A15061:242
An answer to a certain book, writtenAn answere to a certeine booke, written
An answer to a certain book, written by Master William Rainolds student of divinity in the English college at Rhemes, and entitled, A refutation of sundry reprehensions, cavils, etc. by William Whitaker ...An answere to a certeine booke, written by Maister William Rainolds student of diuinitie in the English colledge at Rhemes, and entituled, A refutation of sundrie reprehensions, cauils, etc. by William Whitaker ...
Printed at London : For Thomas Chard, 1585
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
For concerning the holy virgins birth, therein is no contradiction. There was a miracle indeed, that a virgin should bear a son contrary to the course of nature. For to be a virgin, & yet to have a child, are not contradictory, if she have conceived and brought forth by miracle, as did the blessed virgin:1 but to be a virgin, & not a virgin at once, this is the contradiction. So for Christs body to be visible & invisible, local and not local at once, is in every respect the like contradiction: and therefore impossible to be true.
For concerning the holie virgins birth, therein is no contradiction. There was a miracle indeed, that a virgine should beare a sonne contrarie to the course of nature. For to be a virgine, & yet to haue a childe, are not contradictorie, if she haue conceiued and brought forth by miracle, as did the blessed virgine:1 but to be a virgine, & not a virgine at once, this is the contradiction. So for Christs bodie to be visible & inuisible, locall and not locall at once, is in euerie respect the like contradiction: and therefore impossible to be true.
- 1M.R. objections nothing to the purpose.M.R. obiections nothing to the purpose.
Your other example of Christs entering in, the doors being shut, what show of contradiction hath it? Can you prove he entered through the doors? and if he did, then was there an alteration of qualities, & that by miracle, either in Christs body, or in the doors, but no contradiction in nature: unless you know not what is a contradiction. Your third and last example of the fire ⟨p. 181⟩in Nebuchadnezzar's oven, which consumed the Ministers, but hurt not those that were in the middest of it, appeareth to be of no weight, by that hath already been answered. You imagine belike that in every miracle a contradiction is implied: which is absurd. If you can prove that this fire was both hot and cold, then you say something to the purpose: but that it burnt up some, and hurt not others, is no contradiction, because by miracle the force thereof was repressed. Thus are you truly and fully answered to your simple sophisms: and your Real presence is disproved by the eternal law of God in nature, whereunto he hath even bound himself, never to do any thing, wherein there is a contradiction to be found, as your own Divines have well and truly taught. Then may you see that my argument was not taken out of Aristotle and Euclid, as you say, but is grounded upon the eternal decree, and most unchangeable trueth of God: to which your Real presence must give place, being nothing else, but an irreligious and contradictorius devise of your own brain.