body which receyued God, and which the Prince of life was in. As for the miracle of the Apostles brought together, S. Thomas comming the thirde day after, the Angels singing hymnes three dayes, the buriall of the virgins body, the desire of Thomas to see it, the sepulcher opened for his sake, and the body assumpted into heauen: he saith not one worde of these conceites, not one word. Nay he rather saith against them. For he noteth namely that Iames was also present the brother of the Lord, and Peter the chiefe and ancientest toppe of the Apostles. Which it is not likelie he would so note of two Apostles, if they had all béene present. Much lesse is it likely that he would say nothing of so great a miracle, if any such had happened.