Christ commandeth us to eat his flesh, and he taking the bread in his hand, sayeth: This is my body. Now the transubstantiators said: It cannot be that the body of Christ should be together with the bread, Wherefore, it must needs follow that the nature of the bread, be turned by transubstantiation into Christs body. And that it is so transubstantiated, they will needs persuade men by an argument of the power of God,1 because he is able to do it. But in the mean while, the transubstantiators do thus object against us We do not this allow, (say they,) for Chrysostom, Ambrose, & Cyrillus, when they treat of this mutation: the likewise remit us to the power of god, & magnify the same power of god with wonderful high lauds & praises. But to this we answer, that the fathers speak very well, for undoubtedly, it belongeth to the power of God so to change bread and wine that they be made sacraments, which they were not afore: neither is it the work of nature that bread and wine should ⟨p. lxxxv⟩so mightily and so effectually signify offer and represent the body and blood of our lord to be comprehended with our minds and with our faith. Wherefore the holy ghost doeth here intermeddle himself: & the lords institution and ordinance in this behalf, is of great strength and virtue: & the words being at the first pronounced by the inspiration of God and now repeated again by the minister do work no small effect. Ye may to the premisses put our conversion and changing into Christ when we do receive the communion, all which things are far above the power & strength of nature. And now where as the supernatural power of the lord may be required to all these things: these men apply the said power of God to transubstantiation. But this is a much like thing as it we should make an argument and should reason, (as the logicians termes bee) ab universiliore ad particularius, that is to say, from the more general to the less general affirmatively, that is, by the way of affirming a thing to be thus or thus, which is the worst kind of argument that can be made: as for exam •le there can not be a worse argument than to sa•. This same is a tree: ergo it is an apple tree. For it may be a theritree, or an oak tree, or some other tree. But contrary wise, to say: this in an apple tree.
Chryst commaundeth vs to eate hys fleash, and he takynge the breade in hys hande, sayethe: This is my bodye. Now the transubstanciatours said: It cannot bee that the bodye of Chryste shoulde bee to gether with the bread, Wherefore, it must nedes folow that the nature of the breade, bee turned by transubstanciacyon into Chrystes body. And that it is so transubstauncyated, they wyll nedes parswade men by an argumente of the power of God,1 because he is hable to doe it. But in the meane whyle, the transubstanciatours dooe thus obiecte agaynst vs We dooe not thys alowe, (say they,) for Chrysostome, Ambrose, & Cyrillus, whan they traict of thys mutacion: the lykewyse remit vs to the power of god, & magnyfye the same power of god wt wunderful high laudes & praises. But to thys we aunswer, yt the fathers speake veray wel, for vndoubtedly, it belongeth to ye power of God so to chaunge breade and wyne that they bee made sacramentes, whyche they wer not afore: neyther is it the worke of nature that bread and wine should ⟨p. lxxxv⟩so mightely and so effectually signifie offre and represente the bodye and bloud of our lorde to bee comprehended wyth our myndes and wyth our feith. Wherefore the holy ghoste dooeth here entremeole hymself: & the lordes institution and ordinaunce in this beha•fe, is of great strength and vertue: & the wordes beeyng at the fyrst pronounced by the inspiracion of God and now repeated agayn by the ministre dooe weorke no smalle effecte. Ye maye to the premisses putte our conuersion and chaungeyng into Christe whan we dooe receiue the communion, all whiche thynges are ferre aboue the power & strength of nature. And now wher as the supernatural power of the lorde maye bee required to al these thynges: these men applye ye sayd power of God to transubstanciacion. But thys is a muche lyke thyng as it we should make an argumente and should reason, (as the logicians termes bee) ab vniuersiliore ad particularius, that is to saie, from the more general to the lesse general affirmatyuely, that is, by the waye of affirmyng a thyng to bee thus or thus, whiche is the wourstkynde of argumente that can bee made: as for exā •le there can not bee a wourse ar•umēte thē to sa•. Thissame is a tree: ergo it is an applee tree. For it maye bee a theritree, or an oke tree, or some other tree. But contrarie wyse, to saye: this in an aple tree.
- 1Why the fathers speaking of this sacrament do so magnify the power of god.Why the fathers speakin•g of this sac•amente dooe so magnifie the power of god.