A17167:218
A confutation of the Popes bull which was published more then two years ago against Elizabeth the most gracious Queen of England, France, and Ireland, and against the noble realm of England together with a defence of the said true Christian Queen, and of the whole realm of England. By Henry Bullinger the Elder.A confutation of the Popes bull which was published more then two yeres agoe against Elizabeth the most gracious Queene of England, Fraunce, and Ireland, and against the noble realme of England together with a defence of the sayd true Christian Queene, and of the whole realme of England. By Henry Bullinger the Elder.
London: printed by John Day, 1572London: printed by Iohn Day, 1572
Title page typeset from the transcription.
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Moreover, look how many soever within the noble Realm of England have in any wise sworn to the Queens majesty, the Bishop of Rome utterly dischargeth them from such oath, and from all duty of subjection, fealty, & obedience. But we ask him again, from whence he hath that power, and what God or rather what fiend hath given him commission to release those of their oath once made, & of all duty, and of all their rightful obedience, whom the true God himself in his own true word openly and strictly bindeth to keep their promise? he is not able to allege so much as one little word out of Gods book, for this power of his which he lewdly surmiseth, worthily therefore is this traitorous ambition and rashness of his spitted at: and the faithful know that they must obey their gracious Queen by the commandment of God.
MOreouer, looke how many soeuer within the noble Realme of Englād haue in any wise sworne to the Quéenes maiestie, the Bishop of Rome vtterly dischargeth them from such othe, and from all dewtie of subiection, fealtie, & obedience. But we aske him againe, from whence he hath that power, and what God or rather what féend hath giuen him commission to release those of their othe once made, & of all dewtie, and of all their rightfull obedience, whom the true God himselfe in his owne true word openly and streitly bindeth to kéepe their promise? he is not able to alledge so much as one litle word out of Gods booke, for this power of his which he leawdly surmiseth, worthely therefore is this trayterous ambition and rashnesse of his spitted at: and the faithfull know that they must obey their gracious Quéene by the commaundement of God.
1For whereas the Bishops soothers allege certain things in maintenance of their treachery, out of Gratian 22. Quaest. 4. and chiefly this saying of Isidore: In evil promises go back from thy word: and such other things, which the Lombard gathereth together about the end of the third book of his sentences: & that Jehu the king of Israel called all the Priests of Ball to make sacrifice, and when they were at their business brake promise with them and slew them every mothers son: and also that the Coū cell of Constance were of opinion that there was no promise to be kept with heretics: They make nothing at all for the beautifying of their most rightless case. For by sound judgement we willingly admit the examples of David and Herod, and the sentences of Ambrose, Isidore, and Bede, which are alleged by the Master of the Sentences. ⟨p. 66⟩But we say further, that the oath which the nobility and commons have made to the Queen of England, is not to be accounted among evil promises, and unadvised vows or oaths: but among such promises and oaths as are promised and confirmed with swearing, by the commandment and allowance of God. Wherefore I say, that those oaths must in any wise be performed, and in no wise reversed. And who soever teacheth that they are to be reversed, he provoketh Gods wrath against himself, and putteth them that obey him, in danger of Gods grievous judgement.
1For wheras the Bishops soothers alledge certein things in maintenaunce of their trecherie, out of Gratian 22. Quaest. 4. and chiefly this saying of Isidore: In euill promises go backe from thy word: and such other thinges, which the Lombard gathereth together about the end of the third booke of his sentences: & that Iehu the king of Israell called all the Priestes of Ball to make sacrifice, and whē they were at their businesse brake promise with them and slew them euery mothers sonne: and also that the Coū cell of Constance were of opinion that there was no promise to be kept with heretikes: They make nothing at all for the beawtifying of their most rightlesse case. For by sound iudgement we willingly admit the examples of Dauid and Herode, and the sentences of Ambrose, Isidore, and Bede, which are alledged by the Maister of the Sentences. ⟨p. 66⟩But we say further, that the othe which the nobilitie and commons haue made to the Quéene of England, is not to be accounted among euill promises, and vnaduised vowes or othes: but among such promises and othes as are promised and confirmed with swearing, by the commaundement and allowance of God. Wherefore I say, that those othes must in any wise be performed, and in no wise reuersed. And who soeuer teacheth that they are to be reuersed, he prouoketh Gods wrath agaynst himselfe, and putteth them that obey him, in daunger of Gods greuous iudgement.
