A16330:802
Instructions for a right comforting afflicted consciences with special antidotes against some grievous temptationsInstructions for a right comforting afflicted consciences with speciall antidotes against some grievous temptations
Instructions for a right comforting afflicted consciences with special antidotes against some grievous temptations: delivered for the most part in the lecture at Kettering in North-hampton-shire: by Robert Bolton ...Instructions for a right comforting afflicted consciences with speciall antidotes against some grievous temptations: delivered for the most part in the lecture at Kettering in North-hampton-shire: by Robert Bolton ...
London: printed by Felix Kyngston for Thomas Weaver, 1631
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
And we may see these rules represented unto us in the practise of Manasseh, who being a most grievous ⟨p. 447⟩sinner: 2. Chron. 33.6. Humbled Himself greatly before the God of His Fathers: vers. 12. In the Woman, who is called a Sinner; Luk. 7.37. [Greek or Hebrew], as they say, by a kind of singularity; and therefore takes on extraordinarily, vers. 38. So that she wipes Christs feet with tears. In the idolatrous Israelites upon their turning unto the Lord: 1. Sam. 7.4.6. who drew water, and poured it out before the Lord. In the Hearers of Peter, who having their consciences all bloody with the horrible guilt of crucifying the Lord of life; Act: 2.33.36. were pricked in their hearts: vers. 37. with such horror and raging anguish, as tho so many empoisoned daggers and Scorpions stings stuck, and were fastened in them *punctually. In Paul, who having been an heinous offender, a grievous Persecutor, Act. 9. whereas the other Apostles, as One says, had been honest and sober fisher-men, tasted deeper of this cup then they. For He tells us, Rom. 7.11. That the Law slew Him. He was strangely amazed with a voice from Heaven, struck down to the earth, and stark blind. He trembled, and was astonished: For three days He did neither eat, nor drink. &c. Act. 9.
And wee may see these rules represented unto us in the practise of Manasses, who beeing a most grievous ⟨p. 447⟩sinner: 2. Chron. 33.6. Humbled Himselfe greatly before the God of His Fathers: vers. 12. In the Woman, who is called a Sinner; Luk. 7.37. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, as they say, by a kinde of singularity; and therefore takes on extraordinarily, vers. 38. So that she wipes Christs feete with teares. In the idolatrous Israelites upon their turning unto the Lord: 1. Sam. 7.4.6. who drew water, and poured it out before the Lord. In the Hearers of Peter, who having their consciences all bloody with the horrible guilt of crucifying the Lord of life; Act: 2.33.36. were pricked in their hearts: vers. 37. with such horrour and raging angvish, as tho so many empoisoned daggers and Scorpions stings stucke, and were fastned in them *punctually. In Paul, who having been an hainous offender, a grievous Persecuter, Act. 9. whereas the other Apostles, as One sayes, had been honest and sober fisher-men, tasted deeper of this cup then they. For Hee tells us, Rom. 7.11. That the Law slew Him. Hee was strangely amazed with a voyce from Heaven, strucke downe to the earth, and starke blinde. He trembled, and was astonished: For three daies Hee did neither eate, nor drink. &c. Act. 9.
- *[Greek or Hebrew], pungendo penetro. Punctìm caede. Scap.〈non-Latin alphabet〉, pungendo penetro. Punctìm caede. Scap.
And there is good reason for it. For ordinarily the newly-enlightened eye of a fresh-bleeding Conscience, is very sharp, and clear; piercing and sightfull; greedy to discover every stain, and spot of the Soul; To dive even to the heart-root, to the blackest bottom and ugliest nook of a Mans former Hellish courses; to look back, with a curious survey, through the pure Perspective of Gods righteous Law, over his whole life to His very Birth-sin, and Adams rebellion. And in this sad, and heavy search, it is very inquisitive after, and apprehensive of all circumstances, which may add to the heinousness of sin, and horror to his heart. It is quick-sighted into all aggravating considerations; and quickly learns, and looks upon all those ways, degrees, and circumstances, by which sins are made more ⟨p. 448⟩notorious and hateful. And what the spirit of bondage, in a fearful heart, may infer hereupon, you may easily judge.
