A14347:94
A discourse or treatise of Peter Martyr Vermilla Floor[n]tine, the public reader of divinity…A discourse or traictise of Petur Martyr Vermilla Flore[n]tine, the publyque reader of diuinitee…
A discourse or treatise of Peter Martyr Vermilla Floor[n]tine, the public reader of divinity in the University of Oxford wherein he openly declared his whole and determinate judgement concerning the sacrament of the Lords supper in the said University.A discourse or traictise of Petur Martyr Vermilla Flore[n]tine, the publyque reader of diuinitee in the Vniuersitee of Oxford wherein he openly declared his whole and determinate iudgemente concernynge the sacrament of the Lordes supper in the sayde Vniuersitee.
London: printed by Robert Stoughton i.e. E. Whitchurch for Nicolas Udall, 1550London: printed by Robert Stoughton i.e. E. Whitchurch for Nycolas Udall, 1550
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Another false and ill-favoured opinion also follow eth this said transubstantiation, 1in that they have supposed and thought, that after the receiving of the Sacrament, the Sacrament did remain still, and that the bread or the likenesses of bread did really and verily contain Christs body in it. Which thing not to be so but much otherwise, we prove by the use of the other Sacraments, where all the whole matter doeth consist only in the action and doing: Which action finished the sacrament doeth by and by cease, and doth no more remain a sacrament. First in baptism, As soon as one is baptised in water according to Christs words and ordinance: and the action of baptism once accomplished, it ceaseth immediately to be a sacrament. And the same thing was likewise in circumcision. For that sacrament also had his strength and virtue for so long time,2 whiles it was in doing and no longer. Neither will I disdain or think scorn for the proof hereof to take which they themselves call sacraments, as confirmation, (which we have used in English to call bishopping,) and also the sacrament of extreme unction. (Which we have accustomed to call anointing,) and also the sacrament of penance. With other like sacraments, all which sacraments we see to take place only for the time whiles they be in doing, and no longer.3 But they be wont to say that this sacrament of thanks giving must be in this behalf excepted.4 But how reasonably and how Logician like the adversaries so say may easily be understanded. For seeing that all the parts of other like examples and sacramentest granted, and an exception ⟨image 30⟩made of that same thing only which is in doubt and controversy: Who seeth not, that it is unconueniently doo•n, and only to defeat out argument with a blind cinque (as the common proverb saith?) For it is in a manner as much as if one would grant the first parts and members of an argument: and yet deny the conclusion that by good reason must necessarily follow of the same.