An answer to a challenge madeAn ansvver to a challenge made
An answer to a challenge made by a Jesuit in Ireland Wherein the judgement of antiquity in the points questioned is truly delivered, and the novelty of the now romish doctrine plainly discovered. By James Usher Bishop of Meath.An ansvver to a challenge made by a Iesuite in Ireland Wherein the iudgement of antiquity in the points questioned is truely delivered, and the noveltie of the now romish doctrine plainly discovered. By Iames Vssher Bishop of Meath.
James Ussher 1581–1656Dublin: printed by the Society of Stationers and Eliot's Court Press, 1624Dublin: printed by the Societie of Stationers and Eliot's Court Press, 1624
[24], 527, [9] p. · 153k words · STC 24542 · ESTC S118933
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Thus far the Master of the Sentences: who is followed herein by the rest of the Schoolmen; who generally ⟨p. 143⟩agree, that the power of binding and loosing committed to the Ministers of the Church, is not absolute, but must be limited with Clave non errante, as being then only of force nwhen matters are carried with right judgement, and no error is committed in the use of the keys.
Thus farre the Master of the Sentences: who is followed herein by the rest of the Schoolemen; who generally ⟨p. 143⟩agree, that the power of binding and loosing committed to the Ministers of the Church, is not absolute, but must be limited with Clave non errante, as being then onely of force nwhen matters are carried with right iudgement, and no error is committed in the use of the keyes.
nQuod in terrâ Sacerdos clave non errante, & recto judicio procedens retinet, nec dimittit; Deus etiam in coelo retinet, nec dimittit. Tolet. comment. in Johan. 20.Quod in terrâ Sacerdos clave non errante, & recto iudicio procedens retinet, nec dimittit; Deus etiam in coelo retinet, nec dimittit. Tolet. comment. in Iohan. 20.
Our Saviour therefore must still have the privilege reserved unto him, of being the absolute Lord over his own house: it is sufficient for his officers, that they be esteemed as Moses was, o
unjust steward did, and presume to strike out their Masters debt without his direction, and contrary to his liking. Now we know that our Lord hath given no authority unto his stewards, to grant an acquittance unto any of his debtors, that bring not unfeigned faith and repentance with them.
Neither Angel nor Archangel can, neither yet the Lord himself, (who alone can say; I am with you) when we have sinned, doth release us, unless we bring repentance with us: saith S. Ambrose. and Eligius Bishop of Noyon, in his Sermon unto the Penitents:
Before all things it is necessary you should know, that howsoever you desire to receive the imposition of our hands; yet you cannot obtain the absolution of your sins, before the divine piety shall vouchsafe to absolve you by the grace of compunction. To think therefore that it lieth in the power of any Priest truly to
⟨p. 144⟩
absolve a man from his sins, without implying the condition of his believing and repenting as he ought to do; is both presumption and madness in the highest degree. Neither dareth Cardinal Bellarmine, who censureth this conditional absolution in us for idle and superfluous, when he hath considered better of the matter, assume unto himself, or communicate unto his brethren, the power of giving an absolute one. For he is driven to confess with other of his fellows, that when the Priest
saith, I absolve thee, he doth not affirm that he doth absolve absolutely; as not being ignorant, that it may many ways come to pass that he doth not absolve, although he pronounce those words: namely if he who seemeth to receive this Sacrament (for so they call it) peradventure hath no intention to receive it, or is not rightly disposed, or putteth some block in the way.
Our Saviour therefore must stil have the priviledge reserved unto him, of being the absolute Lord over his owne house: it is sufficient for his officers, that they bee esteemed as Moses was, ofaithfull in all his house as servants. The place wherein they serve, is a Stewards place: and the Apostle telleth them, pthat it is required in Stewards, that the man be found faithfull. They may not therefore carrie themselves in their office, as the qunjust steward did, and presume to strike out their Masters debt without his direction, and contrarie to his liking. Now we know that our Lord hath given no authoritie unto his stewards, to grant an acquittance unto anie of his debtors, that bring not unfayned faith and repentance with them. rNeyther Angell nor Archangell can, neyther yet the Lord himselfe, (who alone can say; I am with you) when we have sinned, doth release us, unlesse vvee bring repentance with us: saith S. Ambrose. and Eligius Bishop of Noyon, in his Sermon unto the Penitents: sBefore all things it is necessary you should know, that howsoever you desire to receive the imposition of our hands; yet you cannot obtaine the absolution of your sinnes, before the divine piety shall vouchsafe to absolve you by the grace of compunction. To thinke therefore that it lyeth in the power of anie Priest truely to ⟨p. 144⟩absolve a man from his sinnes, without implying the condition of his beleeving and repenting as he ought to doe; is both presumption and madnesse in the highest degree. Neyther dareth Cardinall Bellarmine, who censureth this conditionall absolution in us for idle and superfluous, when he hath considered better of the matter, assume unto himselfe, or communicate unto his brethren, the power of giving an absolute one. For he is driven to confesse with other of his fellowes, that when the Priest tsaith, I absolve thee, he doth not affirme that he doth absolve absolutely; as not being ignorant, that it may many wayes come to passe that he doth not absolve, although he pronounce those words: namely if hee who seemeth to receive this Sacrament (for so they call it) peradventure hath no intention to receive it, or is not rightly disposed, or putteth some blocke in the way.
rNec angelus potest, nec archangelus: Dominus ipse, (qui solus potest dicere; Ego vobiscum sum) si peccaverimus, nisi poenitentiam deferentibus non relaxat. Ambr. epist. 28. ad Theodosium Imp.
sAnte omnia autem vobis scire necesse est; quia licèt impositionem manuum nostrarum accipere cupiatis, tamen absolutionem peccatorum vestrorum consequi non potestis, antequàm per compunctionis gratiam divina pietas vos absolvere dignabitur. Eligius Noviomens. homil. 11. tom. 7. Biblioth. Patr. pag. 248. edit. Colon.Ante omnia autem vobis scire necesse est; quia licèt impositionem manuum nostrarum accipere cupiatis, tamen absolutionem peccatorum vestrorum consequi non potestis, antequàm per compunctionis gratiam divina pietas vos absolvere dignabitur. Eligius Nouiomens. homil. 11. tom. 7. Biblioth. Patr. pag. 248. edit. Colon.
tNam qui dicit; Ego te baptizo, vel absolvo, non affirmat se absoluté baptizare vel absolvere, eùm non ignoret, multis modis fieri posse, ut neque baptizet neque absolvat, licèt ea verba pronunciet: nimi•um si is, qui Sacramentum suscipere videtur, fortè non habeat suscipiendi intentionem, vel non sit ritè dispositus, aut obicem ponat. Igitur Minister illis verbis nihil aliud significat, nisi se, quod in se est, Sacramentum reconciliationis vel absolutionis impendere, quod vim habet in homine disposito peccata omnia dimittendi. Bellarmin. de Poenitent. lib. 2. cap. 14. sect. penult.
Therefore the Minister (saith he) signifieth nothing else by those words, but that he, as much as in him lieth, conferreth the sacrament of reconciliation or absolution, which in a man rightly disposed hath virtue to forgive all his sins.
Therefore the Minister (saith hee) signifieth nothing else by those words, but that hee, as much as in him lyeth, conferreth the sacrament of reconciliation or absolution, which in a man rightly disposed hath vertue to forgive all his sinnes.
Now that Contrition is at all times necessarily required for obtaining remission of sins and justification, is a matter determined by the Fathers of uTrent. But mark yet the mystery. They equivocate with us in the term of Contrition: and make a distinction thereof into perfect and imperfect. The former of these is Contrition properly: the latter they call Attrition. which howsoever in it self it be not true Contrition, yet when the Priest with his power of forgiving sins ⟨p. 145⟩interposeth himself in the business, they tell us that xattrition by virtue of the keys is made contrition: that is to say, that a sorrow arising from a servile fear of punishment, and such a fruitless yrepentance as the reprobate may carry with them to hell, by virtue of the Priests absolution is made so fruitful, that it shall serve the turn for obtaining forgiveness of sins; as if it had been that zgodly sorrow which worketh repentance to salvation not to be repented of. By which spiritual cozenage, many poor souls are most miserably deluded, while they persuade themselves that upon the receipt of the Priests acquittance upon this carnal sorrow of theirs, all scores are cleared until that day: and then beginning upon a new reckoning, they sin and confess, confess and sin afresh, and tread this round so long till they put off all thought of saving repentance; and so the ablind following the blind, both at last fall into the pit.