And there is good reason for it. For ordinarily the newly-illightened eye of a fresh-bleeding Conscience, is very sharpe, and cleare; piercing and sightfull; greedy to discover every staine, and spot of the Soule; To dive even to the heart-roote, to the blackest bottome and ougliest nooke of a Mans former Hellish courses; to looke backe, with a curious survay, thorow the pure Perspective of Gods righteous Law, over his whole life to His very Birth-sinne, and Adams rebellion. And in this sad, and heavy search, it is very inquisitive after, and apprehensive of all circumstances, which may adde to the hainousnesse of sin, and horrour to his heart. It is quick-sighted into all aggravating considerations; and quickly learnes, and lookes upon all those wayes, degrees, and circumstances, by which sins are made more ⟨p. 448⟩notorious and hatefull. And what the spirit of bondage, in a fearefull heart, may inferre hereupon, you may easily iudge.
Now to the Case proposed; I say, first;
1. That between sin and sorrow, we cannot expect a precise adequation; not an Arithmetical, but a Geometrical proportion: Great sins should be greatly lamented; yet no sin can be sufficiently sorrowed for; Tho it may be savingly. When we say, the pangs of the New-birth must be answerable to our former sinful provocations; we mean not, that we can mourn for sin according to it's merit; that is impossible: But great sins require a great deal of sorrow. We must not think, that we have sorrowed enough for any sin, tho we can never sorrow sufficiently.
1. That betweene sinne and sorrow, wee cannot expect a precise adequation; not an Arithmeticall, but a Geometricall proportion: Great sinnes should bee greatly lamented; yet no sinne can bee sufficiently sorrowed for; Tho it may bee savingly. When wee say, the pangs of the New-birth must bee answerable to our former sinnefull provocations; wee meane not, that wee can mourne for sinne according to it's merit; that is impossible: But great sinnes require a great deale of sorrow. Wee must not thinke, that wee have sorrowed enough for any sinne, tho wee can never sorrow sufficiently.
Before I proceed to a further, and fuller satisfaction in the Point, let me tell you by the way, how discomfortable, and doubtful, the Popish doctrine is here about; that the truth of our Tenet may appear the more precious, and taste more sweet.
Before I proceede to a further, and fuller satisfaction in the Point, let mee tell you by the way, how discomfortable, and doubtfull, the Popish doctrine is here about; that the truth of our Tenet may appeare the more pretious, and taste more sweet.
Their Attrition and Contrition, as I take it, differ, as our Legal and Evangelical repentance; 1. In respect of the object. Contrition, as they say, is sorrow for sin, as an offence to God: Attrition is a grief for sin, as liable to punishment. 2. In respect of the cause. Contrition ariseth from son-like, Attrition from servile fear. [See Valent. Disp. 7. Q. 8. De contrit. punct. 2.]
Their Attrition and Contrition, as I take it, differ, as our Legall and Evangelicall repentance; 1. In respect of the object. Contrition, as they say, is sorrow for sinne, as an offence to God: Attrition is a griefe for sinne, as liable to punishment. 2. In respect of the cause. Contrition ariseth from sonne-like, Attrition from servile feare. [See Valent. Disp. 7. Q. 8. De contrit. punct. 2.]
This Contrition is the cause of the remission of sins. [Bellar. lib. 2. de poenit. cap. 12. Arb. At Catholici] & alij passim. Well then, thou art a Papist, and troubled in conscience. Thou knowest well, that without contrition no remission: But when comest thou to that measure and degree, which may give thee some contentment about the pardon of thy sins? Go unto them in this Point for resolution and relief, and thou goes unto a ⟨p. 449⟩Rack. Consult with their Chapters, de quantitate contritionis, of the muchness of sorrow, and they are able to confound thee with many desperate distractions.
