A14347:234
A discourse or treatise of Peter Martyr Vermilla Floor[n]tine, the public reader of divinity…A discourse or traictise of Petur Martyr Vermilla Flore[n]tine, the publyque reader of diuinitee…
A discourse or treatise of Peter Martyr Vermilla Floor[n]tine, the public reader of divinity in the University of Oxford wherein he openly declared his whole and determinate judgement concerning the sacrament of the Lords supper in the said University.A discourse or traictise of Petur Martyr Vermilla Flore[n]tine, the publyque reader of diuinitee in the Vniuersitee of Oxford wherein he openly declared his whole and determinate iudgemente concernynge the sacrament of the Lordes supper in the sayde Vniuersitee.
London: printed by Robert Stoughton i.e. E. Whitchurch for Nicolas Udall, 1550London: printed by Robert Stoughton i.e. E. Whitchurch for Nycolas Udall, 1550
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Further, the plain, and rude and ignorant people have no such learning nor knowledge that they can judge nor discern, or put any difference between the school terms of Accidents, and Substance. And these men that feign them selves to be moved with such great and hole zeal in this matter for avoiding this Idolatry, should have done very well to have made a transubstantiation of the cup self too, lest peradventure the cup might chance to be worshipped, and prayed unto, when it is lifted up above the priests head, & showed. And truly this argument hath ever seemed unto me, a very slender & a vain argument, though in deed it be objected of school doctors, yea, and such school doctors as be of no small name.
Further, the plaine, and rude and ignoraunt people haue no suche learnynge nor knoweledge that they can iudge nor discerne, or put anye difference betwene the schole termes of Accidentes, and Substaunce. And these men that feygne theim selues to be moued wyth suche greate and hole zeale in thys matter for auoydinge thys Idolatrie, should haue done very well to haue made a transubstantiation of the cuppe selfe too, leste peraduenture the cuppe myght chaunce to be worshypped, and prayed vnto, whan it is lifted vp aboue the priestes heade, & shewed. And truly thys argumente hath euer semed vnto me, a veray slender & a vayn argumēt, though in dede it be obiected of schole doctours, yea, and such schoole doctours as be of no small name.
1It was further argued against us, that except we grant and put a transubstantiation, there shall in this sacrament two natures or substances of bodily quantity be put together, at one time, and in one place. Who would not marvel to see these men to be of such holiness, and confidence towards lady Nature, and of such high reverence, as though they would not by their wills in any point break or violate her laws. Where as yet they will needs have certain accidents to hang by them selves, and to be without any subject of material substance, which thing is most of all others contrary to the course, & ⟨p. lvii⟩