A14095:714
A discovery of D. Jacksons vanity. Or A perspective glass, whereby the admirers of…A discovery of D. Iacksons vanitie. Or A perspective glasse, wherby the admirers of…
A discovery of D. Jacksons vanity. Or A perspective glass, whereby the admirers of D. Jacksons profound discourses, may see the vanity and weakness of them, in sundry passages, and especially so far as they tend to the undermining of the doctrine hitherto received. Written by William Twice, Doctor of Divinity, as they say, from whom the copy came to the pressA discovery of D. Iacksons vanitie. Or A perspective glasse, wherby the admirers of D. Iacksons profound discourses, may see the vanitie and weaknesse of them, in sundry passages, and especially so farre as they tende to the undermining of the doctrine hitherto received. Written by William Twisse, Doctor of Divinitie, as they say, from whom the copie came to the presse
Amsterdam: printed by the successors of Giles Thorp, 1631
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
First you tell us of an extract or Corollary hereof thus; ⟨p. 267⟩It is impossible for ought that is not to be, &c. Is this the way you take to discover the simplicity of this fallacy? this savoureth strongly of your fallacious dealing; in as much as by collecting consequences you labour to discredit the syllogism, this surely is not to answer it. Besides not one of your consequences are sound, there is no ingenuity in the collection of them. For the conclusion of the former syllogism being this therefore, every thing that is comes to pass of necessity, your self have acknowledged this necessity to proceed in respect of Gods decree. And therefore what necessity of things soever you do infer herence, you must accordingly understand it in respect of Gods decree not otherwise. Now this necessity is but necessity secundum quid not simpliciter as the learned call it, and such as may stand with contingency, and possibility to the contrary. Like as the apprehension of a Traitor is a thing possible not to be and in its own nature merely contingent, but upon supposition that God hath ordained that such a Traitor shall be apprehended by certain means, you profess that the success of those means is absolutely necessary, which is as much as to say that the apprehension of that Traitor upon Gods ordaining it, is absolutely necessary; which is more then the divines whom you impugn as overlashing do use to say, or can in any sobriety of speech be justified. For if it must necessarily come to pass only upon supposition of Gods decree, then not absolutely but upon supposition.
First you tell us of an extract or Corollary hereof thus; ⟨p. 267⟩It is impossible for ought that is not to be, &c. Is this the way you take to discover the simplicity of this fallacy? this savoureth strongly of your fallacious dealing; in as much as by callecting consequences you labour to discredit the syllogisme, this surely is not to answere it. Besides not one of your consequences are sounde, there is no ingenuity in the collection of them. For the conclusion of the former syllogisme being this therefore, every thing that is comes to passe of necessity, your selfe have acknowledged this necessity to proceede in respect of Gods decree. And therefore what necessitie of thinges soever you doe inferr herence, you must accordingly understand it in respect of Gods decree not otherwise. Now this necessity is but necessity secundum quid not simpliciter as the learned call it, and such as may stand with contingency, and possibility to the contrary. Like as the apprehension of a Traytor is a thinge possible not to be and in its owne nature meerely contingent, but upon supposition that God hath ordeyned that such a Traytor shall be apprehended by certeyne meanes, you professe that the successe of those meanes is absolutely necessary, which is as much as to say that the apprehension of that Traytour upon Gods ordeyning it, is absolutely necessary; which is more then the divines whom you impugne as overlashing doe use to say, or can in any sobriety of speech be justified. For if it must necessarily come to passe onely upon supposition of Gods decree, then not absolutely but upon supposition.