This Contrition is the cause of the remission of sinnes. [Bellar. lib. 2. de poenit. cap. 12. Arb. At Catholici] & alij passim. Well then, thou art a Papist, and troubled inconscience. Thou knowest well, that without contrition no remission: But when comest thou to that measure and degree, which may give thee some contentment about the pardon of thy sinnes? Goe unto them in this Point for resolution and reliefe, and thou goes unto a ⟨p. 449⟩Racke. Consult with their Chapters, de quantitate contritionis, of the muchnesse of sorrow, and they are able to confound thee with many desperate distractions.
1. Look back upon the elder Schoolmen: and you shall have Adrian Quaest. de poenit: Quodlib 5. Artic. 3.] and others tell you of a Contrition intensivè summa; in the highest strain; and to which nothing can be added, as aValent. reports it. This opinion Vega refutes [de justif. lib. 13. cap. 14. ad princ.] And Bellarmine dislikes it [De poenit. lib. 2. cap. 11. Art. denique si summus]. Note by the way, how sweetly they agree: our concord is Angelical, in respect of their confusions.
1. Looke backe upon the elder Schoolemen: and you shall have Adrian Quaest. de poenit: Quodlib 5. Artic. 3.] and others tell you of a Contrition intensivè summa; in the highest s•reine; and to which nothing can bee added, as aValent. reports it. This opinion Vega refutes [de iustif. lib. 13. cap. 14. ad princ.] And Bellarmine dislikes it [De poenit. lib. 2. cap. 11. Art. denique si summus]. Note by the way, how sweetly they agree: our concord is Angelicall, in respect of their confusions.
- aMultò minùs requirere putandus Deus est, ut doleamus de peccato, dolore simplicitèr summ•, qùo nullus intensior esse possit, ut Hadrianus requirere videtur. Tom. 4. disp. 7. qu. 8. De contritione punct. 5.
2. Go to Scotus [In 4. Sent. Dist. 14. Q 2], and his Followers. And you shall find him to talk of a certain intension of contrition; which is [soli Deo cognita] onely known unto God: but this Greg. de Valent. censures as very false [Tom. 4. Col. 17.24]. You see again, as there is no truth in their Tenets; so no constancy, no concord; and by consequent, no comfort to a truly troubled spirit.
2. Goe to Scotus [In 4. Sent. Dist. 14. Q 2], and his Followers. And you shall finde him to talke of a certaine intension of contrition; which is [soli Deo cognita] onely knowen unto God: but this Greg. de Valent. censures as very false [Tom. 4. Col. 17.24]. You see againe, as there is no truth in their Tenets; so no constancy, no concord; and by consequent, no comfort to a truly troubled spirit.
3. Come at length to the latter Locusts, some Modern Jesuits, daubers over of their superstitious ruins, with many rotten distinctions: I mean Bellar. Greg. de Valent. and their fellows: And they dare not stand either to the unknown intension of Scotus, nor that of highest pitch, which Hadrian holds: But come in with a sorrow for sin, appreciativè summus. And what is that, think you?
3. Come at length to the latter Locusts, some Moderne Iesuites, dawbers over of their superstitious ruines, with many rotten distinctions: I meane Bellar. Greg. de Valent. and their fellowes: And they dare not stand either to the unknowne intension of Scotus, nor that of highest pitch, which Hadrian holds: But come in with a sorrow for sin, appreciativè summus. And what is that, thinke you?
Hence Bellarmine [for Valent. speaks more warily in the quoted place, Art. Neque verò]. Yet very weakly too (for in such Cases, the troubled mind is not wont to rest upon generals only, but will (will we, nill we) bring us to particular; howsoever Scotus, Navarre and Madin•, advise the contrary).
Hence Bellarmine [for Valent. speakes more warily in the quoted place, Art. Neque verò]. Yet very weakely too (for in such Cases, the troubled minde is not woont to rest upon generalls onely, but will (will wee, nill we) bring us to particular; howsoever Scotus, Navar and Madin•, advise the contrary).
