A19149:36
A second manuduction, for Mr. Robinson. Or a confirmation of the former, in an…
A second manuduction, for Mr. Robinson. Or a confirmation of the former, in an answer to his manumissionA second manuduction, for Mr. Robinson. Or a confirmation of the former, in an ansvver to his manumission
Amsterdam? : s.n., Anno Domini. M. DC. XV. 1615
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
True, the relation ceaseth, But is that external relation unto an efficient cause any part of the substance or essence of ⟨p. 18⟩the ministry? I had thought that the substance & essence of a thing had consisted in matter & form, & not in such external relations. Marriages are also made (as Mr. R. affirmeth) by Bishops authority: take away Bishops therefore & by this reason the marriages shall not remain the same for substance which they are now. Licences for teaching school & in many places for practicing of physic are given by the Bishops & their officers: take away the Bishops, & may not the same schoolmasters & physicians yet still remain (for substance) that were before? Fie upon sophistry.
Trew, the relation ceaseth, But is that externall relation unto an efficient cause any part of the substance or essence of ⟨p. 18⟩the ministerie? I had thought that the substance & essence of a thing had consisted in matter & forme, & not in such externall relations. Mariages are also made (as Mr. R. affirmeth) by Bishops authoritie: take away Bishops therfore & by this reason the mariages shall not remayne the same for substance which they are now. Licences for teaching school & in many places for practizing of physick are given by the Bishops & their officers: take away the Bishops, & may not the same schoolmasters & physitians yet stil remayn (for substāce) that were before? Fie upon sophistrie.
2. Take away the prelacy (saith Mr. R.) and how can such a ministry continue, whereof one part (viz: ruling) shall be usurped by the prelate? As if when once that power is taken from the minister, it now appertained to the substance of his ministry, by whom it were usurped, whether he that possessed it were a Bishop, or a high commissioner, or of some other place! that which is without a thing may be changed without any substantial change of the thing it self: else how can Mr. R. say that either the function of mass-priests, or of Popish Bishops do remain still in England as of old for substance, when there is so great an alteration in that supreme power from whence of old they were derived? The office of a king also, it remaineth the same for substance now, that it was in time of popery, for the substantial parts of it: yet one part thereof was in those times usurped & possessed by the pope, & is now restored to the crown, viz: power over ecclesiastical persons, & in ecclesiastical causes. It cannot therefore be denied, but by the same reason, the parochial ministry should abide the same for substance that now it is, though that part which is now usurped by Bishops should be restored again. So that Bishops being removed, whether that power of ruling should be translated unto some other officers, or settled in the ministers as it ought, Mr. R. argument hath by neither way any weight or force at all.