Certes as for Jehu's deed in slaying the Priests of Baal,1 God disallowed it not, for he said openly that he had done the thing that was righteous in Gods sight, & the thing that was in Gods hart. But this was a singular or peculiar deed, like as certain of Samsons doings were, and of certain other noble men, which are not set forth in the Scriptures for every man to follow, being not rightly called thereunto by God. For we know we must live according to laws, and not according to custom nor after the example of particular deeds. But the law commandeth that we should not lye, or deceive any man by covin or craft, and much less then may we defile our selves with perjury. The things are known well enough which Austen hath discoursed to Consentius against lying. We may add hereunto, that king Jehu bound not himself by any solemn oath to the Priests of Baal: but only allured them by putting them in hope that he would offer a right great and sumptuous sacrifice: & that the Priests being blinded with their own naughtiness and their overeager desire of Idolatry, came flocking by heaps, & therefore suffered just punishment in Gods behalf, for their own sturdy wickedness and their unappeasable hatred towards the true Religion and true Ministers of God. Neither is this to be overpassed here, that Jehu commanded diligent search to be made in the temple least there might be any of the Lords Prophets among the wicked Priests of Baal: meaning ⟨image 72⟩thereby, that the true servants and worshippers of God, must not be punished or put to death with the offenders & Idolaters that be hated of God. Which thing doth strongly assault and batter the purpose and endeavour of the Roman Bishop, whose greedy gaping is for nothing else but the destruction of the true servants and worshippers of God. His desire is to advance and maintain Idolaters, and to oppress and destroy the true servants and worshippers of God. And to bring this to pass, he is not ashamed at all to pretend, and dissemble, to lye, to deceive, and to deal craftily, to lay wait, to forswear, yea and in the end to murder cruelly.
Certesse as for Iehus déede in sleaing the Priestes of Baal,1 God disallowed it not, for he said openly that he had done the thing that was rightous in Gods sight, & the thing that was in Gods hart. But this was a singular or peculiar déede, like as certein of Sampsons doinges were, and of certeine other noble men, which are not setforth in the Scriptures for euery man to folow, being not rightly called therunto by God. For we know we must liue according to lawes, and not according to custome nor after the example of particular déedes. But the law commaundeth that we should not lye, or deceiue any man by couin or craft, and much lesse then may wee defile our selues with periurie. The thinges are knowen well inough which Austen hath discoursed to Cōsentius against lying. We may adde hereunto, that king Iehu bound not himselfe by any solemne othe to the Priestes of Baal: but onely allured them by putting them in hope that he would offer a right great and sumptous sacrifice: & that the Priestes being blinded with their owne naughtinesse and their ouereager desire of Idolatrie, came flocking by heapes, & therfore suffered iust punishment in Gods behalfe, for their owne sturdy wickednesse and their vnappeasable hatred towardes the true Religion and true Ministers of God. Neither is this to be ouerpassed here, that Iehu commaunded diligent search to be made in the tēple least there might be any of the Lordes Prophetes among the wicked Priestes of Baal: meaning
1But admit we should grant, that promise is not to be kept with heretics and infidels that be enemies of our faith: yet ought it to be first proved, that the Queen of England is an heretic and such a one as promise is not to be kept unto. But that the Queen of England is of a right opinion, Catholic, and no heretic, I have already abundantly, evidently and clearly enough declared. Therefore promise ought to be kept with her: and they that be sworn unto her, can not be released of their oath by any law of God or man.2 As for the Council of Constance, it hath in many other things (and specially in the Decree of the xiij. Session,) set forth Decrees openly against Christ the Lord and against his most holy Gospel. And therefore it is of no authority among godly and well minded men. For not even S. Austen him self would have any Councils (of what sort so ever they be or have ben) to be had in any estimation, if they disagree with reason, right, and Scripture.