Sorrow for sin, saith bhe, is then summus appreciativè ⟨p. 450⟩when the will doth more esteem the detestation of sin, then the attainment of any good, or escaping any ill. And so by consequent, (for as I intimated, a troubled conscience in such a Case, is very curious, and inquisitive; and will not stay only upon confused, and general notions of good and ill, but easily descend to Particulars, to know it's state more perfectly, especially in a Point of so great importance) A man must find his heart first to prize the hatred of sin, before the happiness of heavenly joys, or avoiding hellish pains; before he can come to comfort of the remission of his sins. What a torture were it to a troubled spirit, to fall into the hands of such true Pharisees, who lay heavy burdens upon others, but will not touch them themselves with the least of their fingers. But blessed be God! we truly teach, that it is not so cmuch the measure and muchness, as the truth, and heartiness of o• sorrow; which fits for the promises of life, and pardon of sin. Yet I must say this also; He that thinks, he hath sorrowed sufficiently, never sorrowed truly. And I like dBellarmines last Proposition well in the fore-•••ted place; If it be thus understood: That we must desire, aim, and endeavour after the highest pitch of godly sorrow, which can possibly be attained. But […] is one thing to say; either, just so much measure of sorrow, or no mercy; such a quantity of contrition, or no remission: An other thing to say, we must long and labour to bring our naughty hearts to this: Even to be willing rather to lie in Hell, then to live in sin. Perfections of grace are aimed at in this life, not attained.
Sorrow for sinne, saith bhee, is then summus appreciativè ⟨p. 450⟩when the will doth more esteeme the detestation of sinne, then the attainement of any good, or escaping any ill. And so by consequent, (for as I intimated, a troubled conscience in such a Case, is very curious, and inqui•itive; and will not stay onely upon confused, and generall notions of good and ill, but easily descend to Particulars, to know it's state more perfectly, especialy in a Point of so great importance) A man must finde his heart first to prize the hatred of sinne, before the happinesse of heavenly joyes, or avoiding hellish paines; before hee can come to comfort of the remission of his sinnes. What a torture were it to a troubled spirit, to fall into the hands of such true Pharisies, who lay heavy burdens upon others, but will not touch them themselves with the least of their fingers. But blessed bee God! wee truly teach, that it is not so cmuch the measure and muchnesse, as the truth, and heartinesse of o• sorrow; which fits for the promises of life, and pardon of sinne. Yet I must say this also; Hee that thinkes, hee hath sorrowed sufficiently, never sorrowed truly. And I like dBellarmines last Proposition well in the fore-•••ted place; If it bee thus understood: That wee must desire, aime, and endeavour after the highest pitch of godly sorrow, which can possibly bee attained. But 〈…〉 is one thing to say; either, just so much measure of sorrow, or no mercy; such a quantitie of contrition, or no remission: An other thing to say, wee must long and labour to bring our naughty hearts to this: Even to bee willing rather to lie in Hell, then to live in sinne. Perfections of grace are aimed at in this life, not attained.
- bDolor est summus appreciativè, quando voluntas plur•s aestimat detestationem alicuius mali, quàm cuiuscunque boni consecutionim, aut alterius mali evitationem. De poenit. lib. 2. cap. 11. Art. Secunda propositio.
- cIf any cavilling Romanist except, and say, that this doctrine may open a way to sloth; let him hear his own man, E•ius: Doctrina haec benè intellecia non sovet ignaviam poenitentium, sed dubias conscientias magis consolatur & in spem •rigit, dumb tradit sceundum Scripturas omnibus peccatoribus synce•è conversis ad Deum & peccatum ex animo detestant: bus — patcre reditum in gratium cum Deo. In 4. Sent. Dist. 16. §. 8. Art. Ad extren•um].If any cavilling Romanist except, and say, that this doctrine may open a way to sloth; let him heare his owne man, E•ius: Doctrina haec benè intellecia non sovet ignaviam poenitentium, sed dubias conscientias magis consolatur & in spem •rigit, dum tradit sceundum Scripturas omnibus peccatoribus synce•è conversis ad Deum & peccatum ex animo detestant: bus — patcre reditum in gratium cum Deo. In 4. Sent. Dist. 16. §. 8. Art. Ad extren•um].
