A15061:164
An answer to a certain book, writtenAn answere to a certeine booke, written
An answer to a certain book, written by Master William Rainolds student of divinity in the English college at Rhemes, and entitled, A refutation of sundry reprehensions, cavils, etc. by William Whitaker ...An answere to a certeine booke, written by Maister William Rainolds student of diuinitie in the English colledge at Rhemes, and entituled, A refutation of sundrie reprehensions, cauils, etc. by William Whitaker ...
Printed at London : For Thomas Chard, 1585
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
But the godly Christian, who hath perhaps offended in surfeiting, or drunkenness, and is truly sorrowful therefore, hath repented, though he fast not every Friday from morning to night, but useth a sober and moderate diet every day. Nevertheless if he prescribe unto himself, without superstition of satisfaction or merit, some abstinence for a time, that thereby he may be further estranged from that vice, who will deny but this is well and Christianlike done? And this was commanded by God in public and private fasts, and practised by the godly, as we read in the scriptures. Thus may you see what an idle head you have, that allege so many testimonies of scripture, to prove a thing, which no man ever hath denied. I perceive your leisure is great, but you should have more discretion to use it well. In a plain case, wherein we need not your help, you bring plenty of scriptures: in a matter of controversy and debate, which beggeth relief at your hands, you pass by, as though you heard not: which yet I ⟨p. 98⟩impute not to want of compassion, but of ability. We dispute not whether the children of God have used, and ought to use sometimes outward punishing and afflicting of their bodies (for this we do willingly confess) but whether this outward affliction be a proper part of repentance, and whether it satisfieth for sins. The first is an error, the second is an heresy, or rather blasphemy. These things you should have proved, for these we deny: the other being not denied, required no proof.
But the godlie Christian, whoe hath perhappes oftended in surfeting, or dronkennesse, and is trulie sorowfull therefore, hath repented, though he fast not euerie Fridaie from morning to night, but vseth a sober and moderate diet euerie day. Neuertheles if he prescribe vnto himselfe, without superstition of satisfaction or merite, some abstinence for a time, that thereby he may be further estraunged from that vice, whoe will denie but this is well and Christianlike done? And this was commaunded by God in publike and priuate fastes, and practised by the godlie, as wee read in the scriptures. Thus may you see what an idle head you haue, that alleadge so many testimonies of scripture, to prooue a thing, which no man euer hath denied. I perceiue your leisure is great, but you should haue more discretion to vse it well. In a plaine case, wherein we need not your helpe, you bring plentie of scriptures: in a matter of controuersie and debate, which beggeth reliefe at your hands, you passe by, as though you heard not: which yet I