Three treatises of the vanity of the creature. The sinfulness of sin. The life…Three treatises of the vanity of the creature. The sinfulnesse of sinne. The life…
Three treatises of the vanity of the creature. The sinfulness of sin. The life of Christ. Being the substance of several sermons preached at Lincolns Inn: by Edward Reynolds, preacher to that honourable society, and late fellow of Merton College in Oxford.Three treatises of the vanity of the creature. The sinfulnesse of sinne. The life of Christ. Being the substance of severall sermons preached at Lincolns Inne: by Edward Reynoldes, preacher to that honourable society, and late fellow of Merton Colledge in Oxford.
Edward Reynolds 1599–1676London: printed by Felix Kyngston for Robert Bostocke, 1631
[20], 100, 99-535, [1] p. · 188k words · STC 20934 · ESTC S115807
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Thus have I at large opened those many great evils which this sin hath in it, that life of concupiscence which the Apostle here speaketh of. I cannot say of it as the Roman Epitomizer of his History, I• brevit abella totanteius imagi•m amplex• su•, that in1 a small compass I have comprised the whole Image of old Adam, but rather clean contrary, In amplatabull non dimidiam eius imaginem amplexus sum. The half of this sin hath not all this while been described unto you.
Thus have I at large opened those many great evils which this sinne hath in it, that life of concupiscence which the Apostle here speaketh of. I cannot say of it as the Romane Epitomizer of his Historie, I• brevit abella totanteius imagi•m amplex• su•, that in1 a small compasse I have comprized the whole Image of old Adam, but rather cleane contrary, In amplatabull non dimidiam eius imaginem amplexus sum. The halfe of this sinne hath not all this while beene described unto you.
Now therefore to conclude this Argument (wherein I have been the larger, both because of the necessariness of it, that we may know whither to rise in our humiliations for sin, and because it is the principal s•ope of the Apostle in the place, and serves most abundantly to show our own everlasting insufficiency for happiness in our selves) we see by these things which have been discovered in this sin, at what defiance we ought to stand with the doctrine of those men, first, who mince and qualify, and extenuate this sin as the Papists do, making it the
wrath, then only a want of his beatifical presen•e, and that too without any pain or sorrow of mind, which might be apt to grow from the apprehension of so great a loss, nay not only denying it after Baptism to be a sin, but only the seed of sin, an evil disease, languor, tyranny, and impotency of nature: but that even in the wicked themselves
reviling the doctrine of the Reformed Divines, for exaggerating this sin, as that which overspreadeth in its being all our nature, and in its working all our lives. Secondly, of those who heretofore, and even now deny any sinfulness either in the privation of the Image of God, or in the concupiscence and deordination of our nature. It was the doctrine of the Pelagians in the primitive times, that
concupiscence being the punishment of sin cannot be a sin likewise.
Now therefore to conclude this Argument (wherein I have been the larger, both because of the necessarinesse of it, that we may know whither to rise in our humiliations for sinne, and because it is the principall s•ope of the Apostle in the place, and serves most abundantly to shew our owne everlasting insufficiency for happinesse in our selves) we see by these things which have been discovered in this sin, at what defiance we ought to stand with the doctrine of those men, first, who mince and qualifie, and extenuate this sinne as the Papists doe, making it the asmallest of all sinnes▪bnot deserving any more of Gods ⟨p. 199⟩wrath, then onely a want of his beatificall presen•e, and that too without any paine or sorrow of minde, which might be apt to grow from the apprehension of so great a losse, nay not onely denying it after Baptisme to bee a sinne, but onely the seed of sinne, an evill disease, langvor, tyranny, and impotency of nature: but that even in the wicked themselvesc concupiscence is rather imputed for sinne, then is really and formally sinne, dnotwithstanding it be forbidden in the Commandement; and upon these presumptions ereviling the doctrine of the Reformed Divines, for exaggerating this sinne, as that which overspreadeth in its beeing all our nature, and in its working all our lives. Secondly, of those who heretofore, and even now deny any sinfulnesse either in the privation of the Image of God, or in the concupiscence and deordination of our nature. It was the doctrine of the Pelagians in the primitive times, that fmans nature was not corrupted by the fall of Adam, that his sinne gwas not any ground to his posterity either of death, or of the merit of death, that hsinne comes from Adam by imitation, not by propagation. That iBaptisme doth not serve in Infants for remission of sinne, but onely for adoption and admission into Heaven; that as kChrists righteousnesse doth not profit those which beleeve not, so Adams sinne doth not prejudice, nor injure those that actually sinne not. lThat as a righteous man doth not beget a righteous Childe, so neither doth a sinner beget a Childe guilty of sinne. Thatm all sinne is voluntary, and therefore not naturall. That nMarriage is Gods ordinance, and therefore no instrument ⟨p. 200⟩of transmitting sinne. That oconcupiscence being the punishment of sinne cannot bee a sinne likewise.