- dUtilissimum tamen est, peccata singula amarissimè, et longo tempore it a destere, ut con tritio non solùm appreciativè, sed etiam intensivè, & extensivè, utsic loquamur, summa dici possit.Vtilissimum tamen est, peccata singula amarissimè, et longo tempore it a destere, ut con tritio non solùm appreciativè, sed etiam intensivè, & extensivè, utsic loquamur, summa dici possit.
4. I confess some of them sometimes, by reason of freedom in their Schools, over-ruled like Caiaphas, or over-mastered by the clearness and invincibleness of ⟨p. 451⟩the truth, &c. speak something more orthodoxally. As in this Point, Vega. lib. 13. cap. 24. Art. Ad qua accedit] Ibid. Art. Et Sacerdotes] Tolet. Instruct. Sacerd. Lib. 2. cap. 5. Art. Quartum dubium] cNavarre. Cap. 1. Num. 18. Estius In 4. Sent. dist. 16. §. 7. Art. Add quòd fi summus]. fGratians Mothers Confessor.
4. I confesse some of them sometimes, by reason of freedome in their Schooles, over-ruled like Caiphas, or over-mastered by the clearenesse and invinciblenesse of ⟨p. 451⟩the truth, &c. speake something more orthodoxally. As in this Point, Vega. lib. 13. cap. 24. Art. Ad qua accedit] Ibid. Art. Et Sacerdotes] Tolet. Instruct. Sacerd. Lib. 2. cap. 5. Art. Quartum dubium] cNavar. Cap. 1. Num. 18. Estius In 4. Sent. dist. 16. §. 7. Art. Adde quòd fi summus]. fGratians Mothers Confessour.
- cPoenitens si non cognoscatur habere sufficientem dolorem, doleat se talem non babere, & proponat in posterum non peccare, & absolvatur.
- fGratianum Lombardum, Camestorem, fratres fuisse ex adulterio fama obtinuit: & eorum matrem in extremis confitentem negâsse posse sibi displicere peccatum; quum filios videret esse lumina Ecclesie: hinc confessorem, Si non habes, inquisse, tantum dolorē, quantum exigit tam horrendum scelus, de hoc tam•n doleas, quòd non potes dolere. Referent Chamiero, Tom. 3. De Satisfac. proprijs Lib. 23. Cap. 21.Gratianum Lombardum, Camestorem, fratres fuisse ex adulterio fama obtinuit: & eorum matrem in extremis confitentem negâsse posse sibi displicere peccatum; quum filios videret esse lumina Ecclesie: hinc confessorem, Si non habes, inquisse, tantum dolorē, quantum exigit tam horrendum scelus, de hoc tam•n doleas, quòd non potes dolere. Referente Chamiero, Tom. 3. De Satisfac. proprijs Lib. 23. Cap. 21.
But you see them still like the four winds, blow in one another's faces.
But you see them still like the foure windes, blow in one anothers faces.