1But admit we should graunt, that promise is not to be kept with heretikes and infidels that be enemies of our faith: yet ought it to be first proued, that the Quéene of England is an heretike and such a one as promise is not to be kept vnto. But that the Quéene of England is of a right opinion, Catholike, and no heretike, I haue already abundantly, euidently and clearely inough declared. Therfore promise ought to be kept with her: and they that be sworne vnto her, can not be released of their oth by any law of God or man.2 As for the Councell of Constance, it hath in many other thinges (and specially in the Decrée of the xiij. Session,) set forth Decrées openly against Christ the Lord and against his most holy Gospell. And therfore it is of no authoritie among godly and well minded men. For not euen S. Austen him self would haue any Councels (of what sort so euer they be or haue ben) to be had in any estimation, if they disagrée with reason, right, and Scripture.
1And truly about a xxvj. years after the holding of the Council of Constance, those holy fathers, according to their own rule, That promise ought not to be kept with heretics and infidels, executed that power of theirs in discharging Ladislaus king of Hungary and Poland from the oath which he had lawfully made of Amurathes the Emperor of Turkey. For Julianus Caesarinus the Legate of Eugenie the iiij. the Bishop of Rome made a very ⟨p. 67⟩long oration in the presence of King Ladislay, and the Nobility of his realm: the only drift whereof was, to make the King and his noble men believe, that the league which they had made with the king of the Turks being an Infidel, was to be broken, and the promise made unto him to be reversed, but in any wise to keep league with the bishop, who representeth the person of God upon earth. Which thing if ye do not (saith he) I fear me lest even as Judas betrayed Christ, so you will seem to betray Christs vicar: and so lest you find God your utter enemy hereafter, whom ye have always hitherto found helpful and favourable in your affairs.
1And truly about a xxvj. yeares after the holding of the Coūcell of Constance, those holy fathers, according to their owne rule, That promise ought not to be kept with heretikes and infidels, executed that power of theirs in discharging Ladislaus king of Hungarie and Pooleland from the othe which he had lawfully made of Amurathes the Emperour of Turky. For Iulianus Caesarinus the Legate of Eugenie the iiij. the Bishop of Rome made a very ⟨p. 67⟩long oration in the presence of King Ladislay, and the Nobilitie of his realme: the onely drift whereof was, to make the King and hys noble men beleue, that the league which they had made with the king of the Turkes being an Infidell, was to be broken, and the promise made vnto him to be reuersed, but in any wise to kéep league with the bishop, who representeth the person of God vppon earth. Which thing if ye do not (sayth he) I feare me lest euen as Iudas betrayed Christ, so you will séeme to betray Christes vicar: and so lest you finde God your vtter enemy herafter, whom ye haue alwayes hetherto found helpfull and fauourable in your affayres.
But hearken (I pray you) how helpful and favourable the king and nobility found God toward them, according as the false prophet Cesarinus bare them in hand, after they had concluded to break promise with the Turk, and to make horrible war upon him, when he looked for no such thing. Truly at the battle of Waray which was the greatest of all others,1 when it was likely that all should have gone to wrack on both sides, Amurathes plucking out of his bosom the book of the league that was concluded, and solemnly sworn, opened it, and looking earnestly up into heaven, said: These even these, O Jesus Christ, are the covenants which thy Christians have made with me: they have sworn solemnly by thy Godhead, and broken their promise made in thy name, and like false forsworn persons have denied their God. Now Christ if thou be God (as they say, and we be borne in hand) I pray thee revenge here the wrongs and mine, and show the punishment of promise-breaking to such as know not yet thy holy name▪ He had scarce said these words, but the battle which had been uncertain and doubtful a long while, began to incline (like as we read also how it came to pas after the same sort long afore that in the time of Clodeway the first king of France, by reason of his calling upon Christ, in a battle against the Almains) & fortune turned against the Christians, so ⟨image 73⟩as being wearied and tired with fighting all the day long, they turned their backs, and were miserably slain. In that battle the King himself was slain, who otherwise was a very good prince, and worthy of commendation, and with him were slain the chief of his nobility, and stoutest men of war: also there was slain the soothsayer of Tolumne, Cesarinus. Scarce the third part of the kings army returned. Platina in the life of Eugenie the fourth, numbereth above thirty thousand Christians that were slain, and layeth all the blame of this misfortune upon Eugenie the pope. He that desireth to know the whole story, (which is undoubtedly both notable and terrible) shall find it set out at large in Antony Bonfine, in the sixth book of his third Decade of the matters of Hungary. Also the same author giveth warning advisedly, that God did justly revenge the breach of promise upon the Christians.