aIntensive Maius est peccatum actuale quam originale. Aquin. p. 3. q. 1. •rt. 4. c. A theologis nos•ris minimum omnium peccatorum censetur. Andrad. Orthodox▪ explic. lib. 3. Omnium peccatorum levissimum si ipsam per se criminis rationem intuearis. Idem in de•ens▪•id. Trident. lib. 5. part. 1.
c[…] non renatis in peccatum imputatur potius quàm revera & propriè peccatum est Stapleton. de Justis. lib. 3. cap. 3. Falsum est concupiscentiam quae in nobis manet esse peccatum originale. Becan▪ Opuscul. de Authore peccat. c. 4. Bellarm. de Amiss. grat. & statupeccati. lib. 5. cap. 5. 7. 89. Greg. Val. to. 2. disp. 6 qu. 12. p. 1. §. 5. 6. Soto de natura & gratia, lib. 1. cap. 10. Durandus & privationem Justitiae & concupiscentiam peccatum hoc esse negat, & quod sit Reatus seu dignitas contendit. lib. 2. distinct. 30. qu. 3.〈…〉 non renatis in peccatum imputatur potius quàm revera & propriè peccatum est Stapleton. de Iustis. lib. 3. cap. 3. Falsum est concupiscentiam quae in nobis manet esse peccatum originale. Becan▪ Opuscul. de Authore peccat. c. 4. Bellarm. de Amiss. grat. & statupeccati. lib. 5. cap. 5. 7. 89. Greg. Val. to. 2. disp. 6 qu. 12. p. 1. §. 5. 6. Soto de natura & gratia, lib. 1. cap. 10. Durandus & privationem Iustitiae & concupiscentiam peccatum hoc esse negat, & quod sit Reatus seu dignitas contendit. lib. 2. distinct. 30. qu. 3.
dQuamvis in decalogo prohibeatur, peccatum tamen non est. Staplet. de Justif. lib. 3. c. 5. Omnem [Greek or Hebrew] esse peccatum nonest verum. Bellar. de Stat▪ peccati. lib. 5. c. 14.Quamvis in decalogo prohibeatur, peccatum tamen non est. Staplet. de Iustif. lib. 3. c. 5. Omnem 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 esse peccatum nonest verum. Bellar. de Stat▪ peccati. lib. 5. c. 14.
eStaplet. de Justif. l. 1. c. 13. Greg. Val. to. 2. disp. 6▪ q. 12. p. 1. § 4. & qu. 13. p. 1.Staplet. de Iustif. l. 1. c. 13. Greg. Val. to. 2. disp. 6▪ q. 12. p. 1. § 4. & qu. 13. p. 1.
fAug. opere poster. con. Jul. lib. 2. c. 16.Aug. opere poster. con. Iul. lib. 2. c. 16.
gEpist. 106.
hDe Re•iss. peccat. l. 1. cap. 8. 9. 13. De natura & gratia. c. 9. De peccat. Orig. c. 14.
pThese and the like Antitheses unto Orthodox Doctrine did the Pelagians of old maintain. And (as it is the policy of Satan to keep alive those heresies which may seem to have most relief from proud and corrupted reason, and do principally tend to keep men from that due humiliation, and through-conviction of sin, which should drive them to Christ, and magnify the riches of Christs Grace to them) there are not wanting at this day a abrood of sinful men, who notwithstanding the evidence of Scripture, and the consent of all Antiquity, do in this Point concur with those wicked Heretics, and deny the original corruption of our nature to be any sin at all, but to be the work of Gods own hands in Paradise; nay deny further the very imputation of Adams sin to any of his posterity for sin. And now because in this point they do expressly contradict not only the bDoctrine of holy Scriptures, the cfoundation of Orthodox Faith, the dconsent of Ancient Doctors, and the eRule of the Catholic Church, but in no less then four or five particulars do manifestly oppose the doctrine of the Church of England in this Point most evidently delivered in fone article; for the Article saith, Man is Gone from original righteousness; they say, Man did not go away from it, but God snatched it away from man: the Article saith, that by Original sin Man is inclined unto evil, and calleth it by the name of concupiscence and lust, they say, that Original sin is only the privation of righteousness, and that concupiscence is a concreated ⟨p. 201⟩and original condition of nature: the Article saith, that the flesh lusteth always contrary to the spirit, they say in express terms, that this is false, and that the flesh when it lusteth indeed doth lust against nothing but the spirit, and that the Apostle in that place meant only the Galatians, and not all spiritual or regenerate men: the Article saith, that this lust deserveth Gods wrath and condemnation; they say, that it doth not deserve the hatred of God: and lastly, the Article saith, that the Apostle doth confess that concupiscence and lust hath of it self the nature of sin; they say, that it is not properly either a sin, or a punishment of sin, but only the condition of nature:
pThese and the like Antitheses unto Orthodox Doctrine did the Pelagians of old maintaine. And (as it is the policy of Satan to keepe alive those heresies which may seeme to have most reliefe from proud and corrupted reason, and doe principally tend to keepe men from that due humiliation, and through-conviction of sinne, which should drive them to Christ, and magnifie the riches of Christs Grace to them) there are not wanting at this day a abroode of sinfull men, who notwithstanding the evidence of Scripture, and the consent of all Antiquitie, doe in this Point concurre with those wicked Heretikes, and deny the originall corruption of our nature to bee any sinne at all, but to be the work of Gods owne hands in Paradise; nay deny further the very imputation of Adams sinne to any of his posterity for sinne. And now because in this point they doe expressely contradict not onely the bDoctrine of holy Scriptures, the cfoundation of Orthodox Faith, the dconsent of Ancient Doctors, and the eRule of the Catholike Church, but in no lesse then foure or five particulars doe manifestly oppose the doctrine of the Church of England in this Point most evidently delivered in fone article; for the Article saith, Man is Gone from originall righteousnesse; they say, Man did not goe away from it, but God snatched it away from man: the Article saith, that by Originall sinne Man is enclined unto evill, and calleth it by the name of concupiscence and lust, they say, that Originall sinne is onely the privation of righteousnes, and that concupiscence is a concreated ⟨p. 201⟩and originall condition of nature: the Article saith, that the flesh lusteth alwayes contrary to the spirit, they say in expresse termes, that this is false, and that the flesh when it lusteth indeed doth lust against nothing but the spirit, and that the Apostle in that place meant onely the Galatians, and not all spirituall or regenerate men: the Article saith, that this lust deserveth Gods wrath and condemnation; they say, that it doth not deserve the hatred of God: and lastly, the Article saith, that the Apostle doth confesse that concupiscence and lust hath of it selfe the nature of sinne; they say, that it is not properly either a sinne, or a punishment of sinne, but onely the condition of nature:
in all these respects it will be needful to lay down the truth of this great Point, and to vindicate it from the proud disputes of such bold Innovators.
in all these respects it will be needfull to lay downe the truth of this great Point, and to vindicate it from the proud disputes of such bold Innovators.
And first let us see by what steps and gradations the Adversaries of this so fundamental a doctrine (which as gSaint Austin saith is none of those in quibus optimi fidei Catholicae defensores salvâ fidei compage inter se aliquando […] consonant, wherein Orthodox Doctors may differ and abound in their own sense) do proceed to deny the sinfulness of that which all Ages of the Church have called Sin.
And first let us see by what steps and gradations the Adversaries of this so fundamentall a doctrine (which as gSaint Austin saith is none of those in quibus optimi fidei Catholicae defensores salvâ fidei compage inter se aliquando 〈…〉 consonant, wherein Orthodox Doctors may differ and abound in their owne sense) doe proceed to denie the sinfulnesse of that which all Ages of the Church have called Sinne.
First they say, That the aSin of Adam is not any way the sin of his posterity, that it is against the nature of sin, against the goodness, wisdom, and truth of God, against the rule of Equity and Justice, that Infants who are Innocent in themselves, should be accounted Nocent in another; therein taking away Baptism for remission of sins from Infants, who being not borne with guilt of Adams sin stand yet in no need of any purgation.
First they say, That the aSinne of Adam is not any way the sinne of his posterity, that it is against the nature of sinne, against the goodnesse, wisedome, and truth of God, against the rule of Equitie and Iustice, that Infants who are Innocent in themselves, should bee accounted Nocent iu another; therein taking away Baptisme for remission of sinnes from Infants, who being not borne with guilt of Adams sinne stand yet in no neede of any purgation.
aAnabaptists in their Dialogue of Predestination. Nec Scriptura, nec veracitas, nec sapientia, nec bonitas Divina, nec peccati natura, nec ratio justitiae atque aequitatis permittunt, ut dicamus, Deum posteros Adami revera censuisse eiusdem cum Adamo peccatireos. Remonstr. Apol. seu Exam. Cens. ca. 7 sect. 4. fol. 84.Anabaptists in their Dialogue of Predestination. Nec Scriptura, nec veracitas, nec sapientia, nec bonitas Divina, nec peccati natura, nec ratio iustitiae atque aequitatis permittunt, ut dicamus, Deum posteros Adami revera censuisse eiusdem cum Adamo peccatireos. Remonstr. Apol. seu Exam. Cens. ca. 7 sect. 4. fol. 84.
Secondly, they say that thoughb Adams sin may be thus far said to be unto posterity imputed; as that by reason of it they become obnoxious unto Death, (namely to an eternal dissolution of body and soul without any reunion, and an eternal loss of the divine vision, without any pain of sense) yet that death which to Adam in his person was a punishment, is not so to his posterity, but only the condition of their nature.
Secondly, they say that thoughb Adams sinne may be thus farre said to be unto posterity imputed; as that by reason of it they become obnoxious unto Death, (namely to an eternall dissolution of body and soule without any reunion, and an eternall losse of the divine vision, without any paine of sense) yet that death which to Adam in his person was a punishment, is not so to his posteritie, but onely the condition of their nature.
bCum Rem•nstrantes Adamum morti aeteraae [Sive ut supra dicunt Aeternae poenae damni] obnoxium factum fuisse dicunt cum poster is omnibus, non volunt mortem istam eodem prorsus modo inflictam fuisse utrisque tum Adamo •tum posteris, sed volunt eam inflictam fuisse Adamo ut transgressori-In posteros vero ejus propagatam propter conditionem natur• ejusdem quam ex Adamo peccatore trahunt. Ibid. cap 4. fol. 57.
Thirdly, they say thatc that which is called original sin is nothing else at all, but only the privation of original righteousness; and that concupiscence was […] contracted, and brought upon nature by sin, but was originally in our nature, suspended indeed by the presence, but actuated by the loss of that righteousness.
Thirdly, they say thatc that which is called originall sinne is nothing else at all, but onely the privation of originall righteousnesse; and that concupiscence was 〈…〉 contracted, and brought upon nature by sinne, but was originally in our nature, suspended indeede by the presence, but actuated by the losse of that righteousnesse.
cIidem in Confessi. seu declaratione sententiae circa articulos fidei. cap. 7. §. 4. Corvin. contr Molin▪ cap. 10. ad §. 4. & expressius cap. 8. ad §. 1, 2, 3. Pigh. contr.
Fourthly, they say,d That that Privation was not by man contracted, but by God inflicted as a punishment upon Adam from whom it comes, but only as a condition of nature unto us; that man in his fall and prevarication did not Throw away or actually shake off the Image of God, but God pulled it away from him; which if God had not done, it would have remained with him, notwithstanding the sin of the first fall.
Fourthly, they say,d That that Privation was not by man contracted, but by God inflicted as a punishment upon Adam from whom it comes, but onely as a condition of nature unto us; that man in his fall and prevarication did not Throw away or actually shake off the Image of God, but God pull'd it away from him; which if God had not done, it would have remained with him, notwithstanding the sinne of the first fall.
dRespons. ad Epistolam Walachr. pag. 88. In Apolog. seu Exam. Censur. ca. 7. §. 4. fol. 85. poenae non peccati respectum habetista car• tia, Corv. cont. Molin. cap. 8. pag. 122.
Fifthly, they say,e That in as much as the privation of original righteousness was a punishment by God upon Adam justly inflicted, and by Adam unto us naturally and unavoidably propagated, It is not therefore to be ⟨p. 203⟩esteemed any sin at all, neither for it can God justly condemn any man; nor is it to be esteemed a punishment of sin in us, though it were in Adam, because in us there is no sin going before it of which it may be accounted the punishment, as there was in Adam, but only the condition of our present nature.
Fifthly, they say,e That in as much as the privation of originall righteousnesse was a punishment by God upon Adam justly inflicted, and by Adam unto us naturally and unavoidably propagated, It is not therefore to be ⟨p. 203⟩esteem'd any sinne at all, neither for it can God justly condemne any man; nor is it to be esteem'd a punishment of sinne in us, though it were in Adam, because in us there is no sinne going before it of which it may bee accounted the punishment, as there was in Adam, but onely the condition of our present nature.
eCorv. ibid. pag. 122. 126, 127, 128. Malum culpae non est quia nasci plane est involuntarium: Et si malum culpae non est, nec potest •sse malum poenae, &c. Apol. ca. 7. fol. 84. 8. David did not sin in being conceiv'd and borne, ergo thereby he had no sin. Anabaptists in their Dialogue. atque hoc erat Pelagi• rum argumentum. Argui non debent quae vitari non possunt. Aug De natura & gra•. cap. 12. Infans aliud nisi quod natus est esse non potest, adeoque nec reus est dum Hoc est quod nascitur. Aug. cont. Jul▪ lib. 3. cap. 12. Our Divines unanimously withstand the doctrine of the Papists in this Point, that Concupiscence is natural and not sinfull. Whitak. De peccat. orig. lib. 3. Field of the Ch. lib. 3. cap. 26. Bishop Whites desp. 24.Corv. ibid. pag. 122. 126, 127, 128. Malum culpae non est quia nasci plane est involuntarium: Et si malum culpae non est, nec potest •sse malum poenae, &c. Apol. ca. 7. fol. 84. 8. David did not sinne in being conceiv'd and borne, ergo thereby he had no sinne. Anabaptists in their Dialogue. atque hoc erat Pelagi• rum argumentum. Argui non debent quae vitari non possunt. Aug De natura & gra•. cap. 12. Infans aliud nisi quod natus est esse non potest, adeoque nec reus est dum Hoc est quod nascitur. Aug. cont. Iul▪ lib. 3. cap. 12. Our Divines unanimously withstand the doctrine of the Papists in this Point, that Concupiscence is naturall and not sinfull. Whitak. De peccat. orig. lib. 3. Field of the Ch. lib. 3. cap. 26. Bishop Whites desp. 24.
Lastly, they say that Adam being by God deprived of original righteousness, (which is the faculty and fountain of all obedience) and being now constituted under the deserved curse,f all the debt of legal obedience, wherein he and his posterity in him were unto God obliged, did immediately cease; so that whatsoever outrages should after that have been by Adam or any of his children committed they would not have been sins, or transgressions, nor involved the Authors of them in the guilt of just damnation. That which unto us reviveth sin, is the new covenant; because therein is given unto the law new strength to command, and unto us new strength to obey, both which were evacuated in the fall of Adam. Upon which premises it doth most evidently follow; that unless God in Christ had made a covenant of grace with us anew, no man should ever have been properly and penally damned but only Adam; and he too, with no other then the loss of Gods presence: (For • Hell and torments are not the revenge of Legal, but of Evangelical disobedience) not for any actual sins, for there would have been none, because the exaction of ⟨p. 204⟩the Law would have ceased; and where there is no Law, there is no transgression; not for the want of righteousness, because that was in Adam himself but a punishment, and in his posterity neither a sin, nor a punishment, but only a condition of nature; not for habitual concupiscence, because though it be ah disease and an infirmity, yet it is no sin, both because the being of it is connatural and necessary, and the operations of it inevitable and unpreventable for want of that bridle of supernatural righteousness which was appointed to keep it in. Lastly, not for Adams sin imputed, because being committed by another mans will, it could be no mans sin but his that committed it.
Lastly, they say that Adam being by God deprived of originall righteousnesse, (which is the facultie and fountaine of all obedience) and being now constituted under the deserved curse,f all the debt of legall obedience, wherein he and his posteritie in him were unto God obliged, did immediately cease; so that whatsoever outrages should after that have beene by Adam or any of his children committed they would not have beene sinnes, or transgressions, nor involv'd the Authors of them in the guilt of iust damnation. That which unto us reviveth sin, is the new covenant; because therein is given unto the law new strength to command, and unto us new strength to obey, both which were evacuated in the fall of Adam. Vpon which premises it doth most evidently follow; that unlesse God in Christ had made a covenant of grace with us anew, no man should ever have beene properly and penally damned but onely Adam; and he too, with no other then the losse of Gods presence: (For • Hell and torments are not the revenge of Legall, but of Evangelicall disobedience) not for any actuall sinnes, for there would have beene none, because the exaction of ⟨p. 204⟩the Law would have ceased; and where there is no Law, there is no transgression; not for the want of righteousnesse, because that was in Adam himselfe but a punishment, and in his posteritie neither a sinne, nor a punishment, but onely a condition of nature; not for habituall concupiscence, because though it be ah disease and an infirmitie, yet it is no sinne, both because the being of it is connaturall and necessary, and the operations of it inevitable and unpreventable for want of that bridle of supernaturall righteousnesse which was appointed to keepe it in. Lastly, not for Adams sinne imputed, because being committed by another mans will, it could bee no mans sinne but his that committed it.
fLex prima cessabat primosoedere per inobedientiam primi hominis rupto, cessabat etiam obligatio ad obedientiam ed lege praescriptam. Lex aut ad obedientiam obligat, aut ad poenam; cum itaque homo jaceret sub maledictione ad obedientiam ampl•s non obligabatur, quia ab eo coli amplius Deus non vol•bat. Corv. contra Molin. cap. 8. ad §. 8. pag. 122. Remonstrantes negant actus illos qui sequuntur privationem divinam esse formaliter peccata, non negant quidem mate•aliter peccata dici posse, qua•nus Actus sunt difformes voluntati divinae, at negant cosformaliter esse peccata quaescil. ad p•nam valide obligent eos à quibus fiunt, &c. In Apolog. seu Exam Censur. cap. 7. fol. 86. • Ibid. fol. 83. b. Si Deus mortem temporalem comminatus fuisset Adamo, eiusque posteris, necesse fuisset Adamum eiusque posteros ex morte ista iterum resurgere, & postea in […] cruciatus praecipitari: De quo sane Scriptura ne [Greek or Hebrew] quidem meminit. De ijs qui Evangelium & apertam vitae aeternae promissionem respuunt ac reijciu•t ita loquitur Scriptura, de Adamo eiusque poster is nec volam habet nec vestigium. Deus non omnibus peccatis, id est, peccatoribus, adsignavit •ternam poenam sensus & damni. Ibid. cap. 7. […]. 90.Lex prima cessabat primosoedere per inobedientiam primi hominis rupto, cessabat etiam obligatio ad obedientiam ed lege praescriptam. Lex aut ad obedientiam obligat, aut ad poenam; cum itaque homo jaceret sub maledictione ad obedientiam ampl•s non obligabatur, quia ab eo coli amplius Deus non vol•bat. Corv. contra Molin. cap. 8. ad §. 8. pag. 122. Remonstrantes negant actus illos qui sequuntur privationem divinam esse formaliter peccata, non negant quidem mate•aliter peccata dici posse, qua•nus Actus sunt difformes voluntati divinae, at negant cosformaliter esse peccata quaescil. ad p•nam valide obligent eos à quibus fiunt, &c. In Apolog. seu Exam Censur. cap. 7. fol. 86. • Ibid. fol. 83. b. Si Deus mortem temporalem comminatus fuisset Adamo, eiusque posteris, necesse fuisset Adamum eiusque posteros ex morte ista iterum resurgere, & postea in 〈…〉 cruciatus praecipitari: De quo sane Scriptura ne quidem meminit. De ijs qui Evangelium & apertam vitae aeternae promissionem respuunt ac reijciut ita loquitur Scriptura, de Adamo eiusque poster is nec volam habet nec vestigium. Deus non omnibus peccatis, id est, peccatoribus, adsignavit ternam poenam sensus & damni. Ibid. cap. 7. . 90.
So that now upon these premises we are to invert the Apostles words, By one man, namely by Adam, sin entered into the world, upon all his posterity, and death by sin; By one man, namely by Christ (tanquam per causam sine quâ non) sinne returned into the world upon all Adams posterity, and with sin, the worst of all deaths, namely hellish torments, which without him should not have been at all. O how are we bound to praise God, and recount with all honour the memory of those Worthies who compiled Our Articles, which serve as a hedge to keep out this impious and mortiferous doctrine (asi Fulgentius calls it) from the Church of England, and suffers not Pelagius to return into his own country.
So that now upon these premises we are to invert the Apostles words, By one man, namely by Adam, sinne entered into the world, upon all his posterity, and death by sinne; By one man, namely by Christ (tanquam per causam sine quâ non) sinne returned into the world upon all Adams posteritie, and with sinne, the worst of all deaths, namely hellish torments, which without him should not haue beene at all. O how are wee bound to prayse God, and recount with all honour the memorie of those Worthies who compiled Our Articles, which serue as a hedge to keepe out this impious and mortiferous doctrine (asi Fulgentius cals it) from the Church of England, and suffers not Pelagius to returne into his owne country.
There are but three main arguments that I can meet with to colour this heresy, and two of them were the Pelagians of old. First,k that which is natural and by consequence necessary and unavoidable cannot be sin; lOriginal sin is natural, necessary, and unavoidable; therefore it is no sin. Secondly, thatm which is not voluntary cannot be sinful; nOriginal sin is not voluntary; therefore not sinful. Thirdly, noo sin is immediately caused by God; but original sin, being the privation ⟨p. 205⟩of original righteousness is from God immediately, who pulled away Adams righteousness from him; Therefore it is no sin.
There are but three maine arguments that I can meet with to colour this heresie, and two of them were the Pelagians of old. First,k that which is naturall and by consequence necessarie and unavoidable cannot be sinne; lOriginall sinne is naturall, necessarie, and unavoidable; therefore it is no sin. Secondly, thatm which is not voluntarie cannot be sinfull; nOriginall sinne is not voluntarie; therefore not sinfull. Thirdly, noo sinne is immediatly caused by God; but originall sinne, being the privation ⟨p. 205⟩of originall righteousnesse is from God immediately, who pull'd away Adams righteousnesse from him; Therfore it is no sinne.
kExam. Censur. c. 7. fol. 86 p. 8 & Pelag. apud Aug. De natura & gratia. cap. 12.
lExam. Censur. cap. 5. fol. 57. 8.
mIbid cap. 7. fol. 84. 8 & Pelag. apud Aug. cont. Jul. lib. 3. cap. 12.Ibid cap. 7. fol. 84. 8 & Pelag. apud Aug. cont. Iul. lib. 3. cap. 12.
For the more distinct understanding the whole truth, and answering these supposed strong reasons, give me leave to premise these observations by way of Hypothesis.
First, there are Two things in original sin, The privation of righteousness and the corruption of nature; for since original sin is the root of actual, and in actual sins there are both the omission of the good which we ought to exercise, and positive contuma•ies against the Law of God, therefore a vis formatrix, something answerable to both these must needs be found in original sin. This positive corruption (for in the other all agree that it is original sin) is that which thep Scripture calls fl•sh, and members, and law, and lusts, and body, and Saintq Austin, viciousness, inobedience or inordinateness, and a morbid affection: Consonant whereunto is ther Article of our Church, affirming, that man by original sin is far gone from righteousness, which is the privation; secondly that thereby he is of his own nature inclined unto evil, which is the pravity or corruption: and this is the doctrine ofs many learned papists.
First, there are Two things in originall sinne, The privation of righteousnesse and the corruption of nature; for since originall sinne is the roote of actuall, and in actuall sinnes there are both the omission of the good which we ought to exercise, and positive contuma•ies against the Law of God, therefore a vis formatrix, something answerable to both these must needs be found in originall sinne. This positive corruption (for in the other all agree that it is originall sinne) is that which thep Scripture cals fl•sh, and members, and law, and lusts, and bodie, and Saintq Austin, vitiousnesse, inobedience or inordinatenesse, and a morbid affection: Consonant whereunto is ther Article of our Church, affirming, that man by originall sinne is farre gone from righteousnesse, which is the privation; secondly that thereby he is of his owne nature enclined unto evill, which is the pravitie or corruption: and this is the doctrine ofs many learned papists.
Secondly, the Law beingt perfect and spiritual searcheth the most intimate corners of the soul, and reduceth under a law the very roots and principles of all humane operations: And therefore in a• much asu well being is the ground of well working, and that the Tree must be good before the fruit, therefore we conclude, ⟨p. 202⟩that the Law is not only the Rule of our works, but of our strength, not of our life only but of our nature, which being at first delivered into our hands entire and pure, cannot become degenerate, without the offence of those who did first betray so great a trust committed unto them. xThou shalt love the Lord thy God, Ex•ni vald• tuo, with all thy might, saith the Law; it doth not only require us to love, but to have minds furnished with all strength to love God, so that there may be life and vigour in our obedience and love of him. The Law requires no more love then strength, therefore if it did not of us require strength to love, but only suppose it, it could require no love neither, for the yApostle tells us that by nature we are without strength. So that if the meaning of the Law be only this, Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all the strength which thou hast; and not this, Thou shalt love him with all the strength that I require thee […] have, and that I at first gave thee (so that the strength and faculty, as well as the love and duty may c•dere sub pr•cepto, fall under the command) the meaning of the Law would amount but to this, Thou shalt not, or needest not to love the Lord thy God at all, because thou hast no strength so to do, and art not to be blamed for having none.
Secondly, the Law beingt perfect and spirituall searcheth the most intimate corners of the soule, and reduceth under a law the very rootes and principles of all humane operations: And therefore in a• much asu well being is the ground of well working, and that the Tree must be good before the fruite, therefore wee conclude, ⟨p. 202⟩that the Law is not onely the Rule of our workes, but of our strength, not of our life only but of our nature, which being at first deliver'd into our hands entire and pure, cannot become degenerate, without the offence of those who did first betray so great a trust committed unto them. xThou shalt loue the Lord thy God, Ex•ni vald• tuo, with all thy might, saith the Law; it doth not only require us to love, but to have mindes furnish'd with all strength to love God, so that there may be life and vigo• in our obedience and love of him. The Law requires no more love then strength, therefore if it did not of us require strength to love, but onely suppose it, it could require no love neither, for the yApostle tels us that by nature we are without strength. So that if the meaning of the Law be onely this, Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all the strength which thou hast; and not this, Thou shalt love him with all the strength that I require thee 〈…〉 have, and that I at first gave thee (so that the strength and faculty, as well as the love and duty may c•dere sub pr•cepto, fall under the command) the meaning of the Law would amount but to this, Thou shalt not, or needest not to love the Lord thy God at all, because thou hast no strength so to doe, and art not to be blamed for having none.
uMath. 7. 18 Absit ut sit in aliquo vera virtus qui ipse Justus non est. Aug. contr. Jul. l. 4. c. 3.Math. 7. 18 Absit ut sit in aliquo vera virtus qui ipse Iustus non est. Aug. contr. Iul. l. 4. c. 3.
xDeut. 6. 5. Luk. 10. 27. Lex etiam origines delictorum, id est, concupiscc•tias & voluntates non minus qu•mfacta conde•nat. Tertul de pud• cit. c. •.
cQui negat omnes homines primorum hominum peccato nasci obnoxios, ipsa Christianae fidei subvertere firmamenta conatur. Aug. cont. Julian. lib. 1. c. 2.Qui negat omnes homines primorum hominum peccato nasci obnoxios, ipsa Christianae fidei subvertere firmamenta conatur. Aug. cont. Iulian. lib. 1. c. 2.
dUid. Uoss. Histor Pelag. lib. 2. part. 1. Thesi. 6. Aug. cont. Jul. l. 1 c 23.Uid. Uoss. Histor Pelag. lib. 2. part. 1. Thesi. 6. Aug. cont. Iul. l. 1 c 23.
eInfants Baptizari• remissionem peccatorum secundum regulam universalis ecclesiae con•itemur. C•lestius Pelag. apud Aug. de peccat▪ original. lib. 2. c. 5.Infantes Baptizari• remissionem peccatorum secundum regulam universalis ecclesiae con•itemur. C•lestius Pelag. apud Aug. de peccat▪ original. lib. 2. c. 5.
fArtic. 9.
〈non-Latin alphabet〉
•
•
〈…〉
hUitium illud defectus est non peccatum. Corv. contr. Moli. • 8. ad §. 14. p. 128.