A19178:12
A reply to Dr. Mortons general Defence of three nocent [sic] ceremonies viz. the…A reply to Dr. Mortons generall Defence of three nocent [sic] ceremonies viz. the…
A reply to Dr. Mortons general Defence of three nocent [sic] ceremonies viz. the surplice, cross in baptism, and kneeling at the receiving of the sacramental elements of bread and wine.A reply to Dr. Mortons generall Defence of three nocent [sic] ceremonies viz. the surplice, crosse in baptisme, and kneeling at the receiving of the sacramentall elements of bread and wine.
Amsterdam: printed by Giles Thorp, 1622
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
And then what is the sense (trow you) in which these ceremonies may be called Innocent? when Calvin (whom the Defender calleth an honourable witness) would devise a charitable title for them, he stiles them tolerabiles incptiae, viz. tolerable fooleries, or fopperies, Epist. 200. & 206. When he speaketh more out of judgement, he not only calleth them frivolous and unprofitable, but saith plainly that their proper name is hurtful, noxious, or nocent, clean contrary to this Defendants language. Surely one of these writers, not differing only, but flatly opposing and contradicting the other, must needs be far wide.
And then what is the sence (trow you) in which these ceremonies may be called Innocent? when Calvin (whom the Defender calleth an honorable witnes) would devise a charitable title for them, he stiles them tolerabiles incptiae, viz. tolerable fooleries, or fopperies, Epist. 200. & 206. When he speaketh more out of iudgement, hee not onely calleth them frivoulous and unprofitable, but saith plainlie that their proper name is hurtfull, noxious, or nocent, cleane contrarie to this Defendants language. Surely one of these writers, not differing onely, but flatly opposing and contradicting the other, must needs be farre wide.
Innocent indeed these ceremonies may be called in regard of their materials, and the fashions also which they have in their natural being: for the cloth of a Surplice and the fashion of it is innocent, and so are all the idols of Papists and Heathens very innocent: so that this is no praise. But if we look at the use whereunto they have been applied, and wherein they have been a long time employed, I may truly say by the devil, not only among the Papists, but even in our Churches, to the breeding of dissension and distraction among brethren, to quenching of many, and many a burning shining light, to the grieving and unsettling of so many good souls, and to the advancing of the Kingdom of darkness: If these things I say be considered, then it is more then manifest, that this licking them over with a fair word will make them no more innocent indeed then Pilats hands were when they were washed. The fashion of a Surplice natural or artificial in another use, as if a Porter or Baker wear such a garment is indifferent.