A19149:45
A second manuduction, for Mr. Robinson. Or a confirmation of the former, in an…
A second manuduction, for Mr. Robinson. Or a confirmation of the former, in an answer to his manumissionA second manuduction, for Mr. Robinson. Or a confirmation of the former, in an ansvver to his manumission
Amsterdam? : s.n., Anno Domini. M. DC. XV. 1615
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
His first reason why this power is not civil is because it is not coactive or bodily enforcing, but the Bishop after excommunication can go no further except he procure a civill coactive process by writ out of another court. I answer 1. Though it had no bodily enforcing at all annexed unto it yet it might be a civill power. Bodily enforcing is but a penal sanction which cometh after the authority or power civil, & may be separated from it 2. It is therefore coactive or bodily enforcing, because it may directly require as due & by law belonging unto it such coactive assistance by other officers as Mr. R. himself speaketh of. So many civill commissions & letters patent are granted to men which have no authority seated in themselves for forcing of men unto obedience, but have authority to charge the constable or justice that ⟨p. 22⟩next is to aid them in their affairs, which authority of theirs notwithstanding is civil, & in that respect coactive.
His first reason why this power is not civil is because it is not coactive or bodily enforcing, but the Bishop after excomunication can goe no further except he procure a civill coactive processe by vvritt out of another court. I answer 1. Though it had no bodily enforcing at all annexed unto it yet it might be a civill power. Bodily enforcing is but a penall sanction which commeth after the authoritie or power civil, & may bee seperated from it 2. It is therfore coactive or bodily enforcing, because it may directly require as due & by law belonging unto it such coactive assistance by other officers as Mr. R. himself speaketh of. So many civill commissions & letters patent are granted to men which haue no authoritie seated in themselves for forcing of mē unto obedience, but haue authoritie to charge the constable or justice that ⟨p. 22⟩next is to ayd them in their affayres, which authoritie of theirs notwithstanding is civil, & in that respect coactive.
A second reason is taken from the works of prelates jurisdiction, which are for substance (saith he) the making of ministers, & excommunicating of offenders, with their contraries & appurtenances: which are not civil works, neither can be performed by any civil magistrate. Where, if by can or may he understandeth such right as men have for their deeds by the law or word of God, then I willingly grant that no civil magistrate may by his civill office perform those works of ordination excommunication &c. Neither can the Bishop so perform them: herein consisteth that presumptuous usurpation whereof they are guilty before God & man. But if he understandeth such right or power as men have for their deeds by mans law, then I avouch out of the former grounds & testimonies of law, that any other civil magistrate may receive authority of jurisdiction in those causes as well as prelates. Which experience confirmeth de facto in the high commission, & some other courts. Whereby it is manifest, that though these works in their nature be spiritual, yet (thorough great abuse) they are performed by civill authority. Secondly I answer, that these works of ordination & excommunication with their contraries & appurtenances are not the substance or in effect the whole jurisdiction which Bishops do exercise in their provinces & diocese, though Mr. R. affirm it again & again. For 1. The principal jurisdiction which prelates have is under the king to make certain rules canons or laws for ordering of certain causes committed unto them 2. Those causes are for a great part of them merely civil, such as by Gods law the civil magistrate hath power to order. Of which kind are the causes of matrimony, of wills or testaments & many circumstances pertaining to the several churches within their precincts. 3. In the very business of ordination & excommunication, it is of substance to see that worthy men be admitted & unworthy excluded. The forms of ordination & excommunication usurped by them, are corrupt appurtenances to those lawful actions, & not the substance whereto all the rest appertain.