A15061:140
An answer to a certain book, writtenAn answere to a certeine booke, written
An answer to a certain book, written by Master William Rainolds student of divinity in the English college at Rhemes, and entitled, A refutation of sundry reprehensions, cavils, etc. by William Whitaker ...An answere to a certeine booke, written by Maister William Rainolds student of diuinitie in the English colledge at Rhemes, and entituled, A refutation of sundrie reprehensions, cauils, etc. by William Whitaker ...
Printed at London : For Thomas Chard, 1585
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
In that you bear your reader in hand, I have dissented from Calvin, and the Protestants, that argueth a weakness of your brain, which causeth you to utter such idle talk. All Protestants, not only I, confess that Melchizedek was a Priest, & that he offered sacrifice: doth it follow therefore M. R. that the sacrifice was in bread & wine, as you pretend? whom then do I forsake? with whom do I join? what fantasy is this that troubleth your head so much?
In that you beare your reader in hand, I haue dissented from Caluin, and the Protestants, that argueth a weakenes of your braine, which causeth you to vtter such idle talke. All Protestants, not onelie I, confesse that Melchisedech was a Priest, & that he offered sacrifice: doth it follow therefore M. R. that the sacrifice was in bread & wine, as you pretend? whome then do I forsake? with whome doe I ioyne? what fantasie is this that troubleth your head so much?
In this taking you begin to throw out arguments,1 which must needs be full simply and miserably made. Howbeit sooner may you devise many formal syllogisms for your sacrifice, then make one sound reason in divinity for confirmation thereof. Thus you have framed your argument with ⟨p. 71⟩your own hands:2 That Christ did, and appointed to be done, that may & ought to be done: But Christ at his last supper offered sacrifice according to the order of Melchizedek, and appointed the Apostles and priests to do the same: Ergo the Apostles & priests may, & ought to offer sacrifice. This syllogism seemeth to be terribly compounded, and to prove invincibly the sacrifice of the Mass: doubtless Master Rainolds is persuaded he shall herewith fray us all away. But be not dismayed (good Reader) the light driveth darkness before it, and trueth cannot be vanquished with an army of false arguments, be they never so cunningly framed, much less with such slender sophisms as these. Your Assumption hath two parts, & they both are false: whereof the conclusion following cannot be able to look the trueth in the face. For where you say I have acknowledged the former part, I acknowledge no such thing, nor ever did.