Hereupon I have many times marvelled, that understanding Papists looking into the Point, are not plunged into desperate perplexities; considering the gvariety of opinions, and uncertainty of the degree of sorrow, required to their Contrition. But when I reflected upon another rotten daubing trick of theirs, I rather wonder at the depths of their Anti-Christian craft, in so politicly, and plausibly patching together their Popish Paradoxes; that they may still keep their damnably-deluded Disciples in contentment, and please them still, at least, with some palliate cures. It is this I mean; They hold also, (prodigious infatuation!) it is impossible, that the learned on the Popes side (but that, that curse is justly upon them; 2. Thes. 2.10.11. Because they received not the love of the truth, that they might be saved: God sends them strong delusion, that they should believe a lie) should ever be so grossly blinded: I say, they hold, that a man hex attrito, by the power of the priestly absolution, ⟨p. 452⟩is made hcontritus; and that ex opere operato, as Valent. affirms. Which upon the matter is thus much: That having but only Attrition, Legal repentance, that fruitless sorrow, which may be found in a iJudas, a Latomus; and which a reprobate may carry with him to hell, is, by the virtue of their sained Sacrament, by the Sacramental act of Absolution, as they call it, made truly, and savingly Contrite, & put into a state of justification. Hear it in the words of that great & famous light of kIreland; and for ever abhor all such Popish impostures: When the Priest with his power of forgiving sins, interposeth himself in the business, they tell us, that Attrition, by virtue of the Keys, is made Contrition: that is to say, that a sorrow arising from a servile fear of punishment, and such a fruitless repentance, as the reprobate may carry with them to hell; by lvirtue of the Priests absolution, is made so fruitful, that it shall serve the tur•• for obtaining forgiveness of sins; as if it had been that mgodly sorrow, which worketh repentance to salvation, not to be repented of. By which spiritual cozenage, many poor souls are most miserably deluded, while they persuade themselves, that upon the receipt of the Priests acquittance, upon this carnal sorrow of theirs, all scores are cleared until that day;
Hereupon I have many times marvailed, that understanding Papists looking into the Point, are not plunged into desperate perplexities; considering the gvarietie of opinions, and uncertainety of the degree of sorrow, required to their Contritiō. But when I reflected upon another rotten dawbing tricke of theirs, I rather wonder at the depths of their Anti-Christian craft, in so politikly, and plausibly patching together their Popish Paradoxes; that they may still keep their damnably-deluded Disciples in contentment, and please them still, at least, with some palliate cures. It is this I meane; They hold also, (prodigious infatuation!) it is impossible, that the learned on the Popes side (but that, that curse is justly upon them; 2. Thes. 2.10.11. Because they received not the love of the truth, that they might be saved: God sends them strong delusion, that they should believe a lie) should ever bee so grosely blinded: I say, they hold, that a man hex attrito, by the power of the priestly absolution, ⟨p. 452⟩is made hcontritus; and that ex opere operato, as Valent. affirmes. Which upon the matter is thus much: That having but only Attrition, Legall repentance, that fruitlesse sorrow, which may be found in a iIudas, a Latomus; and which a reprobate may carry with him to hell, is, by the vertue of their sained Sacrament, by the Sacr•mentall act of Ab•olution, as they call it, made truly, and savingly Contrite, & put into a state of justification. Heare it in the words of that great & famous light of kIreland; and for ever abhorre all such Popish impostures: When the Priest with his power of forgiving sins, interposeth himselfe in the businesse, they tell us, that Attrition, by vertue of the Keyes, is made Contrition: that is to say, that a sorrow arising from a servile feare of punishment, and such a fruitlesse repentance, as the reprobate may carry with them to hell; by lvertue of the Priests absolution, is made so fruitful, that it shall serve the tur•• for obtaining forgivenesse of sinnes; as if it had been that mgodly sorrow, which worketh repentance to salvation, not to bee repented of. By which spirituall cousenage, many poore soules are most miserably deluded, while they perswade themselves, that upon the receit of the Priests acquittance, upon this carnall sorrow of theirs, all skores are cleered untill that day;
- gQuidam adcontritionem requiri dicunt summum conatum hominis, ideóque dolorem debere esse juxta vires hominus quàm maximè intensum. Alijcertum quendam gradum intensionis, itémque certam quantitatem extensionis seu continuationis in contrition requirunt. Alij aliter opinantur. Verùm hac opinionum varietate omissâ, &c. And so he comes in with a new one of his own. Esti. in 4. dist. 16. §. 7.Quidam adcontritionem requiri dicunt summum conatum hominis, ideóque dolorem debere esse iuxta vires hominus quàm maximè intensum. Alijcertum quendam gradum intensionis, itémque certam quantitatem extensionis seu continuationis in contritione requirunt. Alij aliter opinantur. Verùm hac opinionum varietate omissâ, &c. And so hee comes in with a new one of his owne. Esti. in 4. dist. 16. §. 7.
