A15061:209
An answer to a certain book, writtenAn answere to a certeine booke, written
An answer to a certain book, written by Master William Rainolds student of divinity in the English college at Rhemes, and entitled, A refutation of sundry reprehensions, cavils, etc. by William Whitaker ...An answere to a certeine booke, written by Maister William Rainolds student of diuinitie in the English colledge at Rhemes, and entituled, A refutation of sundrie reprehensions, cauils, etc. by William Whitaker ...
Printed at London : For Thomas Chard, 1585
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Your beginning is of an other matter.1 For this question of Peters being at Rome, M. Jewell made not any part of his challenge, knowing well enough, that this might easily be proved by testimony of fathers a great many. And this was I not ignorant of neither, when I said, that no Papist can prove, that Peter indeed was at Rome. For albeit I know that diverse have so written, since the Apostles ⟨p. 148⟩times, yet can I not receive this as a sufficient proof, neither yet ought you, there being against it so many reasons out of scripture,2 whereof every one hath more weight, then all the testimonies of fathers alleged. You know, and can not deny that your whole Church & religion is built upon Peters sitting at Rome: which being a matter of such consequence, as that the whole is upholden, and sustained thereupon, so as if it shake, all is in danger, if it fall, all is clean overthrown: it ought to be made manifest to all Christians, that Peter was at Rome, by greater proof and warrant, then is in the writings of men, which being as good as any of that nature can be afforded, is not of sufficient strength to stay the conscience desirous to be soundly and perfectly resolved in points of faith and religion: but now further being by sundry testimonies of holy scriptures utterly discredited, it must be thought that they have small conscience of truth, or regard of their everlasting estate, that hang the salvation of their souls upon so uncertain and rotten a stay. The first reporter of Peters being at Rome was Papias, a man of mean credit & authority ⟨p. 149⟩in the Church of God,3 and as Eusebius writeth of him, a father of diverse fables: a fit father of your faith. Of him Hegesippus received this, and of Hegesippus others, as in writing histories the latter follow those that went before: so that this whole matter is grounded upon Papias word, for which your pope hath good cause to give him thanks. Now the scriptures in many places weigh so strongly on the other side, that if many a thousand such as Papias should tell us Peter was at Rome, their report were not to be trusted. Peter promised to remain with the Jews,