But harken (I pray you) how helpfull and fauourable the king and nobilitie found God toward them, according as the fals prophet Cesarinus bare them in hand, after they had concluded to breake promise with the Turke, and to make horrible warre vpon him, when he looked for no such thing. Truely at the battell of Waray which was the greatest of all others,
By all which things it appeareth manifestly, how well God liketh the decree of the council of Constance, That promise is not to be kept with heretics & infidels.
By all which thinges it appeareth manifestly, how well God lyketh the decrée of the counsell of Constance, That promise is not to be kept with heretikes & infidelles.
1Doubtless the catholic truth teacheth men expressly, to keep their lawful promise, assurance, or oath at all times, aswell to the bad as to the good, that is to wit, both to believers, and unbelievers or infidels. For our Lord in his law commandeth all and every person,2 that they lye not, nor commit perjury by breaking their promise. But indeed he lieth, which uttereth an untruth with a purpose to deceive: for commonly men say that to lye, is nothing else, but to speak against a mans own knowledge, for liars speak one thing & think an other. And Gelasius in the decrees, Lib. 22. Quest. 4. which beginneth with, S. Paul: &c. That man lieth in committing perjury, which knoweth the thing to be untrue which he sweareth: for (as Saint Austen saith) a lye is an untrue utterance of the voice with a purpose to beguile. As for example, When the pope promiseth safety of lime and life to such as he esteemeth to be heretics, (but in deed are right believers and catholics) ⟨p. 68⟩and yet purposeth in his mind to deceive them by opening them the gap of that hope, and so to bring them in peril of life, lime, and all worldly substance, that is to say, to destroy them cruelly, which was the thing that he purposed, when he guilefully promised them safety, and therefore promised it, to the intent he might destroy them. This is a shameful lye, and a cursed and abominable perjury. Whereof the Prophet hath spoken saying:3 Lord thou hatest all them that commit iniquity, and wilt destroy them that speak lies. The Lord abhorreth a bloodthirsty and deceitful or falsehearted man.
1Doubtlesse the catholike truth teacheth men expresly, to kéep theyr lawfull promise, assurance, or oth at al times, aswell to the bad as to the good, that is to wit, both to beeleuers, and vnbeleuers or infidelles. For our Lord in his law commaundeth all and euery person,2 that they lye not, ne commit periury by breaking theyr promise. But indéed he lyeth, which vttereth an vntruth with a purpose to deceiue: for commonly men say that to lye, is nothing els, but to speake against a mans owne knowledge, for lyers speake one thing & thinke an other. And Gelasius in the decréees, Lib. 22. Quest. 4. which beginneth with, S. Paule: &c. That man lyeth in committing periurie, which knoweth the thing to be vntrue which he sweareth: for (as Saint Austen sayth) a lye is an vntrue vtterance of the voyce wt a purpose to beguyle. As for example, When the pope promiseth safety of lymme and life to such as he estéemeth to be heretikes, (but in déed are rightheleuers and catholikes)
Therefore when Joshua, and the Elders of Israel had made a league of peace with the Gibeonites, who came with a false tale, and (as ye would say) beguiled the people of God, yet they nevertheless kept promise with them unimpeached, even after they had found out their deceit. Whereupon Ambrose in his book of duties, and Austen unto Boniface, give us to understand, and that full rightly, that the promise that is once made, must be performed, yea even unto our enemies, and to evil men, and infidels. Besides this, certain hundred years after, the people of Israel were punished with a sore dearth, for Sauls breaking of the league that was made with the Gibeonites, and amends could not be made for the fault, until seven men of Saul's posterity were hanged to death under the reign of David, according as it is read written in the second book of Samuel, the xxi. chapter. And like as our Lord saith in the Gospel. that the Ninevites, and the Queen of Saba shall judge the Jews at the day of judgement: Even so there is no doubt, but that Marcus Attilius Regulus, & the whole Senate of Rome, which were heathen men, shall condemn these most blessed fathers, forasmuch as they esteem it a thing of nothing to break the promise that is made, yea, & confirmed even with an oath: but the Romans kept promise that a man would wonder at it, yea even to their enemies. The histories bear witness of these things in many places