- hAttritio virtute clavium fit Contritio. Romani Correctores Gloss. Gratiani de poenit. Dist. •. in princ. Attritus virtute Sacramenti fit contritus. Navarre. Man. Cap. 1. Num. 38. Itaque omninò sentiendum est in proposito, Christum per institutionem clavium voluisse infirmita•i hominum it a subvenire; ut cum ij alio qui non possent remissionem peccatorum, nisi per veram contritionem, quae difficillimè babetur, obtinere; alium praetereà haberent modum, quo etiam absque ciusmodi contrition divinam gratiam certò consequerentur solâ attrition, beneficio potestatis clavium in usu Sacramenti. Greg. de Valent. Disp. 7. q. 8. de Contritione, punct. 3. Art. Atque haec nimirùm] & alij passim. Some later Schoolmen labour in vain, to make this Point appear not so extremely absurd, by mincing, nay, by beating into powder (& confusum est quicquid in p•lverem sectum est) this poore word Attritio, utterly unknown to Scriptures and ancient Fathers, as their own Man, ••lius, confesseth [Attritionis nomen Scripturae & Patribus incognitum, • Scholae Doctoribus distinctionis & doct•inae causà excogitatu, &c.] by vexing, and violent distinctions, of which it is utterly uncapable: and then lose themselves in the mists of them. Es•tus is glad to distinguish so long, until he flatly make Attrition, Contriton, [Caeterùm postremi generis attritio vera Contritio est. In 4. dist. 16. § 9.] which, how ridiculous and absurd it is, every Child may judge. And how will he answer Aquinas his argument to the contrary? which runs thus: Quorum principia sunt diversa omnin•, corum unum non potest fiert id quod est alterum: sed Attritionis principium est timor servilis; cont•itioni• autem timor silialis; ergo Attritio non potest fieri Contritio Suppl. 3. p. q. 1. Art. 3.Attritio virtute clavium fit Contritio. Romani Correctores Gloss. Gratiani de poenit. Dist. •. in princ. Attritus virtute Sacramenti fit contritus. Navar. Man. Cap. 1. Num. 38. Itaque omninò sentiendum est in proposito, Christum per institutionem clavium voluisse infirmita•i hominum it a subvenire; ut cum ij alio qui non possent remissionem peccatorum, nisi per veram contritionem, quae difficillimè babetur, obtinere; alium praetereà haberent modum, quo etiam absque ciusmodi contritione divinam gratiam certò consequerentur solâ attritione, beneficio potestatis clavium in usu Sacramenti. Greg. de Valent. Disp. 7. q. 8. de Contritione, punct. 3. Art. Atque haec nimirùm] & alij passim. Some later Schoolemen labour in vaine, to make this Point appeare not so extremely absurd, by mincing, nay, by beating into powder (& confusum est quicquid in p•lverem sectum est) this poore word Attritio, utterly unknowne to Scriptures and ancient Fathers, as their owne Man, ••lius, confesseth [Attritionis nomen Scripturae & Patribus incognitum, • Scholae Doctoribus distinctionis & doct•inae causà excogitatu, &c.] by vexi•g, and violent distinctions, of which it is utterly uncapeable: and then lose themselves in the mists of them. Es•tus is glad to distingvish so long, untill he flatly make Attrition, Contriton, [Caeterùm postremi generis attritio vera Contritio est. In 4. dist. 16. § 9.] which, how ridiculous and absurd it is, every Childe may judge. And how will hee an•wer Aquinas his argument to the contrary? which runs thus: Quorum principia sunt diversa omnin•, corum unum non potest fiert id quod est alterum: sed Attritionis principium est timor servilis; cont•itioni• autem timor silialis; ergo Attritio non potest fieri Contritio Suppl. 3. p. q. 1. Art. 3.
