Here you talk,1 as well becometh a man of your profession, falsely, vilely, blasphemously ⟨p. 197⟩against the true doctrine of Christs sacrament. I am unwilling to answer such profane speeches of an opprobrious & slanderous enemy. So much only will I speak as shall serve to stop the mouth of this railer. Do we think no otherwise of our communion, then as of common bread and wine, without all grace, virtue, and sanctification? 2do we make it a bare figure of Christ absent? Have we as good figures at our common breakfast, dinners and suppers? Thus you say, but all the world knoweth you say most untruly. Common bread, common wine,3 bare figure was never any part of our doctrine: this is your unlearned collection of that we deny the real presence. For had you but half an eye, you might see how this slander is easily disproved. In baptism, a sacrament of Christs own ordinance, there is not any real presence of Christs blood or body, as your selves confess. Now if one had as heretical a judgement of this sacrament as you have of the other, he might charge you as justly for denying Christs real presence in the sacrament of baptism, as you do us, for denying his real presence in the sacrament of the supper. For if you ⟨p. 198⟩reason with any trueth against us, that we make it common bread, common wine, a bare figure, without grace, virtue, or sanctifying power, because we affirm that Christ is not present carnally & grossly therein: then must it as truly and necessarily follow, that the water of baptism is common water,4 is a bare figure, is void of all spiritual effect: because in baptism there is no real presence. And surely by this your kind of argument it plainly appeareth, you have no other opinion thereof, then, as you have said, of common water, wherein is neither grace, nor virtue, nor sanctification: and of a bare figure, such as you may have enough, whensoever you wash your hands.
Here you talke,1 as wel becommeth a man of your profession, falslie, vilelie, blasphemouslie ⟨p. 197⟩against the true doctrine of Christs sacrament. I am vnwilling to answere such profane speaches of an opprobrious & slaunderous enemie. So much onely wil I speake as shall serue to stoppe the mouth of this railer. Doe we thinke no otherwise of our communion, then as of common breade and wine, without all grace, vertue, and sanctification? 2doe we make it a bare figure of Christ absent? Haue we as good figures at our common breakefast, din•ers and suppers? Thus you say, but all the world knoweth you say moste vntrulie. Common bread, common wine,3 bare figure was neuer any part of our doctrine: this is your vnlearned collection of that we deny the reall presence. For had you but halfe an eye, you might see how this slaunder is easilie disprooued. In baptisme, a sacrament of Christs owne ordinaunce, there is not anie reall presence of Christs blood or body, as your selues confesse. Now if one had as hereticall a iudgement of this sacrament as you haue of the other, he might charge you as iustlie for denying Christs reall presence in the sacrament of baptisme, as you doe vs, for denying his reall presence in the sacrament of the supper. For if you ⟨p. 198⟩reason with anie trueth against vs, that we make it common bread, common wine, a bare figure, without grace, vertue, or sanctifying power, because we affirme that Christ is not present carnally & grosselie therein: then must it as truelie and necessarilie follow, that the water of baptisme is common water,4 is a bare figure, is void of all spirituall effect: because in baptisme there is no reall presence. And surelie by this your kinde of argument it plainlie appeareth, you haue no other opinion thereof, then, as you haue said, of common water, wherein is neither grace, nor vertue, nor sanctification: and of a bare figure, such as you may haue enough, whensoeuer you wash your hands.
- 1pag. 209.
- 2M. R. reporteth falsely of our doctrine touching the sacrament.M. R. reporteth falslie of our doctr•ne touching the sacrament.
- 3We deny Christs bo•y to be Really present in the supper: Ergo we make the supper a bare figure of Christ, Thus our papists unlearnedly reason.We denie •hrists bo•y to be Really present in the supper: Ergo we make the supper a bare figure of Christ, Thus our papistes vnlearnedlie reason.
- 4The popish argument maketh the sacrament of Baptism no better then a bare element.The popish argument maketh the sacrament of Baptisme no better then a bare element.