A14347:216
A discourse or treatise of Peter Martyr Vermilla Floor[n]tine, the public reader of divinity…A discourse or traictise of Petur Martyr Vermilla Flore[n]tine, the publyque reader of diuinitee…
A discourse or treatise of Peter Martyr Vermilla Floor[n]tine, the public reader of divinity in the University of Oxford wherein he openly declared his whole and determinate judgement concerning the sacrament of the Lords supper in the said University.A discourse or traictise of Petur Martyr Vermilla Flore[n]tine, the publyque reader of diuinitee in the Vniuersitee of Oxford wherein he openly declared his whole and determinate iudgemente concernynge the sacrament of the Lordes supper in the sayde Vniuersitee.
London: printed by Robert Stoughton i.e. E. Whitchurch for Nicolas Udall, 1550London: printed by Robert Stoughton i.e. E. Whitchurch for Nycolas Udall, 1550
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Now will we make answer to the argument which is the third season alleged in the beginning of this book for the establishing of transubstantiation:1 and the argument is concerning things of diverse and contrary natures which are called of the Logicians in the school term disparata as is afore said, which are so unlike (say they) and so dissevered one from another, that the one of them can not be said nor verified of the other. Whereunto we answer, that such things as of themselves are in such sort diverse, & unlike, and dissevered or contrary of nature and kind the one to the other: yet if they be well joined together well applied and proportioned the one to the other for the better signifying and expressing of a thing, they may now in such case be so joined together that they will make a good proposition and a perfect sentence. Which thing we see to have been done not only of Christ where he sayeth, The seed is the word of God & in another place, I am a vine tree: but also of Paul where he sayeth, that we all are one bread, & in another place, the bread which we break is the partaking and communion of the body of Christ: and again: this cup is the new testament in my blood. Nor we do not much pass on that that some say, that Matthew & Mark did in plain & express words say, this is my blood of the new testament. &c. for we deny not but y• these Evangelists did so write, but in the mean time we stiffly hold & say that the words which Luke and Paul have written, are to be received ⟨image 58⟩and allowed too, aswell as the others. And those words of Luke and Paul we affirm (as we have said of the other sentences) that they are made of words so far disagreeing and dissevered in their natures that they may after the said school term of the Logicians be but well called disparata: but yet in the way of signifying and for the better expressing of the matter that is meant and intended by them, they be very aptly joined and knit together and do very well accord.
Nowe will we make aunswere to the argumēt which is the thyrde ceason alleged in the beginnyng of this booke for the establishyng of transubstanciacion:1 and the argumente is concernyng thynges of dyuerse and contrary natures whiche are called of the Logicians in the schoole terme disparata as is afore sayed, whiche are so vnlyke (saye they) and so disseuered one from another, that the one of them can not be sayed nor verifyed of the other. Whereunto we aunswere, that suche thynges as of themselues are in suche sorte dyuerse, & vnlyke, and disseuered or contrary of nature and kinde the one to the other: yet yf they bee well ioigned together wel applyed and proporcioned ye one to the other for the better signifying and expressinge of a thynge, they maye nowe in suche case bee so ioygned together that they will make a good proposicion and a perfecte sentence. Whiche thing we see to haue been dooen not onely of Christe where he sayeth, The seed is the worde of God & in another place, I am a vine tre: but also of Paule where he saieth, that we all are one breade, & in another place, the breade whiche we breake is the partakyng and cōmunion of the body of Christ: and agayn: this cup is the new testamēt in my blud. Nor we do not muche passe on yt that some saie, that Mathew & Mark did in plain & expresse wordes say, this is my bloud of the new testamēt. &c. for we deny not but y these Euangelistes did so write, but in the meane tyme we stifly hold & saye yt the wordes which Luke and Paule haue writen, are to bee receaued