- hAttritio virtute clavium fit Contritio. Romani Correctores Gloss. Gratiani de poenit. Dist. •. in princ. Attritus virtute Sacramenti fit contritus. Navarre. Man. Cap. 1. Num. 38. Itaque omninò sentiendum est in proposito, Christum per institutionem clavium voluisse infirmita•i hominum it a subvenire; ut cum ij alio qui non possent remissionem peccatorum, nisi per veram contritionem, quae difficillimè babetur, obtinere; alium praetereà haberent modum, quo etiam absque ciusmodi contrition divinam gratiam certò consequerentur solâ attrition, beneficio potestatis clavium in usu Sacramenti. Greg. de Valent. Disp. 7. q. 8. de Contritione, punct. 3. Art. Atque haec nimirùm] & alij passim. Some later Schoolmen labour in vain, to make this Point appear not so extremely absurd, by mincing, nay, by beating into powder (& confusum est quicquid in p•lverem sectum est) this poore word Attritio, utterly unknown to Scriptures and ancient Fathers, as their own Man, ••lius, confesseth [Attritionis nomen Scripturae & Patribus incognitum, • Scholae Doctoribus distinctionis & doctrinae causà excogitatu, &c.] by vexing, and violent distinctions, of which it is utterly uncapable: and then lose themselves in the mists of them. Es•tus is glad to distinguish so long, until he flatly make Attrition, Contriton, [Caeterùm postremi generis attritio vera Contritio est. In 4. dist. 16. § 9.] which, how ridiculous and absurd it is, every Child may judge. And how will he answer Aquinas his argument to the contrary? which runs thus: Quorum principia sunt diversa omnin•, corum unum non potest fiert id quod est alterum: sed Attritionis principium est timor servilis; cont•itionis autem timor silialis; ergo Attritio non potest fieri Contritio Suppl. 3. p. q. 1. Art. 3.Attritio virtute clavium fit Contritio. Romani Correctores Gloss. Gratiani de poenit. Dist. •. in princ. Attritus virtute Sacramenti fit contritus. Navar. Man. Cap. 1. Num. 38. Itaque omninò sentiendum est in proposito, Christum per institutionem clavium voluisse infirmita•i hominum it a subvenire; ut cum ij alio qui non possent remissionem peccatorum, nisi per veram contritionem, quae difficillimè babetur, obtinere; alium praetereà haberent modum, quo etiam absque ciusmodi contritione divinam gratiam certò consequerentur solâ attritione, beneficio potestatis clavium in usu Sacramenti. Greg. de Valent. Disp. 7. q. 8. de Contritione, punct. 3. Art. Atque haec nimirùm] & alij passim. Some later Schoolemen labour in vaine, to make this Point appeare not so extremely absurd, by mincing, nay, by beating into powder (& confusum est quicquid in p•lverem sectum est) this poore word Attritio, utterly unknowne to Scriptures and ancient Fathers, as their owne Man, ••lius, confesseth [Attritionis nomen Scripturae & Patribus incognitum, • Scholae Doctoribus distinctionis & doctrinae causà excogitatu, &c.] by vexi•g, and violent distinctions, of which it is utterly uncapeable: and then lose themselves in the mists of them. Es•tus is glad to distingvish so long, untill he flatly make Attrition, Contriton, [Caeterùm postremi generis attritio vera Contritio est. In 4. dist. 16. § 9.] which, how ridiculous and absurd it is, every Childe may judge. And how will hee an•wer Aquinas his argument to the contrary? which runs thus: Quorum principia sunt diversa omnin•, corum unum non potest fiert id quod est alterum: sed Attritionis principium est timor servilis; cont•itionis autem timor silialis; ergo Attritio non potest fieri Contritio Suppl. 3. p. q. 1. Art. 3.
- iMatth. 27.3.
- kIn his answer to the Jesuits challenge, pag. 145. and 150.In his answer to the Iesuites chalenge, pag. 145. and 150.
- lReceptissimum est aliorum omnium Theologorum axionia, quòd Sacramentum suppleat ex opere operato defectum Contritionis. Disput. 7. q. 8. De Contritione Punct. 3.
- m2. Cor. 7.10.
and then beginning upon a new reckoning, they sin and confess, confess and sin a fresh, and tread this round so long, till they put off all thought of saving repentance; and so the blind following the blind, both at last follow into the pit. Or thus a little after:
and then beginning upon a new reckoning, they sinne and confesse, confesse and sinne a fresh, and tread this round so long, till they put off all thought of saving repentance; and so the blind following the blind, both at last follow into the pit. Or thus a little after: