and than will we grant and yield unto them the abovesaid tropes also, which is, that it is called bread not because it is bread still, but because it was bread afore. And to the same effect and purpose it is, that they further allege. If a man had given me wine, which wine did immediately wax sour, I having in my punch•on or vessel the same being now turned into vinegar, might very well say: This is your wine not for that it is wine at this present, but because it had been wine to fore. But there of the conversion of wine into vine agree the sense of tasting doeth judge, which thing in the sacrament doeth not happen, where neither any of the five senses nor any reason,1 nor yet the holy Scripture enforceth us to confess or grant any such conversion or change to be made. They object also another place out of the second chapter of S. Ihons gospel. When the master of the feast had tasted the water that was now made wine. &c. Whereby they well declare & prove the wine newly made of Christ ⟨image 15⟩by miracle to keep yet still the name of water. But the Evangelist did not say water and there leave,2 but he said, water now made wine. But in all the holy scriptures they shall not find any such declaration concerning the Sacrament, that the bread is said to be converted or changed into the body of Christ. They take also their refuge sometimes unto the sixth chapter of John,3 so that they affirm the Apostle in the places above cited to name it bread, not wheaten bread, nor any other common bread, but the Lords body, which in the sixth chapter of John is called by the name of bread, where Christ said: I am the bread of life.4 But against them it maketh that Paul sayeth: The bread which we break, is it not a participation of Christs body?5 Which cannot conveniently agree with Christs body, that it should be broken, forasmuch as it is written: a bone of him shall ye not break. But these so few and high witted men, although they have found in the sixth chapter of John that Christ called himself bread, yet where will they find (I beseech you) that he hath at any time called himself wine? For in this supper the one part of the Sacrament is called wine, although by a strange manner of speaking, as appeareth in those words in the gospel expressed: I will not from henceforth drink of this fruit of the vine tree. c&.
and than will we graūt and yelde vnto them the abouesaid tropes also, which is, that it is called breade not because it is breade still, but because it was breade afore. And to thesame effect and purpose it is, that thei ferther allege. If a mā had geuen me wyne, which wyne did immediately weaxe soure, I hauyng in my punch•on or vessel thesame beyng now turned into vineagre, might verai well saie: This is your wine not for that it is wyne at this present, but because it had been wyne to fore. But there of the conuersion of wyne into vine agre the sense of tastyng dooeth iudge, whiche thyng in the sacramente doeth not happen, where neither any of the fiue senses nor any reason,1 nor yet the holye Scripture enforceth vs to confesse or graunt any suche cōuersion or chaūge to bee made. They obiect also another place out of the second chapitur of S. Ihons ghospell. Whan the maister of the feast had tasted the water that was now made wyne. &c. Wherby thei well declare & proue the wyne newely made of Christ ⟨image 15⟩by miracle to kepe yet styl the name of water. But the Euangeliste did not saye water and there leaue,2 but he sayed, water now made wyne. But in al the holy scriptur•s they shall not fynde anye suche declaracion concernyng the Sacrament, that the breade is saied to be conuerted or chaunged into the body of Christe. Thei take also their refuge sometimes vnto the sixth chapitur of Ihon,3 so that thei affirme the Apostle in the places aboue cited to name it breade, not wheaten breade, nor any other common breade, but the Lordes body, whiche in the sixth chapitur of Ihon is called by the name of bread, where Christ saied: I am the bread of life.4 But agaynst thē it maketh that Paule saieth: The bread whiche we breake, is it not a participacion of Christys bodye?5 Whiche cannot conueniently agree with Christes body, that it should bee broken, forasmuche as it is written: a bone of hym shall ye not breake. But these so fewe and high witted men, althoughe thei haue foūd in the sixth chapitur of Ihon that Christe called himselfe breade, yet where will thei finde (I beseche you) that he hath at any tyme called hymselfe wyne? For in this supper the one parte of the Sacrament is called wyne, although by a straūge manier of speaking, as appereth in those woordes in the gospell expressed: I wyl not from hensefoorth drinke of this fruite of the vynetree. c&.
- 1Another sophistical objectionA•other sophis•ical obieccion
- 2The answerThe aūswer
- 3Another objection.Another obiecciō.
- 4The answer
- 5The material b•eade of the Sacrament.The m•teriall b•eade of the Sacrament.