Therfore when Iosue, and the Elders of Israell had made a league of peace with the Gabaointes, who came wt a false tale, and (as yée would say) beguiled the people of God, yet they neuertheles kept promise with them vnimpeached, euen after they had found out their deceit. Wherupon Ambrose in hys booke of duties, and Austen vnto Boniface, geue vs to vnderstand, and that full rightly, that the promise that is once made, must be perfourmed, yea euen vnto our enemies, and to euill men, and infidelles. Besides this, certayne hundred yeares after, the people of Israell were punished with a sore dearth, for Saules breaking of the leage that was made with ye Gabaonites, and amendes could not be made for the fault, vntill seueu men of Saulss posterity were hanged to death vnder the raign of Dauid, according as it is read written in the second booke of Samuell, the xxi. chapter. And like as our Lorde sayth in the Gospell. that the Niniuites, and the Quéene of Saba shall iudge the Iewes at the day of iudgemet: Euen so there is no doubt, but that Marcus Attilius Regulus, & the whole Senate of Rome, which were heathen men, shal condemne these most blessed fathers, forasmuch as they estéeme it a thing of nothing to breake the promise that is made, yea, & confirmed euē with an oth: but the Romanes kept promise that a man would wonder at it, yea euen to their enemies. The histories beare witnes of these things in many places
1The Prophet Jeremiah exhorteth Gods people with many words, and very earnestly to keep promise with Nebuchadnezzar, though he were a heathen prince, and an infidel, and to obey him, and to pray to God for his welfare. Ezekiel also speaking of the unfaithfulness of Zedechias towards Nebuchadnezzar,2 saith: He hath set light by his oath, and broken his covenant, even when he had given his hand upon it. All these things hath he done, and therefore he shall not escape. As truly as I live (saith God) I will bring mine oath which he hath despised, and my covenant which he hath broken, upon his own head. These sayings are more apt and fit for our present case, than that they read to be expounded & applied with many words.
1The Prophet Ieremy exhorteth Gods people wt many wordes, and very earnestly to kéepe promise with Nabuchodonozor, though he were a heathen prince, and an infidell, and to obay him, and to pray to God for hys welfare. Ezechiel also speaking of the vnfaythfulnes of Zedechias towardes Nabuchodonozor,2 sayth: He hath set light by hys oth, and broken hys couenaunt, euen when he had geuen hys hand vpon it. All these thinges hath he done, and therefore he shall not escape. As truely as I liue (sayth God) I will bring myne othe which he hath despysed, and my couenaunt which he hath broken, vpon hys owne head. These sayinges are more apt and fit for our present case, than that they read to be expounded & applyed with many wordes.
1None other thing taught Christs Apostles in the new Testament: for Peter teacheth men expressly to perform faithfulness, even to wicked masters and rulers. Let servants (saith he) obey their masters, not only if they be good and gentle, but also if they be crabbed. &c. A little afore having spoken also of the magistrate, he commandeth the faithful to obey them: for so is Gods will, that we may stop the mouths of foolish men by doing well. And we know, that in the Apostles days, the Lords and masters were heathen men or infidels.2 Likewise S. Paul instructing servants saith: As many servants as be under the yoke, let them esteem their masters worthy of all honour, lest the name of God, and his doctrine be il spoken of. Which thing the Apostle speaketh of heathen and unbelieving masters: for against these he matcheth the believers saying forthwith: And they that have believing masters let them not despise them, because they be brethren, but let them be the more serviceable to them because they be believers. After the same manner speaketh he in Rom. 13. and Tit. 3. and in other places, of performance, of faithfulness, and obedience to the heathen magistrate. And we also inferring upon these things after the same manner say: If the faithful be bound to wayward and unbelieving masters, how much ⟨p. 69⟩more are the Englishmen bound by Gods commandment to keep their promises and oaths made to their Queen, being a faithful, holy, and gracious Prince?
