And Austen in the third book Detrinitate, and the fourth chapter.1 The Apostle (saith he) might by signifying, have preached and set forth the Lord Jesus Christ diverse and sundry ways, as one way by his tongue and words, or otherwise by his epistles and writings, or else another way, by the Sacrament of his body and blood. The same Austen in the book that he writeth against Adimanus hath these words. The Lord doubted not to say. This ⟨image 60⟩is my body, when he gave but the sign of his body. And likewise the same Austen upon the third psalm. He admitted Judas to his maundy, in the which he gave & commanded unto his disciples a figure of his body. The same man against Maximinus in the .iii. book, & .xxii. chap. sayeth thus. In the sacraments it is diligently considered and regarded, not that they were, but what they show and signify. For the sacraments are signs of things, and are in very deed one thing, and yet signify an other thing. By these places thou perceivest & seest, y• the fathers and ancient writers, do not abhor to put a signification of the body of Christ in this sacrament but do plainly put, that there is a signification of Christs body in the sacrament. Furthermore we have already showed out of the holy scriptures,2 that there are many such manners of speaking, as to say: that this or that thing is such a thing, or such a thing, wham the meaning is, that this or y• thing signifieth such a thing, or such a thing. Where fore this argument is plain blank, & is brought to nought. Therefore wham they object y• Christ did not say, that it did either signify, or represent his body: we make answer, that yet nevertheless even out of the scriptures it may so be taken, & that have we proved lately enough before. Neither do we as (they think) reason or argue after this manner & sort. This kind & manner of speaking is so taken in other places, & therefore it ought so to be taken here. But we only make answer to them, who when they should prove their transubstantiation they bring for their purpose this text. This is my body, which is the very place that all the doubt and controversy is of, and of whose sense & meaning all the doubt is.
And Austen in the thyrde booke Detrinitate, and the fourth chapitur.1 The Apostle (sayth he) might by signifiynge, haue preached and sette forthe the Lord Iesus Christe dyuerse and sondrye waies, as one way by hys tonge and wordes, or otherwise by hys epistles and writinges, or els another waye, by the Sacramente of hys bodye and bloude. The same Austen in the boke that he writeth agaynste Adimanus hathe these wordes. The Lord doubted not to say. This ⟨image 60⟩is my body, whan he gaue but the sygne of hys bodye. And likewyse the same Austen vppon the thyrd psalme. He admitted Iudas to hys maūdye, in the which he gaue & cōmaūded vnto his disciples a figure of his body. The same mā against Maximinus in the .iii. boke, & .xxii. chap. sayeth thus. In the sacramentes it is diligentelye considered and regarded, not that they were, but what they sh•we and signifie. For the sacramentes are signes of thynges, and are in veraye dede one thynge, and yet signifie an other thyng. By these places yu perceiuest & seest, y• the fathers and aūcient wryters, do not abhorre to put a signification of the body of Christ in this sacramēt but do playnly put, yt there is a significatiō of Christes body in the sacramēt. Ferthermore we haue alredi shewed out of ye holy scriptures,2 that there are many suche maners of speakinge, as to saye: that thys or that thinge is suche a thyng, or such a thing, whā the menyng is, that this or y• thing signifieth such a thing, or such a thīg. Wher fore thys argument is playn blanke, & is brought to nought. Therefore whā they obiect y• Christ dyd not say, yt it did eyther signifie, or represent hys body: we make answere, yt yet neuertheles euen out of the scriptures it may so be taken, & that haue we proued lately inough before. Neither do we as (they thynke) reason or argue after thys maner & sort. Thyskind & maner of speking is so takē in other places, & therfore it ought so to be taken here. But we only make answere to thē, who when they should proue their transubstanciatiō they brynge for their purpose thys texte. Thys is my body, which is the verie place that all the doubt and controuersie is of, and of whose sence & mening al the doubt is.
- 1Austen.
- 2The solution and confutation of the fourth reason, that was first recited for tram substantiationThe solutiō and confutation of the fourth reason, that was first recited for trā substātiatiō