Now that Contrition is at all times necessarily required for obtayning remission of sinnes and iustification, is a matter determined by the Fathers of uTrent. But marke yet the mysterie. They equivocate with us in the terme of Contrition: and make a distinction thereof into perfect and imperfect. The former of these is Contrition properly: the latter they call Attrition. which howsoever in it selfe it be not true Contrition, yet when the Priest with his power of forgiving sinnes ⟨p. 145⟩interposeth himselfe in the businesse, they tell us that xattrition by vertue of the keyes is made contrition: that is to say, that a sorrow arising from a servile feare of punishment, and such a fruitlesse yrepentance as the reprobate may carry with them to hell, by vertue of the Priests absolution is made so fruitfull, that it shall serve the turne for obteyning forgivenesse of sinnes; as if it had beene that zgodly sorrow which worketh repentance to salvation not to be repented of. By which spirituall coosenage, many poore soules are most miserably deluded, while they perswade themselves that upon the receipt of the Priests acquittance upon this carnall sorrow of theirs, all skores are cleered untill that day: and then beginning upon a new reckoning, they sinne and confesse, confesse and sinne afresh, and tread this round so long till they put off all thought of saving repentance; and so the ablinde following the blinde, both at last fall into the pit.
uConcil. Tridentin. sess. 14. cap. 4.
xA•t•i•io virtute clavium sit contritio. Romani Corrector•s Gloss. Gratiani, De poeni•ent. d•stinct. 1. in principi•: & alij passion.A•t•i•io virtute clavium sit contritio. Romani Corrector•s Gloss. Gratiani, De poeni•ēt. d•stinct. 1. in principi•: & alij passi•n.
bEvil and wicked, carnal, natural, and devilish men (saith S. Augustin) imagine those things to be given unto them by their seducers, which are only the gifts of God, whether sacraments, or any other spiritual works, concerning their present salvation. But such as are thus seduced, may do well to listen a little to this grave admonition of S. Cyprian. cLet no man deceive, let no man beguile himself: it is the Lord alone that can show mercy. He alone can grant pardon to the sins committed against ⟨p. 146⟩him, who did himself bear our sins, who suffered grief for us, whom God did deliver for our sins. Man cannot be greater then God; neither can the servant by his indulgence remit or pardon that which by heinous trespass is committed against the Lord: lest to him that is fallen this yet be added as a further crime, if he be ignorant of that which is said; Cursed is the man that putteth his trust in man. Whereupon S. Augustin sticketh not to say, that good ministers do consider that dthey are but ministers, they would not be held for Judges, they abhor that any trust should be put in them: and that the power of remitting and retaining sins is committed unto the Church, to be dispensed therein, enot according to the arbitrement of man, but according to the arbitrement of God. Whereas our adversaries lay the foundation of their Babel upon another ground: that fChrist hath appointed Priests to be Judges upon earth with such power, that none falling into sin after Baptism may be reconciled without their sentence; and hath gput the authority of binding and loosing, of forgiving and retaining the sins of men, in their arbitrement.
bEvill and wicked, carnall, naturall, and divellish men (saith S. Augustin) imagine those things to be given unto them by their seducers, which are onely the gifts of God, whether sacraments, or any other spirituall workes, concerning their present salvation. But such as are thus seduced, may doe well to listen a little to this grave admonition of S. Cyprian. cLet no man deceive, let no man beguile himselfe: it is the Lord alone that can shew mercy. He alone can grant pardon to the sinnes committed against ⟨p. 146⟩him, who did himselfe beare our sinnes, who suffered griefe for us, whom God did deliver for our sinnes. Man cannot be greater then God; neyther can the servant by his indulgence remit or pardon that which by haynous trespasse is committed against the Lord: lest to him that is fallen this yet be added as a further crime, if hee be ignorant of that which is said; Cursed is the man that putteth his trust in man. Whereupon S. Augustin sticketh not to say, that good ministers doe consider that dthey are but ministers, they would not be held for Iudges, they abhorre that any trust should be put in them: and that the power of remitting and retayning sinnes is committed unto the Church, to be dispensed therein, enot according to the arbitrement of man, but according to the arbitrement of God. Whereas our adversaries lay the foundation of their Babel upon another ground: that fChrist hath appointed Priests to be Iudges upon earth with such power, that none falling into sinne after Baptisme may be reconciled without their sentence; and hath gput the authoritie of binding and loosing, of forgiving and retayning the sinnes of men, in their arbitrement.
bMali & facinorosi, carnales, animals, diabolici, á seductoribus suis sibi da•i arbitrantur, quae non nisi munera Dei sunt, sive sacramenta sive spiritales aliquas operations, circa praesentem salutem. August. de Baptism. contra Donatist lib. 3. cap. ult.Mali & facinorosi, carnales, animales, diabolici, á seductoribus suis sibi da•i arbitrantur, quae non nisi munera Dei sunt, sive sacramenta sive spiritales aliquas operationes, circa praesentem salutem. August. de Baptism. contra Donatist lib. 3. cap. ult.
cNemo see fallat, nemo see decipiat: solus Dominus misereri potest. Veniam peccatis, quae in ipsum commissa sunt, solus potest ille largiri, qui peccata nostra portavit, qui pro nobis doluit, quem Deus tradidit pro peccatis nostris. Homo Deo esse non potest major; nec remittere aut donare indulgentiâ suâ servus potest, quod in Dominum delicto graviore commissum est: ne adhuc lapso & hoc accedat ad crimen, si nesciat esse praedictum; Maledictus homo qui spem habet in homine. Cyprian. de Lapsis (sect. 7. edit. Pamel. 14. Goulart.)Nemo se fallat, nemo se decipiat: solus Dominus misereri potest. Veniam peccatis, quae in ipsum commissa sunt, solus potest ille largiri, qui peccata nostra portavit, qui pro nobis doluit, quem Deus tradidit pro peccatis nostris. Homo Deo esse non potest major; nec remittere aut donare indulgentiâ suâ servus potest, quod in Dominum delicto graviore commissum est: ne adhuc lapso & hoc accedat ad crimen, si nesciat esse praedictum; Maledictus homo qui spem habet in homine. Cyprian. de Lapsis (sect. 7. edit. Pamel. 14. Goulart.)
dMinistri enim sunt, pro •udicibus haberi nolunt, spem in se pony exhorrescunt. August. in Evangel. Johan. tract. 5.Ministri enim sunt, pro •udicibus haberi nolunt, spem in se poni exhorrescunt. August. in Evangel. Iohan. tract. 5.
eNo secundùm arbitrium hominum, sed secundùm arbitrium Dei. August. de Baptism. contra Donatist. lib. 3. cap. 18.
fChristus instituit Sacerdotes judices super terram cum eâ potestate, ut sine ipsorum sententiâ nemo post Baptismū lapsus reconciliari possit. Bellarm. de Poenit. lib. 3. cap. 2.Christus instituit Sacerdotes iudices super terram cum eâ potestate, ut sine ipsorum sententiâ nemo post Baptismū lapsus reconciliari possit. Bellarm. de Poenit. lib. 3. cap. 2.
Whether the Ministers of the Gospel may be accounted Judges in some sort, we will not much contend: for we dislike neither that saying of S. Hierome, that hhaving the keys of the kingdom of heaven, they judge after a sort before the day of judgement; nor that other of S. Gregory, that the Apostles, & such as succeed them in the government of the Church, iobtain a principality of judgement from above, that they may in Gods stead ⟨p. 147⟩retain the sins of some, and release the sins of others. All the question is, in what sort they do judge, and whether the validity of their judgement do depend upon the truth of the conversion of the penitent: wherein if our Romanists would stand to the judgement of S. Hierome or S. Gregory (one of whom they make a Cardinal, and the other a Pope of their own Church) the controversy betwixt us would quickly be at an end. For S. Hierome, expounding that speech of our Saviour, touching the keys of the kingdom of heaven, in the sixteenth of S. Matthew; kThe Bishops and Priests, saith he, not understanding this place, assume to themselves somewhat of the Pharisees arrogance: as imagining, that they may either condemn the innocent, or absolve the guilty; whereas it is not the sentence of the Priests, but the life of the parties that is inquired of with God. In the book of Leviticus we read of the Lepers, where they are commanded to show themselves to the Priests, and if they shall have the leprosy, that then they shall be made unclean by the Priest. not that the Priests should make them leprous and unclean, but that they should take notice who was a leper and who was not, and should discern who was clean and who unclean. Therefore as there the Priest doth make the leper clean or unclean; so here the Bishop or Priest doth bind or loose: not bind the innocent, or loose the guilty; but when according to his office he heareth the variety of sins, he knoweth who is to be bound and who to be loosed. Thus far S. Hierome.
Whether the Ministers of the Gospell may be accounted Iudges in some sort, we wil not much contend: for we dislike neyther that saying of S. Hierome, that hhaving the keyes of the kingdome of heaven, they judge after a sort before the day of judgement; nor that other of S. Gregory, that the Apostles, & such as succeed them in the governement of the Church, iobtaine a principalitie of judgement from above, that they may in Gods stead ⟨p. 147⟩retayne the sinnes of some, and release the sinnes of others. All the question is, in what sort they doe judge, and whether the validitie of their judgement doe depend upon the truth of the conversion of the penitent: wherein if our Romanists would stand to the iudgement of S. Hierome or S. Gregory (one of whom they make a Cardinall, and the other a Pope of their owne Church) the controversie betwixt us would quickly be at an end. For S. Hierome, expounding that speech of our Saviour, touching the keyes of the kingdome of heaven, in the sixteenth of S. Matthew; kThe Bishops and Priests, saith he, not understanding this place, assume to themselves somewhat of the Pharisees arrogancie: as imagining, that they may either condemne the innocent, or absolve the guiltie; vvhereas it is not the sentence of the Priests, but the life of the parties that is inquired of vvith God. In the booke of Leviticus vvee reade of the Lepers, vvhere they are commanded to shew themselves to the Priests, and if they shall have the leprosie, that then they shall be made uncleane by the Priest. not that the Priests should make them leprous and uncleane, but that they should take notice who was a leper and who was not, and should discerne who was cleane and who uncleane. Therefore as there the Priest doth make the leper cleane or uncleane; so here the Bishop or Priest doth binde or loose: not binde the innocent, or loose the guiltie; but when according to his office hee heareth the variety of sinnes, hee knoweth who is to be bound and who to be loosed. Thus farre S. Hierome.
hQui claves regni coelorum habentes, quodammodo ante judicii diem judicant. Hieronym. epist. 1. ad Heliodorum.Qui claves regni coelorum habentes, quodammodo ante iudicii diem iudicant. Hieronym. epist. 1. ad Heliodorum.
iPrincipatum superni judicii sortiuntur, ut vice Dei quibusdam peccata retineant, quibusdam relaxent. Gregor. h•mil. 26. in Evangel.Principatum superni iudicii sortiuntur, ut vice Dei quibusdam peccata retineant, quibusdam relaxent. Gregor. h•mil. 26. in Evangel.
kIstum locū Episcopi & Presbyteri non intelligentes, aliquid sibi de Pharisaeorum assumunt supercilio: ut vel damnent innocentes vel solvere se noxios arbitrentur: cùm apud Deū non sententia Sacerdotum, sed reorum vita quaer•tur Legimus in Levitico de leprosis, ubi jubentur, ut ostendant se Sacerdotibus, & si lepram habuerint, tunc á Sacerdote immundi fiant: non quò Sacerdotes leprosos f•ciant & immundos: sed quò habeant notitiam leprosi & non leprosi, & possint discernere, qui mundus quive immundus sit. Quomodo ergo ibi leprosum Sacerdos mundum vel immundum facit: sic & hî alligat vel solvit Episcopus & Presbyter, non eos qui insontes sunt vel noxii, sed pro officio suo, cùm peccatorum audierit varietates, scit qui ligandus scit quive solvendus, Hieronym. commentar. in Matth. cap. 16.Istum locū Episcopi & Presbyteri non intelligentes, aliquid sibi de Pharisaeorum assumunt supercilio: ut vel damnent innocentes vel solvere se noxios arbitrentur: cùm apud Deū non sententia Sacerdotum, sed reorum vita quaer•tur Legimus in Levitico de leprosis, ubi iubentur, ut ostendant se Sacerdotibus, & si lepram habuerint, tunc á Sacerdote immundi fiant: non quò Sacerdotes leprosos f•ciant & immundos: sed quò habeant notitiam leprosi & non leprosi, & possint discernere, qui mundus quive immundus sit. Quomodo ergo ibi leprosum Sacerdos mundum vel immundum facit: sic & hî alligat vel solvit Episcopus & Presbyter, non eos qui insontes sunt vel noxii, sed pro officio suo, cùm peccatorum audierit varietates, scit qui ligandus scit quive solvendus, Hieronym. commentar. in Matth. cap. 16.
S. Gregory likewise in the very same place from whence the Romanists fetch that former sentence, doth thus declare in what manner that principality of judgement, which he spake of, should be exercised: being therein also followed step by step, by the Fathers of the Council of Aquisgran. lThe causes ought to be weighed, and then the power of binding and loosing exercised. It is to be seen, what the fault is, and what the repentance is that hath followed after the fault: that such as almighty God doth visit with the grace of compunction, those the sentence of the Pastor may absolve. For the absolution of the Prelate is then true, when it followeth the arbitrement of the eternal Judge. And this do they illustrate by that which we read in the Gospel of the raising of Lazarus, Joh. 11.44. that Christ did first of all give life to him that was dead by himself, and then commanded others to loose him, and let him go. mBehold (say they) the disciples do loose him being now alive; whom their Master had raised up being dead. For if the disciples had loosed Lazarus being dead: they should have discovered a stink more then a virtue. By which consideration we may see: that by our Pastoral authority we ought to loose those, whom we know that our Author and Lord hath revived with his quickening grace. The same application also do we find made, not only by nPeter Lombard, and other of the Schoolmen, but also by Judocus Clichtoveus, not long before the time of the Council of Trent. ⟨p. 149⟩oLazarus (saith Clichtoveus) first of all came forth alive out of the sepulchre, and then was commandment given by our Lord that he should be loosed by the disciples and suffered to go his way: because the Lord doth first inwardly by himself quicken the sinner, and afterwards absolveth him by the Priests ministry. For no sinner is to be absolved, before it appeareth that he be amended by due repentance, and be quickened inwardly. But inwardly to quicken the sinner, is the office of God alone, who saith by the Prophet: I am he that blotteth out your iniquities.
S. Gregory likewise in the very same place from whence the Romanists fetch that former sentence, doth thus declare in what maner that principalitie of iudgement, which he spake of, should be exercised: being therin also followed step by step, by the Fathers of the Councell of Aquisgran. lThe causes ought to bee weighed, and then the power of binding and loosing exercised. It is to be seene, what the fault is, and what the repentance is that hath followed after the fault: that such as almightie God doth visite with the grace of compunction, those the sentence of the Pastor may absolve. For the absolution of the Prelate is then true, when it followeth the arbitrement of the eternall Iudge. And this doe they illustrate by that which we reade in the Gospell of the raysing of Lazarus, Ioh. 11.44. that Christ did first of all give life to him that was dead by himselfe, and then commanded others to loose him, and let him goe. mBehold (say they) the disciples doe loose him being now alive; whom their Master had raysed up being dead. For if the disciples had loosed Lazarus being dead: they should have discovered a stinche more then a vertue. By which consideration vvee may see: that by our Pastorall authoritie vvee ought to loose those, vvhom vvee know that our Authour and Lord hath revived vvith his quickning grace. The same application also doe wee finde made, not onely by nPeter Lombard, and other of the Schoolemen, but also by Iudocus Clichtoveus, not long before the time of the Councell of Trent. ⟨p. 149⟩oLazarus (saith Clichtoveus) first of all came forth alive out of the sepulchre, and then was commandement given by our Lord that hee should be loosed by the disciples and suffered to go his way: because the Lord doth first inwardly by himselfe quicken the sinner, and afterwards absolveth him by the Priests ministerie. For no sinner is to be absolved, before it appeareth that hee be amended by due repentance, and bee quickned inwardly. But inwardly to quicken the sinner, is the office of God alone, who saith by the Prophet: I am he that blotteth out your iniquities.
lCaussae ergo pensandae sunt, & tunc ligandi atque solvendi potestas exercenda. Videndū est quae culpa, aut quae sit poenitentia secuta post culpam: ut quos omnipotens Deus per compunctionis gratiam visitat, illos Pastoris sententia absolvat. Tunc enim vera est absolutio praesidentis: cùm aeterni arbitrium sequitur Judicis. Gregor. in Evangel. homil. 26. Concil. Aquisgran. cap. 37.Caussae ergo pensandae sunt, & tunc ligandi atque solvendi potestas exercenda. Videndū est quae culpa, aut quae sit poenitentia secuta post culpam: ut quos omnipotens Deus per compunctionis gratiam visitat, illos Pastoris sententia absolvat. Tunc enim vera est absolutio praesidentis: cùm aeterni arbitrium sequitur Iudicis. Gregor. in Evangel. homil. 26. Concil. Aquisgran. cap. 37.
mEcce illum discipuli jam viventem solvunt: quem magister resuscitaverat mortuum. Si enim discipuli Lazarum mortuum solverent: foetorem magis ostenderent quàm virtutem. Ex quâ consideratione intuendum est: quòd illos nos debemus per pastoralem auctoritatem solver, quos auctorem nostrum cognoscimus per suscitantem gratiam vivificare. •idem ibidem. & El•gius Noviomens homil. 11. tom. 7: Bibliothec. Pa•r. pag. 248. edit. Colon.Ecce illum discipuli iam viventem solvunt: quem magister resuscitaverat mortuum. Si enim discipuli Lazarum mortuum solverent: foetorem magis ostenderent quàm virtutem. Ex quâ consideratione intuendum est: quòd illos nos debemus per pastoralem auctoritatem solvere, quos auctorem nostrum cognoscimus per suscitantem gratiam vivificare. •idem ibidem. & El•gius Noviomens homil. 11. tom. 7: Bibliothec. Pa•r. pag. 248. •dit. Colon.
nP. Lombard. lib. 4. Sent. dist. 18. lit. f. Alexand. de Hales, Summ. part. 4. quaest. 2•. membr. 1. &c.
oSed ante prodiit redivivus Lazarus ex s•pulchro, & deinde ut solveretur á discipulis & sineretur abire á Domino jussum est: quia peccatorem etiam consuetudine committendi reatus gravatū, priùs Dominus intrinsecus per seipsum vivificat, postea veró eundem per Sacerdotum ministeriū absolvit. Nullus quippe peccator absolvendus est, antequam per dignam poenitentiam correctus, & intrinsecùs appareat vivificatus. Vivificare autem interiùs peccatorē solius Dei munus est, qui per Prophtam dicit: Ego sum qui deleo iniquitates vestras. Clichtov. in Evangel. Joann. lib. 7. cap. 23. inter opera Cyrilli.
The truth therefore of the Priests absolution, dependeth upon the truth and sincerity of Gods quickening grace in the heart of the Penitent: which if it be wanting, all the absolutions in the world will stand him in no stead. For example, our Saviour saith: pIf ye forgive men their trespasses, your heavenly Father will also forgive you; but, if ye forgive not men their trespasses, neither will your Father forgive your trespasses. and in this respect (as is observed by Sedulius) qin other mens persons we are either absolved or bound:
— rgraviusque soluti
Nectimur, alterius si solver vincla negamus.
Suppose now, that a man who cannot find in his heart to forgive the wrong done unto him by another, is absolved here by the Priest from all his sins (according to the usual form of Absolution:) are we to think that what is thus loosed upon earth, shall be loosed in heaven? and that Christ, to make the Priests word true, will make his own false? And what we say of charity toward man, must much more be understood of the love of God and the love of righteousness: the ⟨p. 150⟩defect whereof is not to be supplied by the absolution of any Priest. It hath been always observed for a special difference betwixt good and bad men, that the one shated sin for the love of virtue, the other only for the fear of punishment. The like difference do our Adversaries make betwixt Contrition and Attrition: tthat the hatred of sin, in the one proceedeth from the love of God and of righteousness; in the other, from the fear of punishment. and yet teach for all this, that uAttrition (which they confess would not otherwise suffice to justify a man) being joined with the Priests Absolution, is sufficient for that purpose: he that was attrite being by virtue of this Absolution made contrite, and justified, that is to say, he that was led only by a servile fear, and consequently was to be ranked among disordered and evil persons, being by this means put in as good case for the matter of the forgiveness of his sins, as he that loveth God sincerely. For they themselves do grant, that xsuch as have this servile fear, from whence Attrition issueth, are to be accounted evil and disordered men, by reason of their want of charity: to which purpose also they allege that saying of Gregory, Recti diligunt te, non recti adhuc timent te.
The truth therefore of the Priests absolution, dependeth upon the truth and sinceritie of Gods quickning grace in the heart of the Penitent: which if it be wanting, all the absolutions in the world will stand him in no stead. For example, our Saviour saith: pIf yee forgive men their trespasses, your heavenly Father will also forgive you; but, if ye forgive not men their trespasses, neyther will your Father forgive your trespasses. and in this respect (as is observed by Sedulius) qin other mens persons we are eyther absolved or bound:
— rgraviusque soluti
Nectimur, alterius si solvere vincla negamus.
Suppose now, that a man who cannot find in his heart to forgive the wrong done unto him by another, is absolved here by the Priest from all his sinnes (according to the usuall forme of Absolution:) are wee to thinke that what is thus loosed upon earth, shall be loosed in heaven? and that Christ, to make the Priests word true, will make his owne false? And what wee say of charitie toward man, must much more be understood of the love of God and the love of righteousnesse: the ⟨p. 150⟩defect whereof is not to be supplyed by the absolution of anie Priest. It hath beene alwayes observed for a speciall difference betwixt good and bad men, that the one shated sinne for the love of vertue, the other onely for the feare of punishment. The like difference do our Adve•saries make betwixt Contrition and Attrition: tthat the hatred of sinne, in the one proceedeth from the love of God and of righteousnesse; in the other, from the feare of punishment. and yet teach for all this, that uAttrition (which they confesse would not otherwise suffice to justifie a man) being ioyned with the Priests Absolution, is sufficient for that purpose: he that was attrite being by vertue of this Absolution made contrite, and iustified, that is to say, hee that was led onely by a servile feare, and consequently was to be rancked among disordered and evill persons, being by this meanes put in as good case for the matter of the forgivenesse of his sinnes, as hee that loveth God sincerely. For they themselves doe graunt, that
pM•tth. 6.14, 15. &c. 18.35.
qIn aliorum personis aut absolvimur aut ligamur. Sedul. lib. 2. Paschalis Operis, cap. 11.
tFatemur enim perfectum odium peccati esse illud, quod ex amore Dei, justitiaeque procedit; & ideò dolorem, sive odium ex timore poenae conceptū, non Contritionem, sed Attritionē nominamus. B•llarm. lib. 2. de Poenitent. cap. 18.Fatemur enim perfectum odium peccati esse illud, quod ex amore Dei, justitiaeque procedit; & ideò dolorem, sive odium ex timore poenae conceptū, non Contritionem, sed Attritionē nominamus. B•llarm. lib. 2. de Poenitent. cap. 18.
uId. ibid.
xArgumentū recté probat eos, qui timorem servilem habeat, inordinatos ac malos esse &c. Id. ibid.Argumentū recté probat eos, qui timorem servilem habeat, inordinatos ac malos esse &c. Id. ibid.
But they have taken an order notwithstanding, that non recti shall stand recti in curiâ with them: by assuming a strange authority unto themselves of justifying the wicked (a thing, we know, that hath the curse of yGod and zman threatened unto it) & making men friends with God, that have not the love of God dwelling in them. For although we be taught by the word of God, that aperfect love casteth out fear; that we ⟨p. 151⟩bhave not received the spirit of bondage to fear again, but the spirit of adoption whereby we cry Abba, father; that mount Sinai (which cmaketh those that come unto it to fear and quake) dengendereth to bondage, and is to be cast out with her children, from inheriting the promise; & that ewithout love, both we our selves are nothing, and all that we have doth profit us nothing: yet these wonderful men would have us believe, that by their word alone they are able to make something of this nothing; that fear without love shall make men capable of the benefit of their pardon, as well as love without fear; that whether men come by the way of mount Sinai or mount Zion, whether they have Legal or Evangelical repentance, they have authority to absolve them from all their sins. as if it did lye in their power, to confound Gods Testaments at their pleasure, and to give unto a servile fear not the benefit of manumission only, but the privilege of adoption also; by making the children of the bondwoman children of the promise, and giving them a portion in that blessed inheritance together with the children of her that is free.
But they have taken an order notwithstanding, that non recti shall stand recti in curiâ with them: by assuming a strange authoritie unto themselves of iustifying the wicked (a thing, we know, that hath the curse of yGod and zman threatned unto it) & making men friends with God, that have not the love of God dwelling in them. For although we be taught by the word of God, that aperfect love casteth out feare; that wee ⟨p. 151⟩bhave not received the spirit of bondage to feare againe, but the spirit of adoption whereby wee cry Abba, father; that mount Sinai (which cmaketh those that come unto it to feare and quake) dengendreth to bondage, and is to be cast out with her children, from inheriting the promise; & that ewithout love, both we our selves are nothing, and all that we have doth profit us nothing: yet these wonderfull men would have us beleeve, that by their word alone they are able to make something of this nothing; that feare without love shall make men capable of the benefite of their pardon, as well as love without feare; that whether men come by the way of mount Sinai or mount Sion, whether they have Legall or Evangelicall repentance, they have authoritie to absolve them from all their sinnes. as if it did lye in their power, to confound Gods Testaments at their pleasure, and to give unto a servile feare not the benefite of manumission only, but the priviledge of adoption also; by making the children of the bondwoman children of the promise, and giving them a portion in that blessed inheritance together with the children of her that is free.
fRepentance from dead works, is one of the foundations and principles of the doctrine of Christ. gNothing maketh repentance certain, but the hatred of sin, and the love of God. and without true repentance all the Priests under heaven are not able to give us a discharge from our sins, and deliver us from the wrath to come. hExcept ye be converted, ye shall not enter into the kingdom of heaven. iExcept ye repent, ye shall all perish: is the Lords saying in the new Testament. and in the old: kRepent, and turn from all your transgressions: so iniquity shall not be your ruin. Cast away from ⟨p. 152⟩you all your transgressions, whereby ye have transgressed, and make you a new heart and a new spirit: for why will ye dye, O house of Israel? Now put case one cometh to his ghostly father, with such sorrow of mind as the terrors of a guilty conscience usually do produce, and with such a resolution to cast away his sins, as a man hath in a storm to cast away his goods, not because he doth not love them, but because he feareth to loose his life if he part not with them: doth not he betray this mans soul, who putteth into his head, that such an extorted repentance as this, which hath not one grain of love to season it withal, will qualify him sufficiently for the receiving of an absolution, by I know not what sacramental faculty that the Priest is furnished withal to that purpose? For all do confess with S. Augustin, that lthis fear which loveth not justice, but dreadeth punishment, is servile, because it is carnal, and therefore doth not crucify the flesh. For the willingness to sin liveth, which then appeareth in the work, when impunity is hoped for: but when it is believed that punishment will follow, it liveth closely, yet it liveth. For it would wish rather, that it were lawful to do that which the Law forbiddeth, and is sorry that it is not lawful: because it is not spiritually delighted with the good thereof, but carnally feareth the evil which it doth threaten. What man then, do we think, will take the pains to get him a new heart and a new spirit, and undertake the toilsome work of crucifying the flesh with the lusts thereof;
fRepentance from dead workes, is one of the foundations and principles of the doctrine of Christ. gNothing maketh repentance certaine, but the hatred of sinne, and the love of God. and without true repentance all the Priests under heaven are not able to give us a discharge from our sinnes, and deliver us from the wrath to come. hExcept ye be converted, ye shall not enter into the kingdome of heaven. iExcept yee repent, yee shall all perish: is the Lords saying in the new Testament. and in the old: kRepent, and turne from all your transgressions: so iniquitie shall not be your ruine. Cast away from ⟨p. 152⟩you all your transgressions, whereby yee have transgressed, and make you a new heart and a new spirit: for why will yee dye, O house of Israel? Now put case one commeth to his ghostly father, with such sorrow of minde as the terrours of a guiltie conscience usually doe produce, and with such a resolution to cast away his sins, as a man hath in a storme to cast away his goods, not because he doth not love them, but because he feareth to loose his life if he part not with them: doth not he betray this mans soule, who putteth into his head, that such an extorted repentance as this, which hath not one graine of love to season it withall, wil qualifie him sufficiently for the receiving of an absolution, by I know not what sacramentall facultie that the Priest is furnished withall to that purpose? For all doe confesse with S. Augustin, that lthis feare which loveth not justice, but dreadeth punishment, is servile, because it is carnall, and therefore doth not crucifie the flesh. For the willingnesse to sinne liveth, which then appeareth in the work, when impunitie is hoped for: but when it is beleeved that punishment will follow, it liveth closely, yet it liveth. For it would wish rather, that it were lawfull to doe that which the Law forbiddeth, and is sorry that it is not lawfull: because it is not spiritually delighted with the good thereof, but carnally feareth the evill vvhich it doth threaten. What man then, doe we thinke, will take the paynes to get him a new heart and a new spirit, and undertake the toylsome worke of crucifying the flesh with the lustes thereof;
gPoenitentiā certam non facit, nisi odium peccati, & amor Dei. August serm. 7. de Tempore.Poenitentiā certam non facit, nisi odium peccati, & amor Dei. August serm. 7. de Tempore.
lTimor namque iste quo nō amatur justitia, sed timetur poena, servilis est, quia carnalis est, & ideò non c•ucifigit carnem. Vivit enim peccandi voluntas, quae tunc apparet in opere, quando speratur impunitas. Cùm veró paena c•editur secutura, latenter vivit, vivit tamen. Mallet enim licere & dolet non licere quod lex vetat: quia non spiritaliter delectatur ejus bono, sed carnaliter malum meruit quod minatur. August. in Psalm. 118. conc. 25.Timor namque iste quo nō amatur justitia, sed timetur poena, servilis est, quia carnalis est, & ideò non c•ucifigit carnem. Vivit enim peccandi voluntas, quae tunc apparet in opere, quando speratur impunitas. Cùm veró paena c•editur secutura, latenter vivit, vivit tamen. Mallet enim licere & dolet non licere quod lex vetat: quia non spiritaliter delectatur ejus bono, sed carnaliter malum meruit quod minatur. August. in Psalm. 118. conc. 25.
if without all this ado, the Priests absolution can make that other imperfect or rather equivocal contrition, arising from a carnal and servile fear, to ⟨p. 153⟩be sufficient for the blotting out of all his sins? Or are we not rather to think that this sacramental penance of the Papists is a device invented by the enemy to hoodwink poor souls, and to divert them from seeking that true repentance which is only able to stand them in stead? and that such as take upon them to help lame dogs over the stile after this manner, by substituting quid pro quo, attrition in stead of contrition, servile fear in stead of filial love, carnal sorrow in stead of godly repentance; are physicians of no value, nay such as minister poison unto men under colour of providing a sovereign medicine for them? He therefore that will have care of his souls health, must consider, that much resteth here in the good choice of a skilful physician; but much more, in the pains that must be taken by the patient himself. For that every one who beareth the name of a Priest, is not fit to be trusted with a matter of this moment; their own Decrees may give them fair warning, where this admonition is mtwice laid down, out of the author that wrote of true and false repentance. nHe who will confess his sins, that he may find grace, let him seek for a Priest that knoweth how to bind and loose: least, while he is negligent concerning himself, he be neglected by him who mercifully admonisheth and desireth him, that both fall not into the pit, which the fool would not avoid. And when the skilfullest Priest that is, hath done his best: S. Cyprian will tell them, that oto him that repenteth, to him that worketh, to him that prayeth, the Lord of his mercy can grant a pardon; he can make good that which for ⟨p. 154⟩such men either the Martyrs shall request or the Priest shall do.
if without all this adoe, the Priests absolution can make that other imperfect or rather equivocall contrition, arising from a carnall and servile feare, to ⟨p. 153⟩be sufficient for the blotting out of all his sinnes? Or are wee not rather to thinke that this sacramentall penance of the Papists is a device invented by the enemie to hoodwinke poore soules, and to divert them from seeking that true repentance which is onely able to stand them in stead? and that such as take upon them to helpe lame dogges over the stile after this maner, by substituting quid pro quo, attrition in stead of contrition, servile feare in stead of filiall love, carnall sorrow in stead of godly repentance; are physicians of no value, nay such as minister poyson unto men under colour of providing a soveraigne medicine for them? Hee therefore that will have care of his soules health, must consider, that much resteth here in the good choyce of a skilfull physician; but much more, in the paines that must be taken by the patient himselfe. For that every one who beareth the name of a Priest, is not fit to bee trusted with a matter of this moment; their owne Decrees may give them faire warning, where this admonition is mtwise laid down, out of the author that wrote of true and false repentance. nHee who will confesse his sinnes, that he may finde grace, let him seeke for a Priest that knoweth how to binde and loose: least, while he is negligent concerning himselfe, he be neglected by him vvho mercifully admonisheth and desireth him, that both fall not into the pit, which the foole would not avoid. And when the skilfullest Priest that is, hath done his best: S. Cyprian will tell them, that oto him that repenteth, to him that worketh, to him that prayeth, the Lord of his mercie can grant a pardon; hee can make good that which for ⟨p. 154⟩such men eyther the Martyrs shall request or the Priest shall doe.
mDecret. de Poenit. distinct. 1. ca. 88. Quem poenitet. & dist. 6. ca. 1. Qui vult
nQui confiteri vult peccata, ut inveniat gratiam, quaerat sacerdotem scientem ligare & solver: ne, cùm negligens circa see extiterit, negligatur ab illo, qui eum misericorditer monet, & petit, ne ambo in foveam cadant, quam stultus evitare noluit. Lib. de ver. & fals. penitent. cap 10. inter opera. Augustini, tom. 4.Qui confiteri vult peccata, ut inveniat gratiam, quaerat sacerdotem scientem ligare & solvere: ne, cùm negligens circa se extiterit, negligatur ab illo, qui eum misericorditer monet, & petit, ne ambo in foveam cadāt, quam stultus evitare noluit. Lib. de ver. & fals. poenitent. cap 10. inter opera. Augustini, tom. 4.
oPoenitenti, operanti, roganti potest clementer ignoscere; potest in acceptum refer, quidquid pro tasibus & petierint martyrs, & fecerint sacerdotes. Cyprian. de Lapsis. (sect. 13. edit. Pamel. 29 Goulart.)Poenitenti, operanti, roganti potest clementer ignoscere; potest in acceptum referre, quidquid pro tasibus & petierint martyres, & fecerint sacerdotes. Cyprian. de Lapsis. (sect. 13. edit. Pamel. 29 Goulart.)
If we inquire, who they were that first assumed unto themselves this exorbitant power of forgiving sins: we are like to find them in the Tents of the ancient heretics and schismatics; who ppromised unto others liberty, when they themselves were the servants of corruption. qHow many (saith S. Hierom) which have neither bread nor apparel, when they themselves are hungry and naked, and neither have spiritual meats, nor preserve the coat of Christ entire; yet promise unto others food and raiment, and being full of wounds themselves brag that they be physicians: and do not observe that of Moses, (Exod. 4.13.) Provide another whom thou mayest send; & that other commandment (Ecclesiastic. 7.6.) Do not seek to be made a Judge, lest peradventure thou be not able to take away iniquity. It is Jesus alone, who healeth all sicknesses and infirmities: of whom it is written, (Psalm. 147.4.) He healeth the contrite in heart, and bindeth up their soars. Thus far S. Hierom.
If we inquire, who they were that first assumed unto themselves this exorbitant power of forgiving sins: we are like to finde them in the Tents of the ancient hereticks and schismaticks; who ppromised unto others libertie, when they themselves were the servants of corruption. qHow manie (saith S. Hierom) which have neyther bread nor apparell, when they themselves are hungry and naked, and neyther have spirituall meates, nor preserve the coate of Christ intire; yet promise unto others food and rayment, and being full of wounds themselves bragge that they be physicians: and doe not observe that of Moses, (Exod. 4.13.) Provide another vvhom thou mayest send; & that other commandement (Ecclesiastic. 7.6.) Doe not seeke to be made a Iudge, lest peradventure thou be not able to take away iniquitie. It is Iesus alone, who healeth all sicknesses and infirmities: of vvhom it is written, (Psalm. 147.4.) He healeth the contrite in heart, and bindeth up their soares. Thus farre S. Hierom.
qQuanti panem non hab•n•es & vestimen•a, cùm ipsi esuriant & nudi sint, nec habeant spirituales cibos neque Christi tunicā integram reservârint; aliis & alimonia & vestimenta promittunt, & pleni vulneribus medicos esse se jactant: nec servant illud Mosaicu, Provide alium quē mittas; aliud que mandatū, Ne quaeras judex fieri, ne fortè non possis aufe•re iniquitates. Solus Je•us omnes […] scriptum est▪ Qui sanat contritos cord, & alligat contritiones eorum. H••. onym. lib. 2. co••ent. in Esaei. cap. 3.Quanti panem non hab•n•es & vestimen•a, cùm ipsi esuriant & nudi sint, nec habeant spirituales cibos neque Christi tunicā integram reservârint; aliis & alimonia & vestimenta promittunt, & pleni vulneribus medicos esse se jactant: nec servant illud Mosaicu, Provide alium quē mittas; aliud que mandatū, Ne quaeras judex fieri, ne fortè non possis aufe•re iniquitates. Solus Ie•us omnes 〈…〉 scriptum est▪ Qui sanat contritos corde, & alligat contritiones eorum. H••. onym. lib. 2. co••ent. in Esaei. cap. 3.
The Rhemists in their marginal note upon Luke 7.49. tell us, that as the Pharisees did always carp Christ for remission of sins in earth, so the Heretics reprehend his Church that remitteth sins by his authority. But S. Augustin treating upon the self same place, might have taught them, that hereby the bewrayed themselves to be the off spring of Heretics, rather then children of the Church. For whereas our Saviour there had said unto the penitent woman, Thy sins are forgiven; and they that sate at meat with him began to say within themselves, Who is this that forgiveth sins also? S. Augustin first compareth their knowledge and the knowledge of the woman thus together. ⟨p. 155⟩rShe knew that he could forgive sins; but they knew that a man could not forgive sins. And we are to believe that all, that is, both they which sat at table, and the woman which came to our Lords feet, they all knew that a man could not forgive sins. Seeing all therefore knew this, she who believed that he could forgive sins, understood him to be more then a man. and a little after: sThat do you know well, that do you hold well; saith that learned Father. Hold, that a man cannot forgive sins. She who believed that her sins were forgiven her by Christ, believed that Christ was not only man, but God also. Then doth he proceed to compare the knowledge of the Jews then with the opinion of the Heretics in his days. Herein (saith the) the Pharisee was better then these men: for when he did think that Christ was a man, he did not believe that sins could be forgiven by a man. It appeared therefore that the Jews had better understanding then the Heretics. The Jews said; Who is this that forgiveth sins also? Dare a man challenge this to himself? What saith the Heretic on the other side? I do forgive, I do cleanse, I do sanctify. Let Christ answer him, not I: O man, when I was thought by the Jews to be a man, I ascribed the forgiveness of sins to faith. Not I, but Christ doth answer thee. O Heretic, Thou when thou art but a man sayest; Come woman, I do make the safe. I when I was thought to be but a man said; Go woman, thy faith hath made thee safe.
The Rhemists in their marginall note upon Luke 7.49. tell us, that as the Pharisees did alwayes carp Christ for remission of sinnes in earth, so the Hereticks reprehend his Church that remitteth sinnes by his authoritie. But S. Augustin treating upon the selfe same place, might have taught them, that hereby the bewrayed themselves to be the off spring of Hereticks, rather then children of the Church. For whereas our Saviour there had said unto the penitent woman, Thy sinnes are forgiven; and they that sate at meate with him began to say within themselves, Who is this that forgiveth sinnes also? S. Augustin first compareth their knowledge and the knowledge of the woman thus together. ⟨p. 155⟩rShee knew that hee could forgive sinnes; but they knew that a man could not forgive sinnes. And wee are to beleeve that all, that is, both they which sat at table, and the woman which came to our Lords feet, they all knew that a man could not forgive sinnes. Seeing all therefore knew this, shee who beleeved that hee could forgive sinnes, understood him to be more then a man. and a little after: sThat doe you know well, that doe you hold well; saith that learned Father. Hold, that a man cannot forgive sinnes. Shee who beleeved that her sinnes were forgiven her by Christ, beleeved that Christ was not only man, but God also. Then doth hee proceede to compare the knowledge of the Iewes then with the opinion of the Heretickes in his dayes. Herein (saith the) the Pharisee was better then these men: for when he did thinke that Christ was a man, he did not beleeve that sinnes could be forgiven by a man. It appeared therefore that the Iewes had better understanding then the Hereticks. The Iewes said; Who is this that forgiveth sinnes also? Dare a man challenge this to himselfe? What saith the Heretick on the other side? I do forgive, I doe cleanse, I doe sanctifie. Let Christ answer him, not I: O man, when I was thought by the Iewes to bee a man, I ascribed the forgivenesse of sinnes to faith. Not I, but Christ doth answer thee. O Heretick, Thou when thou art but a man sayest; Come woman, I doe make the safe. I when I was thought to be but a man said; Goe woman, thy faith hath made thee safe.
rNoverat ergo illum post dimittere peccata: illi autem noverant hominem non posse peccata dimittere. Et credendum est, quòd omnes, id est, & illi discumbentes, & illa mulier accedens ad pedes Domini, omnes hi nō verant hominē non posse peccata dimittere. Cùm ergo omnes hoc nossent: illa quae credidit eum posse peccata dimittere, plus quàm hominē esse intellexit. August. hom. 23. ex. 50. cap. 7.Noverat ergo illum poste dimittere peccata: illi autem noverant hominem non posse peccata dimittere. Et credendum est, quòd omnes, id est, & illi discumbentes, & illa mulier accedens ad pedes Domini, omnes hi nō verant hominē non posse peccata dimittere. Cùm ergo omnes hoc nossent: illa quae credidit eum posse peccata dimittere, plus quàm hominē esse intellexit. August. hom. 23. ex. 50. cap. 7.
sTamen illud bene nost•s, been tenetis Tenete, quia homo non potest peccata dimittere. Illa quae sibi á Christo peccata dimitti credidit, Christū non hominē tantùm, sed & Deū credidit Id. ibid.Tamen illud bene nost•s, bene tenetis Tenete, quia homo non potest peccata dimittere. Illa quae sibi á Christo peccata dimitti credidit, Christū non hominē tantùm, sed & Deū credidit Id. ibid.
tSed in eo melior Pharisaeus; quia cùm putaret hominē Christū, non credebat ab homine posse dimitti peccata. Melior ergo Judaeis quàm haereticis apparuit intellectus. Judaei dixerunt, Quis est hic qui etiam peccata dimittit? Audet sibi homo usurpare? Quid contrà Haereticus? Ego mundo, ego sanctifico. Respondeat illi, non ego, sed Christus. O homo, quando ego á Judaeis putatus sum homo, dimissionem peccatorum fidei dedi. Non ego, respondet tibi Christus. O Haeretice, tu cùm sis homo, dicis; Veni mulier, ego te salvam facio. Ego cùm putarer homo, dixi, Vade mulier, fides tua te salvam fecit. Id. ibid. cap. 8.Sed in eo melior Pharisaeus; quia cùm putaret hominē Christū, non credebat ab homine posse dimitti peccata. Melior ergo Iudaeis quàm haereticis apparuit intellectus. Iudaei dixerunt, Quis est hic qui etiam peccata dimittit? Audet sibi homo usurpare? Quid contrà Haereticus? Ego mundo, ego sanctifico. Respondeat illi, non ego, sed Christus. O homo, quando ego á Iudaeis putatus sum homo, dimissionem peccatorum fidei dedi. Non ego, respondet tibi Christus. O Haeretice, tu cùm sis homo, dicis; Veni mulier, ego te salvam facio. Ego cùm putarer homo, dixi, Vade mulier, fides tua te salvam fecit. Id. ibid. cap. 8.
The Heretics at whom S. Augustin here aimeth, were the Donatists: whom Optatus also before him did thus roundly take up for the same presumption. uUnderstand at length, that you are servants, and not Lords. And if the Church be a vineyard, and men be appointed to be dressers of it: why do you rush into the dominion of the householder? Why do you challenge unto your selves, that which is Gods? xGive leave unto God to perform the things that belong unto himself. For that gift cannot be given by man, which is divine. If you think so, you labour to frustrate the words of the Prophets, & the promises of God, by which it is proved that God washeth (away sin,) and not man. It is noted likewise by Theodoret, of the Audian heretics: that ythey bragged they did forgive sins. The manner of Confession which he saith was used among them, was not much unlike that which Alvarus Pelagius acknowledgeth to have been the usual practise of them that made greatest profession of religion and learning in his time. zFor scarce at all (saith he) or very seldom doth any of them confess otherwise then in general terms: scarce do they ever specify any grievous sin. What they say one day, that they say another, as if every day they did offend alike. The manner of Absolution was the same with that, which Theodoricus de Niem noteth to have been practised by the pardoners sent abroad by Pope Boniface the ninth: who areleased all sins to them that confessed, without any penance (or repentance;) affirming that ⟨p. 157⟩they had for their warrant in so doing, all that power which Christ gave unto Peter of binding and loosing upon earth. just as Theodoret reporteth the Audians were wont to do: who presently bafter confession granted remission; not prescribing a time for repentance, as the laws of the Church did require, but giving pardon by authority.
The Hereticks at whom S. Augustin here aymeth, were the Donatists: whom Optatus also before him did thus roundly take up for the same presumption. uVnderstand at length, that you are servants, and not Lords. And if the Church be a vineyard, and men be appointed to be dressers of it: why doe you rush into the dominion of the housholder? Why doe you challenge unto your selves, that which is Gods? xGive leave unto God to performe the things that belong unto himselfe. For that gift cannot be given by man, which is divine. If you think so, you labour to frustrate the words of the Prophets, & the promises of God, by which it is proved that God washeth (away sinne,) and not man. It is noted likewise by Theodoret, of the Audian hereticks: that ythey bragged they did forgive sinnes. The maner of Confession which he saith was used among them, was not much unlike that which Alvarus Pelagius acknowledgeth to have beene the usuall practise of them that made greatest profession of religion and learning in his time. zFor scarce at all (saith hee) or very seldome doth any of them confesse otherwise then in generall termes: scarce doe they ever specifie any grievous sinne. What they say one day, that they say another, as if every day they did offend alike. The maner of Absolution was the same with that, which Theodoricus de Niem noteth to have beene practised by the pardoners sent abroad by Pope Boniface the ninth: who areleased all sinnes to them that confessed, without any penance (or repentance;) affirming that ⟨p. 157⟩they had for their warrant in so doing, all that power which Christ gave unto Peter of binding and loosing upon earth. just as Theodoret reporteth the Audians were wont to doe: who presently bafter confession graunted remission; not prescribing a time for repentance, as the lawes of the Church did require, but giving pardon by authoritie.
uIntelligite ves vel seró operarios esse, non dominos. Et si Ecclesia vinea est, sunt homines & ordinati cultores. Quid in dominium patrisfamilias irruistis? Quid vobis, quod Dei est, vindicatis? Optat. lib. 5. contra Donatist.
xConcedite Deo, praestare quae sua sunt. Non enim potest munus abhomine dari, quod divinum est. Si sic putatis, Prophetarū voces, & Dei promissa inanire contenditis, quibus p•obatur, quia Deus lavat, non homo Id. ibid.Concedite Deo, praestare quae sua sunt. Non enim potest munus abhomine dari, quod divinum est. Si sic putatis, Prophetarū voces, & Dei promissa inanire contenditis, quibus p•obatur, quia Deus lavat, non homo Id. ibid.
zVix enim aut rarissime aliquis talium confitetur nisi per verba generalia: vix unquam aliquod grave specificant. Quod dicunt unâ die, dicunt & alterâ: ac si in omni die aequaliter offendant. Alvar. de Planct. eccles. lib. 2. artic. 78. A.
aOmnia peccata etiam sine poenitentiâ ipsis confitentibus relaxârunt; super quibuslibet irregularitatibus dispensârunt inte•ventu pecuniae: dicentes see omnem potestatem habere super hoc, quam Christus Petro ligandi & solvendi contulisset in terris. Niem de schismaete, lib. 1. cap. 68.Omnia peccata etiam sine poenitentiâ ipsis confitentibus relaxârunt; super quibuslibet irregularitatibus dispensârunt inte•ventu pecuniae: dicentes se omnem potestatem habere super hoc, quam Christus Petro ligandi & solvendi contulisset in terris. Niem de schismaete, lib. 1. cap. 68.
The laws of the Church prescribed a certain time unto Penitents, cwherein they should give proof of the soundness of their repentance: and gave order that afterwards they should be dforgiven and comforted, lest they should be swallowed up with overmuch heaviness. So that first their penance was enjoined unto them, and thereby ethey were held to be bound: after performance whereof they received their absolution, by which they were loosed again. But the Audian heretics, without any such trial taken of their repentance, did of their own heads give them absolution presently upon their confession: as the Popish Priests use to do now a days. Only the Audians had one ridiculous ceremony more then the Papists; that having placed the Canonical books of Scripture upon one side, and certain Apocryphal writings on the other, they caused their followers to pass betwixt them, and in their passing to make confession of their sins: as the Papists, another idle practise more then they; that after they have given absolution, they enjoin penance to the party absolved, that is to say, (as they of old would have interpreted it) they first loose him and presently after bind him. which howsoever they hold to be done in respect of the temporal punishment remaining due after the remission of the fault: yet it appeareth plainly, that the penitential works ⟨p. 158⟩required in the ancient Church, had reference to the fault it self; and that no absolution was to be expected from the Minister for the one, before all reckonings were ended for the other. Only where the danger of death was imminent, the case admitted some exception: reconciliation being not denied indeed unto them that desired it at such a time, yet so granted, that it was left very doubtful, whether it would stand the parties in any great stead or no. fIf any one being in the last extremity of his sickness, saith S. Augustin, is willing to receive penance, and •oth receive it, and is presently reconciled, and departeth hence: I confess unto you, we do not deny him that which he asketh, but we do not presume that he goeth well from hence. I do not presume, I deceive you not, I do not presume. gHe who putteth off his penance to the last, and is reconciled; whether he goeth secure from hence, I am not secure. Penance I can give him, security I cannot give him. hDo I say, he shall be damned?
The lawes of the Church prescribed a certaine time unto Penitents, cwherein they should give proofe of the soundnesse of their repentance: and gave order that afterwards they should be dforgiven and comforted, lest they should be swallowed up with overmuch heavinesse. So that first their penance was injoyned unto them, and thereby ethey were held to be bound: after performance whereof they received their absolution, by which they were loosed againe. But the Audian hereticks, without anie such triall taken of their repentance, did of their owne heads give them absolution presently upon their confession: as the Popish Priests use to doe now a dayes. Onely the Audians had one ridiculous ceremonie more then the Papists; that having placed the Canonicall bookes of Scripture upon one side, and certaine Apocryphall writings on the other, they caused their followers to passe betwixt them, and in their passing to make confession of their sinnes: as the Papists, another idle practise more then they; that after they have given absolution, they injoyne penance to the partie absolved, that is to say, (as they of old would have interpreted it) they first loose him and presently after binde him. which howsoever they hold to be done in respect of the temporall punishment remayning due after the remission of the fault: yet it appeareth plainly, that the penitentiall workes ⟨p. 158⟩required in the ancient Church, had reference to the fault it selfe; and that no absolution was to be expected from the Minister for the one, before all reckonings were ended for the other. Onely where the danger of death was imminent, the case admitted some exception: reconci•iation being not denied indeed unto them that desired it at such a time, yet so granted, that it was left verie doubtfull, whether it would stand the parties in anie great stead or no. fIf any one being in the last extremitie of his sicknesse, saith S. Augustin, is willing to receive penance, and •oth receive it, and is presently reconciled, and departeth hence: I confesse unto you, wee doe not denie him that which hee asketh, but wee doe not presume that he goeth well from hence. I doe not presume, I deceive you not, I doe not presume. g
fSi quis positus in ultimâ necessitate aegritudinis suae, voluerit accipere poenitentiam & accipit, & mox reconciliatur, & hinc vadit: fateor vobis, non illi negamus quod petit, sed non praesumimus quia bene hinc exit. Non praesumo, non vos fallo, non praesumo. August. homil. 41. ex 50. Ambros. exhort. ad poenitent.
gAgens poenitentiam ad ultimum & reconciliatus, si securus hinc exit, ego non sum securus. &c. Poenitentiam dare possum, securitatē dare non possum. Ibid.Agens poenitentiam ad ultimum & reconciliatus, si securus hinc exit, ego non sum securus. &c. Poenitentiam dare possum, securitatē dare non possum. Ibid.
hNunquid dico, damnabitur? Non dico Sed dico etiam, liberabitur? Non. Et quid dicis mihi? Nescio: non praesumo, non promitto nescio. Vis te de dubio liberare; vis quod incertum est evadere? Age poenitentiam dumb sanus es. Ibid.Nunquid dico, damnabitur? Non dico Sed dico etiam, liberabitur? Non. Et quid dicis mihi? Nescio: non praesumo, non promitto nescio. Vis te de dubio liberare; vis quod incertum est evadere? Age poenitentiam dum sanus es. Ibid.
Archbishop of Armagh.
Transcription key
•
an illegible letter
〈…〉
illegible words
〈non-Latin alphabet〉
Greek or Hebrew the transcribers did not key
▪
illegible punctuation
⟨p. 12⟩
a page break in the printed book
gIgitur in horum a•bitrio munus solvendi & ligandi, remittendi & retinendi peccata hominum, á Christo Domino, per Spiritum sanctum fuisse positum, liquido constat. Baron. An•al. tom. 1. an. 34. sect. 197.Igitur in horum a•bitrio munus solvendi & ligandi, remittendi & retinendi peccata hominum, á Christo Domino, per Spiritum sanctum fuisse positum, liquido constat. Baron. An•al. tom. 1. ann. 34. s•ct. 197.
•
Sed ante prodiit redivivus Lazarus ex s•pulchro, & deinde ut solveretur á discipulis & sineretur abire á Domino jussum est: quia peccatorem etiam consuetudine committendi reatus gravatū, priùs Dominus intrinsecus per seipsum vivificat, postea veró eundem per Sacerdotum ministeriū absolvit. Nullus quippe peccator absolvendus est, antequam per dignam poenitentiam correctus, & intrinsecùs appareat vivificatus. Vivificare autem interiùs peccatorē solius Dei munus est, qui per Proph•tam dicit: Ego sum qui deleo iniquitates vestras. Clichtov. in Evangel. Ioann. lib. 7. cap. 23. inter opera Cyrilli.
such as have this servile feare, from whence Attrition issueth, are to be accounted evill and disordered men, by reason of their want of charitie: to which purpose also they alledge that saying of Gregory, Recti diligunt te, non recti adhuc timent te.
Hee who putteth off his penance to the last, and is reconciled; whether hee goeth secure from hence, I am not secure. Penance I can give him, securitie I cannot give him.