1None other thing taught Christes Apostles in the new Testament: for Peter teacheth men expresly to perfourme faythfulnes, euen to wicked maisters and rulers. Let seruauntes (sayth he) obay theyr masters, not onely if they be good and gentle, but also if they be crabbed. &c. A little afore hauing spoken also of the magistrate, he commaundeth the faythful to obay them: for so is Gods will, that we may stop the mouthes of foolish men by doing well. And we knowe, that in the Apostles dayes, the Lordes and maysters were heathen men or infidelles.2
And men agree also with God in this behalf: For of many things,1 I will allege but this one. About the year of our Lord 630. or as other reckon 681. under Sisenand king of Spain, at the city of Toledo in Spain, there was held a competent Synod, wherein this case of performing oaths sworn unto Princes is diligently entreated of. The said Synod is commonly called the fourth council of Toledo. Among other things they make a decree in these words: Can. 74. The report goeth that many nations are so falsehearted, that they neglect to perform the promise, which they have made by oath unto their own princes, and pretend to swear with their mouths, when they wickedly purpose to forswear themselves in their hearts. For they swear to their kings, and impeach the faithfulness which they have promised, and they are not afraid of that book of Gods judgement whereby cursedness is brought upon such as swear by the name of God lyingly. What hope then shall such people have against their enemies, when they be in danger? What credit is to be given them any more in making peace with other countries? what league will they not break? what assurance sworn to the enemies shall stand stable, when they keep not their promises sworn to their own kings? for who is so mad as to cut of his own head with his own hands? But they (as it is well known) forgetting their own salvation, murder themselves with their own hand by turning their own force against their Kings & themselves. And whereas the Lord saith: Touch not mine anointed. And whereas David saith, who can lay his hand upon the Lords anointed and be guiltless: they are not afraid to fall into perjury, nor yet to destroy their own kings. For promise is made to the enemies, and not broken. Now if faithfulness take place in war, how much more is it to be observed in all other things? For it is high treason to God, ⟨image 75⟩if people impeach their faithfulness promised to their Kings.2 For the offence is committed not only against them, but also against God, in whose name the promise is plighted. Hereupon it cometh to pass, that the wrath of God hath so altered many kingdoms upon earth, that one of them is loosened from another, for the wickedness of their promise breaking and evil behaviour.
And men agrée also with God in thys behalfe: For of many things,
Wherefore it behoveth us to take warning at such chances of nations, that we be not likewise stricken with swift plague, and punished with cruel punishment:1 for if God spared not the Angels that transgressed against him, but thrust them out of their heavenly habitation for their disobedience: whereupon also he saith by Isaiah:2 My sword hath been bathed in heaven: how much more must we fear the loss of our salvation, lest we perish for our unfaithfulness through the vengeance of the same sword of God? But if we will eschew Gods displeasure, and be desirous that he should turn his rigour into mercy.3 Let us keep the reverence of religion, and fear towards God, and perform the faithfulness and allegiance, that we promise to our Princes. Let there not be in us, as there is in some nations, wicked wiliness of unfaithful dealing, nor truthless treachery of deceitful meaning, nor villainy of false forswearing, nor traitorous practising of conspiracy. Let no man among us usurp the kingdom through presumptuousness, let no man set his countrymen together by the ears, let no man imagine the destruction of Kings: but when a prince is departed in peace: Let the noblemen and clergy of the whole realm dispose the succession of the kingdom by common advice, that while we retain the unity of concord, no man may practise the disquietness of his country & realm by violence and ambition.
Wherfore it behoueth vs to take warning at such chaunces of nations, that we be not likewise stricken with swift plague, and punished with cruell punishment:1 for if God spared not the Angels that transgressed against him, but thrust them out of their heauenly habitation for their disobedience: wheruppon also he sayth by Esay:2 My sword hath bene bathed in heauen: how much more must we feare the losse of our saluation, lest we perish for our vnfaythfulnes through the vengeance of the same sword of God? But if we will eschew Gods displeasure, and be desirous that he should turne his rigour into mercy.3