The sum of the conference between John Rainoldes and John Hart touching the head…The summe of the conference betwene Iohn Rainoldes and Iohn Hart touching the head…
The sum of the conference between John Rainoldes and John Hart touching the head and the faith of the Church. Wherein by the way are handled sundry points, of the sufficiency and right expounding of the Scriptures, the ministry of the Church, the function of priesthood, the sacrifice of the mass, with other controversies of religion: but chiefly and purposely the point of Church-government ... Penned by John Rainoldes, according to the notes set down in writing by them both: perused by John Hart, and (after things supplied, & altered, as he thought good) allowed for the faithful report of that which past in conference between them. Whereunto is annexed a treatise entitled, Six conclusions touching the Holy Scripture and the Church, written by John Rainoldes. With a defence of such things as Thomas Stapleton and Gregory Martin have carped at therein.The summe of the conference betwene Iohn Rainoldes and Iohn Hart touching the head and the faith of the Church. Wherein by the way are handled sundrie points, of the sufficiencie and right expounding of the Scriptures, the ministerie of the Church, the function of priesthood, the sacrifice of the masse, with other controuerises of religion: but chiefly and purposely the point of Church-gouernment ... Penned by Iohn Rainoldes, according to the notes set downe in writing by them both: perused by Iohn Hart, and (after things supplied, & altered, as he thought good) allowed for the faithfull report of that which past in conference betwene them. Whereunto is annexed a treatise intitled, Six conclusions touching the Holie Scripture and the Church, writen by Iohn Rainoldes. With a defence of such thinges as Thomas Stapleton and Gregorie Martin haue carped at therein.
John Rainolds 1549–1607Londini: printed by John Wolfe, 1584Londini: printed by Iohn Wolfe, 1584
475, [1], 479-674, 659-750 p. · 304k words · STC 20626 · ESTC S115546
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Rainoldes. When this was alleged by the Popes legate, in his behalf, at Carthage: xthe Bishops of Africa said (after long search) that they found it not ordained by any Council. Which moved ya Doctor of your own to write, that it may be doubted whether the Council of Sardica ordained it or no. And sith zat that Council there were not many less than forty Bishops of Africa, who brought home the canons thereof, as it is likely: his doubt hath reason for it Unless peradventure, because in athe fountain and spring of that canon Julius is named, in whom bthe Council had a special affiance for his ⟨p. 662⟩dealing against the Arians: therefore the Bishops of Africa thought it to have been given personally to Julius, not to Popes in general; and so cto have died with him, not lived with them. But if it were ordained indeed by the Council, in respect of him, as Pope, not as Julius: yet dthey, who avouch it to prove the Popes supremacy, do make as good a reason, as if a man should claim the whole city of London, because he hath the lease of a house in Hogsdon. For ethe Council of Sardica tieth him in all points, (save only in this,) to his own province, as well as other Bishops; and in this, it showeth that he had it not of right before time, but now by that grant; neither doth it grant him to judge of the causes, but to commend the judgement thereof to the Synod, or (at the most) to be a fellow-judge with them; and they, in whose causes it granteth him so much, are Bishops, f
none else. Howbeit, even this too, that he should send some from his own side to judge of their causes together with the Synod, was repealed afterward, and the whole committed to Synods of the province, or diocese, if the province served not. Belike, upon experience of some harm ensuing: as
the general Council of Constantinople did forbid the Bishops of a diocese (such as Egypt, containing many provinces) to meddle with the Churches without their own limits: and command that things in every province should be ordered by the Synod of the province, according to the canons of the Nicene Council.
Rainoldes. When this was alleaged by the Popes legate, in his behalfe, at Carthage: xthe Bishops of Afrike said (after long serch) that they found it not ordeined by any Councell. Which moued ya Doctour of your owne to write, that it may be douted whether the Councell of Sardica ordeined it or no. And sith zat that Councell there were not many lesse than fourtie Bishops of Afrike, who brought home the canons thereof, as it is likely: his dout hath reason for it Unlesse peraduenture, because in athe fountaine and spring of that canon Iulius is named, in whom bthe Councell had a speciall affiance for his ⟨p. 662⟩dealing against the Arians: therefore the Bishops of Afrike thought it to haue bene geuē personally to Iulius, not to Popes in generall; and so cto haue died with him, not liued with them. But if it were ordeined indéede by the Councell, in respect of him, as Pope, not as Iulius: yet dthey, who auouch it to proue the Popes supremacie, doe make as good a reason, as if a man should claime the whole citie of London, because he hath the lease of a house in Hogsdon. For ethe Councell of Sardica tieth him in all pointes, (saue only in this,) to his owne prouince, as well as other Bishops; and in this, it sheweth that he had it not of right before time, but now by that grant; neither doth it grant him to iudge of the causes, but to commend the iudgement therof to the Synode, or (at the most) to be a fellow-iudge with thē; and they, in whose causes it granteth him so much, are Bishops, fnone else. Howbeit, euen this too, that he should send some from his own side to iudge of their causes together with the Synode, was repealed afterward, and the whole committed to Synodes of the prouince, or diocese, if the prouince serued not. Belike, vpon experience of some harme ensuing: as ga husband man (in Sicilie) hauing rid stones out of his ground, was troubled so with myre, that he lost his corne till he had layde them in agayne. For hthe generall Councell of Constantinople did forbid the Bishops of a diocese (such as Egypt, contayning many prouinces) to meddle with the Churches without their owne limits: and commaund that things in euery prouince should be ordered by the Synode of the prouince, according to the canons of the Nicen Councell.
xEpist. ad Caelestin. Concil. African. c. 10•.
yCusan. de concordant. cath•l. l. 2. c. 25.
zAthan. in Apolog. 2.
aConc. Sa•dic. can. 3.
bTheodoret. hist. eccle. l. • cap. 8.
cPrivilegium personale extinguitur cum persona. De regulis Jur. in sext.Priuilegium personale extinguitur cum persona. De regulis Iur. in sext.
Hart. But they gave ithe primacy of honour to the Bishop of Constantinople after the Bishop of Rome. Which showeth that the Bishop of Rome in their judgement was over all in primacy.
Hart. But they gaue ithe primacie of honour to the Bishop of Constantinople after the Bishop of Rome. Which sheweth that the Bishop of Rome in their iudgement was ouer all in primacie.
Rainoldes. In primacy of honour, M. Hart, not of power: as I have often said. For in power they made him equal with his brethren, enclosing them all within their own limits ▪ and appointing kthe causes of Bishops to be judged each by his own Synod, first, of the province; then, of the diocese; without mention of the Pope. 1Yet in 2honour, they set him highest; Constantinople, next: as the very words of the Council show. It is true, that this height and preeminence of honour ⟨p. 663⟩was a cause that moved him to lust for greater power too, and means that lift him up unto it. For as lmurderers in Italy are wont to fly to sanctuaries to escape punishment, and mRomulus received runagates at Rome to advance his state: so ndisorderly persons not able to maintain their faults against justice in their own province, did run to the Pope; and oambitious heads, whether of Popes themselves, or of some about them, aspired to greater rule under pretence of privileges of the Church of Rome. But as general Councils had provided general salves against such evils: so the Councils of provinces and dioceses applied them to this particular sore for safety of their Churches. For it was decreed by the Council of Milevis, that, pif any Elder, or Deacon, or clergy-man of inferior state appealed *to the Pope: no man in Africa should communicate with him. The Council of Carthage showeth that qthey had often decreed the same of Bishops. And when yet they could not avoid the shameless shifts of tumultuous brains, who made Rome their refuge; and Zosimus in the quarrel of Apiarius an Elder would have his Bishop Urban to be excommunicated, or appear at Rome: the Bishops of all the provinces of Africa did debate the matter with him and his successors, Boniface, and Caelestine, for the space of four or five years together. In fine, when the true and authentical copies of the Nicene Council, whereon the Pope grounded, were gotten out of the East; and thereby the falsehood of his plea appeared: rthe Council of Africa told him, that he should not meddle with the causes of men in their provinces; nor receive any such to the communion as they had excommunicate. For the Council of Nice (said they) did consider wisely and uprightly that all matters ought to be determined in the places in which they began:
Rainoldes. In primacie of honour, M. Hart, not of power: as I haue often sayd. For in power they made him equall with his brethren, enclosing them all within their owne limits ▪ and appointing kthe causes of Bishops to be iudged eche by his owne Synode, first, of the prouince; then, of the diocese; without mention of the Pope. 1Yet in 2honour, they set him highest; Constantinople, next: as the very wordes of the Councell sh•w. It is true, that this height and preeminence of honour ⟨p. 663⟩was a cause that moued him to lust for greater power too, and meanes that lift him vp vnto it. For as lmurderers in Italie are woont to flie to sanctuaries to escape punishment, and mRomulus receaued runagates at Rome to aduance his state: so ndisorderly persons not able to maintaine their faultes against iustice in their owne prouince, did runne to the Pope; and oambitious heades, whether of Popes themselues, or of some about thē, aspired to greater rule vnder pretense of priuiledges of the Church of Rome. But as generall Councels had prouided generall salues against such euils: so the Councels of prouinces and dioceses applied them to this particular sore for safetie of their Churches. For it was decréed by the Councell of Mileuis, that, pif any Elder, or Deacon, or clergie-man of inferiour state appealed *to the Pope: no man in Afrike should communicate with him. The Councell of Carthage sheweth that qthey had often decreed the same of Bishops. And when yet they could not auoide the shamelesse shiftes of tumultuous braines, who made Rome their refuge; and Zosimus in the quarell of Apiarius an Elder would haue his Bishop Vrban to be excommunicated, or appeere at Rome: the Bishops of all the prouinces of Afrike did debate the matter with him and his successors, Boniface, and Caelestine, for the space of foure or fiue yeares together. In fine, when the true and authenticall copies of the Nicen Councell, whereon the Pope grounded, were gotten out of the East; and thereby the falshoode of his plea appéered:
kcan. 6.
1[Greek or Hebrew]〈non-Latin alphabet〉
2[Greek or Hebrew]〈non-Latin alphabet〉
lMasi•s in Josuam cap. 20.Masi•s in Iosuam cap. 20.
mLivi. lib. 1.Liui. lib. 1.
n•onc. Afric. cap. 101.
ocap. 105.
pConc. Mile•itan. can. 22.
*Ad •ransmarina judicia they term it, whereby the Pope is meant: though Gratian fondly do except him, 2. q. 6. c. placuit ut presbytery.Ad •ransmarina iudicia they terme it, wherby the Pope is meant: though Gratian fondly do except him, 2. q. 6. c. placuit vt presbyteri.
as being persuaded that the grace of the holy ghost would not be wanting to any province, whereby the Christian Bishops might both wisely see, and constantly maintain the right. Chiefly, sith it is lawful for any, if he like not the sentence of his judges, to appeal to the Synods of his own province: yea, or farther also to a 3general Synod. Unless there be any perhaps who will imagine, that our God can inspire the trial of right into one man, and deny it to a great number of Bishops assembled in ⟨p. 664⟩a Synod. And so going forward with proof that the Pope ought not to judge their causes, either at Rome, himself; or by his Legates sent from Rome: they touched his attempt in modest sort, but at the quick, condemning it of 4pride, & smoky stateliness of the world.
as being perswaded that the grace of the holy ghost would not be wanting to any prouince, whereby the Christian Bishops might both wisely see, and constantly maintaine the right. Chiefly, sith it is lawfull for any, if he like not the sentence of his iudges, to appeale to the Synodes of his owne prouince: yea, or farther also to a 3generall Synode. Vnlesse there be any perhaps who will imagin, that our God can inspire the triall of right into one man, and denie it to a great number of Bishops assembled in ⟨p. 664⟩a Synode. And so going forward with proofe that the Pope ought not to iudge their causes, either at Rome, himselfe; or by his Legates sent from Rome: they touched his attempt in modest sort, but at the quicke, condemning it of 4pride, & smokie statelinesse of the world.
3Universal, meaning a Synod of t•e diocese, not, of the whole world. Concil. Cons•antinop. can. 6.Vniue•sale, meaning a Synode of t•e diocese, not, of the whole world. Concil. Cons•antinop. can. 6.
Rainoldes. Torrensis citeth it with as much sincerity, as an other tJesuit doth the four general Councils: both foully abusing the show of some words against the drift and meaning of their whole sentences. For the Council of Africa, though bearing a while with the Popes claim till the Nicene canons (whereby he claimed) were searched, yet at length condemned it, as I have showed:2 and of the four general Councils, as the former two did enclose the Pope within his own province, or diocese at the most; so did the two later, of uEphesus and xChalcedon, confirming the decrees and canons of the former.
Rainoldes. Torrensis citeth it with as much sinceritie, as an other tIesuite doth the foure general Councels: both fowly abusing the shew of some wordes against the drift and meaning of their whole sentences. For the Councell of Afrike, though bearing a while with the Popes claime till the Nicen canons (whereby he claimed) were serched, yet at length condemned it, as I haue shewed:2 and of the foure generall Councels, as the former two did enclose the Pope within his owne prouince, or diocese at the most; so did the two later, of uEph•sus and xChalcedon, confirming the decrées and canons of the former.
tCampian. Ra•ione 4.
2The fourth Division.The fourth Diuision.
uIn sentent. super petition episcopor. Cypr.In sentent. super petitione episcopor. Cypr.
Hart. Nay, doubtless at yChalcedon, the Judges, having heard the former canons read, said that they perceived all primacy & principal honour to be due to the Pope thereby.
Hart. Nay, doubtlesse at yChalcedon, the Iudges, hauing heard the former canons read, sayd that they perceiued al primacie & principall honour to be due to the Pope thereby.
Rainoldes. But they added that the Patriarch of Constantinople ought to be vouchsafed of the same prerogatives and primacy of honour. As zthe C•uncell also it self allotted equal prerogatives to them both: ordaining thereupon, that Constantinople should be magnified in ecclesiastical matters as well as Rome, and be next unto it. Wherein it is manifest that they meant preeminence of honour, not of power. For athemselves decreed that the highest judge of ecclesiastical persons should be the Patriarch of the diocese, or of Constantinople. Whereby they gave greater power to the Patriarch of Constantinople, whom they authorised to deal in every diocese; then to the Roman Patriarch, whom they tied to his own. In so much that bthe Greeks say that all dioceses of the whole world were subject to their Patriarch by the Council of Chalcedon. At least if the Council ha• an eye to power, and not to honour only, in willing them to be magnified: yet that is a disproof still of the Popes supremacy. As you may learn by cGratian. Who seeking to prove it by the same canon renewed in dthe Council ⟨p. 665⟩of Constantinople, hath helped it with a negative: and where the Council said, Let Constantinople 1be magnified as well as Rome; he allegeth it, let 2not Constantinople be magnified as well as Rome.
Rainoldes. But they added that the Patriarke of Constantinople ought to be vouchsafed of the same prerogatiues and primacie of honour. As zthe C•uncell also it selfe allotted equall prerogatiues to them both: ordeining therevpon, that Constantinople should be magnified in ecclesiasticall matters as well as Rome, and be next vnto it. Wherein it is manifest that they meant preeminence of honour, not of power. For athemselues decréed that the highest iudge of ecclesiasticall persons should be the Patriarke of the diocese, or of Constantinople. Wherby they gaue greater power to the Patriarke of Constantinople, whom they authorised to deale in euery diocese; then to the Roman Patriarke, whom they tied to his own. In so much that bye Greekes say that all dioceses of the whole world were subiect to their Patriarke by the Councell of Chalcedon. At least if the Councel ha• an eye to power, and not to honour only, in willing them to be magnified: yet that is a disproofe still of ye Popes supremacie. As you may learne by cGratian. Who séeking to proue it by the same canon renued in dthe Councell ⟨p. 665⟩of Constantinople, hath helped it with a negatiue: and where the Councell sayd, Let Constantinople 1be magnified as well as Rome; he alleageth it, let 2not Constantinople be magnified as well as Rome.
Rainoldes. Yet a Council made them in Constantinople, cwith credit of a general. And fthe next general Council did confirm them. Which thereby disproved the Popes supremacy too. Yea, again gthe next defined of the Pope, as of other Patriarchs: and that upon the ground of the famous Nicene. To be short, the visible Monarchy of the Church was never allowed to him by any Council, general, or provincial: until the East Churches were rent from the West, and the Italian faction did bear the sway in Councils.
Rainoldes. Yet a Councell made them in Constantinople, cwith credit of a generall. And fthe next generall Councell did confirme them. Which thereby disproued the Popes supremacie too. Yea, againe gthe next defined of the Pope, as of other Patriarkes: and that vpon the ground of the famous Nicen. To be short, the visible Monarchie of the Church was neuer allowed to him by any Councell, generall, or prouinciall: vntil the East Churches were rent from the West, and the Italian faction did beare the sway in Councels.
cPraefat. synod. in Trullo ad Justinian.Praefat. synod. in Trullo ad Iustinian.
Hart. What mean you to say so? whereas hthe Council of Lateran under Innocentius did approve it flatly: the Patriarchs of the Churches of Constantinople and Jerusalem being present.
Hart. What meane you to say so? wheras hthe Councell of Lateran vnder Innocētius did approue it flatly: the Patriarks of the Churches of Constantinople and Ierusalem being present.
Rainoldes. Not the right Patriarchs, iI trow. Though if they had been: yet might the Italians make decrees in Lateran at Rome without them. But nether did that Council approve the Popes Monarchy. For the Popes Monarchy is a full and absolute sovereignty of power over the whole Church. Whereupon kthe principal proctors of it teach, that not a general Council is above the Pope, but the Pope above the Council. For lthey (saith Father mRobert) who hold that the Council is above the Pope; do make him like a Duke of Venice: above every magistrate and senator in several, not above the whole Senate. But he is above the whole Church absolutely, and above the general Council: so that he acknowledgeth no judge on earth above him. Now, the sovereignty of ordinary power given to the Pope over all Churches by the Council of Lateran under Innocentius, was but as it were a Dukedom of Venice: over every Church and Bishop in several, not over the whole Church. A signory of great state: but not a Popes Monarchy. His Monarchy was neither allowed by that Council, nor by any other for many ages after: nay, it was condemned expressly by the Council of nConstance, ⟨p. 666⟩& of oBasil. The first, that allowed it, was the pCouncil of Lateran under Leo the tenth: a thousand five hundred and sixteen years after Christ.
Rainoldes. Not the right Patriarkes, iI trow. Though if they had bene: yet might the Italians make decrées in Lateran at Rome without them. But nether did that Councell approue the Popes Monarchie. For the Popes Monarchie is a full and absolute soueraintie of power ouer the whole Church. Wherevpon kthe principall proctours of it teach, that not a generall Councell is aboue the Pope, but the Pope aboue the Coūcel. For lthey (sayth Father mRobert) who hold that the Councel is aboue the Pope; do make him like a Duke of Venice: aboue euery magistrate and senatour in seuerall, not aboue the whole Senate. But he is aboue the whole Church absolutely, and aboue the generall Councell: so that he acknowledgeth no iudge on earth aboue him. Now, the soueraintie of ordinarie power geuen to the Pope ouer all Churches by the Councell of Lateran vnder Innocentius, was but as it were a Dukedome of Venice: ouer euery Church and Bishop in seuerall, not ouer the whole Church. A signorie of great state: but not a Popes Monarchie. His Monarchie was neyther allowed by that Councell, nor by any other for many ages after: nay, it was condemned expresly by the Councell of nConstance, ⟨p. 666⟩& of oBasil. The first, that allowed it, was the pCouncell of Lateran vnder Leo the tenth: a thousand fyue hundred and syxtéene yeres after Christ.
iThe Pope mad• Latin Prelates Patriarchs of Constantinople, against the r••ht Greek ones. Concil. Florent. Sess. ult.The Pope mad• Latin Prelates Patria•kes of Constantinople, against the r••ht Greeke ones. Concil. Florent. Sess. vlt.
kPope Paschal the second. c. Significasti. de electione. Pope Pius the second. Epist. 400. Turrecremata. Summ. de eccle. l. 3. c. 46. Sander. de visib. Monarch. eccle. lib. 7. •o•rensis de autorit. summ. Pont. supra Concilia. Stapleton. Princip doctr. lib. 13. cap. 15. The Schoolmen commonly, in 4. sentent. dist. 19. And almost all the Cano•istes▪ in c. Significas•i. de elect. c. Si Papa. Dist 40.Pope Paschal the secōd. c. Significasti. de electione. Pope Pius the second. Epist. 400. Turrecremata. Summ. de eccle. l. 3. c. 46. Sander. de visib. Monarch. eccle. lib. 7. •o•rensis de autorit. summ. Pont. supra Concilia. Stapleton. Princip doctr. lib. 13. cap. 15. The Schoolemen commonly, in 4. sentent. dist. 19. And almost all the Cano•istes▪ in c. Significas•i. de elect. c. Si Papa. Dist 40.
lGersen & Almain tractat. de po•est. ecclesiae. Cusan us de concordant. cathol. lib. 2. cap. ult. […] in c. sig•i•icasti de elect.Gersen & Almain tractat. de po•est. ecclesiae. Cusan us de concordant. cathol. lib. 2. cap. vlt. 〈…〉 in c. sig•i•icasti de elect.
Rainoldes. But in such sort, that ryour Roman reader, though making the most thereof for the Popes credit, was fain• yet to say, that the Council of Florence did not define it so expressly. In truth sthe Greek Bishops answered of themselves, for they might not treat thereof without consent (they said) of their whole Church, but of themselves they answered, that the Pope ought to have the same prerogatives, that he had before the time of their dissension. Which is a great presumption, that when they subscribed to more then the same, it was not of themselves. Chiefly sith 1they came besides so constrainedly to that which they did, and 2refused to obey the Pope when they had done it. But Leo the tenth with his Italian faction in Lateran defined it. From whom tthe University of Paris appealed straight to a Council; and condemned his Lateran doctrine and decree: as uthe Universities of L•uan, of Cologne, xof Vienna, and of yCracovia had done before also. The consent therefore of Pastors and Doctors throughout all Christendom hath disallowed the Popes Monarchy. And that which the Pastors and Doctors delivered was the religion of their Churches. Whereby you may see the truth of that I said, that, except the crew of the Italian faction, all Christian Churches have condemned his usurped sovereignty.
Rainoldes. But in such sort, that ryour Roman reader, though making the most thereof for the Popes credit, was fain• yet to say, that the Councel of Florence did not define it so expressely. In truth sthe Greeke Bishops answered of themselues, for they might not treate thereof without consent (they sayd) of their whole Church, but of themselues they answered, that the Pope ought to haue the same prerogatiues, that he had before the time of their dissension. Which is a great presumption, that when they subscribed to more then the same, it was not of themselues. Chiefly sith 1they came besides so constrainedly to that which they did, and 2refused to obey the Pope when they had done it. But Leo the tenth with his Italian faction in Lateran defined it. From whom tthe Uniuersitie of Parise appealed straight to a Councell; and condemned his Lateran doctrine and decrée: as uthe Uniuersities of L•uan, of Coolein, xof Vienna, and of yCracouia had done before also. The consent therefore of Pastours and Doctours throughout all Christendome hath disallowed the Popes Monarchie. And that which the Pastours and Doctors deliuered was the religion of their Churches. Whereby you may sée the truth of that I sayd, that, except the crew of the Italian faction, all Christian Churches haue condemned his vsurped soueraintie.
1Upon their Emperors importunity▪ and danger of their S•ate.Vpon their Emperours importun•tie▪ and danger of t•eir S•ate.
2Both presently there, in choosing a new Patriarch: & after when they were returned into their country.Both presently there, in choosing a new Patriarke: & after when they were returned into their countr•y.
tAppellat. Universit. Parisien•is a Leone decimo ad futurū Concilium. In f•scic. rerum expetend. & fugicad.Appellat. Vniuersit. Parisien•is a Leone decimo ad futurū Concilium. In f•scic. rerum expetend. & fugicad.
uAen. Silu de g•stis Basil. Co••il. lib 1.
x•i•tor. de Europa, cap. 22.
y••omer. de […] Polonor. lib. 21.••omer. de 〈…〉 Polonor. lib. 21.
Hart. Truly (I must confess) I see more probability on your side then I did. But in that you said that all Christian Churches have condemned it, and do till this day, you forgot your self, who granted zbefore, that by the Trent-doctrine the Pope is above the Council. For the doctrine agreed on by the Council of Trent (which you call the of Trent-doctrine) is held by Catholic Christians through the whole Church at this day.
Hart. Truly (I must confesse) I sée more probabilitie on your side then I did. But in that you said that all Christian Churches haue condemned it, and doe till this day, you forgot your selfe, who granted zbefore, that by the Trent-doctrine the Pope is aboue the Councell. For the doctrine agreed on by the Councell of Trent (which you call the of Trent-doctrine) is held by Catholike Christians through the whole Church at this day.
Rainoldes. I said, that all Christian Churches have condemned it, and do, except the crew of the Italian faction. Which speech agreeth well with that I said before of the Council Trent. For the aTrent-doctrine of the Popes supremacy, ⟨p. 667⟩is that which the Italian faction at Trent did overbear the rest in. As bClaudius Espencaeus, a Divine of Paris, a Doctor of your own witnesseth: saying, that Ludovicus the Cardinal of Arle did complain justly at the Council of Basil, that look what 3the Italian nation liketh of, that is decreed in Councils; & 4this is that Helena which did prevail of late at Trent. Now, that which the Cardinal Ludovicus spake of, was, cthat in Councils not only Bishops but Elders too should have voices, as of old dtime they had: for 5if Bishops only have voices, (saith the Cardinal) then shall that be done that shall seem good to the Italian nation, which alone hath ether mo Bishops, or as many, as all other nations have. For every baggage-town hath a Bishop there. And these baggage-Bishops, *of whom there were more at the Council of Trent then of all other nations, did allow that doctrine. Though neither they perhaps allowed it in hart, but were induced by Papal means to yield unto it. For ethe answer of Vargas touching the Popes supremacy, (made at Rome, and published, for instruction of the Council assembled then at Trent) doth show that fthere was some sticking at the matter. And your gstories note, that the Pope is foully afraid of general Councils, least they should hurt his State: and cometh like a bear to the stake (as they say) when he is drawn to summon them. What ha do was made before he could be brought to grant that the Council of Trent should go forward? And iwhile the Council lasted, he kept good rule at Rome: but brake loose when it was ended. Besides, it being ended twenty years ago, there hath been none since: nether (I believe) is like to be in hast. Where yet there should be one 6every ten years, by ktheir own decree. All evident tokens, that the Pope himself doth think that Bishops under him like not his supremacy: and would cut it shorter if they might have power and authority to do it. Which if they would do, though being lsworn to maintain it; yea, and to maintain the reservations, the provisions, & other excesses of it: is it not manifest that they disallow it, or detest it rather?
Rainoldes. I said, that all Christian Churches haue condemned it, and doe, except the crew of the Italian faction. Which spéeche agréeth well with that I said before of the Councell Trent. For the aTrent-doctrine of the Popes supremacie, ⟨p. 667⟩is that which the Italian faction at Trent did ouerbea•e the rest in. As bClaudius Espencaeus, a Diuine of Parise, a Doctour of your own witnesseth: saying, that Ludouicus the Cardinall of Arle did complaine iustly at the Councell of Basil, that looke what 3the Italian nation liketh of, that is decreed in Councels; & 4this is that Helena which did preuaile of late at Trent. Now, that which the Cardinal Ludouicus spake of, was, cthat in Councels not only Bishops but Elders too should haue voices, as of old dtime they had: for 5if Bishops only haue voices, (sayth the Cardinall) then shal that be done that shall seeme good to the Italian nation, which alone hath ether mo Bishops, or as many, as al other nations haue. For euery baggage-towne hath a Bishop there. And these buggage-Bishops, *of whom there were more at the Councell of Trent then of all other nations, did allow that doctrine. Though neyther they perhaps allowed it in hart, but were induced by Papall meanes to yéeld vnto it. For ethe answere of Vargas touching the Popes supremacie, (made at Rome, and published, for instruction of the Councell assembled then at Trent) doth shew that fthere was some sticking at the matter. And your gstories note, that the Pope is fowly afraide of general Councels, leaft they should hurt his State: and commeth like a beare to the stake (as they say) when he is drawne to summon them. What
a•ess. 7. de reformat. In pro•mio. & Sess. 14 cap. 7. & Sess. 25. de re•rm. •. cap. ult.•ess. 7. de reformat. In pro•mio. & Sess. 14 cap. 7. & Sess. 25. de re•rm. •. cap. vlt.
bCommentar. in Epist. ad litum ca•. •.
3[…] Italicae〈…〉 Italicae
4[…] est illa Helena quae […] n•per obtinuit.〈…〉 est illa Helena quae 〈…〉 n•per obtinuit.
cAen. Silu. de gestis Basil. Con cil. lib. 1.Aen. Silu. de gestis Basil. Cō cil. lib. 1.
5Si solely episcopi vocem habeant, id demum fiet quod nationi placebit Italicae, quae so•a n• tiones alias in numero episcoporum a•t superat aut aequat.Si soli episcopi vocem habeant, id demum fiet quod nationi placebit Italicae, quae so•a n• tiones alias in numero episcoporum at superat aut aequat.
the Councell of Afrike told him, that he should not meddle with the causes of men in their prouinces; nor receaue any such to the communion as they had excommunicate. For the Councell of Nice (sayd they) did consider wisely and vprightly that all matters ought to be determined in the places in which they began:
while the Councell lasted, he kept good rule at Rome: but brake loose whē it was ended. Besides, it being ended twentie yeares ago, there hath bene none since: nether (I beléeue) is like to be in hast. Where yet there should be one
their own decrée. All euident tokens, that the Pope himselfe doth thinke that Bishops vnder him like not his supremacie: and would cut it shorter if they might haue power and autoritie to do it. Which if they would do, though being
sworne to maintaine it; yea, and to maintaine the reseruations, the prouisions, & other excesses of it: is it not manifest that they disallow it, or detest it rather?
•
*There were almost two hundred Italian Prelates there: of all other nations not a hundred. Concil. Trident. excus▪ a Plantin. in numer. P•• lator. qui ad Trident. Synod. conuene•u••.There were almost two hundred Italiā Prelates there: of all other nations not a hundred. Concil. Trident. excus▪ a Plantin. in numer. P•• lator. qui ad Trident. Synod. conuene•u••.
eResponsum Franci••• Vargas de episcoporum jurisdict. & Pont Max. autorit.Responsum Franci••• Vargas de episcoporum iurisdict. & Pont Max. autorit.
fPauli Manut. praes. ad Respō sum Fr. VargasPauli Manut. praes. ad Respō sum Fr. Vargas
gGui••iardin. hist. Ital. lib. 9. & 20. Jovius. hist. sui temporis lib. 2.Gui••iardin. hist. Ital. lib. 9. & 20. Iouius. hist. sui temporis lib. 2.
hAs Espencaeus showeth, Comment. in epist. ad Titum. cap. 1.As Espencaeus sheweth, Comment. in epist. ad Titum. cap. 1.
iAs Onuphrius saith, Vita Pij quart. in vit. Pont. adiect. ad Platin.As Onuphrius sayth, Vita Pij quart. in vit. Pont. adiect. ad Platin.
6De decennio in decennium perpetuo.
kConcil. Constantiens. Sess. 39. c. Frequens.
lFormaiuram. praestand. ab episcopo elect. in Pontificali Rom. part. 1.